Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Melissa C Avatar

Skin tone: Light with neutral undertones (but I’m self-tanning now – so I can use L’Oreal W4)
Best Waterproof eyeliner: L’Oreal HIP Eyeliners – they stay like no other! Wish they came in more colors
Best Waterproof Mascara: Covergirl Lashblast Waterproof
Best Body Sunscreen: Anything that you can spray on! I like Banana Boat and Aveeno

Christina Avatar

◾Your skin tone/coloring: Makeup forever HD#118, Dior Nude 023, Light with beige undertones
◾Best waterproof eyeliner? MUFE Aqua Liner (this doesn’t smudge on me even after swimming!)
◾Best waterproof mascara? Urban Decay’s Cannonball mascara (doesn’t wilt when I’m swimming)
◾Best body sunscreen? I like Hawaiin Tropic Because I love the summery scent of their products

Sarah Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light with yellow undertones
Best waterproof eyeliner? Still looking! I have monolids and EVERYTHING UNDER THE SUN smears on me… but Bobbi Brown’s gel liner is decent.
Best waterproof mascara? Still looking for above reasons…. so far, Maybelline’s The Falsies Flared is a top contender. Still smudges by the middle of the day, though 🙁
Best body sunscreen? Neutrogena oil-free… such a lovely matte finish! No greasy hands!

cassandra c Avatar

Skin Tone: Very fair with yellow undertones.
Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7!! These last better than MUFE on me.
Mascara: Lights, Camera, Splashes by Tarte. I bought Lash Genius by Anastasia, but that sadly clumps up my mascara and I will return it eventually.
Sunscreen: Neutrogena for face, Target brand spray for body.

Dee Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium Tan w/Olive undertones
Best waterproof eyeliner? MUFE Aqua Black Cream Eyeshadow and UD 24/7 Liquid Eyeliner.
Best waterproof mascara? I’ve had luck with various drugstore brands (Maybelline, L’Oreal, etc)
Best body sunscreen? For body, I prefer natural, mineral blocks like Goddess Garden, Badger, etc.

becca Avatar

skin tone/ coloring: nw/nc10, very pale neutral

best wp eyeliner: giorgio armani black wp liner

best wp mascara: lancome hypnose drama wp

sunscreen: neutrogena spray

Kiss & Make-up Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: light to medium warm

Best waterproof eyeliner? Pupa’s Multiplay eye pencil

Best waterproof mascara? Bourjois Contour Clubbing waterproof mascara

Best body sunscreen? Nivea Protect & Bronze SPF 30

Abbey W Avatar

Skin tone: Light-medium with warm undertones
Best Waterproof eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7
Best Waterproof Mascara: I love Full N’ Soft waterproof! I’ve loved it since my junior year in high school (ten years ago)
Best Body Sunscreen: For everyday outdoor activities I like the Aveeno spray. It has a pleasant scent that’s not too overpowering. If I’m running I like the regular Coppertone Sport spray.

Christina Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30/C4 – neutral light tan

Best waterproof eyeliner? Stila All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner. Blackest black and doesn’t move!

Best waterproof mascara? Clinique Lash Power. The only non-smudging formula for my creaseless lids and very short eyelashes!

Best body sunscreen? No-Ad! A pleasant beachy smell, broad spectrum and high SPF options, inexpensive, absorbs quickly. I use a lot so inexpensive but strong protection are my two musts!

liz Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: cool/neutral, fair. somewhere around NW10/15, i’d guess.
Best waterproof eyeliner? still looking!
Best waterproof mascara? MAC opulash is pretty dang waterproof on me, not sure if it’s meant to be (i ganked it from an ex-friend; i didn’t purchase it so i don’t know much about it)
Best body sunscreen? hawaiian tropic shimmer effect sunscreen!! it has SPARKLES and smells like delicious coconut goodness.

Laurel Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light, neutral with dark hair and dark eyes. MUFE 117
Best waterproof eyeliner? Maybelline Master Drama, Too Faced perfect eyes, or Rimmel Scandaleyes
Best waterproof mascara? I like Maybelline Colossal waterproof or One by One
Best body sunscreen? Any of the cooling spray kinds are nice

A. Mar Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light/neutral
Best waterproof eyeliner? Make Up For Ever Aqua Liner or Aqua Eyes
Best waterproof mascara? Maybelline Great Lash or Urban Decay Cannonball.
Best body sunscreen? Sun Bum! Amazing, amazing. I can’t recommend the brand enough. I have Continuous Spray for daily use and Premium Endurance for running or hiking. They’re both great no more what your active level is that day. And the spray is lightweight and non-greasy.

Mariella Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/cool toned
Best waterproof eyeliner? I don’t wear eyeliner on those rare occasions when I’m going to be in the water but I’m really loving the new Sephora Waterproof Contour Eye Pencils. I can’t attest to how waterproof they are but they apply so beautifully, last well all day on me and come in the most beautiful array of colours.
Best waterproof mascara? I rarely wear mascara and it’s not something I’d every wear to the beach or pool.
Best body sunscreen? For my body, I’m not all that fussy, really, so long as it’s broad spectrum UVA/UVB protection of SPF 45 or higher (I’m using 60 right now). If it’s cheap and cheerful, so much the better – means we’ll all use it liberally, which is the best thing. I heard the other day in a report that the cheap brands from WalMart and Target were among the best ones in some recent testing (by the Canadian or US dermatological organization of some sort…)

ElKay Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring: NW25
■Best waterproof eyeliner? MUFE –
■Best waterproof mascara? The Rocket Waterproof from Maybelline. I just ordered Armani Eyes to Kill Waterproof from Nordstrom. Thanks Christine for the heads up on the buy two get one free!!
■Best body sunscreen? Dr. T’s Supergoop – love the stuff.

Jessica Avatar

Skin Tone: fair and neutral, for the most part. MUFE 115, Nars Finland, UD Naked in 3.5.
Waterproof eyeliner: I don’t wear eyeliner, because I am totally clueless when it comes to application.
Waterproof mascara: Maybelline Falsies Flared made it through “The Office” series finale. Chanel Inimitable Intense lasted through “Toy Story 3.”
Body sunscreen: Neutrogena Wet Skin spray in the highest number, reapplied often. I burn very easily and have turned purple before from sun poisoning, because I missed a spot!

Maddie Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring: MAC C3
■Best waterproof eyeliner? Too Faces Perfect Eyes
■Best waterproof mascara? Estee Lauder Sumptuous Waterproof
■Best body sunscreen? Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Body Mist Sunblock SPF100

Marilyn Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Super-duper light.
Best waterproof eyeliner? Urban Decay 24/7. I still have it left under my eyes after using eye make-up remover
Best waterproof mascara? I don’t use it, but I love L’Oreal for just about any non waterproof use.
Best body sunscreen? I’m allergic to both physical and chemical sunscreen, so I don’t use it. The fact that studies show it may cause liver cancer makes me also steer clear of it.

Martha Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium with yellowish undertone
Best waterproof eyeliner? Urban Decay
Best waterproof mascara? any waterproof (I have to curl my eyelashes and any waterproof formula it will hold the curl)
Best body sunscreen? I will use any. Any protection is better than none

Veronica Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Quite fair, NC/W10-15. Very cool-toned in winter, more neutral in summer.
Best waterproof eyeliner? Urban Decay’s 24/7 liners lasts longer than any other I’ve used on my lower lash line. I’ve yet to find a pencil that lasts more than an hour on my waterline, though. 🙁
Best waterproof mascara? Admittedly, I’ve tried few, but Maybelline’s Waterproof Stiletto holds up quite nicely.
Best body sunscreen? Target’s own brand is surprisingly good, but I rather like Eucerin’s SPF15 body moisturizer.

Aida Avatar

1) Light/yellow
2) Tarte’s skinny smoldereyes pencils, Physicians Formula’s pencils and more recently I tried two from the Flower Beauty line (navy and aubergine), which are amazing.
3) I never use waterproof mascara
4) I love Devita’s SPF30 body solar block. I also use Devita’s SPF30 face moisturizer.

Alesia Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring: Ivory
■Best waterproof eyeliner? Chanel Stylo Waterproof
■Best waterproof mascara? – don’t use
■Best body sunscreen? – don’t use

NeenaJ Avatar

Skin tone: fair with freckles and redness
Best Waterproof Liner: Cargo Swimmables Eyeliner. These are the BEST waterproof pencil liners I’ve ever found.
Best Waterproof Mascara: Maybelline Full n Soft Waterproof but – it doesn’t fare well when it comes into contact with lotion/sunscreen so that’s a poolside fail for me. I’d probably go without at the beach or pool.
Best Body Sunscreen: I’m really picky about my facial sunscreens but, for body it’s anything SPF30 or higher from Hawaiian Tropic. It needs to be reapplied after being in the water but no problem because I cannot get enough of that smell. Love it!

Ashley Avatar

skintone:extremely fair, neutral undertones
best waterproof eyeliner: the saem waterproof eyeliner(pencil), MUFE aqua eyes (liquid)
best waterproof mascara: MUFE smoky eyes or tarte lights, camera, lashes
best body sunscreen: badger sunblock

Morena Avatar

Skin: Nc50 summer (now) and Nc45 winter

Best waterproof liner: sephora jumbo waterproof eyeliner pencil (turquoise my favorite)
MAC LIQUID LAST in aqualine and Blue herizon. I wear these in the gym, at pool or beach and they do not budge.

Best waterproof mascara:I’ve only tried makeup forever smoky lash.

Best sunscreen: any brand that is sunBLOCK (not sunSCREEN ) with titanium dioxide as the ingredient. Because it blocks the rays(sunBLOCK) instead of just absorbing it (SunSCREEN)

Jessica Avatar

Skin tone/coloring: fair with cool, pink undertones.
Best waterproof eyeliner: Tarte Amazonian Clay waterproof liner. I had a hysterical crying fit a couple of months ago and it stayed on! I was dumbfounded.
Best waterproof mascara: Maybelline Define-A-Lash, hands down.
Best body sunscreen: Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch Sunblock. Everything else feels oily in comparison.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!