25 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Leave a Reply

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Sadra Avatar

I used to be attracted to citrus scents, but the last few years I’ve found that white florals (jasmine, tuberose, gardenia) have caught my interest more. I also love aldehydes, although they have lost popularity in the last, oh, 60 years 😉 , and very few new fragrances contain them.

kjh Avatar

Both Mariella and I love Jicky, anecdotally the first major scent with aldehydes. WGAS about eras and current favorites? Today’s fruity and gourmand choices seem a little puerile, sweet, and simple to me. About as appropriate for me now as Sour Patch Kids.. I’d go for a big old (older than me and I’m 73) chypre.
Grossly, two families. For the warmer time, ‘nichey’ salts like Heeley and Brosius’s North Atlantic. These can lean dry (driftwood-ish) or wet (seaweed.) Watery like the Regime Waves and Falls. Citrus, but picky…usually as in men’s colognes. For winter, it’s Vetiver, amber, powdery, oakmoss, firs and woody greens. See why my fave bargain in scent was 450$ from CosBar on Creed? Via Isabella, of course.

Mariella Avatar

Patchouli (I’m a child of the 60’s, what can I say?) and put patchouli oil on an old face cloth and toss it in with my laundry! I also really love vetiver. Things like rose smell lovely to me too but I actually have a hard time identifying “notes” in fragrance – I can just tell if I like a scent or not…

brendacr1 Avatar

My nose only knows what it likes not the name of notes or the other accords in the perfume. I know Guerlain puts something in their perfumes that I don’t like so I stay away from that brand.

Mariella Avatar

It’s funny to read similar comments/reactions. A few years ago, I bought Elizabeth Arden’s White Tea (a lovely warm-weather scent) and then reading about it, learned that it contains musk or maybe white musk. I don’t like musk…I was surprised I liked a fragrance that contains musk. All I know is that it smells lovely and light and fresh.

As for Guerlain’s perfumes, I’m the same. I remember as a pre-teen, seeing ads for L’Heure Bleu and other legendary scents and the photos and copy where so beautiful and I thought “one day…”. As a teen, I did have a bottle of Jicky (Pattie Boyd wore it and I wore my mom down enough that she bought me a bottle – insane!) I do own a bottle of Shalimar which I only got within the last 2 years at Costco for a ridiculously affordable price but I only wear it in cold weather and only in certain circumstances.

Meggan Avatar

I love it when violet and iris are used in a perfume together. That’s why I love Love, Chloe (criminally discontinued).

I love beachy scents with salt, ambergris, florals, wood, and musk. Ellis Brooklyn Salt, CK Reveal, and Armani Air (old version) are best for that theme.

I also love the Narciso fragrances, and that musk DNA

Z Avatar

Palo santo, tobacco, leather, patchouli, hay, sweetgrass, and from the right perfumer something sweet like cardamom, vanilla, lavender, coffee, oude, clove

Z Avatar

I’ve had better luck finding perfume with indie niche companies. Like For Strange Women had a simple “tobacco + leather” fragrance for a long time that’s just divine and I frequently layered it with softer fragrances to “beef them up” a bit. Horse was another. Decadence and Debauchery is a general catalogue fragrance with patchouli and helichrysm (my skin amps that note like crazy).
Possets just stopped offering their Yules until next fall/winter and Hungarian Rhapsody is tobacco all day (so strong too!).
Tom Ford’s Tobacco Vanille is a sweet, lightly woody glory, though it’s a bit softer than I lean toward these days.
Outside of Desert Resins (a For Strange Women limited edition release) I haven’t yet found a palo santo perfume that catches my fancy. Though Humble Brands deodorant in palo santo is quite good (and strong enough to be my scent for the day). I adore the smell of the burning wood SO MUCH and haven’t found that captured in a fragrance yet. The essential oil, while nice, has a bit of a rubber/liquorice thing going that…….isn’t Palo Santo’s best moment.

I’m constantly on the hunt for fragrances in real life that smell like what my mind’s eye wants, you know?

Fey Avatar

Orange blossom/neroli, lime, salt, dry coconut, lily, jasmine OR smoky oud, bourbon vanilla, musk, raspberry, violet, vetiver. I guess those are my 2 moods haha

Nancy T Avatar

Not a category that I’m good at! All I know is that if I really love how something smells on me, then I’m definitely buying it for myself. However, I am super picky. Whatever notes are in Tom Ford Black Orchid, YSL Black Opium Nuit Blanche, Maison Margiela Beach Walk, Fresh Life, and Avon x Christian LaCroix Absynthe would be my favorites! 🤷🏻‍♀️

KiranS Avatar

In my twenties I was a lot into floral but now most make me nauseated. My preference in this phase of life is musky/woodsy fragrances and the notes I like are oud, amber, sandalwood, tonka bean, musk, bergamot, cedar, vanilla lavender, rose and jasmine!

Ana Maria Avatar

Vanilla, vanilla, vanilla… and a dab of more vanilla… 😅

I like gourmand notes like cacao / dark chocolate, coconut, caramel, coffee.
From the fruity notes I only like pear. Although I like cherries as a smell, I never encountered a cherry based perfume I liked.
From the floral notes I like blossom (cherry, pear), peony, freesia.

Cronezilla Avatar

Amber, labdanum, benzoin, rose, incense, plus spring florals like LotV, sweet clover and Hyacinth. I, like you, adore TF Amber Absolute as the perfect Intimate, Warm and Embracing fragrance.

Bea Avatar

In my 20s I used fragrances I cannot smell today, I am 45 now.
My sense of smell has changed a lot and when I test a perfume, sometimes I get a headache.
I recently bought the Tom Ford soleil neige perfume. It was the only one that smelled good in my opinion. I like Chloé and La vie est belle. In my 20s I loved the D&G Feminine but the discontinued the product.
Sometimes I smell a scent on somebody and want to have it and on me it smells differently that I don‘t want to have it anymore.

Nikki Avatar

Depending on the fragrance and how it’s balanced, I like the following notes: lily, violet, orchid, rose, gardenia, jasmine, raspberry, cherry, lemon, chocolate, coffee, caramel, cinnamon, cardamom, vanilla, salt, peppermint, musks, and very occasionally, tobacco (Maison Margiela Jazz Club uses it in just the right amount where it enhances the scent profile without overpowering it or smelling bad).

janine Avatar

Peach!!! 🍑 my favorite fruit also!

Almost all my fragrance has been blind buy and they all have peach in them and I’ve liked them all!!

Pear is a big like all. I should mention I don’t like sweet ones.

C.Blossom Avatar

Love: gardenia, cinnamon, vanilla, chocolate, leather, orange blossom. When I was younger I was obsessed with amber, but now it’s too powdery. Also, I wear aldehydes, but I like them for how they interact with my skin, not how they smell on their own.

Elle Avatar

Hmm…coffee, cardamom and oud…Christine, have you tried ‘The Bewitching Yasmine’ from Penhaligons? It has all those notes, you may like it!

My taste tends to lean pretty heavily in the gourmand direction these days. I’m acquiring lots of vanillas and creamy scents.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!