I like Marc Jacobs Highliners the most, followed by Stila’s Smudgestick liners. I also like MAC Chromagraphic Pencils, but the shade range is more basic/primary, so I just don’t end up reaching for the shades in the range.
— Christine
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Christine, you are correct about this one, since you mentioned Stila, I’ve used the Kajal pencil for the waterline before.. I am not sure if it was for the waterline, do you know??
Christine, have you ever tried the Ardency Inn eyeliners? I’ve heard they last a long time (never tried them myself though). I wonder how they compare to the Marc Jacobs High-liners.
My eyes are super watery… nothing seems to stick! I tried MUFE kohl pencil, Laura Mercier Kohl pencil, and Marc Jacobs highliners…. all came off within the hour 🙁
I’ve had my best luck with Inglot kohl eyeliner and it is only $12.
Thanks! I’ll definitely give it a go once I find a retailer here 🙂
That was my last purchase in my quest for a long-lasting waterline liner, but unfortunately it came off my waterline soon after I applied it. 🙁
I’ve only tried a couple, mainly Urban Decay… For years, I never even tried it–it seems like every issue of Seventeen magazine back in the 80s & 90s had an article on the dangers of lining your waterline, with nightmare stories of scratches/infections!! So I was always afraid to try! Now, with the newer, softer formulas out there, I’ve tried tightlining & lining my lower lash line… Just not for me!! First off, it tickles. Like I feel it all the way down my spine. Very unsettling. Is this just me?? And then, it makes my eyes water like CRAZY. And then, after all that, it is usually half gone by the time I finish my makeup, and totally gone within an hour or 2. Ugh. My eyes are itching just thinking about it!!
Sounds like you had an allergic reaction or something like that. Best if you don’t do water lining.
I really like the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner formula.
MUFE Aqua Eyes Waterproof eyeliners have been the longest wearing for me.
I really like MAC Chromagraphic pencils. I use Pure White a lot to brighten up my eyes and it stays really well. Other than that I can’t really comment since I don’t use much else on my waterline. I don’t have small eyes but I don’t tend to use anything dark on my waterline since I just prefer how my eyes look without it.
I also really like the Marc Jacobs pencil liners and just picked one up today (Blacquer). But my daily go-tos are GOSH, Sephora (both the Contour ones and the Retractable ones) as well as MAC Fluidline and Pearlglide pencils. IT Cosmetics also makes a pot/gel liner that I find lasts and lasts and lasts but I’m a bit of a numpty with cream/gel liners and brushes so most mornings, because I’m in a hurry, I use pencils.
I really have a hard time keeping anything on my waterline, and on me Stila Smudgesticks don’t stay more than a couple hours. But recently I dug out a MUFE khol I hadn’t used in a long time, used it on the lower waterline, and it lasted ALL DAY. I was amazed, so I’m planning to get it in a couple of basic shades for waterline use.
For me it’s UD 24/7 Glide-On Pencil in Perversion. Most of the UD 24/7 pencils will stay in my lower waterline, but Perversion is the only one that stays on my upper. Tarte’s Clay Pot Waterproof Liners. Wet n Wild Kohl-Kajal Eyeliner 656A White.
Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner – expensive, but easy to apply and stays put all day
Hi Anne..same, another vote here: I use these for tightlining and get incredible wear. I purchased a pack of three over a year ago and I am now just starting my third pencil. For my purposes, particularly since I use them for tighlining alone, I consider the price ok 🙂
Mac liquid last eyeliner in black (discontinued) that stuff would stay on after a shower!
And the Makeup forever aqua cream but liquid lats was the best ever. No smudging, no fading, 0but hard to remove of course
I love Marc too but they dry out SO fast!
I’ve tried gel liners, and they stick to my contacts rather than my waterline. Thank goodness for samples. The new kajal liners do the same thing, or dissappear into the corner of my eye. The new one that doesn’t is wet ‘n wild long wearing liner pencils, and good old burn the red pencil, waterproof Maybelline brow and liner. Midnight black works for me. I just hope they don’t stop making it. It has the ability to stay on until I take it off.
Waterline: another vote for Marc Jacobs
Tightlining: another vote for Hourglass Mechanical
If I’m short on time I use Marc Jacobs hi liners, if I have a second to spare Ingot gel liner in #77 (black) wears like IRON!!!
I own a lot of eyeliners but MAC Graph black Technakohl liner stay’s the longest on my waterline! And Bobbi Brown’s Black Plum has good longevity too.
Ah, after a lot of trial and error, I’ve found that the pencil that lasts the longest is one by an Indian brand (Lakme), close second is the Marc Jacobs Fineliner (the little thin one that I got as a point perk from Sephora). I also like MAC’s Black Black Chromographic when I want a smudgey look. For brown/bronze – MAC’s Teddy stays on the entire day. A non-neutral eyeliner with impressive longevity is NARS’s Abbey Road (turquoise).,
L´Oréal Silkissime eyeliners.
Milani Liquif’eye…hands down!
Of the ones I’ve tried, definitely the Marc Jacobs ones. The Urban Decay ones are pretty good too, as are the Tarte clay-based ones, but Marc Jacobs tends to last the longest on me.
Marc Jacobs Highliners
Lancôme’s liqui-gel liners. They are exclusive to Sephora, I think. I tried French Lace , which is white and it lasted for hours.