Thursday, October 23rd, 2008

OVERALL, some of the palettes offer long-time MAC fans colors they haven’t seen before. As always, the warm palette suckered me in, though I’ll use it once or twice and it’ll get forgotten–I just know it! The lip palettes were surprising, because I’ve never been too drawn to them before, but I found two shades I really wanted to have. I only succumbed to the Coral Lips palette (again, bad move on my part), but the Plum Lips is tempting. Ironically, the Plum Lips is probably more wearable for me than the Coral Lips palette!

Quick review of the brush sets: The brush sets are $35 at Nordstrom’s. Yes, $35, down from $49.50. I do not know why, but I only know that this was confirmed by the Nordstrom MA. So get your brush sets at Nordstrom’s if you can! The brush sets are just like previous years’ sets–the handles are just a different color. This year the handles are a shiny bright holiday red with darker, metallic ferrules.

You can get official descriptions here as well as product photos here.

Detailed reviews…

Devoted Poppy: 6 Classic Eyes

  • Sweet Eyes is a soft, satiny light beige with a touch of gold in it.
  • Amorously is a rich, coppery color with a nice metallic sheen. It’s similar to Amber Lights in color, but not as frosty or shimmery.
  • In Awe is very matte-like in texture. It’s a very dark brown, almost with a touch of black. It reminds me of Smut, but with a semi-matte texture.
  • Young Thing is a soft light peach, very pale and low in shimmer.
  • Awaken is a glittery pale, pastel green. It reminds me of one Lustreleaf.
  • Fall Deeply is a mid-tone bule crossed with periwinkle for a very nice shade of blue not currently available in the permanent line.

Intriguing Scarlet: 6 Warm Eyes

  • Sweet Joy is a soft, pale peach-gold color. Obviously the highlighter of the bunch!
  • Well Spiced is a warm-toned mid-tone brown. It reminds me a lot of Arena or Texture (permanent colors).
  • Real Drama is a burgundy-toned dark brown, so I can appreciate the dimension in the shade.
  • Warm Suede is an antique gold with flecks of green, making it both colors depending on the lighting.
  • Gentle Heat is a soft golden taupe-gray. It’s hard to describe. It’s brown, and yet there’s gray in it and flecks of gold.
  • Grand Entrance is a dark, satiny forest green. It’s got darkness and intensity, but the green is still visible.

Infatuating Rose: 6 Cool Eyes

  • Satisfy is a chalky whitish-pink color. It’s not frosty, though, just very pale and pigmented.
  • Bonfete is a pale frosty pink; it reminds me a lot of Pink Freeze, but with better color payoff and texture.
  • Feast is a pretty shade of berry-pink. I don’t know if this shade has been done before.
  • Cavort is a purpler Stars ‘n Rockets. It has some of the dimension that Stars ‘n Rockets has, but this is clearly a bright lavender purple.
  • Platonic is a grayer purple with a periwinkle base to it. It’s like a lighter Cinders (an old holiday shade).
  • Deep Feelings is an intensely rich blue-black-purple kind of shade. I guess that makes it indigo, but I think it has a little more purple to it.

Fascinating Ruby: 6 Smoky Eyes

  • Scant is a satiny beigey-peach shade. It’s a little chalky to me, though not in a bad way – just a way where I’d have to be careful with it on my brow bone.
  • Satin Taupe is a permanent color, but this seems a lot lighter than what I already have.
  • Dark Devotion is a matte-ish dark brown. It doesn’t stand out in a crowd, that’s for sure.
  • Gorgeous is a silvery-white shimmer shade. It reminds me of Electra, but maybe a shade or two lighter.
  • Ambiance is a semi-matte textured mid-tone gray with silver flecks.
  • Carbon is a matte black, and if you don’t own it, you should. That’s really all there is to say about Carbon!

Devoted Poppy: 3 Coral Lips

  • Transparent Love is a peachy-orange color; more of a coral-peach thank anything. It has soft multi-colored shimmer in it.
  • Devoted is a cherry-toned coral. It’s kind of like red and orange, but more pink-red still.
  • Soft Talk is a more intense version of Devoted (not sure why they’re so similar!). It’s richer, more pigmented, and it has brighter gold shimmer in it. This shade is stunning! It reminds me a little of Red Flame/Orange Flicker prolongwear.

Intriguing Scarlet: 3 Cool Pink Lips

  • Sheer Vision is a frosty pale baby pink that goes on pretty sheer.
  • Make Me Melt is a blue-based mid-tone pink with soft fuchsia shimmer.
  • Overjoyed is a muted pink with yellow undertones.

Fascinating Ruby: 3 Plum Lips

  • Mutual Attraction is a rosy-berry sheer shimmer gloss with some color, but not a lot.
  • Insinuate is the stunner of this palette. It is a light raspberry shade with the most gorgeous gold shimmer.
  • Marvel is a sheerer version of Insinuate in a sense, but the shimmer is less gold and more pink.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

39 thoughts on “MAC Cosmetics Passions of Red Collection Review

  1. Jen

    It’s going to be hard to resist those eye pallets! How can I save up for Christmas presents when MAC comes out with all these holiday collection?? No harm in treating myself once in awhile, right?

    I can’t wait for the Little Darlings collection! OOooOoh! Thanks for the swatches!

  2. gypsydancermacaholic

    Thank you so much for this info. You just saved me some money on the brush sets!

  3. sej

    I called my Nordstrom to make sure, and it’s true! Brush sets are only $35 at Nordstrom only and they are going to sell out fast!

  4. RuBie

    I think the brush sets were probably marked down because of the quality. A lot of people who got brush sets last year didn’t like it that much, saying ones the got in previous years were much softer, but I checked out this year’s ones at the MAC counter nearby and they seem to be even worse.

  5. PorcelainPirate

    Wow, I just LOVE the warm eye pallete. I might have to indulge myself!

  6. DevilishDoll

    I love Feast, Cavort and Platonic from the Cool Eyes. I doubt I’ll end up getting it though. Got too much other stuff to buy right now.

  7. Ashley

    Love these palettes but I get little MAC for Christmas (I feel bad enough spending that kind of money on myself let alone asking others for it!!) and need to save up for presents so this is a pass! Not too disappointed though, I hardly reach for my palette from last year.

  8. alex

    I have to agree with RuBie. I saw the brushes in person yesterday and they are FOUL. Not soft, hair falling out all over the place. The 266SE is twice as thick as the full sized (There’s no way you could ever use it to apply eyeliner) and the 187SE was a sad joke compared to the original. You’d be better off buying art brushes from a craft store

    • Wow! That’s crazy. The ones I felt weren’t like that at all.

      • alex

        I saw them at Macy’s. Maybe the ones in MAC stores are better? I’ll have to check them out the next time I’m in an actual store. I’m a little scared of what the budget Nordstrom ones will look/feel like when the full priced ones at Macy’s were so… well… janky.

        • I don’t think they’re made any differently from store to store! I don’t know why they would. The price change JUST came down to employees yesterday, so it doesn’t sound like something they’ve planned. Nordie’s might even be subsidizing the discount for all we know.

          I wonder if maybe the ones you saw were really used? I have no idea.

  9. victoria

    the only palette i like is the warm palette but i’m hesitating because i think i got a lot of dupes for those colors. it is a good buy and the shadows have great payoff, it just may not be worth getting for myself.i like the packaging but i LOVED the packaging last year,last year’s compact had some weight to it too. still you never know i might get it in the end.

  10. I want the warm palette! And the cool! Wait, the lip ones too! LOL! Thanks for some great swatches! Isn’t it confusing that they have a Grand Entrance in green here? :(

  11. pia

    I hope the state of my bank account would stop me from wanting to log on to computer and order the eye palettes from this collection. *praying*

  12. claudine

    why did they call one shadow grand entrance i think its confusing
    wasnt that the name of one of the starflash shadows too?
    why would they do that?

  13. Whitney

    really – less at nordies???? Might have to pick up doubles then

  14. shangrila

    off to nordies!!!!(oh, my poor nordies card……)

  15. cloudburst

    I ended up with the warm e/s palette, but I have my eye on the neutral lip set and maybe the smokey e/s palette – although I really don’t need the smokey eyes as all those colours are dupeable (if not perm). I think I’m gonna skip the brush sets altogether and just buy whatever full sized ones I need.

  16. Angi

    Am I the only one that was very disappointed in the shadow color payoff in some of the shades in the Classic set? That green was horrible. Even the SA couldn’t find something good to say (though she did avoid saying anything bad). I loved the others and bought the warm set. I checked out the cool one but a couple of those colors would not work for me so I passed on it.

  17. the swatches are of which palettes? :D

  18. Christine! I have no idea what to get! Gaah! Anything you’d recommend for me?

    • I think you could really rock the Cool Eyes palette! I just see those colors working so well with your skin tone. Skip the lip palettes, the pay off is just so subpar!

  19. kuku

    what would be a close color to Gentle Heat… i love it but I don’t want to buy the whole palette.