We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Compare Any Two Swatches

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

77 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Your skin tone/coloring: NW20
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Wet ‘n Wild Comfort Zone Palette Crease Color
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Milani Liquifeye in Black
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Chanel Dragon

Your skin tone/coloring:NC05

What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow: Inglot AMC 51, Sugarpill’s Flamepoint and the recent Lime Crime Incantation.

What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Urban Decay’s Perversion.

What’s your favorite red lipstick? MAC Viva Glam Cyndi in general, Wet N’ Wild’s 910D Red Velvet.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC35/37
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Haven’t tried orange yet.
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? For gel, L’Oreal HiP; for pencil, MAC Technakohl.
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Rimmel Kate Moss 01.

Skin tone/coloring: Light/Medium with neutral undertones

Favorite Orange Eyeshadow: Orange is a bit intimidating for me but there’s a gorgeous, muted, burnt orange in my new Stila In The Know palette that I’m dying to test out. It’s perfect for fall and I hear it’s quite flattering.

Fav Black Eyeliner: Right now it’s the Buxom Lashliner in Leatherette. Great cream eyeliner- long lasting and smooth. I tend to prefer black eyeliners in a cream/gel form, you get more control.

Favorite Red Lipstick: I’m only 19 so I haven’t really ventured into the red lipstick jungle yet; I tend to stick with nudes and soft pinks…though I really like The Balm’s Staniac. It’s a gel that turns your lips a deep berry color, depending on how much you layer it. It’s pretty.

Skintone: NARS SG Siberia, Illamasqua LF115-120 (115 is actually a little light for me… meep! But I think 120 would be too pink.).

Orange eyeshadow: Not a massive fan of orange.

Black eyeliner: Prestige Total Intensity in Blackest Black, UD 24/7 in Perversion, and I’m liking the Bobbi Brown gel liner in Black Ink.

Red Lipstick: Illamasqua Sangers, Revlon Colorburst l/s in True Red.

Skintone: NC40, Tanned with yellow undertones.

Fave orange eyeshadow?: Maybelline Color Tattoo in Fierce & Tangy.

Fave black eyeliner?: Lakme Black Satin, Sephora Flashy Waterproof, Stila Smudgestick in Stingray.

Fave red lipstick?: Revlon Mulled Wine, MAC Dark Side.

I’m med warm tone with red/brown undertones

My fave orange e/c is Silk Naturals: Heat

My go to black eye liner is L’Oreal’s Gel Lacquer liner

My fave red l/s is Tarte’s Glamazon in Wild

Skin tone: tan/olive with warm undertone (nc 37)
Orange eyeshadow: mac saffron (use as blush as well)
Black eyeliner: Pantone black, UD zero, Revlon grow luscious black
Red lip: Chanel dragon :), rimmel Boudreaux, occ vintage

Your skin tone/coloring: fair/light with yellow undertones
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Amber Lights is about the closest I get to putting orange on my eyes
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Urban Decay Perversion
What’s your favorite red lipstick? haven’t found a favorite red lipstick, but I do love NARS Diablo lip lacquer

Skintone: Fair with cool undertones

Fave Organe: Never tried. I think it would look hideous on me

Fave black eyeliner: UD Perversion

Fave Red Lipstick: La Creme Color Drenched Lip Cream Stiletto Red by Too Faced

Skintone: NC 20; fair neutral

Orange e/s: NA. Can’t wear it.

Black e/l: MAC Engraved, MUFE Aqua Eyes in the black color. Allergies here, need waterproof.

Red l/s: MAC Cockney (summer); Nars Red Lizard (winter)

Your skin tone/coloring:NC15
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow: I don’t know that I have a favorite true orange. I love golds that lean copper/orange. Baked from UD pulls very orange on me, and I love it.
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Urban Decay’s Perversion and Josie Maran has a black kohl that is killer for the waterline.
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Revlon Really Red Matte. It’s such a beautiful, retro matte lipstick.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC15/20

What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Not an eyeshadow, but MAC Off The Radar Pigment. It’s the first orange I ever fell in love with. I NEVER wore orange before this one.

What’s your favorite black eyeliner? MAC Blacktrack Fluidline.

What’s your favorite red lipstick? MAC Lady Danger. New favorite, though, is Diva! Diva is such a gorgeous, vampy burgundy for the colder weather.

Hm. This list sure seems like a MAC love fest.

Skin tone: medium warm with slight yellow undertones
favorite orange: mac campfire
favorite black eyeliner: mac blacktrack
favorite red lipstick: there are so many reds in my collection and i love them all…but i think my all-time favorite is mac heartless of the venomous villains collection

i don’t think i’ve ever tried orange eyeshadow

bobbi brown gel eyeliner in the darkest black

favorite red is definitely chanel rouge allure passion

■Your skin tone/coloring: mac nc30
■What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? i do not do orange eyeshadow!
■What’s your favorite black eyeliner? urban decay perversion
■What’s your favorite red lipstick? Revlon Lip Butter In Red Velvet

Skin color: very fair with cool undertones (blue eyes, dark hair)
Favorite orange eyeshadow: Chanel’s tigerlily
Favorite black eyeliner: gel: Mac blacktrack, pencil: Mac chroma graphic pencil black black
Favorite red lipstick: Mac runway red (original version)

■Your skin tone/coloring: NW25 medium/fair
■What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I don’t have any, I dislike the colour
■What’s your favorite black eyeliner? I never wear eyeliner ( allergy )
■What’s your favorite red lipstick? So many in fact ! Just to quote one ( I have around 30 red lipsticks, maybe more ! ) M.A.C Runaway red or Nars Fire down below

Your skin tone/coloring: Pale.
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Not my fav but one I use the most is NYX in Hot Orange.
■What’s your favorite black eyeliner? I rarely wear eyeliner but I do like WnW Megaliner in black 861
■What’s your favorite red lipstick? Serge Lutens The Ultimate Red Collection Lip Palette in #1 Levres en Boite Four

* Your skin tone/coloring: medium warm-olive/NC35 in foundation
* What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? none
* What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Prestige waterproof pencil and liquid; MAC Blacktrack (gel)
* What’s your favorite red lipstick? MAC Ruby Woo

NC25, Brown Eyes Brown hair.
Never tried Orange e/s
Urban Decay Zero is my fav black eyeliner

There’s SO many red lipsticks that I love it depends on what I’m wearing so here are my top 4:

1) Besame Red Velvet
2) Besame Cherry Red
3) NARS Fire Down Below
4) Guerlain Greta

And my fav red lip gloss is the Giorgio Armani Red lipgloss.

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium/dark olive
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I don’t have any.
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? MUFE Aqua Creamliner in Matte Black or Aqua eyes liner in Black
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Revlon Fire and Ice

■Your skin tone/coloring:MAC NC50/Loreal N8
■What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I use Russet Blush by Le Femme as an orange blending shadow.It works great. I actually used it this morning!

■What’s your favorite black eyeliner? I love BH cosmetics liquid eyeliner and Eyeko liquid eyeliner. For a pencil I love Smashbox Limitless in Onyx

■What’s your favorite red lipstick?
A tie between MAC Diva and NYX Monte Carlo

■Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/warm
■What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Don’t have one
■What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Lancone Artliner Noir
■What’s your favorite red lipstick? Rimmel Alarm

My skintone is yellow/golden tan NC 42-44. Not too many companies make orange shadow but I found the best by MAC which is called Orange. Any black liner by CG especially Perfect Blend. Fave red lip? For summer it’s MAC lady bug. Fall/winter is Nars Joyous Red and MAC Chili.

Skin tone: light olive (light with golden undertones,very few peach)MAC NC20 at the moment
Orange eyeshadow:never worn orange! maybe will try it out one day
Black eyeliner: MAC blacktrack fluidline
Favorite red lipstick: Dior Rouge Zinnia Red

Your skin tone/coloring: Porcelain with cool undertones
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Fire from Stila’s In the Know Eyeshadow Palette
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Revlon Colorburst Lip Butter in Cherry Tart

NARS Siberia is my closest match for foundation but I use LM TM in Porcelain mixed with MAC F&B in White. I am extremely pale.lol I have deep yellow undertones (warm).
My favorite orange eyeshadow is MAC Coppering.
My favorite black eyeliner is Maybelline black liquid eyeliner. I adore the tip.
My favorite red lipstick is either MAC Chili, or Lancome Rouge in Love 181N, but the cool undertones look a little too intense sometimes.

skin tone/coloring: very fair, NW10

favorite orange eyeshadow: urban decay penny lane

favorite black eyeliner: lancome artliner noir

favorite red lipstick: mac new york apple

Skin Tone : NW 15/20, fair with very pink undertones

Fave Orange Eyeshadow: MAC Gleam (Yeah yeah it’s peach, but it’s as close as I’m getting to orange on my eyes lol)

Fave Black Eyeliner: MAC Blacktrack fluidline

Fave Red Lipstick: Revlon lip butter in Red Velvet

Coloring: Very light, very neutral; extremely dark, cool-toned brown eyes & hair.

Orange shadow: I dislike the color orange itself, so I don’t wear *anything* in that color family. I’ve tried ambers, coppers, corals, etc, but I really don’t like *any* of them. However, I do feel certain people can pull off oranges.

Black liner: L’Oreal Lineur Intense has always been the one I go back to. UD 24/7 Waterproof liquid liner is great, too, but I don’t care too much for the applicator. For pencils, I like Kat von D or any L’Oreal.

Red lipstick: Maybelline Red Revival, although I find myself wearing Rimmel Bordeaux more often.

Skintone: fair, cool
Favourite orange eyeshadow: you’re joking, right? The closest shadow I have to orange is probably All That Glitters (MAC)or Half Baked (UD)so you can see I don’t get very close to orange…
Favourite black eyeliner: Gosh Black Ink (pencil liner)
Favourite red lipstick: discontinued – Estee Lauder Datenut Red; still available – Mac Dubonnet or Clarins Redwood

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair skin with neutral/slightly pink undertones
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? None, I don’t wear orange at all!
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? MAC Fluidline Blacktrack
What’s your favorite red lipstick? MAC Ruby Woo

skin tone – beigey medium lol i don’t know

favorite orange eyeshadow; i don’t really like orange eyeshadow but i’ll say flamepoint by sugarpill

fave black eyeliner; essence gel liner is great

fave red lipstick – lime crime retrofuturist

Skin Tone : NW 20 (fair with pink undertones)

Favorite Orange Eyeshadow: Nars Mediteranee duo and Bare Minerals in Fire Opal

Favorite Black Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 liner in Zero

Favorite Red Lipstick: Lancome Rogue in Love #170

Wow no Mac for once haha.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC10/NARS Siberia
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow: Have never worn orange e/s
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Clinique gel liner in black
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Revlon Lip Butter in Cherry Tart

Your skin tone/coloring: Warm Natural (in Bobbi Brown foundations)
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Pink Bronze pigment
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Bobbi Brown Black Ink gel liner
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Laura Mercier Scarlet lip stain

Fair with pink undertones
Mac saffron- I seriously use this at least 3 times a week.
I don’t do eyeliner because I’m terrible at it- I do black shadow on an angled brush!
Lipstick would be Rimmel temptation… Not even sure if that’s around anymore!

Skin Tone: Bareminerals fairly light, neutral-ish, maybe NW or NC 20.
Coloring: Chestnut hair & dark brown eyes.

Fav orange eyeshadow: I don’t own any, but I’ve been looking at the READY eyeshadow quad in “The Elements” and I think I might be able to pull off that rusty orange.

Fav black eyeliner: Anything cheap from the drugstore.

Fav red lipstick: Still working on that! Reds are hard. I wear UD “Gash” when I want a strong lip color.

Your skin tone/coloring: medium tan with yellow undertone (NC37)
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Rule and the orange shade from NARS Ramatuelle
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? NARS Larger Than Life Pencil in Via Veneto or MAC Blacktrack fluid line
What’s your favorite red lipstick? YSL Rouge Volupte 16, Chanel Rouge Allure in Palpitante, MAC Hibiscus

Your skin tone/coloring: light and warm

What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I don’t really do orange shadows! I have a few that came in palettes but I use them very rarely.

What’s your favorite black eyeliner? For now, Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner in Black Ink. I want to try the felt tip eyeliner from Milani though, I heard a lot about it.

What’s your favorite red lipstick? MAC Dubonnet. It looks really dark in the tube, more like a bordeaux shade, but it’s very red on me. Classy and sexy!

Your skin tone/coloring: Mac nc 20
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Mac orange 😀 – love to add it as an accent, it brings out my eye color very well (my eyes are blue/gray/green, with orange they seem more blue)
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Bobbi brown gel eyeliner
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Chanel rouge allure 85 coquette it is red but still quite wearable 🙂

Skin Tone: Fair/light with neutral undertones.

Favorite Orange Eyeshadow: I love Nars Mediteranee duo. It’s a great orange and gold that’s fun to play with in fall.

Favorite Black Eyeliner: Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner. I’m just starting to dabble in MAC Blacktrack with the 210 brush. My hands shake a lot and the brush is perfect for me. So I may start to stick with Blacktrack.

Favorite Red Lipstick: MAC Russian Red. I have way, way too many shades of red, however. Way too many.

Your skin tone/coloring: Typical Asian Medium skin tone.
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? dont know- Fyrinnae”s
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? UD 24/7 liquid
What’s your favorite red lipstick? All Dolce and Gabanna- like Scartlett, Ultra, Ruby, Magniifica, All YSL Rouge Pur colors

Your skin tone/coloring: Fairly light with yellow undertones
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Mac orange, which I wore today!
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? UD Perversion
What’s your favorite red lipstick? NYX Chic Red

Skin tone: i think i’m NC15 or 20
Fave Orange Eyeshadow: MUFE #5 (but this may be more peach than orange..)
Fave Black Eyeliner: BB eye gel in Graphite
Fave Red Lipstick: OCC NSFW, (devine!); Lipstick Queen in Rouge Sinner, (classic!)

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? never found one that works on me
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Cargo Swimmables in Dark Pewter
What’s your favorite red lipstick? MAC’s New York Apple

NC20; light, yellow undertones

Don’t wear orange eyeshadow.

eyeliner: Rimmel Glam Eyes liquid liner

red lipstick: Revlon Really Red (matte collection)

and recently, Rimmel Kate Moss 01

also; Dior Addict Extreme in Fireworks, and Revlon Lip Butter in Candy Apple

I’m medium w yellow undertones. NC30
Orange eyeshadow: theBalm Mischievous Marissa
Black eyeliner: Tarte Skinny SmolderEyes in Onyx
Red lipstick: Illamasqua Encounter

Your skin tone/coloring: Pale Neutral
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Sugarpill Flamepoint
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Urban Decay 24/7 Perversion liner
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Too Faced Stiletto Red

Skin tone/coloring: NC50/ Clinique Even Better Spice
Orange e/s: MAC Ambering Lights (about as orange as I trust to go)
Black e/l: wet-n-wild liquid liner
Red l/s: I am torn between MAC Dare You and Runaway Red

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair with cool undertones.
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I actually don’t think I own any orange. Not a good color for my skin tone!
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? I love the bold, inky color of L’Oreal Lineur Intense liquid liner, though the applicator and I share a tense working relationship. Chanel’s Illusion d’ Ombre in Mirifique also makes a gorgeous, shimmering black eyeliner, but I don’t know if it counts. 😛
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Currently, it’s Smashbox Grenadine. Gorgeous blue-based red with a touch of pink.

– Light/medium beige with yellow and olive undertones

– Orange from Shiseido Fire eyeshadow trio

– Lancome Artliner (liquid) and Guerlain Kohl Me Ebony (pencil)

– CdP R1 Black Baccara, Serge Lutens Mise a mort, Shiseido RD198 (discontinued)

■Your skin tone/coloring: Mac NW20, Bobbi Brown 3.25 cool beige
■What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Mac Marche aux puces, Dior Aurora Palette
■What’s your favorite black eyeliner? cake liner from Guerlain Liu Palette
■What’s your favorite red lipstick? Mac for Marilyn Charmed I’m Sure, Dior Diorific Diva, Chanel Rouge Allure Inimitable, YSL Rouge Pur Couture Matte Lipstick 201 and 203

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Lime Crime Macarooned
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? MAC Blacktrack or Lancome Artliner
What’s your favorite red lipstick? YSL Rouge Pur Couture #35- Rouge Vernis

Skin tone: NC 40-42
Orange Eyedhadow: None, but I imagine NARS makes a fantastic one
Black Eyeliner: L’oreal infallible lacquer liner
Red Lipstick: Chanel Rouge Allure Velvet in La Sompteuse

skin tone: NC20
favorite orange eyeshadow: MAC Amber Lights and Coppering
favorite black eyeliner: Giorgio Armani Black Eyes to Kill Waterproof Liner, Urban Decay 24/7 Perversion
favorite red lipstick: Guerlain Garconne and Gisela Rouge G Lipsticks, MAC Dubonnet and Deeply Adored Lipsticks, NARS Amsterdam Pure Matte Lipstick

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium Olive (around NC30)

What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow?: I rarely use orange e/s, the closest I use are the shades in Guerlain Les Fauves quad.

What’s your favorite black eyeliner?: I’m still looking for the perfect one, but La Ligne de Chanel (cake e/l) is the closest at the moment.

What’s your favorite red lipstick?: Rouge d’Armani 400… but Guerlain Luxure is in close to it

Your skin tone/coloring: NW25. redhead, blue/green/gray eyes
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Saffron, Texture, Amber Lights… if you can call them orange
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? MAC Typographic
What’s your favorite red lipstick? MAC Chili, Chanel Dragon

Your skin tone/coloring: MAC NC25, Too Faced BB in Vanilla Glow. Nearly black hair, very dark brown eyes, sliiiight olive toned skin. Neutral leaning warm.
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I hate orange eyeshadow. The closest I get is a warm bronze, favorite is Maybelline Bad To The Bronze.
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Too Faced Perfect Eyeliner, Maybelline Eyestudio gel liner
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Revlon Really Red and MAC Chili

Also Stila waterproof pen liner, that is the best, staying power of a liquid liner I’ve ever used. 2 days (with showers!) on my hand, and on my face the entire day.

Your skin tone/coloring: According to MAC I’m NC 45 BUT every foundation of theirs I have ever tried is orangy on me except for Face & Body. I personally think I am more of a warm w/yellow undertones

What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? Hmmmm…Does MAC Coppering count?
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? UD Perversion
What’s your favorite red lipstick? Shu Uemura Rouge Unlimited RD 185

NC15/20; Urban Decay 2.0 (very pale with yellow undertones); strawberry blond; blue eyes.

ORANGE E/S: for a softer, everyday shade, MAC Pro Coral; for a bolder eye look: Sugarpill Flamepoint

BLACK LINER: MAC Blacktrack Fluidline is my #1; MUFE’s Aquarelle (in the bottle w/o applicator) is 2nd. Stila’s Stay All Day pen & UD’s 24/7 Perversion liquid are great for waterproof liquids.

RED LIPSTICK: MAC Charmed I’m Sure, Rocker, Love Goddess, & Fire Sign.

Wow, am I bad at picking just one, or what? I wanted to add 10 more lipsticks lol

medium skin tone, not tan, but not porcelain
I love la colors’ baked eye shadow quad in praline, the orange is very pumpkiney and beautiful
I love almay’s
red lipstick=wet’n wild purty persimmon

Your skin tone/coloring: golden. Between NW30 and NW25

What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I can’t do orange with my coloring. I can only recommend bronzes!

What’s your favorite black eyeliner? A just found my new HG…Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Eyeliner Trio for Brown Eyes. It comes with 3 liners, and one of them is black. It’s $10 for all 3. Stays on like nobody’s business. And trust me…I’ve tried them all!

What’s your favorite red lipstick? One I just bought recently — Chanel Rouge Allure in Pirate

I’m from Germany and I think, we might have a lot of different products but maybe it’s interesting for you too.

Your skin tone/coloring: Mac NW20 (in Winter), In Summer NW25-NW30 (it depends on the time I can spend in sun 😉 )

What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow?: If I had to choose orange it would be “Dalai Drama” by Catrice but I prefer coppery shades. It suits me much better, like “Cheeky Copper” by P2. Both are really good german drugstore brands with great texture and pigmentation.

What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Artdeco Dita von Teese Gel Eyeliner in “Nocturnelle”. It displaced my Mac Fluidline Gel Eyeliner. Great texture, longer lasting, deep black and without preservatives and mineral oil and less pricey.

What’s your favorite red lipstick?: I have three: Mac Russian Red, Lush Ambition and Artdeco Dita von Teese Classics in 656 Black Dahlia a really dark shade between deep burgundy and plum for fall and winter.

Your skin tone/coloring: light/yellow
What’s your favorite orange eyeshadow? I don’t like orange eye shadows
What’s your favorite black eyeliner? Physicians’ Formula
What’s your favorite red lipstick? I don’t wear red lipstick

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!