Archived Post
Survey Says... October 26th, 2011
- Favorite orange eyeshadow?
- Favorite black nail polish?
- Favorite vampy lip color?
Explore Temptalia
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Compare Any Two
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
51 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Comments on this post are closed.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
My very favorite orange eyeshadow was a limited edition, MAC Firespot, from the Moonbathe collection. Love it very much and very easy to tone down or brighten up other looks! Gorgeous.
My favorite survey so far! 🙂
Favorite orange eyeshadow?
Smashbox eyeshadow single in Torch (a golden orange sherbert)
Favorite black nail polish?
Essie nail polish in Licorice (a jelly, glossy black)
Favorite vampy lip color?
!!!
Urban Decay’s lipstick in Requiem!!!!! 😀
Favorite orange eyeshadow: Right now, Shiro Cosmetic’s Zelda… which is more of a peach, really. But I’m picking up NARS Mediteranee palette soon, so that might change!
Favorite black nail polish: Zoya Raven
Favorite vampy lip color: Lancome L’absolu Rouge in Perfect Fig, topped with MAC lipglass in Chai =] Not super vampy, but it’s a start!
orange shadow- wet n wild copper
black polish- eyeko cosmic polish (holo glitter in it 🙂
vampy lippy- dior rouge dior in fantastic plum
Favorite orange eyeshadow?
Sugarpill Flamepoint
Favorite black nail polish?
none
Favorite vampy lip color?
MAC Cunning
Fav Orange shadow: MAC Saffron
Fav Black polish: Don’t have one (since I’ve never worn it – don’t judge me:-))
Fav Vampy lip color: MAC Prince Noir
Orange eyeshadow: Yuck. The closest thing is Morgaine glitter from Aromaleigh. That’s a blend of orange, green, and brown glitter. Looks quite pretty on the eyes.
Black nail polish: Lippman Bad Romance. Black with purple glitter and hexagons!
Vampy lip color: MAC Night Violet with Funtabulous dazzleglass over it.
A little orange is amazing to kick up a warm neutral look. Really! 🙂
I don’t wear orange eyeshadow.
I have two favorite black nail polishes – American Apparel Hassid, and Wet n Wild black (the $1 one). Both are opaque in one coat. The AA one is semi-matte and dries faster.
As for a vampy lipcolor, I love the sleek pout paints – I mix the bright red and the blue for the perfect dark red.
Favorite orange eyeshadow? Don’t have one.
Favorite black nail polish? Zoya’s Raven
Favorite vampy lip color? NARS Fire Down Below
Favorite orange eyeshadow? Shiseido Fire Opal (not sure it’s available any more, though)
Favorite black nail polish? I keep looking for one, but the formulas keep disappointing me…
Favorite vampy lip color? Mac Tribalist, Chanel Ballet Russe (not super-vampy, but still dark), Tom Ford Black Orchid
Favorite orange eyeshadow: Mischevious Marissa from theBalm! (add about a thousand more !!! just to be obnoxious =])
Favorite Black Nail Polish
-Not my thing =/
Favorite vamp lip:
Well, it’s more of a plum but Clinque A different Grape!
orange eyeshadow: milani sun goddess. a “divine” metallic orange.
black nail polish: OPI my private jet. not properly black but very dark.
vampy lipstick: MAC captive + MAC burgundy lip pencil.
Favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Evening Aura for a soft light orange.
Favorite black nail polish? Don’t really have one, Wet N’Wild is good for cheap, one time wear.
Favorite vampy lip color? The dark purple mattene that was part of the MAC Style Black collection.
Fave orange shadow: Still looking…maybe I’ll get some ideas from you guys?
Fave black polish: Sinful Black on Black
Fave vampy lip color: Revlon Black Cherry
Favorite orange eyeshadow? I don’t like any orange eyeshadow.
Favorite black nail polish? Essie Licorice…although I’m not too fond of black nail polish either.
Favorite vampy lip color? Chanel Vamp…but again…not really my thing
Favorite orange eyeshadow? I only have one, and that’s Orange Chrome e/s from NYX and it’s great! Excellent color payoff and nicely sparkly.
Favorite black nail polish? Sinful Colors Black on Black! Budget friendly, opaque in one coat and doesn’t stain my acrylic nails.
Favorite vampy lip color? MAC Dark Deed! So glad I grabbed it from the Venomous Villains collection 🙂
Favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC – Orange MAC – Melon
Favorite black nail polish? Malini – Black Magic, though on my black nails don’t look so great 🙁 but I think some women rock the sh** out of them 😉
Favorite vampy lip color? I rarely wear dark lips. The darkest I go is MAC Plum Danddy.
Orange eyeshadow- the most orange I will wear but hardly ever do is MAC’s Melon pigment. Orange just doesn’t look good on me.
Black eyeshadow- right now it OPI Midnight in Moscow
vampy lipstick- Either MAC Unknown Pleasures or MAC Plum Bright
Orange shadow- Sugarpill Flamepoint. Nothing compares.
Black nailpolish- Sinful Colors is my fave- opaque, long-wearing, super cheap!
Vampy lip color- closest thing I wear is LC Glamour 101. Since I’m ghost white with almost-black hair, anything plummy is too much on me.
Favorite orange eyeshadow: Orange is too warm for my coloring. The closest I own is Mac Woodwinked which shows as orange on my skintone.
Favorite black nail polish: Mac Nocturnelle. I may have to give Essie Licorice a try though. I also love Mac Baby Goth Girl and Seriously Hip. And Sephora OPI 212
Favorite vampy lip color: Does Clinique Black Honey balm count? I don’t wear a dark lip.
Favorite orange eyeshadow?
I only own two orange eyeshadows so I can’t really say if I can have a fav since I haven’t tried enough. But Pearl 407 by Inglot is definitely gorrrrrrgeous!
Favorite black nail polish?
I only own one black polish: Revlon in Lunar. I can’t find Essie Licorice in any of the drugstores, even when I am in NYC! =(
Favorite vampy lip color?
None.
That was what I was thinking as well. Inglot 407 Pearl!
Orange eyeshadow: Tangerine by Beauty From The Earth
Black nail polish: Black by ELF is actually quite good!
Vampy lip color: Make Up For Ever #49!
Orange eyeshadow: Not quite orange, but I’d have to go with MAC Amber Lights… looks great on the inner corner with my blue eyes!
Black nailpolish: Really love American Apparel’s Hassid! It is SO black, even with just one coat. Also love OPI My Private Jet, though that isn’t completely black.
Vampy Lip Color: Not one for vampy lip colors, but a good dark berry can look amazing!
Favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Saffron e/s
Favorite black nail polish? I guess OPI’s Black Shatter
Favorite vampy lip color? Both MAC A Different Groove lipglass from the Give Me Liberty Of London collection and NARS Bougainville. Also MAC Dark Deed lipstick is hot too.
Mac saffron
Crackle or revlon facets of fuchsia
Vampy lipstick…. Not my thing….Kat Von d ftw is as deep as I can get…
Favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Texture
Favorite black nail polish? Essie Licorice
Favorite vampy lip color? Dior #811 Smoky
Favorite orange eyeshadow? Probably Mischevious Marissa from The Balm Shady Lady Vol. 2 palette. So pretty in the summer with a nice tan and a bit of shimmery bronzer in the crease.
Favorite black nail polish? I don’t own one! I prefer colours that are almost black with just a hint of colour.
Favorite vampy lip color? Once again, don’t own one…when I get these braces off though, you can bet I’ll be getting one!
Fave black nail varnish?
OPI Lady In Black
Fave vampy lip colour?
Chanel Rouge Noir
Orange Eyeshadow: It’s not really orange, but has orange shimmers: MAC’s “Amber Lights”
Black Nailpolish: Sephora by OPI’s “What’s a Tire Jack?”
Vampy Lip Color: Nars’ “Trans Siberian’
darn it, i don’t have any : ( but i’ll read everyone elses responses!
Favourite orange eye shadow is MAC Saffron.
Favourite black nail polish is Wet n Wild Black Creme.
Favourite vampy lip colour is Lancome Plum Show.
I am ALL ABOUT ORANGE EYESHADOW! My favorite right now is Inglot AMC 51.
Favorite black nail polish: Nfu Oh GS-14
Favorite vampy lip color: MAC Cyber
Favorite orange eyeshadow? dolce & gabbana – burnt orange from Vulcano quad
Favorite black nail polish? chanel black pearl but it is actually a green.
Favorite vampy lip color? Tom Ford black orchid (old one)
Favorite orange eyeshadow? MAC Rule
Favorite black nail polish? MAC Nocturnelle
Favorite vampy lip color? MAC Prince Noir
Favorite orange eyeshadow? Sugarpill Flamepoint!
Favorite black nail polish? Black with red glitter (NYX Dorthy, Eyeko Vampira Polish…)
Favorite vampy lip color? I adore black lipstick/lip gloss! And also deeper tones of purple
Favorite orange eyeshadow? only have one: the NYX shangri la trio. i love burnt oranges <3
Favorite black nail polish? I don't think I have any…
Favorite vampy lip color? I like deep reds?? haha i don't wear them!!
Favorite orange eyeshadow? None! Don’t wear orange shadow
Favorite black nail polish? OPI Black Onyx
Favorite vampy lip color? Mac Sheen Supreme good to be bad
Fave orange e/s: MAC Rule (or possibly Off the Page, but I spilled some rubbing alcohol on it when I was depotting and it’s not the same anymore 🙁 )
Fave black nailpolih: The only one I have right now is MAC Military (which is more of a grey/silver semi-matte lovely), but I JUST ordered Zoya Raven. I’ve heard good things! Might pick up Essie Licorice after seeing so many reps on here too. 🙂
Fave vampy lip color: MAC Dark Side! Though I said in the post about vampy lips that I somehow cracked mine and need to buy a new one, because it is NOT stable in the tube anymore unless I use a brush, and I’m way too lazy/rushed to do that.
* Favorite orange eyeshadow? – Orange isn’t really my thing, but I did wear an orange eye look with a halloweeny shirt the other day, and I found the oranges in my Coastal Scents Shimmer 88 palette performed well.
* Favorite black nail polish? Revlon Black with Envy–which is a very dark gunmetal with a hint of green, but the darkest polish I have
* Favorite vampy lip color? Don’t really have one, I’m not a big fan of lip color much darker than my natural (though rather pigmented) lip color.
Favourite Orange Eye Shadow – MAC Paradisco
Favourite Black Nail Polish – GOSH Black Passion
Favourite Vampy Lipstick – I don’t really do dark lipstick so the closest I can get is NARS Red Square.
On my MC 40/Matchmaster 5.0 skin tone:
Favorite orange eyeshadow: I only own one thus far, but love it nonetheless, which is MAC’s Papara-she 😀
Favorite black nail polish: Haven’t come across one I love yet.
Favorite vampy lip color: Smoked Purple which I just picked up yesterday!
Oops, I meant NC 40* But I’m sure y’all caught my drift.
No particular favorites….. But some of the orange eyeshadows that I like include Inglot 407 Pearl, the burnt orange in Shiseido luminizing satin eye color trio in Fire, Tequila Sunrise from Sleek Makeup Curacao palette.
I have only one black nail polish, from Prorance, a Korean brand.
Vampy lipstick? MAC Dubonnet? Perhaps? I have Prince Noir but yet to try it.
Favorite orange eyeshadow?
It’s not truly orange, but I love MAC Saffron.
Favorite black nail polish?
For sparkly black I love NARS Night Breed and for smooth I like Zoya Raven.
Favorite vampy lip color?
I don’t have any vampy liptick! I’ve tried so many darker lipsticks and they all look bad on me. 🙁 I’m still looking for the right shade.
Favorite orange eyeshadow?
I dont really have any orange eyeshadow. BE Beautiful Autumn is as orange as I get.
Favorite black nail polish?
I like the black cream polish from Wet n’ Wild.
Favorite vampy lip color?
MAC Night Violet mattene with MAC Quick Tease lipglass over top.
Orange eyeshadow: Doesn’t work for me, to be honest.
Black nail polish: Boosh by Illamasqua
Vampy lip: Right now I’m loving MAC’s Posh Paradise Mattene in Potent Fig. I love the look of Illamasqua’s Kontrol lipstick, though…I keep meaning to pick one up.
The closest I get to orange eyeshadow is UD Free Love. I don’t do black nail polish. And my favorite vampy lipstick is MAC Rebel
orange eyeshadow- its not really orange but on my skin looks like one esp on paint pot base-mac samoa silk
nail polish, not too black again, but anyway-chanel 18 rouge noir, although I absolutely hate chanel nail brushes(I use brush from different polish, just can not manage chanel one-its too jelly-ish for my taste)
vampy lippie-armani 604, esp worn when applied with brush+liner (use it in winter on more pale skin)
Don’t own an orange e/s. Will use Orgasm blush on eyes, to pop up neutrals, but that’s as close as I come.
Don’t own black nail polish- but Nars Night Breed polish is tempting me hard.
Favorite Vampy lipstick? I stay away from Vampy/ Gothy because I’m super fair with natural almost coal black hair with big silver streaks at the temples. Give me a calla lilly and I’m The Bride of Frankenstien. Make up disaster looming!
But, I love Glimmerglass from Style Black. And it doesn’t make me Goth Queen, oddly. So I guess that’s it. Old Punk Woman.