Saturday, December 8th, 2012

Temptalia Asks You


What are your top five favorite discontinued products? Share!

Temptalia's AnswerGuerlain Gems Rouge G Lipstick (amazing coral!), Chanel Dragon Rouge Allure Laque (amazing red!), Illamasqua Raindrops Nail Lacquer (gah! gorgeous!), MAC Queen’s Sin Lipstick (beautiful red), Guerlain Parure de Nuit (ethereal highlighter). I could so go on, LOL!

Thanks to Jennie for today’s question! Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

76 thoughts on “What are your top five favorite discontinued products?

  1. Carrie

    Raindrops is the polish that I wish I’d been able to get my hands on. I wasn’t into grays when it first came out so I didn’t want to bite the bullet. I wish I had!

  2. Safyre

    1. MAC Improvise Mineralize Blush – it just looks so pretty and gives me such a nice glow, I love the color of it.
    2. MAC Jingle Jangle Dazzleglass – I LOVED that it was coral with violet glitter. I love that color combo, especially on the lips. Alas mine went rancid :’(
    3. MAC Float on By Eye Kohl – Perfect shade of teal. Nuff said.
    4. MAC Tendertones… I’ve found respectable dupes, but still… good stuff… good stuff…
    5. The Healing Garden line… just in general. I know tidbits float around drugstores and the internet but it’s not cohesive the way it once was. I miss the spa-ish website they once had with the soothing music playing. In particular I really miss the mandarin, green tea, and jasmine therapy lines… Oh and the “sleep” or whatever they calked it… they smelled SO GOOD and were decently priced. *sigh*

  3. xamyx

    1. While not *exactly* discontinued, just in North America, Max Factor Pan Stik (although, I *really* miss the entire braand, in general).

    2. Kat von D Gypsy eyeshadow palette.

    3. NARS Rajasthan.

    4. L’Oreal matte lipsticks-they had a line some 10+ years ago of amazing matte lipsticks; they had the same feel as the regular line, just a bit less “slip”, but the finish was still very matte. The Matte Maraschino was one of the few products I’ve ever bought backups of…

    5. tarte Femme Fatale eyeshadow palette. This was my first of many tarte palettes, and by far the most beautiful, IMO.

    I find it kind of amusing that 2 of my favorite palettes of all time are in the green range, although it’s a color I rarely wear…

  4. Kristanna

    Chanel original dunes palette- best nudes & the double ended automatic lipliners.

  5. Veronica

    I am sensing a theme, there, Christine.

    Hmmm…I haven’t been into cosmetics long enough to really experience the loss of formerly permanently product, so this is mostly LE:

    -Estee Lauder Electric Teal liner (WHY was this the only LE one?!)
    -Maybelline’s original cream mousse blushes. The old formula wore extremely well on me, and none of the new colors are an exact dupe of my HG blush Soft Plum.
    -Urban Decay Strip and Hot Pants. (Additionally, when I glanced over the newly formulated ones at Sephora, I noticed Sin looked a touch different. That’s a shame if it is – the original version is one of my favorites!)
    -MAC What Joy! Gorgeous berry red.
    -Chanel Notorious (purely for the grump factor of missing out on it)

  6. Anne

    Do limited editions count? If so, I’ll be crying tears of despair when I’ll run out of my Chanel Morning Rose nailpolish. Still kicking myself for not snatching another bottle. It’s one of my favourite nailpolish EVER: it just looks awesome on my nails, and I feel very prett when I wear it. I use it very sparingly now.
    I also love my Chanel Graphite- such an interesting take on silvery nailpolishes! It suits me well, too.
    I’ll also be most bummed when I’ll hit the pan of my Giorgio Armani ETK #14, my Guerlain Cruel Gardenia Meteorites or my Chanel Duo in Sable Emouvant, but I suspect that won’t be for a veeeery long time, so I’m not too pressed.
    Honourable mention goes to my Chanel Calypso Glossimer and my Chanel Rouge Allure Extrait de Gloss in Caprice and Troublant. They’re so flattering and easy to wear (might purchase a backup of the latter when I get my Christmas money).

    Well… All the products stated above make up half of my entire, now that I think of it! (Nailpolishes aside…)

    I would have included my Chanel Coromandel nailpolish, but Chanel brought it back to life! :) I love when brands do that.

  7. Evi

    1. Chanel original cake liner (why oh why did they touch this formula. The original 4 liner case was amazing)

    2. Opi Goldiggers delight (I search for this polish and wish they would just rerelease it)

    3. MAX Factor the old stuff from my teenage years.

    4. Ojon Tawaka best lotion and conditioner ever

    5. Borjois (ok I know they are not discontinued but they are also not in any retailers where I can test colors)

  8. VickyM

    The only two products I can think of are Chanel Rouge Coco 15 Ruban Rose, I loved, loved, loved this color :( , and I discovered it was discontinued when I went to repurchase the lipstick…so I have next to nothing left from my last tube, it was such a unique color why discontinue it? the closest color I have found is Rouge Coco 13 Gardenia, it is beautiful I use it alot but it´s not the same :( .
    The next product I can think of is Chanel Graphite, a friend has it and applied it to my nails, and as a result I´m forever angry with myself for not buying that amazing nail polish when I could have.

  9. Chiara

    Dior Addict Beige Dessous (perfect pink-beige glossy nude)
    MAC Femme-Fi eyeshadow
    Catrice Captain Sparrow’s Boat nailpolish (Chanel black pearl dupe)
    Chanel Kaleidoscope nailpolish (shimmery pewter perfection)
    MAC By Candlelight MSF (perfect warm glow)

  10. Dominique

    M.A.C Offshoot lipstick such a gorgeous deep pink
    M.A.C Musky Amethyst simply beautiful( never seen such a gorgeous colour ! )
    Chanel Horizon blush, LE but so beautiful
    Benefit Bad Gal mascara in blue, pretty shade
    Urban Decay Gash lipstick ( doesn’t exist in France anymore I think ) to me it meant a lot, the time when UD was a true innovative makeup brand

  11. katherine

    Chanel Dragon Rouge Allure Laque was *the* most beautiful red! I bought my oldest daughter a tube and she has porcelain skintone and a tube for my middle daughter who has very yellow undertones. One for me and I’m MAC NC 37ish. We all could wear this red! why oh why oh why did they discontinue?

  12. Teresa

    Gerlains Gems Rouge G, MAC Moxie, MAC Emerald Dusk, UD 24/7 eyeliner in honey.

  13. Sara_BeauTime

    Discontinued: Chanel Kaska Beige (perfect natural smokey eye palette),
    Never made permanent, don’t know why: nail polishes like Chanel Jade, Russian collection, contouring like Chanel notorious, Armani’s buttery soft water resistant eye pencils, Tom Ford’s eyeshadow quad Enchanted and some creme eye shadows from last summer.

  14. Stacey

    -Cover Girl- Nail Slicks clear nail polish

    -Dior- Loose Face Powder in Desert

    -Dior Lipstick Color in Fig, actually alot of Dior lipstick colors when the brand was originally called Christian Dior

    -YSL- powder blush, actually the entire original YSL collection when it first came out over 30 years ago…now YSL is so so so dull. It used to say, the casing was made of gold of some sort

    -All those brands that no longer exist, the entire collection such as Halston, Ralph Lauren, Stendahl (mascara)in blue, Orlane face collection, Payot….I miss them all, the packaging design were all so unique…it was not like MAC…you stick a color label design on and change the name then call it “Limited Edition” The glass bottles of Payot were so pretty.

    • Dinitchka

      Funny you mentioned the CG clear nail slicks. I had 4 bottles in my nail stash. Since I have been doing my own nails, I am down to 1. I had to thin them out a lot! They had thickend up.

  15. Orlane

    1) Mac So Scarlet lipstick ( from Cult of Cherry. My HG red, please Mac bring it back! it’s HIGH TIME. )

    2) Mac Morning Frost paint pot ( lovely ! )

    3) Nars Strawberry Fields lipgloss ( such an AMAZING color! )

    4) OPI Designer de better nail polish ( my HG nail polish :( )

    5) Yves Rocher Yria Cils Souplesse lengthening mascara ( I hoard it when I find some at the store. Lancome Definicils is somewhat similar to it but is also significantly pricier! )

    I also regret Yves Rocher Luminelle Rouge lumineux creme lipstick in Petale ( though I did find some other lipsticks that come close to it but argh. ) and Lush Sandstone soap :(.

    • Michelle

      What? I thought OPI designer de better was still available in store, last time I checked. Have you checked your local trade secrets? If you still want a bottle, I’d love to do a nail polish trade with you through MUA! Regardless, good luck finding it. :( I love nail polish and I’d hate it if my favorites were discontinued.

  16. joyce

    1. Tocca Touch: the original formula (the perfume oil). It was the most delicious scent and years later, I’m still sad it’s discontinued :(

    2. stila Convertible Color in Magnolia: a soft mauve nude, it was so pretty.

    3. stila Bare Color lip tints: I loved Bare Wine so much!

    4. Shiseido Sheer Gloss lipsticks: they shrunk the selection down to 4 colors when they reformulated them as Tender Sheers. Those are great too, but I miss the colors from the previous line.

    5. Revlon SkinLights: these were terrific for illuminating/highlighting.

  17. Diana

    Raindrops polish will re-appear next year!

  18. Liz

    I haven’t been into makeup long enough to even notice 5 discontinued products. I do know that Bobbi Brown discontinued Brownie Pink Lip Color, which is upsetting. L’oreal HIP Cream Eyeliner was discontinued, which is so sad. I have a Revlon nail color that I love called Sunset Bronze that is no longer available.

    • Lacey J.

      Loreal hip cream eyeliner was my holy grail. Nothing compares.

      • Veronica

        There’s a store around here called Five and Below that had a huge bunch of them on clearance for about $3-4. I wound up picking the teal one up out of curiosity. I was wondering why they came so cheap, but if they were being discontinued, that could explain it.

  19. 1) MAC Charred Red lipstick.

    2) Jane nail polish (they stopped making these when Jane was bought out).

    3) Wet n Wild single e/s in Penny (and the 6 pans for that matter).

    4)Revlon Super Lustrous Lipstick in Deep Nude.

    5)Revlon Absolutely Fabulous Lipcreams (WHY did they stop making these??!!!).

    • Rainy.

      I totally agree about Jane nail polish. I have 2 bottles of Hot-Blooded stashed away, because it is my favorite red polish.

  20. Mariella

    Discontinued products – the bane of my makeup “history”. First would be Estee Lauder Datenut Red lipstick (this is from absolute DECADES ago, when Karen Graham was the face of Lauder! Probably before most of you were born!). Next would be the whole MAC Starflash eyeshadow line, especially Grand Entrance, which I have and dole out like gold-dust, but also a few of the shadows I was too slow off the mark to get; also from MAC (sensing a pattern here?), Jardin Aires pigment and Sweet Sienna pigment, Subtle Breeze mineralized blush (was too slow off the mark getting it but I think I’d have liked it much more than Early Morning, which I did get!); from Too Faced, La Vie en Rose blush. Is that 5 yet? More than 5?

  21. Laura H

    I am so sad I missed out on Dragon and Raindrops. Normally I would buy it off Ebay but the ridiculously jacked up prices just disgust me !

    • furandlace

      You can find Dragon on strawberrynet.com and the price isn’t jacked up plus shipping is free. The price does vary from retail but usually only by a few dollars here or there. Also they don’t always have it in stock but you can always check back. I’ve seen it there more often than not. HTH!

  22. Kendra

    Don’t know if I can think of five but here’s a few.
    Calvin Klein lipstick in Plush- one of my first lipsticks, it was a gorgeous medium, bright pink with a nice creamy finish. The formula was wonderful, and the color was gorgeous.
    Korres Ginger and Vitamins Foundation- it looked very natural and lasted ALL day. So sad when the stopped making it since I liked this foundation much better then the wildrose foundation and the watermelon tinted moisturizer.
    I can’t really think of any others…

  23. Lisa

    There used to be a Maybelline brow pencil in Charcoal Grey years ago, and it was the perfect shade for me. I also really miss the Viva Glam Cindy lipstick & gloss, New Weed Fluidline and a plethora of Chanel LE lipsticks. One in particular was called Barcelona Red.

  24. Dinitchka

    I LOVE this question! I can’t wait to come back and read the answers!!

    1) L’Oreal – Rouge Pulp Liquid Lipstick in Carnal (or any colour).
    These have been my ALL TIME fav lipstick/glosses. I can’t remember how I got started on these. Once I could no longer find them and found out they were discontinued, I gave up on finding them. THEN I about fell out at the Dollar Tree! I found some. Went to a few other Dollar Tree’s and found more. For a while I could find them. Then my heart was crushed. I could no longer find them. I know they are available on Ebay but I don’t shop on Ebay.

    2) ck Calvin Klein – Tempting Glimmer Sheer Creme in #311 turquoise blue.
    I found 2 CK sets at Sam’s and this was a part of it. I love me some blue e/s. This is my fav cream. I’ve had it for 2 years. It has not dried out and is still as creamy as the day I opened it. It works well for my oily eyelids. These can be found online as well.

    3) Molinard parfum in Gardenia.
    My Grandmum(zt”l)wore this parfum. I was so intrigued by the frilly atomizer. I have not seen it in a LONG time.

    4) Clarins polish in #230.
    This elusive polish was nicknamed ‘Unicorn pee’ or ‘Unicorn tears’. I have seen 2 on Ebay and swatches and pics online. I refuse to pay the prices asked :)

    5)Rock & Republic e/s in Twisted (a pretty plum-y purple) and Skintight (my perfect highlighter)
    I first started buying these on HauteLook. I think I have every e/s, blush and bronzer. I have a few lipsticks, lipglosses and powders. These really are a quality product and I love the packaging! Too bad they shut down production.

  25. Lauryn

    MAC Botanical eyeshadow
    MAC Moth Brown eyeshadow
    MAC Pink Aperitif lipstick
    Stila AOS Eyes *8
    GA Sheer Lipstick 10
    Becca Shantung and Lurex Eyeshadows
    Those huge NARS palettes! I had Honey Rider once upon a time, and who knows where it went now?

  26. Lee

    #1 would be Max Factor 2000 Calorie Mascara in Auburn, it was my holy grail mascara. There simply aren’t any good Auburn mascaras out there right now and Auburn looks so much better on me (very pale redhead) than brown or black.

    MAC Starflash Eye Shadow in Style Snob was the perfect wearable taupe for me. I wish they’d bring back some Starflashes, they were great.

    I’ve always wanted to try Queen’s Sin and I don’t understand why they’ve never brought it back. It sold out before I could buy it the first time around and I’ve been waiting so patiently for it to be repromoted.

    • Ellen Farkas

      On amazon.com you can get a Max Factor maxcara in auburn, its not the 2000 calorie, although I do think they have it in brown and black. I read about it on a website about makeup for redheads and I tried it. It smuudged a little, but it was auburn! Also, there is a website called Just for Redheads. They make several mascaras in redhead shades, I’ve never tried any, but let me know if any work out well for you.

  27. cncx

    i have been able to dupe or replace most of the DC stuff I have used except for two:
    Chantecaille Whisper blush- there are a few that come close to duping but can’t match the texture;
    and a Bobbi Brown lipstick from the early 2000s called Brown Sugar, it was the perfect MLBB shade.

  28. Kate

    MAC lipstick in 3-D (an awesome everyday work lipstick), Urban Decay deluxe eyeshadow in Shag (I have tons of eyeshadows that are this same neutral-bronzey color, but this is by far the best one), Revlon Super Lustrous lip gloss in Nude Lustre (the best nude gloss EVER), Hermes Un Jardin Apres La Mousson (an absolutely gorgeous summer fragrance – melony and gingery and so yummy), and TheBalm To the Rescue lip balm (never found anything comparable).

  29. Amanda

    1. OPI Teenage Dream – My absolute favourite glitter polish! I hate that the one I have is half done and getting clumpy, and the prices for it on eBay are $20+!
    2. Maybelline 24h Color Tattoo in Barely Beige – They’ve come out with another similar colour in another LE collection but they really should make this colour permanent. So pretty!
    3. Urban Decay E/S in Blaze – Mine is shattered. I managed to piece it back together but I’d have loved to be able to buy a new one ):
    4. MAC Tendertones – When the Shop & Cook Collection came out, I really should’ve bought more than just Purring. I hope they come out with more sometime soon. But really, they should make them permanent – they’re awesome!
    5. Lush Snow Fairy – It’s seasonal, so I don’t know if it it counts as discontinued. They bring it out every year, and this year I stocked up because I love it~

  30. Mugdha Patwardhan

    1. Chanel powder blush in Mocha
    2. Christian Dior lipstick in Rouge Mysore (Indian Red)
    3. Lancome lipstick in Breathless, a very deep pink
    4. MAC Copperbeam pigment
    5. Prescriptives Voodoo lipgloss

  31. Kris

    Clairol Hydrience haircolor in Rosewood. I mourn the day that was discontinued and have yet to find a replacement.

  32. Danielle

    1) Mac Romp eye shadow
    2) Mac Shimmermoss eye shadow
    3) Mac Juxt eye shadow
    4) Mac Gem of Rose lipstick (which was LE)

    I’m not sure if I can think of anymore. And I didn’t realize they were all going to be Mac haha.

  33. Gena

    I miss this one product enough for five products put together: Nicholas V. Perricone Ceramic Skin Smoother primer!! This made my skin look sooooo perfect, it appeared to be made of plastic.

    If anyone has a dupe or near-dupe of Perricone Ceramic Skin Smoother, please, please, PLEASE reply to this ccomment!! I’ve been searching for a replacement for long enough!

  34. chris

    IMAN Vanilla Eye Shadow
    MAC Miss Dish and Queen’s Sin Lipsticks
    MAC Rebel and Squirt Lipglasses

  35. Angela

    1. La Prairie Brow Pencil Crayon Pour les Sourcils, 01 Taupe. The original one with an actual pencil on one end, spooly on the other end, and comes with a sharpener in the box. My HG brow pencil, the only one that actually matches, isn’t too soft, too red, grey, or brown. Their new one is nice, same color, w/brush, but somehow, Luxe Browlineer Automatique, with the thin pencil inside & refill, no sharpener, just isn’t the same. Before they disappeared, I bought like like 20 of them! I should be stocked up ’til I’m 60! I hear the Tom Ford brow pencil is awesome so I’m def going to try it soon.

    2. Chanel Teint Pur Mat Matte, Alabaster. In the short round bottle. God, I really miss this stuff!! Consistency was thin a bit like Armani Maestro, it matched my super fair skin PERFECTLY since it was truly neutral, not pink or yellow! HG formula. Nothing’s come close since. Not even Chanel’s new one’s or the Armani Maestro that looks like a dry mask on me. Though, UD Naked .5 is what I’m using now & I’m pretty happy w/that. I’ll be trying all of the Geurlain 01 beige pale’s next.

    3. Mac ?? — after the Chanel Pur Mat discontinued, I was using a Mac foundation in a white/cream color tube, can’t remember the name, it wasn’t the studio sculpt, instead was in a shorter, wider tube. Anyone remember it? Whatever it was, it was discontinued. The formula was really similar to Lancome’s Teint Idole Freshwear, which have now, along with the UD Naked.

  36. 1: Urban Decay Gash eyeshadow
    2: This isn’t make-up, but all of the Sweet On Paris products from Bath and Body Works.
    3: Loreal HIP Chrome eyeliners

    …And that’s all I can think of. xD

  37. kp

    Only 5? ;)

    -Lancome Code Red Lipstick
    -MAC Camel Eyeshadow
    -Nars Kink Lipstick (LE from 10 yrs or so ago)
    -MAC Delish lipstick
    -MAC Goldbit E/S

  38. Jess

    1. Mac maneater eyeshadow
    2. Atmospheric lipglass
    3. The entire smoky palette from the holidays in the black velvet box. Still my go to for smoky eyes.
    4. Rave pearlglide liner (all the purples Mac puts out are le!)
    5. I would have said lucky green but they brought it back. I bought the last 2 from corporate and bid highly on eBay for it!)

  39. JEN

    1. Origins Spring Fever perfume!!! – please Origins bring this back!
    2. MAC Glamour Check! starflash eyeshadow
    3. NARS Danmari blush palette
    4. Origins Spring Fever!!

    Would love all of these for Xmas!

  40. Ellen

    Bobbi Brown lipsitck in Malted and Mocha Stain, Estee Lauder lipsticks in Burnished Bronze and Mysterious Mocha, and the original Prescriptives foundation (and then the whole line!)

  41. Chanel Double Perfection Foundation
    Stila Rouge Pots
    YSL Excite Lipstick
    Essie Starry Starry Night
    Dove Calming Night body wash

    I miss Chanel’s Double Perfection the most! I found that Aqualumiere is quite close but I realized it gives me a bit of an allergic reaction so I can’t use it anymore :( Hope they bring out a new one soon!

  42. Mimi

    YSL lipstick in “Prismatic Purple” was sheer and just the right combo of purple and fuschia without being too loud. It was really flattering.
    A lip pencil by L’Oreal that was part of their Canyon Colors collection. It was the perfect rose/my-lips-but-better/fuschia color. Went with so many of my lipsticks and was so flattering! It was a chubby creamy pencil that I’ve never been able to dupe. Perfect for outlining lips without that ring-around-your-mouth look.

  43. shelly

    1) MAC Strada blush. Lovely contour for pale skins and a pretty blush overall.

    2) MAC Scanty l/s. IMO, the perfect pink — just between baby and bright, if that makes sense.

    3) Victoria’s Secret’s matte/satin finish eyeshadows. They were very easy to work with and blend, not to mention lovely pigmentation. Nice and buttery.

    4) MAC Studio Sculpt Concealer. :(

    5) Can’t think of a fifth.

  44. shelly

    Oops, I thought of a fifth!

    5) LUSH Skinny Dip shower gel. :( :( :( :(

  45. tea-chan

    1) HiP Cream Eyeliners
    2) Sahara eyeshadow from Christian Siriano for VS Makeup
    3) All the old Maybelline Colorama polishes
    4) Sumptuous Color mascaras by Estee Lauder
    5) Lip Enamels from Stila’s Barbie Loves Stila collection. They were added to the permanent collection for a while but not anymore. :c

    …also, makeup brands that don’t exist anymore or are hard(er) to come by, like Perscriptives, Max Factor, Rock & Republic, and Kevyn Aucoin. :/

  46. Ash

    1) Avalon Juniper perfume spray by Pacifica(the solid just isn’t the same)
    2) Gash liquid liner by Urban Decay
    3) Max Factor Erace concealer stick in #221
    4) Ghost shower gel from Lush
    5) Dirty Boy/Dirty Girl styling gel by VAIN

  47. kumsal

    1)dior crıstal shine lip balm and gloss jewel 002
    2)mac devoted poppy : 6 classıc eyes
    3)bobbi brown palette Orchid Eye Shadow Strip
    4)mac hello kitty palette: lucky tom
    5)viva glam gaga 1

  48. Michelle

    I don’t own very many discontinued products, but 2 things do come to mind that I miss very much. Shiseido’s sheer gloss lipsticks were really great and Rock and Republic’s eyeshadows and blushes were the bomb for the price!

    Argh, why’d you have to list the most amazing (Guerlain Gems Rouge G Lipstick) discontinued coral lipstick ever? I’ve been looking for that perfect shade of color since forever! It looks quite similar to one of your favorites, cle de peau #2 gloss, I believe. If you have any other dupes or perfect coraly gold shimmer lippies, please divulge! Thanks in advance :)

  49. 1. NARS Joie de vivre palette (All best sellers in one palette)
    2. MAC Ripe Peach Blush (Gorgeous ombre effect plus beautiful color for pale girls like me
    3. MAC Lipstick Candy Yum Yum (Haven’t found an exact dupe yet)
    4. Color Tattoo in Barely Beige (Amazing dupe for Bare Study and I can’t find it since it was LE)
    5. MAC MSF in By Candlelight (Wish I had it even tho if ppl say its just like soft and gentle the pinks on it make it different for me)
    And just a sixth. MAC Paint Pot in Soft Ochre which I can’t find anywhere and its perfect for us pale gals. (My perspective obv).

  50. L

    I don’t have anything ._., and I hope I never do because it would suck to not be able to get it.

  51. Laura

    1) Revlon Skinlights Illuminating Powder
    2) Estee Lauder So Clean Deep Pore Mask
    3) Lush Crash Course in Skin Care Fresh Face Mask
    4) Rescue Beauty Lounge Aqua Lily
    5) NARS Diablo Lip Lacquer

  52. reena

    maybeline lash stylist mascara!!

    does anyone know a dupe for this??

  53. Jess

    I forgot Mac Firespot, which I sorely miss!

  54. MAC yellow color corrector
    MAC Studio sculpt concealer
    MAC MV2 perfume
    Maybelline Wet Shine Lipstick in Wine Shine
    Max Factor everything, lol

  55. Liz

    Ok, I’m not including LE items in this list, because that would be a loooong list. So, permanent items only, that have been d/c:

    Quo True Skin Tinted Moisturizer – This product got rave reviews everywhere I looked, and yet the discontinue this and keep a bunch of mediocre products in their lineup.
    Quo Minerals Matter duo in Sahara Sand
    Sally Hansen Lip Quencher – the ONLY truly heavy duty lip product that would fix my lips any day, no matter what
    MAC 272 brush – WHY???
    MAC 15-pan palettes – Good thing I have one extra empty one, I sure hope I never fill it. No one should have more than 6 of these filled. But alas, we do anyway.
    Can I also add Viva Glam Cyndi lipstick? I know it was LE, but it was around for a year. I wish they kept this in the perm VG lineup.

  56. Jessica

    I don’t know if I can think of 5 products, but I love MAC Go For It lipstick! It’s seriously the most perfect real purple lipstick, and I mean real because it’s truly blue-based light mid tone purple and not reddish or burgundy purple. Plus, its semi-opaque and glossy, and perfect for brown girls, lol. I’m down to the end of my tube, makes me sad. I have MAC Prolongwear in Goes and Goes but it’s not the same; a color dupe isn’t good enough, unfortunately.

  57. they’re mostly sentimental…
    Stella Mccartney Rose Absolute parfum(I just really like it, this is the only one I’ve missed as an adult)
    Urban Decay Face Case in Sell-out(LOVED this when i was a teen)
    Urban Decay Body Powder in Champagne
    the entire Hard Candy line circa 2000(another middle school throwback<3)
    Clinique Lip Glosses in the little pots with the brushes from around 1998
    these are mainly things i miss from when i was entering junior high and first starting to care about makeup. such fun memories. <3

  58. caitlin

    1. UD shadow in gash

    2. UD 24-7 liner in honey :(

    3. stila + barbie lip laquers

    4. abercrombie & fitch perfume in ready (i am not an abercrombie girl by nature but this scent was perfect and cheap!)

    5. hard candy when it used to be sold at sephora..they have completely changed it now!

  59. Claire

    1. Urban Decay eyeshadow in Gash
    2. Hard Candy Eyeshadow Palette in Techno (I still have mind, it had the most beautiful iridescent white that I could never find a dupe of!)
    3. MAC eyeshadow in Lovelace (LE)
    4. I missed out on MAC Candy Yum Yum and I really wanted to try it.
    5. Jane Eyeshadow in Cool Pink, it was my first eyeshadow!

  60. jiya

    my fav all time is fibre rich mascara from mac, i would buy 20 if it ever comes back!! :))

  61. Looking for Bobbi Brown calyspo coral lipstick. Impossible to find. HELP!