We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

49 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Your skin tone/coloring: not quite super pale, more light than anything/neutral-toned colouring
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? red liquid liner! i swear by MUFE’s.
Best concealer for under eye circles? i just double up on my foundation-lancome teint idole, but when it’s particularly bad i use sephora’s concealor sticks, which are now discontinued.
Best every day mascara? sephora’s purple mascara (not with the red eyeliner though) since i have blue eyes.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/Neutral
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Turquoise
Best concealer for under eye circles? Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer
Best every day mascara? Maybelline Pumped Up Colossal Volume Express

Your skin tone/coloring: very fair with pink undertones (NW10)
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I love a good dark green eyeliner like Stila’s liquid liner in Moss
Best concealer for under eye circles? Nars Radiant Creamy concealer or Maybelline Age Eraser
Best every day mascara? L’Oreal Voluminous Butterfly mascara

■Your skin tone/coloring: NC20
■Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I love Stila Smudge Stick in Mint Julep or Canary. Or both lol.
■Best concealer for under eye circles? I love my NARS Radiant Concealer in Vanilla.
■Best every day mascara? I like thick, long, dramatic lashes (I don’t believe in falsies), so my faves are L’Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black Mascara, Lancome Hypnose Drama, and MAC Zoom Fast Black Lash.

Your skin tone/coloring: fair / warm
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Purple/Plum
Best concealer for under eye circles? Clinique Line Smoothing concealer
Best every day mascara? Benefit They’re Real

Your skin tone/coloring: Very pale, MAC NC15
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Purple
Best concealer for under eye circles? So far Revlon Colorstay Concealer
Best every day mascara? Maybelline Big Eyes Volume’Express, really nice mascara!

Skin Tone- medium dark (nc42-45 in Mac foundations)
Eyeliner- Rockstar from Urban Decay
Under eye concealer- Mac Pro Longwear baby!! NC 42
Everyday Mascara- YSL babydoll/benefit they’re real

Your skin tone/coloring: Light medium with yellow undertones
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? MAC Purple Dash (is the most colorful I can put)
Best concealer for under eye circles? Maybelline Instant Age Rewind
Best every day mascara? Maybelline The Falsies Flared

Skin tone/coloring – very fair with neutral/slightly cool undertones
Eyeliner for a pop of color – I like the urban decay liquid liners as well as the 24/7 glide ons. The sephora brand pencils aren’t bad either. I couldn’t pick just one color though!
Under eye concealer – Always trying new things and switching between what I have dependant on the day. Overall guess I’d have to go with the nars radiant creamy concealer. Also pixy’s color corrector is nice if used lightly.
Everyday mascara – The original volume express collosal works super nicely, although I no longer use it. Pretty stuck on better than sex from too faced, as well as chanel le volume. Wouldn’t consider those everyday options by most people’s standards though.

Your skin tone/coloring: medium – tan / yellow-olive / nc 30-35
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? navy
Best concealer for under eye circles? ysl &/or Nars
Best every day mascara? jordana

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium, warm (NC25)
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Something light and pastel, like NARS Barrow Street or the light blue Rimmel eyeliner, or a rose gold! L’Oreal makes a really nice one 🙂
Best concealer for under eye circles? OCC Skin Conceal in R1. A little dab of this will cancel out my darkest circles!
Best every day mascara? L’Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black. Amazing volume and curl!

Your skin tone/coloring: Honey Beige, warm undertone, biracial
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I love navy blue, purple or emerald green.. NYX and Rimmel are my current favorites
Best concealer for under eye circles? I am currently using Garnier Skin Renew Anti Dark Circle Eye Roller in Light/Medium
Best every day mascara? Covergirl Clump Crusher

Skintone/Coloring: Dark tan, Mac NW43
Best eyeliner for a pop of color:Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Pencils (all colors)
Best Concealer for under eye circles: La Girl Pro Concealer, Mac Prolongwear, Nars Creamy concealer, & Maybelline Fit me concealer. ..couldn’t choose one
Best Everyday Mascara: hands down to Rimmel Lash Accelorator & Volumizer.

Your skin tone/coloring: cool fair
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? UD pencil in Deep end
Best concealer for under eye circles? Bobbi Brown corrector in Bisque
Best every day mascara? Benefit Bad gal

Your skin tone/coloring: Light with yellow undertones (Revlon Colorstay foundation in buff)
Best eyeliner for a pop of color?: I really don’t use colored eyeliner, but I do like to place a colored eyeshadow on the lower eyelid, like MAC Purple Haze
Best concealer for under eye circles?: Maybelline Instant Age Rewind concealer in fair/light
Best every day mascara?: L’Oreal Voluminous Original

Your skin tone/coloring: Very light, neutral.
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Purple or burgundy. I know burgundy probably sounds a little odd, but on green eyes it looks amazing.
Best concealer for under eye circles? I’ve recently fallen in love with the NYX correcting under eye concealer. It’s a lot cheaper than most of the similar products I’ve seen and it’s a miracle worker.
Best every day mascara? I’m into Maybelline Mega Plush lately. If a mascara flakes on me you can see it from a mile away and that’s never an issue with this one.

Your skin tone/coloring: Nw50
◾Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I usually just use eyeshadow.
◾Best concealer for under eye circles? L.A girl pro concealer
◾Best every day mascara? L’Oreal Miss Manga

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool-toned
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Sephora Surfer Babe or Good Mood
Best concealer for under eye circles? IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye or Clarins Instant Concealer
Best every day mascara? L’Oreal Voluminous or Bobbi Brown Intensifying Long-Wear

◾Your skin tone/coloring: NC15-20
◾Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Teal or vibrant purple
◾Best concealer for under eye circles? IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye
◾Best every day mascara? Maybelline Lash Stiletto

◾Your skin tone/coloring: NW-25 light medium cool
◾Best eyeliner for a pop of color? UD 24/7 in purple….can’t think of the name
◾Best concealer for under eye circles? Benefit Erase Paste
◾Best every day mascara? Benefit They’re Real

Your skin tone/coloring: Light medium, warm yellow tones

Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Toss up between MAC Pearlglide Undercurrent or Milani Liquid Like Perfect Purple

Best concealer for under eye circles? Time Balm mixed with a teensy bit of illuminating cream

Best every day mascara? Elf Mineral Infused Mascara, the brush is excellent!

Your skin tone/coloring: Porcelain, cool undertones
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I am decidedly boring with eyeliner shades, so Marc Jacobs Midnight in Paris, a blackened navy with tonal shimmer, is about as much pop as I can handle.
Best concealer for under eye circles? I use NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer in Chantilly most of the time as it is one of the few shades fair enough.
Best every day mascara? YSL Babydoll

Skin tone – MAC NC15, MUFE 117
Best eyeliner for a pop of color- I don’t really wear colored eyeliner.
Best concealer for under eyes- Bobbi Brown creamy concealer (and corrector).
Best every day mascara- Benefit They’re Real mascara, it’s the only mascara I’ve found that keeps my naturally straight eyelashes curled (when I use it with an eyelash curler).

Coloring: Snow White (Character)
Pop of Color: I like Sephora Collection Banana Split
Concealer for Undereyes: Maybelline Fit Me Concealer… when I don’t leave my color match in another state and end up having to use the wrong shade since I’m too stubborn to buy a new one but refuse to look COMPLETELY dead.
Everyday Mascara: Maybelline Lash Discovery. Tiny brush, lots length & body, hard to mess up even on the earliest of mornings.

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair/neutral; auburn hair, hazel/green eyes

Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Silkissime Cobalt, UD Woodstock, UD Deep End, UD Voodoo, Kat von D Lightning Liner in Poe, Nyx Studio Liquid Liner in Extreme Green.

Best concealer for under eye circles? E.l.f. Studio HD Lifting Concealer in Brightening.

Best every day mascara? Physician’s Formula Va Va Voom Macara, Almay i-Color in Plum and Sappire, or UD Perversion.

Your skin tone/coloring: NW 20-ish; strongly cool undertones with some golden tan overlay
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Urban Decay 24/7 eye pencil in Abyss (bright metallic blue shimmer with blue micro sparkle) or Chaos (bright cobalt blue matte with slight floating pearl), or NARS Eye Paint in Interstellar (bright silver)
Best concealer for under eye circles? IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye in ‘neutral medium’ — the ‘light’ shade is a bit too light/yellow for me
Best every day mascara? IT Cosmetics Hello Lashes on upper lashes, IT Cosmetics Tightline mascara primer on lower lashes — when I want more drama, I use both the primer and the mascara on both top and bottom lashes. I also use Anastasia Beverly Hills Lash Genius waterproof top coat because every mascara (except tubing mascaras) smudges on me (even waterproof mascaras smudge on me) — it prevents smudging with almost every mascara I’ve ever tried it with. It has definitely changed my mascara life — before I found it I could only wear the limited selection of tubing mascaras available in the U.S., and some of them flaked on me!

Probably NW 25
Too may to list: UD Mainline, LSD, Junkie, Stila Mint Julep, Periwinkle, Sephora, MUFE: at my age, it’s all about the colored eyeliner…
Concealer: Eve Pearl, Erase Paste, IT Corrector
Mascara: colored or they’re real on top, always blinc on the bottom…it’s the only one that does not smear in the concealer, even set.

Your skin tone/coloring: NW20, green eyes, ginger

Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Sonia Kashuk Purple Passion

Best concealer for under eye circles? NYX salmon under eye concealer in medium, then Maybelline Instant Age Rewind in Fair

Best every day mascara? Benefit They’re Real or Lancôme Definicils.

Your skin tone/coloring: Neutral-toned, very fair

Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Stila Smudge Stick in Turquoise

Best concealer for under eye circles? It Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye in Light

Best every day mascara? I’m all for big lashes all day, every day. My favorites are Benefit They’re Real, Too Faced Better Than Sex, and Urban Decay Perversion Mascara. Add Urban Decay Subversion for extra oomph.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light medium neutral cool
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I like bronzes and plums
Best concealer for under eye circles? I use the Armani master corrector in 1 topped with either Nars creaming concealer in vanilla or Cle de Peau in ivory
Best every day mascara? I don’t have a mascara specific for day time, whatever mascara is open I’ll wear it. Now it’s Too Faced Better Than Sex.

Your skin tone/coloring: NW20
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? The teal by MUFE
Best concealer for under eye circles? MAC prolongwear
Best every day mascara? Clinique High Impact

Your skin tone/coloring: Deep, Golden Undertones
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Marc Jacobs Intro(Vert) Eyeliner
Best concealer for under eye circles? I’m currently not using a concealer. I used to use Bobbi Brown Corrector in Dark Bisque
Best every day mascara? Sisley So Intense Mascara

Your skin tone/coloring: light to light medium with yellow undertones (Chanel B20/30)
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I like purple on myself! Like Tarina Tarantino’s Amethyst Android or Ultraviolet
Best concealer for under eye circles? Still on the search for my holy grail! I think I’ve like the Clinique Airbrush concealer in neutral fair
Best every day mascara? Clinique’s High Impact mascara!

skin tone/coloring: medium – neutral
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? blue /purple, loreal, sephora & marc jacobs make nice 1’s
Best concealer for under eye circles? ysl & covergirl ready set
Best every day mascara? love maybelline mascaras & dior show

Your skin tone/coloring: fair/light
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? teal
Best concealer for under eye circles? urban decay 24/7 concealer
Best every day mascara? l’oreal miss manga

Skin tone – medium/tan, with a little bit of yellow undertones.
Best eyeliner for a pop of color – I usually stick to black, and just use color eye-shadow if I want a pop of color.
Best concealer for undereyes – I don’t really have a problem with under eye bags or discoloration, but I’ve been loving physicians formula nude wear concealer!
Best everyday concealer – either too faced better than sex, or cover girl flamed out

Skin Tone/Coloring – Tan/Medium Dark (Nars Syracuse, Bobbi Brown Golden, BM Golden Tan).
Best eyeliner for a pop of color – Urban Decay’s 24*7 eyeliner in Mars
Best concealer for under eye circles – Laura Mercier UnderEye Perfector in Orange/Yellow and Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer (Ginger) over that.
Best everyday mascara – I use just one – Benefit’s They’re Real.

Skin coloring is medium with warm undertones…
Eyeliner for a pop would be probably teal
I usually use Nars but not thrilled with any I have tried..’
I am still trying to find a good mascara that lenghtens and curls my short thick eyelashes…..

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium tan
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Purples are my favorite color eyeliners! I love Urban Decay’s.
Best concealer for under eye circles? Make Up For Ever Full Cover concealer
Best every day mascara? Milani Runway Lashes in Deepest Black

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/Neutral

Best eyeliner for a pop of color? I’m still mastering eyeliner. I love Tarte Golden Tiger’s Eye, but that’s not really a *pop* of color. I think cobalt, plum, and teal eyeliner look really cool.

Best concealer for under eye circles? Currently, I’m really liking the Cle de Peau concealer.

Best every day mascara? Almay and Pacifica are my favorites.

■Your skin tone/coloring: Light olive
■Best eyeliner for a pop of color?: MAC Designer Purple
■Best concealer for under eye circles?: Natural Finish Concealer by Shiseido
■Best every day mascara?: Elizabeth Arden Beautiful Color (the old version that’s gone now though! So sad!!!)

Your skin tone/coloring: light med/yellow
Best eyeliner for a pop of color?: UD 24/7 Deviant or MAC Pro Longwear in Mountain Air
Best concealer for under eye circles?: I love Nars creamy concealer but right now I used Shiseido Natural finish more
Best every day mascara?: Clinique High Impact and Lancome Defenicils high definition with these two combo,it’s make my lash look really beautiful!

Your skin tone/coloring: light to medium warm

Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Maybe my new green Revlon ColorStay Eye Pencil

Best concealer for under eye circles? none, really… under eye concealers and I just don’t get along

Best every day mascara? Covergirl Flamed Out mascara

Your skin tone/coloring:
Fairest neutral – Koh Gen Do Maifanshi Moisture Foundation in 001 etc. Too pale to register on the fancy Dior contraption that they use to match you to a foundation colour!

Best eyeliner for a pop of color?
I love both teal and purple. It’s hard to choose between the two but at the moment I’ve been going for purple a lot more. Saying that, I did actually wear teal today, so I can’t really pick one over the other!

Best concealer for under eye circles?
The two I’ve found that work best for me are the Bobbi Brown Tinted Eye Brightener (I use Porcelain Peach) and the Tarte Maracuja Creaseless Concealer (I use Fair). They both set really well and don’t migrate into my fine lines. I tend to use the Bobbi Brown one most of the time only because it sets to more of a satin finish and the Tarte one still retains some shine. Both are great options, however, I would love something closer in colour to my beloved Laura Mercier Secret Concealer in 1. It’s very dark compared to my skintone but it cancels out my dark circles so well. It does crease on me though so I don’t use it much anymore.

Best every day mascara?
I still love my L’Oréal Voluminous in Carbon Black. I’ve tried lots of mascaras and I’ve not found one that performs much better. It’s as good as many of the more expensive ones at less than half the price. I don’t splurge on mascara, not least of all because you need to replace it every three months or so. Some high-end cosmetics are worth the money but for me mascara isn’t one of them.

Light pink under stones NC20
Either mildew by UD or cobalt by stila
I have tried I so many but my best is Maybelline age rewind dark circle eraser in neutralizer with Bare minerals well rested
High end: They’re real by benefit Drugstore: L’Oreal butterfly

Your skin tone/coloring: Very pale with warm undertones
Best eyeliner for a pop of color? Navy blue with some shimmer to it
Best concealer for under eye circles? Nyx HD concealer
Best every day mascara? CK One mascara

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!