We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

133 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Worst eyeliner – MAC Feline (love how black it is, but it runs really bad on me for some reason)
Best gel liner – MAC Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – Urban Decay 24/7 Liner in Whiskey

Same here! Feline is so beautiful but it sucks on my waterline.

Best gel liner – MAC Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – Covergirl Brown Blaze

Worst eyeliner?
Avon, at least for me. It wasn’t bad in itself, but I guess it’s not meant for sensitive eyes. Made my eyelids swell up.

Best gel eyeliner?
Come to think of it, I’ve yet to try gel eyeliner. It seems to me like too much of a fuss.

Eyeliner you’re wearing right now?
None, my eyes needed a break. I normally wear UD 24/7, though.

Worst eyeliner – some of my Clinique Kohl Shapers are dry and drag when i try to use them.
Best Gel liner – Bobbi Brown gel liners
Eyeliner I’m wearing now – an LE Lancome liner not sure of the name. Its a shimmery grey color.

Worst eyeliner? wet n wild
Best gel eyeliner? mac fluidline
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now?loreal carbon blk intense liner

Worst eyeliner? I tried an eyeliner forever ago from UD called smoke out I think? TERRRIBLE. It was hard, hurt to use, and had no color payoff.

Best gel eyeliner? I love love love everything about the Wet n’ Wild gel liner, except that the low quality of the jar dries out the product far too quickly. So for me, it would have to be MAC Fluidline.

Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? None today! I have been very minimalist w/ my makeup lately, just mascara on my lashes.

Worst eyeliner: Tough one! Urban Decay 24/7, just because I don’t understand all the hype about them and I think they are too expensive !
Best gel liner: I only used one, so the one by Clinique
Eye liner I’m wearing right now: None! No make-up on my face yet!

Worst eyeliner title definitely goes to NYC’s Automatic Eye Pencil. Horribly stratchy, drags across the skin, and you have to press down very hard to get any color to show.
I don’t have any gel liner yet.
I’m not wearing any liner as I just woke up, but I’ve been wearing the UD 24/7 liner in Zero a lot.

Worst eyeliner? the classic chanel pencils, they’re so soft that when you smudge them , they’re gone
Best gel eyeliner? mac fluidline thogh I’m not sooo impressed with it either (stil liquid-liner last longer on my lids)
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? none, as I had a terrible headache and didn’t leave the house today

* Worst eyeliner? – Maybelline
* Best gel eyeliner? – MAC Fluidline
* Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? – L’oreal Felt Tip SuperLiner (AKA super lineur intense)

Worst: E.L.F. Shimmer Eyeliner Pencil
Best? I don’t tend to use gel liners b/c I don’t like them. I love U.D. 24/7 and MUFE pencils. ELF also makes a liquid liner pen in midnight blue that I love
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: UD 24/7 in zero

Worst eyeliner – MUFE Aqua Eyes, it goes on great but only lasts about an hour!
Best gel liner – All gel liners are great, but Maybelline makes gel liner that’s just as good as fluid line but half the price!
Eyeliner I’m wearing now – I get no kick eye pencil by MAC

Worst eyeliner? Sephora brand’s nano pencil thingy-mah-jigs. They’re hard and they pull at your eyes and hurt to put on!
Best gel eyeliner? MAC’s Blacktrack fluidline!
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Eyeshadow used as liner on the upper lashline (black with purple and red shimmer) and Urban Decay’s Zero on the lower lashline and waterline.

Worst eyeliner – Wet n Wild
Best gel liner – I haven’t tried any yet, but I want to!
Eyeliner I’m wearing – Stila Smudgestick in Blue Ribbon, the color works really well with my blue eyes i love it!

Worst eyeliner? Any of Clinique’s I’ve tried don’t stay put.

Best gel eyeliner? Bobbi Brown and M.A.C. Fluidline

Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Bobbi Brown Black Mauve gel eyeliner

Worst eyeliner: Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil
(too hard, no color)
Best gel liner : MAC Fluidline Blacktrack and Waveline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: MAC Fluidline Blitz and Glitz

Greets from Germany

Worst eyeliner: Bourjeois Paillettes (ow ow ow for application!) and Rimmel Kohl liner (I think) in white. So little pigmentation, and so coarse!
Best gel liner: have only ever tried MAC fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: Lancome artliner on top lashline and UD 24/7 in Baked on lower lashline

Worst Eyeliner- E.L.F. liquid…too watery!
Best Gel Liner- L’Oreal HiP Gel Liner in black
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now- LA Splash Liquid Eyeliner in Black

Worst eyeliner – MAC technakohls

Best gel eyeliner – Bobbi Brown or MAC – like both equally.

Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: Tarina Tarantino Hyperliner in Puppeteer – LOVE IT! Fantastic eyeliner.

Worst eyeliner? maybelinne

Best gel eyeliner? mac fluidline

Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? none, but i usually wear UD whiskey

Worst eyeliner – Too Faced, I think it was called Lava Liner? I don’t know if they still make it, but it was a great creamy intense black. Unfortunately it lasted all of one second on!
Best gel liner – MAC Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – Urban Decay 24/7 Liner in Bourbon

Worst eyeliner? MAC Smolder – it gets all over my eyelids.
Best gel eyeliner? Clinique and Bobbi Brown (I like them both pretty equally).
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? None.

Worst eyeliner? When I try to use eyeshadow as eyeliner, because it messes up my contacts and makes my eyes hurt if I get it in my eyes.
Best gel eyeliner? I’ve only tried Bobbi Brown, and I love it! I thought it would be more trouble than using pencil eyeliner, but it’s actually easier. I used to only use UD 24/7 liners, but I much prefer the gel now.
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner in Chocolate Shimmer

Worst – sephora pencils…dragged on my eyes and didn’t last at all.

gel – not sure i’ve used

wearing right now – super skinny line of kat von d tattoo liner in trooper with UD 24/7 in Ransom a little thicker stacked on top.

Worst eyeliner- NYX Jumbo. Will not stay in one place no matter what you do, it’s a mess lol. I don’t like it as a base either, creases a lot.
Best gel eyeliner- Maybelline. I really wasn’t expecting it to be so great, but it is- stays on forever and super pigmented- even better than my old go-to Stila Smudge Stick.
Eyeliner I have on now- A little of the black Maybelline on my inner rims, and a mix of Urban Decay Gunmetal and Creep around my eyes instead of liner.

Worst Eyeliner — Golden Rose High-Shine Black Metallic liner. Don’t know how many people know of/use Golden Rose, but they’re a European brand with very affordable products, sort of comparable to Nyx. One of their kiosks opened in my mall, and I like a lot of their products — their glitter liners and baked bronzers in particular are cute, and the price is right for what I would consider just a fun novelty product. NOT so with this liner. Yes, it’s super-pigmented and as black as sin, and really glossy, but it’s also very runny and IMPOSSIBLE to remove if you make a mistake. The brush attached to the cap is crap, and the bottle is sort of elongated so you couldn’t stick your own brush in there. When I try to take it off, it smears into giant black raccoon eyes, to the point where I’d have to take a shower just to get it all off. I gave up on trying to work with it and just tossed it.

Best gel liner — I don’t use gels, so no comment.

Liner I’m wearing right now — Milani Infinite Eyeliner in Endless, the purple metallic color.

Worst eyeliner? the BonneBell Eye Definers. really hard, so they tug and pull on your eyes. if you warm them up, they work okay for eye bases.
Best gel eyeliner? I love the Stila Smudge Pots. I got the little set of 4 from Sephora and I love them.
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Urban Decay Creep eyeshadow from the Naked Palette because I was too lazy to sharpen my Zero pencil.

NARS pencil is definitely worst for me. I’ve also tried MAC Feline and it was smudgy too 🙁
I only own two gel liners: MAC’s blacktrack fluidline which is a solid liner, and Bobbi Brown’s Cobalt Ink (which I purchased yesterday and currently wearing/testing).

Worst eyeliner- none that I own. Only, Nars pencils and Chanel waterproof pencils are hard, so difficult to line lower eyelid with them.
Best gel liner- I only have Bobbi Brown cobalt ink and a dark green one which I am satisfied with.
Eyeliner I wore today(just cleaned my make up)was Givenchy blue lagoon liquid eyeliner.

Worst eyeliner? Wet n Wild
Best gel eyeliner? I don’t own any yet
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? ArtDeco Soft Eye Liner Waterproof in Dark Indigo

Worst eyeliner – Urban Decay liquid liner. Ugh, a mess; it smeared, ran, and looked awful.
Best gel liner – Bobbi Brown; love Denim Ink
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – None; it’s a no-makeup day! But I used MAC Eye Kohl in Teddy yesterday.

worst eyeliner… I still have to find one… none of them are that bad on my eyes…
best gel liner: MAC fluidline!
eyeliner I’m wearing now: MAC Technakohl Liner

worst: any wet and wild pencils. so rough. they tug.
best: mac fluidline. ive tried stilas smudgepot and smashbox’s jetset and none compare to mac.
eyeliner im wearing right now: im taking a day off.

Worst eyeliner: I’d have to say Clnique’s twisty ones. They dry so fast.
Best gel liner: MAC Fluidlines
Eyeliner that i’m wearing right now: nothing, but if i were, it would be MAC smolder.

worst eyeliner – l’oreal pencil black
best gel liner – bobbi brown black
eyeliner I am wearing right now – urban decay 24/7 black

Worst Eyeliner- Idk yet, hope I never have to experience a dreadful one! 🙂
Best gel liner- Idk either! haha ive never used gel liner!
Liner im wearing now- NYX studio professional liquid liner in extreme black

Worst – Smashbox Cream Liner – tried it years ago and what a mess
Best gel – I’ve only tried one – Clinique – and it’s okay but I think I’m just not a fan…
Wearing right now – not actually eyeliner, but MAC’s Birds & Berries applied like liner…pretty with dark eyes

Worst eyeliner?
Max factor Kohl liner – smudge like no one’s business

Best gel eyeliner?
I don’t use gel liner, not anymore, too much hassle of getting a brush!

Eyeliner you’re wearing right now?
Urban decay 24/7. Best liner so far. Even better than MAC’s powerpoint in my opinion!

Worst eyeliner – Pretty much any pencil by CoverGirl has been crappy for me.
Best gel liner – “True Black” by Coastal Scents. I’ve heard lots of poor reviews about this, and I don’t understand why, because it’s my holy grail of eyeliners. Sooo black, and it doesn’t budge!
Eyeliner I’m wearing now – See above. 🙂

Worst Eyeliner: Probably Hard Candy Liquid Liners. Too streaky and messy.

Best Gel Eyeliner: Either the MAC Fluidline or the MAC Chromaline.

Currently Wearing: MAC Chromoline 😀

Worst Eyeliner- Revlon ColorStay (Runny, smudgy, made my eyes look like a raccoon)
Best Gel Eyeliner- Mac Blacktrack
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now- MAC Technakohl Eyeliner in Photogravure (stays put all day, no smudging. Better than MUFE’s and Urban Decays!)

Worst: Maybelline Define a Line. It required far too much pressure to apply so I just did my homework with it… heh.
Best gel: MAC Fluidlines are good but I like Bobbi Brown more for the colors.
Now: UD El Dorado on the lower lashline.

* Worst eyeliner? The drugstore cheapies like Wet’nWild. So hard.
* Best gel eyeliner? MAC Fluidline
* Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Mac Fluidline Rich Ground, my everyday go to liner

worst: Urban Decay Zero, it’s super dry and i have to “warm it up” on the back of my hand so it glides on without pulling on my skin

best gel: i don’t use gel eyeliner but i do have L’Oreal HIP in eggplant and it’s a beautiful color, super pigmented, and goes on smoothly. there’s also something pretty and luxurious about it coming in a little glass jar with a liner brush.

right now: MAC Feline. I love the richness of the black and it goes on wonderfully smooth and doesn’t run at all on me.

I’d be tempted to exchange that UD Zero liner for another. I’ve *never* heard of any UD liner being hard or tugging. Super weird.

Worst eyeliner – L’oreal liner intense
Best gel liner – Never tried
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – Sephora black liquid eyeliner. I love it and have been using it for years. Great formula!

Worst eyeliner – elf they sucks

Best gel – wet and wild I have used the high end one and really I think this one is just about the same but a lot cheaper

eyeliner I am using now – urbann decay 24/7

* Worst eyeliner? Sephora eye liner it’s so hard onmy eyes, I didn’t buy, it was just a gift for birthday
* Best gel eyeliner? Bobbi brown gel eye liner
* Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Milani, liquif’eye metallic eye liner pencil in brown

worst eyeliner – UD 24/7
Best gel eyeliner? BB gel e/l – worn it for many yrs. Have in 6 shades
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? LM cake eyeliner in Emerald Green (this was dc’d shade – Forest Green is one of the three new shades just released)

Worst Eyeliner – Clinique Kohl pencil does not stay put. While not awful, I can’t understand the hype behind UD’s 24/7 liners.
Best Gel Liner – MAC Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m Wearing Right Now – Mac Fluidline – Blacktrack

Worst eyeliner? MAC Teddy and Feline smudge EVERYWHERE!
Best gel eyeliner? Clinique- MAC Fluidline and Bobbi Brown dry out too quickly but Clinique stays nice and fluid forever.
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Clinique and UD 24/7 on waterline

Worst eyeliner – I can’t remember now! But my eyelids are all so oily that without any kind of eyeshadow base like a MAC paint pot or the Nars eyeshadow base, ANY eyeliner would become the worst eyeliner on me! LOL It’s just the way it is.

Best gel liner – MAC Fluidline

Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – Just the MAC Mega Metal eyeshadow in Unflappable. I smoked it out a bit as usual.

Worst eyeliner – Clinique Kohl Pencil – does not stay put. I also do not understand the hype surrounding UD 24/7 Liners, but they are not the worst.
Best gel liner – MAC Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – MAC Fluidline Blacktrack

Worst eyeliner: I don’t know if they are the worst, but any MAC pencil or Technakohl eyeliner. They smudge on me like crazy!
Best gel liner: Mac Fluidline.
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: Urban Decay 24/7 in Bourbon on upper lash line and in Baked on lower lash line.

Worst eyeliner?- I don’t have one yet
Best Gel Eyeliner?- Wet N’ Wild Gel Eyeliner
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now?- Revlon Colorstay pencil eyeliner in Black

Worst eyeliner: Revlon Colorstay
Best gel eyeliner: MAC Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: Urban Decay 24/7 in Zero

Worst eyeliner – NARS – the one I tried melted onto my face 30 minutes after I put it on

Best Gel Eyeliner – MAC Fluidline

Eyeliner I’m wearing right now- UD 24/7 pencil in Perversion on the upper lashline, MUFE Aqua Eyes in 1L on the waterline and lower lashline

Worst eyeliner – Aside from not being a big pencil liner fan in general, it’d have to be a cheapie gray liquid liner that just smelled from the second I opened it up. It wasn’t a spoiled smell, it was like a horrible paint smell, so I just threw it away. I don’t even remember the brand, except it wasn’t Wet and Wild–I’ve had some success with their metallic liquid liners.

Best gel liner – Those Physician’s Formula shimmer strips ones! L’Oreal HIPs are pretty much the same quality-wise, but you only get one huge pot of color (that I’m sure will dry out before I use it all), compared to the three with PF.

Eyeliner I’m wearing – I actually took the black w/glitter shade from my Wet and Wild 6-pan Lust palette and used my wedge-eyeliner brush. Can’t get a fine gel line with it for some reason, but it’s crazy good to do a fine powder line for some odd reason.

Worst Eyeliner: Sephora ‘Pure’ eyeliner pencils. Those were terrible! Hard, little color pay-off, and pulled at my lids. Ugh
Best Gel liner: I’ve been wanting to try MAC fluidline but haven’t had the chance. The best I’ve come across so far is tarte’s gel liner. Mines a bit dried out now but it’s still easy to use and stays on well.
Eyeliner I’m wearing: Either Urban Decay 24/7 in zero or my Sephora liner in black (I think they’re called flashy liners?) it works just as good as urban decay.

Worst eyeliner- MAC Feline
Best gel eyeliner- I’m yet to try a gel eyeliner.
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now Loreal Intense liner in black

Worst eyeliner: I have come across many bad ones such as the really long eyeliners from wet n wild, some cover girl and maybelline eyeliners
Best gel liner: Black Radiance Creme Liner
Eye liner I’m wearing right now: None, but I love Milani’s Liquif’eye

Worst eyeliner? Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer. It fades, smudges like crazy and somehow flaked and smeared all the way to my under eyes.

Best gel eyeliner? Tried a lot and I don’t like gel liners.

Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Urban Decay 24/7 Liner in Stash

Worst Eyeliner: I don’t really have one, I try to research alot before I buy
Best Eyeliner: MUFE AquaEyes Pencils, Loreal Hip
Eyeliner Wearing Right Now: MUFE AuqaEyes Pencil in 3L

Worst?- Jordana Easy Liner (smudge/transfer city)
Best?- Stila Smudge Pot (so far)
Now?- Nada (I had a bad reaction to the Maybelline cooling effects shadow)

* Worst eyeliner? MAC Khol instantly smudges all over my face
* Best gel eyeliner? MAC Fluidline = love
* Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? MAC Grey Utility PPoint

Worst eyeliner: too many to list!
Best gel liner: Inglot Gel Liners
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: milani liquif’eye & revlon colorstay both in Black

Worst Eyeliner?
Best Gel Eyeliner- Wet n Wild Gel Eyeliner
Eyeliner I’m Wearing right now- Physicians formula eye define eye marker

Worst? Feline–and I hate to say it because it is a black to die for!!
Best gel–MAC Fluidline.
Wearing now–Wolf, a gold/black Pearlglide from few years ago by MAC.

Worst Eyeliner- Clinique Kohl Shapers—SOOOO dry.
Best gel liner- Bobbi Brown
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now- UD 24/7 in Revolver

Worst eyeliner- anything by wet & wild; they are 99 cents for a reason.
Best gel liner- Smashbox Eyeliner Palatte
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now- Prestige Total Intensity in black. It is honestly the BEST eyeliner I have ever come across. I’ve tried anything from wet & wild and cover girl to MAC and Lancome

Worst eyeliner? The “liner side” of Covergirl smoky shadow blast – HORRIBLE. And Sephora brand, I never understood the concept of “traveling”, smudgy eyeliner until I tested theirs out.
Best gel eyeliner? I’m partial to Urban Decay – but Wet N Wild also has a great little jet black gel liner for less than $3, and it works almost as well as UD Ink for Eyes
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? UD 24/7 in Perversion blended with a little Midnight Cowboy, from the UD15 kit.

* Worst eyeliner? Used to love Revlon Colorstay Eyeliners but the formula changed and it is now too creamy and it runs.

* Best gel eyeliner? I really like Clinique’s

* Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Milani Pencil Liquifeye love it!!!

* Worst eyeliner?
When you put together price, ease of use, and colour payoff… Urban Decay 24/7. Not worth the coin.

* Eyeliner you’re wearing right now?
It’s my day off, haha. Usually Rimmel Pro Liquid Liner. Gets the job done and stays there.

Worst Eyeliner: The worst I’ve experienced is the eyeliners from The Body Shop.
Best gel liner: I’m not a big gel liner person, so I don’t really now.
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: Stila Kajal in Onyx. Favorite eyeliner eeever!!

Worst eyeliner? I haven’t had a bad eyeliner in a long time.
Best gel eyeliner? MAC and Bobbi Brown
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Bobbi Brown Black Plum gel liner

Worst: Avon eyeliner. Splotchy. ‘Nuff said.
Best: Urban Decay’s 24/7 Liner
Eyeliner I’m wearing Now…At the moment none, but I have been using Sephora’s new shadows in place of a stick liner. Other than that, usually Sephora Nano liners or UB’s 24/7 liners.

Worst Eye Liner – Tarte Emphaseyes AquaGel Liner Pencil – smears like no ones business
Best Gel Liner – Technically cream but Stila Smudge Pot
Liner Im Wearing now – Laura Mercier Kohl in Stormy Grey

worst eyeliner- victoria’s secret beauty rush glitter liner. everyone that has tried them has loved them but whenever I put it on, it stings my eyelids!
best gel liner- mac fluidline
eyeliner i’m wearing right now- mac fluidline in blacktrack on upper lashline, and physician’s formula eye definer pencil on my lower lashline (also a great eyeliner, IMO)

Worst: any elf liner!!!!! It doesn’t draw on the skin at all!!!! Esecially eyes!
Best: Mac fluidline or wet n wild cream liner!!!
Right now: maybelline gel liner

Worst eyeliner: Maybelline Ultra Liner Liquid Liner
Best gel liner: Any Mac Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: Mac Siahi Fluidline

Worst eyeliner: Clinique Cream Shaper for Eyes
Best gel eyeliner: Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner or MAC Fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: MAC Eye Kohl in Phone Number & I Get No Kick

Worst: ELF liquid liner. It smells.

Best Gel liner: Its the creme HIP eyeliner. MAC Fluidline is ok but I find it to be a bit tough to work with. The HIP eyeliner is very pigmented and creamy and easy to work with.

NOW: I am wearing my Smashbox Limitless eyeliner in Onyx. The creamiest pencil liner I’ve ever tried.

Worst: covergirl
Best gel: Bobbi brown:They have great colors and long wear!
What Im wearing now: Laura mercier They taught me the “tightline” technique with their cake liner , and with some practice– a lot actually, I am finally good at it- and cant think of doing it any other way, It stays on and doesnt smudge and most importantly, looks natural. Its really THAT good!

Worst eyeliner- Covergirl! Makes my eyes burn and water like crazy
Best getl liner- Stila Smudge pots
Eyeliner Im wearing right now- Urban Decay 24/7 liner in Corrupt

Worst eyeliner-Mufe-it was always breaking and wore off within an hour or wo. On the bright side it was soft.
Best gel eyeliner-I have only tried the maybeline gel eyeliner and I like it, eventually I’ll get my hands on a MAC fluidline, I have heard so many wonderful things about it.
Currently wearing-none however if I am short on time, I wear the Cover Girl black pencil. The gel one is my go-to eyeliner though!

Worst eyeliner: Loreal Natural Kohl Liner…ugh
Best gel liner: Dalton Eyeliner…amazing liner, packaging, mirror, everything…I am doing a review this week on my channel. I was shocked!
Eyeliner I am wearing right now: Mac Fluidline…Peep something…discontinued:)

Worst eyeliner? NYC pencil eyeliner
Best gel eyeliner? Wet’n’Wild Creme Liner
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Nothing, I didn’t have time for that much makeup today.

Worst eyeliner – Elf in ash… It doesn’t show up on me for some reason
Best eyeliner – Tarte Emphaseyes (each form of pencil and the gel are excellent in every color)
Current eyeliner – L’oreal Extra Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner in gray

Worst Eyeliner: Rimmel London Full Color Eye Definer Eyeliner in Sable
Best Gel Liner: Clinique True Black Brush On Creme Liner
Eyeliner I’m Wearing Now: Essence Retractable Eye Pencil in Black Fever

Worst eyeliner?
Smashbox Cream Liner. It just always seems to smear and smudge and get above my crease somehow …

Best gel eyeliner?
I really like Sephora’s Smoky Cream Liner. I was positively surprised by how well it wears and how creamy it was and how smoothly it glides on without tugging the lashline.

Eyeliner you’re wearing now?
Sephora’s 🙂

Worst eyeliner? So many, it’s tragic. The Volturi Cosmetics black eye liner comes to mind first and foremost.
Best gel eyeliner? MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack. Solid black, not sheer at all 🙂 Second fave is Graphblack, great for when I’m not feeling like using a brush! Feline is third fave, but hate that it is limited edition
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Blacktrack 😉

i don’t have a “best eyeliner” …perhaps its because i havent tried gel! i’m planning to pick some up soon…im wearing urband decay 24/7 iner in zero. whic doesnt even last two hours on my waterline! boo.

Worst eyeliner? Bonne belle pencils.
Best gel eyeliner? Mac fluidline.
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? I’m wearing Mac fluidline blacktrack.

Worst Eyeliner: Neutrogena liners are the worst!! there is NO pigmentation
Best Gel Liner: Maybelline Eye Studio…great application, stays put, and doesn’t dry out in the jar
Eyeliner wearing right now: Smolder by MAC

Worst Eyeliner: Not sure

Best Gel Liner: I’ve only used MAC Fluidline. But i love so i feel no need to try any others.

Eyeliner I’m Wearing Right Now: None. I just finish getting ready for bed. But i WAS wearing MAC fluidline in Blitz & Glitz 🙂

Worst- ELF, all gel, liquid and pencil ..seriously
Best cheap liquid liner- Jordana semi permanent eyeliner
Wearing now- not wearing any

Worst eyeliner–Mac Penultimate, any color–when I apply it, it leaves little color specs all around the eye.
Best gel eyeliner–Mac fluidline–Dipdown, a dark, rich chocolate brown
Wearing now–Urban Decay, 24/7 glide on pencils in Rockstar–love all of these.

Worst eyeliner? The Urban Decay Smoke Out Pencils (now discontinued) were the worst – hard as nails and no pigmentation.
Best gel eyeliner? Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner in Espresso

Worst eyeliner: hard candy(forgot name)
Best gel liner: Macs gel liner in black track
Eyeliner im reading out loud: Im using the nyx jumbo eye pencil in pots and pans

Worst eyeliner: MAC liquidlast…its a pain to put on and even worse to get off.
Best eyeliner: MAC fluid line in blitz and glitz
Eyelinder I’m wearing right now: Urban Decay 27/7 in Stash

Worst Eyeliner – clinique cream liner. its probably not the worst but its the one i’ve been most disappointed with. The Bourjois liquid liner flakes really badly too.
Best gel liner – still trying to find it!
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – Clinique cream liner. (I’m trying to persevere with it. pretty sure its smudged up to my crease right now though)

worst eyeliner: any thing that runs and not waterproof
Best gel liner: Maybelline gel
Eyeliner I’m wearing now is: MAC Feline (LOVELOVE)

Worst Eyeliner – Not sure about this.. most pencil eyeliners smudge on my oily lids ):
Best Gel Liner – Definately MAC’s Fluidline in Blacktrack, despite not being as intense as the Bobbi Brown one, it stays put all day!
Eyeliner I’m Wearing Now – Nothing! Time for my bed time hehe ^.^

Worst Eyeliner- Generic 99 cents eyeliner pencil from walgreens
best gel liner- Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Liner
Eyeliner I’m wearing now- UD 24/7 in Zero

Worst Eyeliner: Tie between NYC’s Kohl pencil or Wet and wilds kohl pencils
Best Gel Eyliner: Mac Fluidline Definitely.
Eyeliner Now: Rimmel soft very black kohl pencil(okay not a favorite. i prefer rimmels clean intense kohl pencil for 50 cents more :))

Worst eyeliner: sephora eyeliners. Hate it
Best gel liner: Mac fluidline
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: My chanel Crayon Yeux will hate me because I’m dating with mac feline. For many reasons, I love this kohl.

Worst eyeliner: NYC liquid eyeliner
Best gel liner: Maybelline gel eyeliner
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now: Maybelline unstoppable automatic pencil eyeliner

Worst eyeliner – Malani Liquid Eyeliner
Best gel liner – Sonja Kashuk Gel Liner
Eyeliner I’m wearing right now – Kat Von D Tattoo Liner

Worst eyeliner? revlon luxurious color eyeliner
Best gel eyeliner: mad minerals black cherry
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? gosh velvet touch -metallic brass

Worst eyeliner? Tarte aqua-gel, this one burned my eyes (and made them tear) for 1/2 an hour, even after I took it off!
Best gel eyeliner? the new Physicians Formulas. they wear like iron!
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Urban Decary Zero & MAC Powersurge Kohl

Worst eyeliner? All pencil liners since I can’t wear them on my upper lid b/c of my oil slick eye lids.
Best gel eyeliner? Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Liners
Eyeliner you’re wearing right now? Ben Nye Cake Eyeliner in Black

Best eyeliner Ben Nye cake eyeliner,especially for lower lashline.Dont use anything in waterline,nothing lasts anyway,makes eyes looks smaller.
Best gel MSCHIC eyestain&Lancome ink artliner
Worst? Kryolan,not poor lasting but brown had no colour payoff(?).Now Lumene blueberry liquid,top&low.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!