We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • b-glowing20% off skincare orders of $60+ with code 20SKINCARE, ends 10/25.
  • Ulta50% off Urban Decay Naked Concealer (now $14.50), ends 10/28.

Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

Get Updates by Email

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!


Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic.

Please do not ask if/when a review will be posted as we cannot review everything and often change priorities from day-to-day. If you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us. Thank you!

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

Just got a Maybelline Full n Soft mascara at a discount store for $3 today! Don’t need a new one yet, but for that price, I couldn’t pass it up.

Rich Mahogany and Mossy Green Color Tattoos by Maybelline
Charmed, I’m Sure and Love Goddess l/s from MAC

I don’t know if it counts, but I just bought the UD Smoked palette, and I primarily wanted a backup of Rockstar & Mushroom, which I have in the “old” formula, and I wanted another Loaded, which *really* makes brown eyes pop. I find greens to be a bit tricky, but this I wear alot.

I also just picked up L’Oreal Infallible in Smoldering Plum. It was on sale as a BOGO 50%, so I picked it up, although I have Burning Black. I wasnt’t sure they were *exactly* the same, but I figured it couldn’t hurt.

I usually only buy backups if there’s a BOGO Free deal, and usually only with foundation.

Tough as Taupe. It’s partially because it melted and separated in my car, but not really because I was able to fix it. It’s mostly because its a brilliant product that I’d hate for them to ever stop making.

I bought two palette refills of the MAC Pro Sculpting Powder in Sculpt. I was at South Coast Plaza and took advantage of the physical MAC PRO store! πŸ™‚

MAC 35 Lash. These are my favourite lashes and I was really upset when MAC discontinued them so when they were repromoted with the Marilyn Monroe collection I had to stock up!!!

Oh craaaap read this wrong i thought you meant last beauty product bought in general ): Blonde moment and I’m not even blonde…

I rarely backup a product, mainly due to money issues, but I did recently buy a backup of MAC’s Forever Marilyn Beauty Powder. It’s perfect for us pale folk, and with a name like that it’s unlikely it will be re-promoted any time soon.

MAC’s Crew highlighting powder from the Hey Sailor! collection. I absolutely LOVE it & use the hell out of it. I don’t think I’ve bought a backup of anything else, ever, as I always wind up finding something I like better not long after. Most limited edition products don’t get me very excited, but this one is something I want to have around for a very long time.

Oh, actually, I’m wrong. I always buy a backup of my L’oreal Double Extend waterproof mascara because I use it all the time – I know it’s not limited edition or anything but it’s one of the rare mascaras that I really love & would be very upset if they ever discontinued it. Most flake like crazy & have rubbish, clumpy formulas with ridiculously enormous brushes that I just hate. I’m talking to YOU MAC, CoverGirl & Makeup Forever! Even the more expensive brands I’ve tested out I’ve found the same problems with. I also bought two of theBalm’s Two-Timer mascaras when they were on sale for about $8 each. Love the formula, brushes, everything about that mascara and don’t want to run out of it anytime soon. The stuff is bulletproof!

Oddly I don’t really buy backups, I might buy two of an item so I can have one in my ‘go to’ handbag make-up and one in my main stash.

The last actual backup must have been about 15 years and was a Max-Factor eye-shadow that was being discontinued. It was a great colour that I could use as a blush as well. Still trying to find a good dupe.

FUSION BEAUTY Balm Lip Conditioning Stick – in Butterscotch, my absolutly favorite Lip Balm and discontinued

Not so much a backup but duplicates so I can carry one in my bag and keep one where I put on my makeup – it would be GOSH pencil liners in Black Ink and Metallic Brass.

The Marilyn Monroe MAC Beauty Powder ‘Forever Marilyn’ – I absolutely love the colour on my face as an all-over highlighting powder, it’s the absolute perfect shade for me so I had to buy two!

MAC Real Posh lipglass from the Cosmetics Company Store because it’s limited edition, even though I’m on a no buy at this time.

I try not to buy backups, since I rarely get through a full sized product. But, I did buy a couple of UD Smog eyeshadows when Sephora had them for $6 – it’s one of my top eyeshadows of all time, and I couldn’t resist the price.

I purchased backups of the Maybelline Color Tattoos in Rich Mahogany and the gold one, both from the limited edition fall collection. I won’t be surprised if all four colors are worked into the regular line.

So far none though I occasionally think about buying another OPI Teenage Dream while it’s still available. Rationally I know that I’ve never used up an entire bottle of polish so it’s probably a waste to get a backup.

I’m try to be strict with myself about finishing/or nearly finishing until the product expires before I buy replacements. I share a studio apartment so I don’t have much free space to store makeup I’m not currently using. πŸ™‚

Wet n Wild Vanity, sadly they discontinued it but that’s my favorite out of all my palettes I’ve ever purchased because of the mattes and the one gold color. They’re easy to work with and look great on my dark brown eyes.

Tarina Tarantino Neopolitan Lane blush! I bought it first when it went on sale, then loved it so much I had to buy a backup!!

I am tempted to do the same. I bought one last week when it went on sale and have been using it every day since. But I’ve never hit pan on any product no matter how much I love it… so I’m afraid I’ll regret it if I buy another. Oh what to do!

Honestly? My first Rouge G (Garance). I misplaced it, thought it was gone forever, and immediately bought another one. Now I have two.

Revlon’s Lilac Pastelle lipgloss. Just wanted to be prepared in case they discontinued it. I love that gloss on top of a few of my purple lippies.

Smashbox Halo powder and Smashbox BB cream. I really love Halo. It makes my face look so healthy and alive. I really loved the BB cream in the summer, but now that it’s fall, I’m back to heavier foundations. And the color match isn’t as good as it had been in the summer when I was darker. So, my backup is going to be put away until it gets warm again.

I just bought 10 Maybelline Full n Soft mascaras because I found them for $3. I gave 5 to my daughter.

I bought 6 bottles of Latisse and 6 Retin-As because I get them from India and the shipping is expensive. I get enough for a year.

Voce poderia me orientar como e onde voce compra o Latisse e o Retin-Como, sou brasileira e gostaria muito de suas informaçáes.Obrigada, se possivel responder no meu e mail, agradeço. Bjs.

UD Primer Potion in the pro sized tube…only because it was on sale and my first thought was that with UD that’s a good sign that they are either getting rid of that size all together or they are changing the formula or packaging. Plus I needed to use up the last of my pro discount allotment before it reset in October. A girl can never have too much primer potion lol

I bought like 8 Maybelline Lash Stylist waterproof mascaras when they discontinued it. I buy Maybelline Dream Matte Powder whenever they are on sale too. I go through powder fast. What else…cleansers and eye makeup removers. The only time I purchased a back up of any color products is when Poppy King had her partnership w J. Crew. Bought two of the lipsticks. I love the color, but I probably will never get to the back up. Plan foiled!

Actually, there are several back-ups I purchased at the same time: Tarte Lights Camera Lashes (my HG mascara; bought 2 for the price of 1 during Ulta’s 21 days of beauty), Rimmel nail polish in Hard Metal (one of my top 5 polishes of all time; also bought 2 of these, BOGO 50%off) and 1 Ulta nail polish in Moody Blues (my favorite dark blue/navy polish, also in my top 5).

I bought backups of Pur Minerals 4 in 1 Pressed Mineral Foundation in both my summer and winter shades when they were on sale buy 1 get 1 free at Ulta a while back. I use it every day – I should be good for a while.

I very rarely buy a backup, but the last one I bought was Chanel Dragon. I actually bought two because I knew it was being discontinued.

Where did you get it? I can’t find it online and I have searched in every drugstore within a 50 mile radius, lol.

i got mine from CVS and bought the last 2. This is LE and its sold out everywhere but i’m thinking about selling my back up.

The last one was the purple pearlglide eyeliner by Mac, released in the spring.
I dont ususally buy backups, I just have the Pressed amber mineralized blush, one of those cool liquid powders released with the Venomous Villains and a stick bronzer from the Surf baby collection, all by Mac.

NYX Jumbo Eye Pencils in Milk and Cottage Cheese. I think I got 3 of each shade when Ulta was doing a crazy promotion (60% off or something) a few weeks ago. These shades are eyeshadow primer miracles when I am short on cash for Urban Decay’s Primer Potion.

Sally Hansen DVD–it’s still probably my favorite nail polish, and it takes more coats than normal to reach true opacity, so I wanted a second.

Aside from that, I rarely buy backups, though I might still nab a UD Midnight Cowboy lipstick if I see them somewhere, as I’ve used quite a bit of mine up. And I kind of wish I grabbed a backup of WnW’s Lust 6-pan palette because the pans are tiiiiny and I’ve used quite a bit of it up!

Just today, I picked up another lipstick from MAC. The shade was Fire Sign. Best sheer red for my complexion. (Medium/Tan)

I found MAC Pink Burst lipstick (a pretty, sheer fuchsia) from Spring Colour Forecast in 2010 at a CC and bought all they had. Which was actually only one but it did replace the one I just used up anyway.

I CANNOT live without Anastasia Brow Wiz pencil. I have sparse eyebrows and they are getting thinner as I get older… For me its not a optional purchase-its my life lol.

I have never bougt a backup for anything, but I wish I had purchased one or two for Chanel Ruban Rose lipstick πŸ™ it was a gorgeous shade and I loved it and it was my first rouge Coco also…no one told me that it was being discontinued and when I went to repurchase it after I had almost finished my last tube the SA told me it was gone πŸ™ I bought Gardenia rouge Coco instead the closest shade to Ruban Rose but itΒ΄s just not the same… I have never found anything like that and it was my favorite lipstick πŸ™ πŸ™ πŸ™ .

Rarely buy backup of makeup items mostly skincare. Makeup prob. Only one: Majolica Majorca Lash Expander Frame Plus. It’s all about the Japanese mascara for me.

Wet n’ Wild’s Creme Shadow Pencil in Pixie. It’s the best bargain product so there’s one for my purse, one for my office, one for home and one in the car!

I bought the Laura Mercier rose rendezvous highlighter from last Christmas… so beautiful! And Le Metier de Beaute Corinthian eyeshadow. It was so hard to find that I picked up two. Not cheap! :/

TT Eyeliners and Sephora Flashy eyeliner in taupe. I often times want to buy backups of nail polishes, but by the time I realize how much I like a polish, I can never find it it to buy a backup. πŸ™

I never but back ups because I feel like there’s always something new to try. So if I ever actually finish anything, I’ve decided to search feverishly for a dupe!

If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!