Archived Post

What are your must-have brushes for an eye look?

MAC 239s (or Chikuhodo GSN-09s) for initial application of color (although, I will just as readily use them for all placement, blending, including crease color and brow bone color!). For the crease, if I want something more diffused, I’ll use a larger, rounded crease brush like Wayne Goss #19 or #03, and if I want something with more definition, then I’ll use a more tapered, smaller crease brush like Wayne Goss #04. For the brow bone, I use Hakuhodo J5523, which isn’t too fluffy nor too dense.

— Christine

39 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Katherine T. Avatar

I always use this $ 6 Eco Tool set that has 2 double- ended brushes (shadow/brow and crease/smudger). I have some higher end brushes, but this one seems to work just fine, and because it’s double ended, fewer brushes to wash. And I can get it BOGO 50% off. If I need extra blending, I have a fluffy domed IT brush.

Katherine T. Avatar

I was amazed at the quality. I bought maybe 10 sets on sale and have been using them for 2 years now. I wash my eye brushes everyday, with some softsoap and water, and they hold up really well. They haven’t shed a hair, and they still look like new. Makes it hard for me to justify paying $25 for 1 eye brush !

Jessica Avatar

I bought the double-ended Eco-Tools brushes recently and couldn’t believe how good they are! Will definitely be buying at least one more set of them.

Charlotte Avatar

Hakuhodo j242g or j004g lay down brush. Blend out eyeshadow with hakuhodo j5523 or j5529 brush. Outer v and smudge the lower lash line with hakuhodo g5520. I’m pretty simple with eye looks.

Ray Avatar

I use the EcoTools dual-ended duo set. Two brushes with a brush head on each end. I don’t love the blending brush (though I think my primer makes it difficult to blend with any brush), but the smudging brush is great for buffing away mistakes.

Momo Avatar

I use mostly generic brand brushes, but I can describe them.
• fluffy blending brush
• dense blending brush
• fluffy tapered crease brush
• pencil brush/tapered brush (dense crease brush)
• medium synthetic creme brush
• large round [dense] shadow brush
• medium round [dense] shadow brush
• small round [dense] shadow brush
• angled shadow brush
• small chisel brush (a.k.a. smudger brush)
• precision brush
• angled eyeliner brush
• spoolie brush

These are all the brushes I need to complete any eye look.

Mariella Avatar

MAC 239 and 217 and also some very inexpensive but totally excellent Sonia Kashuk brushes (one of which -#28- is like a hybrid of the 239 and 217). For cream eyeshadows, Real Techniques Shading brush. And Sephora’s #70 Smudge Brush for smudging out pencil liner and applying shadow neatly under my lower lashes.

Astrild Avatar

Zoeva 234 for lid application. MAC 217Sigma E25 for blending more precisely and Sigma 35 for a more diffused crease. MAC 221 is my new love for darkened the outer V.

Leslie Avatar

MAC 217. I have two of them but I need to buy a couple more. I use it to blend but sometimes I also use it to apply eyeshadow when I’m in a hurry. It’s the best brush I’ve ever used.

Tova J Avatar

Hmmm I don’t have a lot of brushes… I usually use one or two fluffy blendinges brush for my crease colours and blending lower lashline etc. Two flat shader brushes, one for lid colour and one for the lower lash line. A smaller blending brush for more concentrated crease colours. Lastly a detail brush for inner corner highlight etc, sometimes I use a flat shader for this as well. 🙂

HeavyMetalJess Avatar

An old-school Body Shop eyeshadow brush with a broad base and pointed tip. Can do a whole eye with it without must difficulty. Wish I could buy 30 more. I miss so much about old-school Body Shop.

Lulle Avatar

I only own eye brushes from affordable brands and I’m actually really happy with them. I use a Coastal Scents flat shading brush to apply color, an e.l.f. fluffy angled brush for the outer corner, another e.l.f. rounded brush for the crease, and a generic Target up & up fluffy brush for the brow bone (one of my best brushes despite being a “no-brand”). I also usually tightline with dark eyeshadow using e.l.f. square eyeliner brush.

Rachel R. Avatar

Well, technically I can do an eye look using one or two brushes if I have to, but that’s not usually how I roll. So this list is my must haves for my usual looks:

1. Lid — something with which to pack color on. I prefer some older Sonia Kashuk brushes that came in sets. They’re smaller than something like a MAC 217, and work well with my limited eyelid space, especially if I do more than one color. They don’t really have numbers and they haven’t been in ages, so I’ve no idea what they’re called.
2. Crease — my favorite is the Real Techniques Base Shadow Brush. It works perfectly for my eye shape and size. I have somewhat hooded eyes, so I need to bring my crease shade up really high.
3. Sonia Kashuk Kashuk Tools Pencil Brush No. 31. Great for lining with powders and precision work. It’s also perfect for smudging pencil liner.
4. e.l.f. Smudge Brush. It’s a $1 and great for applying and smudging eyeshadow along the lower lashline.
5. e.l.f. Studio Blending Brush. It works great and is inexpensive enough to buy several so I can use one for each color I’m working with that day.
6. Real Techniques Brow Brush — excellent for my brows. It’s also great for lining the eyes with powders, smudging powder and pencil liners, and doing a cut crease.
7. Real Techniques Base Brush — for applying a base/transition shade in if I need one.
8. Accent brush — either the Real Techniques Accent Brush or e.l.f. Small Precision Brush. For precision work and the inner corners of the eyes.
9. For loose minerals — A fluffy but firm angled eyeshadow brush. I have a few, with an older BareMinerals one being my favorite. These are great for applying and buffing out loose mineral shadows, especially when doing quick 1 or 2 color looks.
10. Brows — I have to have a spoolie. I don’t care about brand as long as it works. I think my most used is from Coastal Scents.

Claire L Avatar

I need to get some decent eyeshadow brushes I think. I have an awesome double ended foundation/concealer brush and a decent powder brush as well as a blusher brush but haven’t found his enough e/s brushes. I tried the Eco Tools ones but didn’t find them to work very well on my eyelids. I’m thinking of investing in a couple of MAC brushes, failing that, Real Techniques or Zoeva.

Erin Avatar

Right now, I’m using mostly SK brushes and the RT eye set. I occasionally bust out my Armani brushes, a flat one for color placement and a HUGE fluffy one for blending or washes. I can also use the tapered end of the Armani to place shadow on the lower lash line and smoke it out.

I’m looking to upgrade and diversify my collection a bit and buy a few dupes of my other brushes since I’m terrible about cleaning them quickly enough.

Tammy B Avatar

I have killed my Mac 239 and want to try everything! My December beauty budget might be devoted to brushes. Because of all of you, here is my December brush wish list: Chikohodo GSN-09, Wayne Goss #19, Zoeva 234 (I will have to order the metals eyeshadow palette to make it worth the shipping), Sigma E55, and Hakuhodo J242.

Genevieve Avatar

I have a lot of eye shadow brushes that I have received with EL gifts with purchase – so I don’t know the numbers/names of them. However they are great – I use a dense brush for my initial eye shadow application, a dense rounded brush for my second colour, a couple of fluffy brushes to blend and use on my highlighter colour.
A setting powder brush and an angled blush brush and I am good to go.

Genevieve Avatar

Oh – I meant to say this in my response above. The basin in our ensuite has been clogged for a little while. So the man in the house (aka husband) decided to sort it out once and for all. Armed with draino, harpic toilet cleaner etc. he set to work. The culprit turns out to be one of my eye shadow brushes that must have gone done the plug hole when I was cleaning them (how, I don’t know). It is too far down to get out with tweezers and besides dismantling the whole sink and plumbing (a big job), we are not sure what to do.

Christy Avatar

Laydown: Hakuhodo J242G (I also use this one’s edge for browbone)
Crease/Blending: Hakuhodo J142 or J5523 (I like the J142 better)
Outer V: Koyudo C011 (optional–edge of J242G also works well for me)
Inner Corner/Tearduct: Hakuhodo G5515
Angled Liner: The Ecotools one

BonnieBBon Avatar

I love my Wayne Goss eye set and usually just grab whatever looks like it’ll do what I want. I also get a ton of use out of a too faced 3 brush eye set I’ve had for years. It’s still available and I give it a huge thumbs up….the TF 20% off sale started today so it’s a good time to snag them. Oh and Elfs C eyeshadow brush is amazeballs!

Cat Avatar

Theoretically, I could do a complete eye look with my Goss #6 and a generic liner brush (that I wish I could find more of!).

— However —

The five brushes I use every time I do my makeup are:
Goss #6 for placing shadow all over the lid
Goss #4 for my transition shade in and above the crease
Goss #5 (the original #5) for applying shadow along lower lash line, for deepening the crease, and for the outer V
Generic liner brush for lining the upper lash line
Ecco Tools angled brush for lining/blending out the lower lash line

Jisela Avatar

The brushes I use the most are MAC 217 and 239 and a pencil brush from Sigma and a fluffy blending brush also from sigma. I also use a small angle brush for my gel liner and a small detail brush for highlighting my inner corner of my eyes.

viv Avatar

i use some older becca brushes, one which is a but more fluffy than the mac 239, one got less hair and is more dense and one for smudging. for blending the usual mac 219(?) and some small dome shaped zoeva for the crease.

Pasheeda Morris Avatar

My Must Have Eye Brushes
1.) Sephora Pro Domed Crease Shadow, #16-Great for applying/creasing shadows.
2.) Sephora Pro Blending Shadow, #27-Fabulous Multi-purpose eye brush. It is better than a regular large eye shadow brush. I can shade, crease, highlight, etc. with this brush.
3.) Sephora Pro Brow Comb, #21- I always comb my lashes before applying my lash base and mascara.
4.) Sephora Pro Cream Shadow, #28-Besides my fingers, I only use this brush for my cream eye shadows.

Cory Avatar

When I’m getting ready in the morning I always always always use
• RT deluxe crease brush – to lay down a base (powder only) over my concealer or foundation or primer, whichever I’ve used on my lids that day
• MAC 217 for my crease & above crease shades
• MAC 224 to diffuse the above crease shade
• MAC 239 for my lids
• MUG defined crease for outer v
• MUG outer-v for outer v lol
• Bare Minerals pencil brush to smudge out my liner & to add shadow to the liner (I’ve been debating a MAC 219, but I’m not sure that I need it yet… The Bare Minerals brush came in a “Rock n’ Roll” set from Sephora about 6yrs ago, so maybe it’s time to let go lol!

* great question! Loved reading everyone’s answers!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!