Wednesday, March 17th, 2010

Temptalia Asks You


What discontinued/limited edition product would you pay BUCKS! to have again? Share!

Temptalia's Answer.

I really loved Fashionably Fuchsia Lipstick! I remember I’d wear it all the time with Dejarose lipglass!

Thanks to Sally for this question!

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

187 thoughts on “What discontinued/limited edition product would you pay BUCKS! to have again?

  1. Rachel

    Mac Rockocco Lipstick!!!

  2. Rich and Ripe lipgloss from cult of cherry collection.

  3. the mac msf’s in smooth merge and triple fusion omg.
    annnd i wish that urban decay would just keep their book of shadows around.
    limited edition makes me mad sometimes cause i might not have money for the things i want at that point in time and once i save up money to get them, they’re all sold out and not coming back. :(

  4. Jessica

    MAC Ripe Peach haha because it sold out on the first day :( and Perfect Topping MSF.

  5. Maddie

    Mutiny Pigment all the way
    PLEASE MAC

  6. mars

    MAC Skinsheen Leg Spray!!!!! It’s not coming back this summer and it’s my all time favorite product. It makes my glow in the dark white legs look perfectly golden, hides bruises & veins, doesn’t rub off on clothes or furniture & I can go swimming in it. WHY OH WHY isn’t it coming back this year????

    Also the John Frieda Beach Waves Spray. Just the right amount of oil & salt water that didn’t make my hair greasy but made it look like I spent the day at the beach & smelled amazing. I’ve tried all the others & nothing comes close.

    • Molly

      if you google shopping seach the john frieda beach waves spray you can find it but it cost an arm and a leg!

    • Kelly

      THIS!!! I loooooove the leg spray…. They have it on allcosmeticswholesale.com-I need to order some too!
      The beach hair stuff was so fun too. =(

    • I SO agree on the Beach Waves Spray! I used to buy 2 at a time because I used it so much and was devastated when I couldn’t find it in stores anymore.

    • Kerri

      I still have half a bottle of that John Frieda stuff from like 7 years ago. It didn’t really do much for my hair since it’s already curly so it just sits here collecting dust. I’d give it to you if I could. I need the room but I never throw anything beauty related away if it’s still good.

  7. Az

    Hmm maybe Lollipop Loving.

  8. Elizabeth

    Barbie Loves Mac Pearl Blossom Beauty Powder

  9. tracy

    I would pay anything for Chanel Hydrabase lipstick No 11 Sirene.

  10. I would love to get my hands on Springtime Skipper from Barbie Loves MAC.

  11. MAC pharaoh p/p! i wasn’t a MAC addict yet when Alexander McQueen launched. *sigh*

  12. Lila

    Most of those stuff from the hello kitty collection.

  13. amy

    MAC Palatial Lustreglass and MAC Spanish Fly lipstick (frost).

  14. The Chanel Smokey Eyes Quad from the F/W 09 collection. :(

  15. Molly

    Lightscapade MSF *sighs*

  16. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Janette Janette

    MAC Parrot E/S i airport lost my makeup and i never recovered this eyeshadow that i <3

  17. Aveda used to make these multi-purpose duo pencils (fatty little pencils with two shades on each end) in MANY different colors. One of them had the PERFECT mid-tone grey on it, it was very close to Silver Ring by MAC but with a little more blue in it – VERY pretty! I would LOVE to have that again!

    I’d also like to see MAC release their Volcanic ash exfoliator and masque as perminant products.

    My favorite moisturizer is also a discontinued Aveda moisturizer (if I think about it, most of my favorite discontinued products are actually skincare ones).

  18. Kerry

    Mac ripe peach

  19. Meika

    MAC’s Metal Rock MSF. PLEASE!!!!

  20. Salvinia

    MAC Daft Pink mineralize blush. I didn’t pick it up when I had the chance (for some reason), and now I mentally kick myself every time I think about it!

  21. DevilishDoll

    Comet Blue Dazzleglass mostly. And all of the old pretty colored Shadesticks, a few old Pigments, and a bunch of other stuff.

  22. valerie

    loooovvvve MAC equality

  23. Sarah

    MAC Alta Moda plw, Wild ‘Bout You l/s, Isabella Blow l/s, Sun Dressing tanner!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! OMG, that shit was AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  24. MAC’s ‘Way to love’ lipstick….Damn you MAC…damn you.

    • Alex

      i will have to “amen” to the way to love lipstick, plus alpha girl beauty powder!!!!!

    • Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Alice Alice

      way to love was my first MAC lipstick, and I bought it completely on a whim before I was into MAC or makeup, in general.

      I used to wear it everyday but now it’s down to the last few bits, and I can’t bear to use it up!!

  25. Urban decay BOS Volume 2! =(

  26. Shannon

    MAC Lightscapade MSF

  27. Queen’s Sin l/s.

    i can’t understand why MAC haven’t repromoted it yet. makes me sad :(

  28. Karin

    Mac Strada Blush

  29. Alexander McQueen Paint Pots – they haven’t made anymore colourful paint pots, boo!

  30. Diana

    MAC Foolish Me blush & Perfect Topping MSF

  31. Crissy

    MAC Lipglass in Perfectly Pink – So far, it’s the first and only lipglass I’ve used up to the end

  32. amelia

    oh, i have a ton. Chanel Jade (i wasnt just following the crowd there i really do love Chanel nail polish)lots of different beauty powders (which i also love) mac MSF in perfect topping, and the naked honey skin salve.

  33. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Jo Jo

    MAC Hello Kitty cute-ster lipstick. I have already finished one and bought another from eBay!

  34. Olga

    Estee Lauder Ideal Matte Refinishing MakeUp spf 8 in colour Ivory. It was the best foundation I have ever used.

  35. Sarah

    MAC Yogamode Beauty Powder

  36. I remember Fashionably Fuchsia. I had it but swapped it away because I didn’t really wear such bold colours.

    I’ve really been lusting after Pop Iris liquidlast liner for some reason. Wish it wasn’t discontinued, such a pretty colour!

  37. Natalie

    I think I have the most things from the past/LE collections.. But I wouldn’t mind paying a bit for a full jar of Softwash Grey pigment :D

  38. vinna

    MAC Redhead MSF ……. it flew off the shelves :(

  39. Well, I HAVE paid big bucks for Pleasureflush MSF and Stereo Rose MSF (the latter was cheaper as I found it on MUA, but eBay prices are crazy) already! :) Wish they were repromoted though, so I could stock up. Also Metal Rock, because I really want it, but afraid to pay loads for it, since I don’t even know if it’ll work for me as I’m quite pale and it looks so dark.

    I’m desperately trying to find Guerlain Meteorites Voyage Powder in Midnight Diamond, it came out about 5 years ago and I desperately want it. I’ve missed out on it 3 times on eBay already, and it hardly ever appears on there anyway. :(

  40. MAC hello kitty fun n’ games bpb, MAC blow dry lipstick, lickable lipstick, petit indulgence cremesheen glass… and see thru colour secret crush!

  41. haley

    Omigosh, MAC’s 3N lipstick. For me, it is THE perfect color for my lips.

  42. Shannon

    MACs C-Shock shadows.. This collection came out the month was completely broke and didnt dare even look at MAC stuff; so I missed it..

  43. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Emily Emily

    In 2003 or 4 MAC launched a fall quad with a deep purple, a matte muted lilac, a frosty taupe, and a light yellow frost color….I LOVED that thing! I’ve been looking for dupes for the light yellow in it for a long time but nothing comes close. Also, the MSF in Smooth Merge.

  44. Paola

    Def Raquel welch? For mac amazon eyes palette…my friend has it and the color combinations she gets out of it are awesome! Hers is running out and I know she wants another one.. And also the spiced chocolate quad from the cult of cherry collection….it’s like perfect wedding palette!!

  45. rose

    Proenza Pink, Pout-a-Porter by Lancome…Never even got to try it. :-(

  46. Avon lipstick in Party Pink. I also wish J Lo would make Miami Glow permanent!

  47. Valerie

    The MSF Lightscapade! I would love to have it!!!!

  48. Cherie

    I’d like to see the MAC’s Cult of Cherry and Barbie collections come back. I missed out on them the first time.

    Ohhhhhh and Rainforest by OPI return!

    • cmferrets

      oh me too ! i want the cult of cherry e/s quad in spiced chocolate. and i want the stuff from barbie love mac. also maybe some fafi, heatherette, naughty nauticals and cool heat. i missed all those collections and they had some fun bright colors!
      why doesnt mac come out with one of these collections that everybody wants stuff from and make a part 2 series. then they can add some old stuff and some new stuff from those collections! that would be killer cool! right?

  49. LUCY

    MAC REAL DOLL LIPSTICK FROM BARBIE LOVES MAC <3

  50. Pam

    black ore solar bits:)

  51. Tina

    I would love to get my hands on pleasureflush!

    and lightly ripe lipstick from cult of cherry.

  52. Henriette

    The Urban Decay Book of Shadows,especially The Alice in Wonderland.

  53. Bren

    MAC Hypnotizing Eyeshadow

    • Alex

      if you have a freestanding store go ask them!! i just bought 2 hypnotizing from the PRO store in San Francisco!!! they said it wasnt a “popular” selller but i freaking LOVE IT!

  54. Michelle

    Chanel Jade nail polish

  55. Kerri

    Mac Firespot eyeshadow. Everytime I see a look with a really pretty orange color it always turns out to be firespot. I’d give my entire paycheck for just for one pan. I’d be soooo afraid to use it though!

  56. Nat

    i miss MAC Studiolights in Sand. it’s the only product that conceals my dark circles so perfectly and brightens my eye area.

    i think i must have single-handedly bought all the tubes on ebay. sigh. now down to my last tube!

  57. Firespot!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  58. Barbie Loves MAC Pearl Blossom Beauty Powder, Malibu Barbie Lipglass and Rocking Chick Lipstick

  59. Proximity

    The mythical perfect taupe from Shu Uemura, ME Brown 945, I think it was called?

    • Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Alisha Alisha in WI

      i heard the me brown 850 is supposed to be the new packaged version of this shade. Just ordered it the other day because couldn’t get my hands on that one!

  60. MAC Strawberry Blonde Lipstick from the Catherine Denueve collection.
    Le Sigh…

  61. TG

    BB’s Ruby Stain or Sheer and Agree shampoo with the original 80s-early 90s fragrance. Nothing smelled better than Agree. Oh, and Halsa, Maybelline’s Shine-Free line, PermaSoft (for scent only) and make the MAC Greasepaints permanent. I’m sure there are 1000 others too that I’m not thinking of, and realized I’ve totally dated myself by mentioning some of the above products.

    • Samantha

      Don’t forget, Gee Your Hair Smells Terrific Shampoo and the original Clairol Herbal Essences Shampoo…the green one with the hippie chick on the front with flowers in her long blond hair! haha Ahhh…the seventies.

      • TG

        I actually never smelled the original Herbal Essences and wish I had! I did buy a bottle of Gee Your Hair Smells Terrific from the Vermont Country Store, but I never smelled the original of that either and don’t know if it was on the mark or not. It smelled kind of, well…plasticky.

        Strawbaby lipstick should be permanent. And Kissing Koolers need to come back. Actually, can the 80s themselves just return?

  62. Krista

    Oil of Olay Powder Foundation!

  63. Jenna

    Perfect Topping and Smooth Merge MSF. I never got around to buying them and they look so nice!

  64. Alexis

    I missed the whole Barbie line from MAC so I would LOVE it if it magically appeared again!!

  65. Darrien

    MAC Blush Ombre in Ripe Peach, sold out at my MAC store two days after the collection came out, :(
    MAC Lavender Whip lipstick.

  66. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Schara Thincspot

    Anything from the MAC Neo Sci-fi or Moonbathe collection.

  67. Frances

    I’m not at all a MAC person, but I would pay good money for Queen’s Sin, Port Red and Check Please.

  68. MakeupGalore--Abbie

    I totally missed the MAC Kitty collection. I would like to see it come back too. I was on vacation and when I got back it was gone!!!

  69. Elle

    “Also the John Frieda Beach Waves Spray. Just the right amount of oil & salt water that didn’t make my hair greasy but made it look like I spent the day at the beach & smelled amazing. I’ve tried all the others & nothing comes close.”

    Seconding that! I have one bottle left and I don’t even know if it’s still good to use. Oh well. :(

  70. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Erin Erin

    MAC Lollipop Loving l/s! I had a backup, but it disappeared. I want more of the Sugarsweet release! it has the most amazing base color on me, and the green/gold sheen is really cool, too. I’ve been trying to find a perm equivalent for the base color, but no success so far. :/

    • Kalee

      yes, they definitely need to make that lipstick perm. stupid not to. i LOVE that color, but i only have one and barely use it because i cant get it anymore. =\

    • Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Alisha Alisha in WI

      I just got lollipop loving at the CCO. Not sure if I like it yet but check there…saw some shadows too

  71. Kristeen

    I wish I had picked up MAC’s Peppermint Patti nail polish! Now it sells on eBay for up to 5 times as much! I’d also like the Chocolate Spice quad from MAC’s Cult of Cherry collection.

  72. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Nic Nicole.

    MAC’s Mothbrown from the Barbie collection. I have it, but I use it *SPARINGLY*

    Chanel’s Jade nail polish. Oh how I covet thee. Le sigh.

  73. shantinini

    i would love to have the warm pallette from the holiday collection year 2008 back.lost it when handbag got snatched.

  74. Anna

    Barbie Loves MAC Pearl Blossom Beauty Powder
    MAC Rubia lipstick (I try not to use it… crazy, I know!)
    Lancome Behnaz Red (Gone before I could get it…)

  75. moraima

    I would dye for the smoke signals quads and pigments to be back, the MINERAL Eye shadow from EMANUEL UNGARO, Ripe Peach Blush Ombre, MAC PAINT POT IN STRAY GREY, MAC BUFFER BRUSH in 180, and Finally the old pigment container it’s not fair in this economy to pay the same price for less product, or MAC should reduce the price. a lot of faithful MAC adicts are hurt by this new change.

  76. Casey

    MAC Peppermint Patti Nail Polish & MAC Volcanic Ash Exfoliator…I managed to get one Ebay but I agree that they should make all skincare products permanent.

  77. jennifer

    Lancome Misty Mink eyeshadow and Chanel Starlette Glossimer.

  78. Karish

    I love mac lipstick utterly frivolous (lustre) from the fafi collection.I find it strange that I never hear that other people love the colour. Does somebody know a similar color from mac??

  79. Hannah

    mac pharoah paint pot, peppermint patti nail polish, firespot eyeshadow, starflash eyeshadows, matte2 eyeshadows…THE LIST COULD GO ON!
    Seriously, if mac bought some of these out in upcoming collections then surely after the excessive use and all the hype last time, sales would be through the roof! Maybe they lost the formula…. :S

    • Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Alisha Alisha in WI

      Love the starflash eyeshadows…my fav finish besides VP. I like the matte2’s better than reg matte’s.

      • Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Robin MAChostage

        I totally agree. Those finishes (Starflash, VP amd M2) are the top of the MAC shadow line, IMO!

  80. Michelle M

    Lip Gelees! They are dying a slow death and I’m devastated! I will be stocking up at the CCO until they run out for good.

  81. I would kill for the Shy Beauty beauty powder blush from Mac. I used up one, bought another from Ebay, and am halfway through that! Thankfully, there are still a few listed on Ebay, though they’re a bit overpriced. Hope they’re still there when I need one!

  82. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Shontay shontay

    I’d pay serious money for Cult of Cherry lipglass,Tahitian Sand Beauty Powder and Utter Fun lipstick all buy Mac. I have all 3 of these, but I don’t want to think about when I will run out.

  83. Meagan

    MAC So Scarlet l/s! It’s like the perfect scarlet shade for me :(

  84. Wendy

    I don’t own this product but I would love to get my hands on MAC So Ceylon MSF! All the swatches that I see look so beautiful. *sigh*

  85. audrey

    I would pay a load for anything from the Kitty Kouture collection or the Barbie loves MAC collection!! I went to a warehouse sale and they didn’t have any of the Barbie stuff!!!

  86. Steph2

    MAC Deliciously Rich lipstick!

  87. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of aradhana aradhana

    mac stiletto lipstick

  88. Jazmin

    Mac msf in Shimpagne

  89. beeks

    Pure Rose lipstick from mac’s Ungaro collection. My life revolves around finding a reasonable dupe.

  90. ocelot1

    CHANEL VEGA!!!
    and original MAC VAE…and AOT greasepaint sticks…and MAC Feline!

  91. Ashley

    Well it used to be MAC Lucky Green e/s but thank god they made it permanent 5 years later! otherwise it would probably be ripe peach…I don’t think I would pay BIG bucks for it though

  92. Ruth

    Lancome Poudre Majeur pressed powder
    Estee Lauder Vinyl lip gloss
    Clinique lipstick in Apple Butter
    L’oreal supreme lipstick in Warm Cedar
    Revlon moisturestay lipsticks

  93. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Kim Kim

    3N lipstick, i found it at a CCO and didnt know the treasure i had stumbled upon until it was too late :(

    Redhead MSF, perfect as a blush on me. . . im terrified to hit pan on it

    I never got to try Ripe Peach Ombre blush and would have loved to :(

  94. Sally

    MAC GOLDBIT! It has been 5, FIVE!!!, years since they repromoted it. I have one tiny piece left and I’m clinging for dear life. Also, Moth Brown and Smoke and Diamonds. I was a poor college student when the Barbie collection came out and couldn’t afford anything. A backup for my Emanuel Ungaro Pure Rose l/s would be amazing too.

  95. selena

    i still have fashionably fusc. lipstick!

  96. Brenda

    solar white e/s. I’ve been kicking myself ever since I didn’t buy it.

  97. Brenda

    Cover Girl Pink Aura and Maybelline wet shine lipsticks. i used to have Pink Aura and I’m sorry I ever gave it away.

  98. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Brenda kate

    Oligo Shampoo with the blue lid…this was late 80’s early 90’s…it had the best smell

  99. Vivi

    Milani single eyeshadows- the ones that came in those hard-to-open disk packaging. Gawd, they used to have amazing colors! They don’t have as many now. :/

    Also, the eyeshadows from MAC’s C-Shock collection. Wish they’d relaunch some collections…