What are the most unique eyeshadows you own?

What are the most unique eyeshadows you own? Shades that you just don’t think can be duped?

MAC Rye is a shade that I loved and used a lot that I didn’t really feel I could find elsewhere (but I haven’t used it in some time, so perhaps something has come out since!).

Thanks to Elizabeth for today’s question!

Got a question idea? Submit yours here.


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
kira Avatar

i dont own mac’s my melody or newled minted but i wish they would repromote them or i could find dupes. i tried mufe’s #93 but i find it a little bit more green.

kira Avatar

i just started my makeup collection and as of now the most unique one that i got is JEALOUSY WAKES 🙂 since i know that there are no dupes of that eyeshadow and it is beautiful!!

stacey Avatar

I’m a glitter girl…not everyday, but like the colors I own. Urban Decay kiddie pool. I think Sin by Urban Decay (not glitter) is unique also. I bought this Guerlain duo shadow about 20 years ago….which I never used ….burnt orange and prune (purple) that I have not seen anywhere. Unique combo.

Carrie Ann Avatar

I think MAC Vex e/s is pretty unique. Jealousy Wakes is unique and so are Sun Blonde, Pincurl (because of the pink sort of duochrome) and Saffron. I also feel that Dalliance is fairly unique because it has a bit of an olive or green tint to it that I’ve never seen in a shade like that.

Mel Avatar

I agree Fyrinnae shadows are not easy to dupe. Which is why I have to be careful not to ruin them when I press them especially the discontinued shades:)

artemis Avatar

i have a cheap no name eyeshadow like that rye it’s a brownish gold hehe when i wear it people love it 😛 kinda forgot about it, plus i dropped it n it cracked :))
hmmmm….most unique shades i own are a matte hot pink and neon orange eyeshadows :)) i hate shimmers, except on a silver or gold base

Mariella Avatar

Unique in terms of colour would probably be the exclusive light purple shade from Too Faced’s Enchanted Glamourland, UD’s Suspect or MAC’s Greensmoke. Unique in terms of “rare” or hard to get hold of is probably MAC’s Smoke & Diamonds.

Krista Avatar

For me it has to be MAC Rubenesque Paint Pot. I really love the texture and the color is just so brilliant on my skintone. I have honestly not found any cream eyeshadow that has the exact same color, pigmentation, texture, and finish as this baby.

Helena Avatar

I have this Kryolan palette of cream colors. There’s one that is similar to Rubenesque, except it’s substantially pinker, as well as greasier and prone to creasing. Still similar, though…

Maureen Avatar

Unique is relative… but I have two 88 palettes; I wonder if that counts? I guess Lucky Green, I love that color. I also have a bunch of Shiro colors from the Super Effective collection. I guess my most unique eyeshadow is Charmander. I do have a “most unique” eyeliner, though… Actually, several from tokidoki. I’m so sad they’re not going to continue making Mostro. I bought another one to stock up. >_>

Iggy Avatar

Lancome Erika F. Not the colour (what taupe? it’s green on me, haha!) as much as the really unique type of sparkle. Mac’s duochrome Motif.

Marina Avatar

I love the silver pewter in the Chanel Mystic Eyes Quad, i’ve never seen anything like that! Another good example would be Shiseido Hydro-Powder Shadow in Spring Plum – a reddish plum with green shimmer.

Diana Avatar

Mac’s Twillery from the 2005 inventive eyes quad!!!!! im almost out of it…will only use it for special occasions. ive spent hundreds of dollars trying to find an exact dupe but nothing ever comes close!

meme Avatar

I have some old Lancome eye shadows from the late 80’s that I love – 1 was GWP. So old now, names worn off the bottom – no idea what they were but know they are no longer made. UD shadows I have are among the most unique shadows I have (that I like) – there are lots of unique ones I don’t like!!!

Karyn Avatar

The most unique I own is definitely MAC Club. Most unique and one of the most loved — other two most loved/used (not necessarily unique) are Woodwinked and Rubenesque Paint Pot.

Lorraine ER Avatar

Most of the really unique shadows I have are from Indie companies. Picachu from Shiro cosmetics is awesome, it’s a bright yellow with red microglitter. Meerkat from Fyrinnae, actually there’s a lot of colors from Fyrinnae that are unique. Two of the colors from The Balm Shady Lady vol. 2 palette are pretty unique as well- they are the top two shadows in the right row, both are taupe-ish with one being purple-tinged. They make awesome single-shade looks because of their depth.

Renske Avatar

I love Make Up Store’s City Jungle. It’s like a matte blue, but it also has green-ish gold shimmers. And I don’t think I can actually describe it like it really is, so you have to check it out for yourself;)
My other fave and unique eyeshadow is Too Faced Label Whore. It is a reddish-brown colour with a green glow (depends on the light if you see it) and with some little glitters.

Meow Avatar

I have so many eyeshadows (Yes I’m a big collector) so I’m going to have to put down three of my most unique shades.

NYX Taupe Pearl: It’s a frosty almost metallic ( or borderline so)taupe-y pearl that reflects flashes of rich white gold and it is so pretty it can be worn entirely by its self. I got this shade originally because I thought it was similar to MACs Satin Taupe but it ended up being sooo much better than that, and it even beat out my Dior shadows as well. One of the best shades I’ve ever come across.

Parfait Amour: It may strike similarities to certain urban decay shadows and NYX ones by its initial color in the pan, but on the lid it takes on a whole identity of its own. It’s a very complex purple, a blue violet sheen with ruby undertones when it catches the light and just the right shade of purple, extremely lux and gorgeous! I’ve worn this on it’s own as a lid shade with a white gold highlight and gotten heaps of compliments.

Nars’s Galapagos: This is going to be hard to describe I’m not sure whether I’d call it a metallic or duochrome, it’s a bronzey-brown shade with a double layer of intense gold reflects and sheen with a cream like consistency that can single handedly do a bronze smokey eye all by its self.

Emiloulou Avatar

MAC Shale. Doesn’t look very exciting, but it’s neither too grey nor too plummy. Just right. Gorgeous on hazel or green eyes…

Chelsea Avatar

I haven’t checked for any dupes yet but I think good unique one is Estee Lauder’s Polished Platinum. It’s a really pretty silver with a gold shimmer/sheen.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!