Swatch Gallery

Looking for the perfect color?
Look no further than Temptalia's Swatch Gallery.

Foundation Matrix

Need help finding your perfect foundation shade?
The Foundation Matrix is designed to help.

Dupe List

Duplicate a high-end product or never buy
the same shade twice. The Dupe List is here to help.

The Scarlet Season: MAC New York Apple Lipstick

Wednesday, December 23rd, 2009


MAC New York Apple Lipstick

The Scarlet Season: MAC New York Apple Lipstick

MAC New York Apple Lipstick ($14.00) is a classic berry-based red. It’s a deep raspberry red with lots of lighter raspberry shimmer. This has always been one of my favorite MAC lipstick shades, red or not, and it’s something that suits a lot of skin tones. It can be worn alone or topped with gloss for an extra kick. MAC lipsticks usually last four to six hours on me, depending on the finish (lustres wear off the fastest), and this one stays on for somewhere in-between–five hours or so. I love layering this with a gold gloss to make it perfect for the holidays!

What about you? Would you wear this red?

The Scarlet Season is a series of posts showcasing and featuring my favorite shades of red lips–from glosses to lipsticks that runs through December 2009. You can sure expect to see a lot of red this holiday season!

See photos and swatches…

Dolce & Gabbana Ruby Lipstick
MAC New York Apple Lipstick

Dolce & Gabbana Ruby Lipstick
MAC New York Apple Lipstick


MAC New York Apple Lipstick

Dolce & Gabbana Ruby Lipstick
MAC New York Apple Lipstick

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Love this color on you Christine. So much so, I had someone pick it up for me yesterday. Cant wait until I get it.

Hope you love it, Allison :)

It has been a while since I got this color. I loved it in the tube and in swatches on my hand, but not so much on my lips...it felt like something was missing. I found out on Saturday what that something was...Creme Allure Dazzleglass Cream! I love the two of them together! :D

Oh I love this one!!! It's one of the most elegant and wearable reds I have and I just love it!! :)

I own this one. I really need to pull it out again, based on your swatches. It's gorgeous

I love NY apple, although it looks distinctly pink on me, rather than red. It's strange how shades can appear so differently on people.

I am not usually bold enough to wear a red lipstick, but I think that the raspberry shimmer in it takes it back a little bit to make it a little bit more acceptable. I love it.

This looks like the perfect red but I have thin lips and am terrified of red lipstick on them. Wish I had the lips to pull this off because I really love the color.

You should give it a try, Rachel :)

You know what? Try the Russian Red lipglass first to make your lips slightly 'fuller' looking, first. Or try a dark pink lipstick.

I am totally lemming this, I adore frosty raspberry reds, I'm NW15/NW20 and it seems like fate! But I'm on a no-buy. Any dupes out there that run cheap?

I gotta say, I usually stick to neutral lips but I really like this red!! Do you think it'll look okay with a heavier eyeliner look? Or is it definitely better paired with neutral eyes?

You could, if you did it just right!

I have this lipstick. It is my very favorite red. It's the perfect shade for everyone and makes my teeth look whiter in contrast. I just love it! ttfn :) Yuki in chilly Silver Spring, Maryland

merry christmas christine! this is gorgeous on you. i'm so glad i found your blog and i hope i win a giveaway one of these days! xxoo

Thanks so much, Yvette! Happy holidays!

You think this could be anice red for my NC43 skin?

Yes, definitely Susan!

Oh yes I would wear this! It really does look like gloss. :) How does it feel?

Hey Christine, how does NY Apple compare to Queen's Sin or Port Red? They look sort of similar... but beautiful!

It's way, way more berry-ish - it has more berry/raspberry in it, whereas both of those have a lot of red in them.

I love this lipstick - it's one of my faves, though I sadly haven't been able to pick it up yet!

looks really nice! I will try that next time I am at the mac counter Happy holidays Christine!

Happy holidays, Silvia!

Wow, this is gorgeous! I have a few B2M empties, I'll make sure to get this lipstick with them when I next go to a Mac counter! Thanks Christine!

That is really pretty. That may be my next B2M lipstick!!

How did I not know about this stunning colour??? Hello boxing day pickup with my MAC gift card :) Thanks Christine!!! You introduce me to so many delicious products - I along with VISA thank you :) hehe

LOL! Are you SURE your Visa thanks me? Doesn't want to beat me over the head? ;)

Hahaha, I'm sure VISA thanks you b/c I use their services to buy makeup! Lol bad habit :( I actually gave my bf my visa this holiday season as I have no self control!!! Lol so sad. So maybe my bf wants to frown at you! Lol not me though :)

LOL! OK, I can see that ;)

Ahh! I love this -- stunning. And I agree; it looks very wearable!

I love that color! Looks great on your lips, Christine!

This is really pretty! I can't wait for your round-up (sooo many reds!)!

Hey I really like this red. I don't really wear reds not because I don't like them they just seem to high maintenance for me. I would worry all the time about smearing and looking messy(maybe I have too many little girl playing w/granny's red lipstick memories). I have enjoyed the scarlet season however is there going to be a pink season coming? LOL. That would probably break my bank for sure!

There's the Spring Season - soft pinks, nudes, and corals :)

But New York Apple is a really nice looking red on you Christine! And it's subtle; not too frosty and either the way you've applied it or the way the lipstick actually is, it looks slightly sheer in a good way too.

Thank you! It's a good color for a more berry kind of red!

Oh! And a plum season perhaps? hahaha I know lipsticks can be a bit much after a while. Thanks for taking the time to lip swatch all of these BTW. =) helps so much!

I would wear this and so would my mom lol

I have this thing where I generally do not like frosty reds, but this one seems really nice to me! I'll have to try it out & see.