We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

109 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.

Again, I change things up almost every day, but some I know I’ve been hitting more often than others lately. Notably, the pinkish peach shade in KVD Alchemist, along with Emerald or Saphye, plus CP Lunch Money have all been getting plenty of use. MAC Highlight The Truth MSF and LM Matte Radiance 01, also.

The shades in the Alchemist palette literally make your skin look like it’s naturally radiating whatever color you use. It’s amazing. You can see it from every angle and it looks like your skin! It’s an insanely amazing formula. Def grab it when you get a chance.

I prefer to use a lighter concealer as a highlighter versus a shimmery cream or powder. I alternate between two Charlotte Tilbury products: The Retoucher and Mini Miracle Wand. Both are light-reflective and I prefer the look and finish they give my skin versus something with shimmery particles.

For a subtle highlight, Becca Moonstone pressed powder; for a blinding hightlight, MAC Tutu from the Nutcracker Sweet, so pretty!!

I am using a more subtle highlight over the past couple of weeks and it doesn’t have a name. It is from a Heimish (Asian makeup company) face palette that has a highlighter, blush and contour. I really like the highlight and the blush. The contour is too dark and red undertoned for me to use as a contour or a bronzer (which I don’t really use anyway) but I have used it as a transition shade when used lightly through the crease,

I haven’t been using one lately! But most recently, the liquid Becca in Opal–I blend it out with a damp beauty blender and it’s nicely subtle, but glowy.

MAC Extra dimension Eyeshadow in Triple Impact (yes, really!) and Milk makeup holographic stick. Holo or nothing, I guess ?

All others have been abandoned for the subtle Laura Mercier Matte Radiance 01. At my age, it’s enough. It doesn’t highlight my eye troughs, which most other highlighters seem to. The LM adds just enough. So many others are SOOOO beautiful, but this works best for me.

Laura Mercier baked Highlight 01, Revlon cream highlighter 200 Pink Light, Dior Amber Diamond. For night out the bolder Modern Mercury, Dior Glowing Nude. The Balm Mary-Lou. Huston, I have a problem’

I’m still experimenting with different highlighters, but when I’m in a hurry and want something that’s reliably pretty on me, no matter what else I have on, with minimal effort, then Hourglass Incandescent (or Iridescent) does the trick.

The new Milani Strobelight Instant Glow Powder in the shade Afterglow. When it first arrived I wasn’t the most blown away by it. (it was beautiful but took SO long to build up) I did this trick I remember having to do on a MAC blush once, took a very scratchy brush I don’t like and took it all over the surface of the highlighter to get the very top layer off. Not so buildable anymore but I don’t mind because it is LITERALLY the glow I have been looking for all my life. I am considering passing on the upcoming Plisse Lumiere de Chanel and instead going in on a couple backups of this baby. I really am impressed with the way it works with my particular skintone (MAC NW15-20ish, fair with pink undertones) and how NOT glittery it is. This is a highlighter I can wear absolutely anywhere depending on how I apply and build it. I love it so much, even my Cle de Peau Luminizing Face Enhancer has taken a backseat lately.

I read a review just yesterday praising the new Milani Strobelight Instant Glow Powder. The writer spoke of the ease of application and the wonderful effects of the powder. She had tried the Golden Glow shade. I wonder if perhaps the Afterglow shade is more difficult to apply than the Golden Glow?

TheBalm Mary Lou-Manizer. Although, I finally bought WNW Reserve your Cabana last week and I’ve been experimenting with it. Color is nice but it’s so dusty. I prefer the application of TheBalm so I’m still not sure how I feel about WNW.

I find Reserve Your Cabana to be closer to an ambient lighting powder than a true highlighter, though in my opinion it is more subtle than both! I used it more as a finishing powder and and under eye setting powder to brighten up under the eye (though I don’t really do it in winter as where I live is very hard on skin and it can make my under-eyes look dry since my skin tends towards dryness by default). It doesn’t reflect under a flash and is very sublet in sheen so outside of deep winter it works quite nicely.

Becca topaz and nars unfiltered I watch me. I use the Becca when I want more a a blingy blinding highlight and the nars for a soft but glowy highlight. These two highlighters are all I need in life! Love them. I hope the nars is sold separately so that I can repurchase.

Hands down the MACxTaraji Highlight. It’s the perfect peachy highlight that gives deeper skin tones that “lit from within” type of glow. I never thought I would use a highlighter everyday, but this one has been on non stop since I bought it.
For nights out, I use The Balm Mary Loumanizer or a MAC Extra Dimension Skinfinish that has a bronzy and golden highlight ( I can’t remember the name).

Hourglass Diffused Light. More like a powder than a real highlighter, but it’s the only one I have — am not so much into highlighters — and it works fine for my needs. I use lightly on top of checks / below the undereye area, to bring just a little brightness.

Although I don’t wear highlighter regularly, I’ve really been enjoying Becca Shimmering Skin Perfector Pressed in Topaz for nights out. For a more subtle, casual glow, I’ve found a beautiful gem at the dollar store by L.A. Colors in the color bronze. It is so pretty and versatile on my NC45 skin tone! I can use it on its own for a subtle glow, or I mix with blush for a nice bronze tone. I have two or three for backups just in case Dollar Tree discontinues it.

Dior Nude Air Glowing Gardens Illuminating Powder 001 (LE Pink)
Burberry Fresh Glow Nude Radiance No. 1 Highlighting Powder

Could these names get any longer? Sheesh!

My holy grail highlight is Sephora Brand Baked Luminizor in 01 Star Dust.

But MUFE ME512 (a shimmery gold!) has been my go lately for a quick highlight!!

Estee Lauder Modern Mercury. I just love this highlighter and I wish they would make more but I don’t think it will be happening anytime soon. My favorite two items from Estee Lauder Victoria Beckham collaboration is the Modern Mercury Highlighter and the Single Shadow Bitter Clove. I just purchased the New Dior in 02 which I hope I love just as much as the 01.

ELF baked blush/highlighter in Pinktastic. One of the best highlighters I have ever used and was only $3. It is pigmented, nice color, perfect shimmer.

I don’t really wear much in the day, a touch of Tom Ford’s Moodlight or some of Guerlain’s Meteorites. I just received the Kevyn Aucoin Neo Highlighter, and it seems very subtle and glowy for day so it might be a new favourite. I collect highlighters like a fiend though, must be the packaging!

Depending on the day, my go-two highlighters are MUG Lit & Jouer Ice. Lit I love bc it doesn’t have a color as a base. It’s a translucent base w/ peach & pink reflects. But Ice is has that white base that stands out on my skin & shines beautifully. I have a million highlighters but these are the two I reach for over all others.

I have actually discovered that in addition to a bomb highlight, Laura Mercier’s Matte Radiance 01 makes an amazing finishing powder with a light hand – it makes my skin look like CREAM!!! And I own all the Hourglass Ambient Light powders, they don’t compare.

I’m determined to use up 2 highlighters this year. One is a very old pan of Laura Gella Portofino & the other is a Mac cream highlighter in shell. These two are well loved, but I’ve promised myself not to add anymore to the collection until I see these in the empties bag!

I’ve got a few that have migrated to my everyday basket. MAC pink buttercream face powder, mac strobe cream. BECCA ssp poured in Pearl and ssp pressed in rose quartz. MAYBELLINE master highlight blush in nude. HARD CANDY glow all the way ombré baked blush in punch. GUERLAIN meteorites in 02- Clair. Charlotte Tilbury bar of gold.
Which is way more highlighter than anyone needs but I love to switch it up everyday.

Becca opal poured. Now I’ve been using Becca opal in a bottle that’s a facial highlighter, a little bit does a lot and oh so dewey faced.

For everyday, I use my trusty The Balm Mary Lou-minizer. I have a tan complexion, and it works great for me. (I’ve been wearing just this one highlighter for a few years now! A pan lasts forever!) I get compliments all the time!

I did buy the new Too Faced Peach Palette with the highlighter, blush, and bronzer, so we’ll have to see if I like it.

For special events or nighttime, I like Jefree Star Ice Cold. Again, I have a tan complexion, but a little goes a long way and is so beautiful.

This was a fun question. I do love a blinding highlight!!!

I used Too Faced Candlelight Glow in Rosy Glow for years … actually was on my second compact when I bought the trio of fair skin highlighters from Make Up Geek. I’m using those for the time being.

I only have one and I love it so I use it subtly every day! It’s Mac mineralize something Soft n Gentle. It’s silver and Gold I adore it! I’m thinking of trying a pink one next maybe BB sunset glow and/or hourglass.

Surprisingly NARS Hot Sand. Typically I don’t wear a gold highlight as I don’t think it compliments my skin tone but since it was included in Unfiltered II I tried and OH MY. I just love it. It gives me the most beautiful warm glow.

Oh boy. MAC Extra Dimension Skin Finish in Double Gleam, Lorac Starlight, Makeup Revolution baked highlighters in Radiant Light and Peach Light (quite nice and very reasonable in price), MUFE Pro Light Fusion in 01 Golden Pink, and if I want something more subtle I’ll use the ELF highlight palette or Hourglass Ambient Lighting palette. I came late to the highlighter party and I’m trying to catch up, lol.

Laura Mercier Matte Radiance 01. Probably always will be! It goes with my skintone so perfectly that I don’t have to worry about which bronzer or blush to wear with it, I just know that it’ll work. Plus it’s both intense and nearly textureless.

Mine is LM Matte Baked Radiance in 01…subtle and glowy!
I do have a suggestion for you, Christine: do you think you can show us a side face picture to demonstrate the highlight on the cheekbones? Its hard to tell the texture, shimmer, sparkle, etc from that far away and also from a front-view picture of your face. Its almost like it captures the light on the apple of your cheeks the same way for every highlighter and it makes it difficult to compare highlighters on your face and predict how they will look on us… If you could make a gif of you turning your head to see how light captures your highlight on your cheekbone, that would be even better.
What do you think?

MAC Nutcracker Sweet Tutu and Too Faced Candlelight Glow in Rosy Glow. I have Becca Moonstone, but I feel like it emphasizes my pores a little bit. I prefer powder form.

Am probably a lightweight compared to a lot of you ladies as I only own 4 highlighters – NARS Albatross, UD Angel from the Gwen Stefani palette and both Ballerina and Gilded Honey by Laura Geller. Out of these my go to is Ballerina as it gives just the right amount of subtle sheen.

MUFE Pro Light Fusion in 01 (the pink)! This is the fist advertised highlighter that doesn’t emphasize my larger pores & looks as natural as a highlighter can look from every angle. Love. Love. Love!

* KVD’s Alchemist palette formula has a similar effect on my skin, in how it makes it look like it’s just naturally glowing w/color, however is less “natural-looking”.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!