We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • TarteSale on Sale! Up to 70% off Sale items, ends 10/18.

Get Updates by Email

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

54 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

Skin tone?
Medium

Last product you resisted?
Becca Shimering Skin Perfector Luminous Blush in Tigerlily

Last product you caved on?
Tarte Rainforest of the Sea Skin Twinkle Lighting Palette

Last product you wish you had purchased?
Nars Dual Intensity Eyeshadow in Callisto

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30ish light-medium, warm leaning neutral.
Last product you resisted: Bite Beauty Pepper, Chai, Beetroot, Thistle (One day…)
Last product you caved on: NARS Dominique
Last product you wished you had purchased: KVD Bauhau5/L.U.V. Soon, my pretties!

I have been thinking about NARS Dominique for a long time — how are you liking it? My coloring is a bit lighter and a lot cooler than yours — do you think it would work for someone with lighter, cooler coloring?

Your skin tone/coloring: light to medium warm

Last product you resisted? the new Paula’s Choice Niacinamide Booster

Last product you caved on? MAC Prep + Prime eyeshadow primer

Last product you wished you had purchased? nothing comes to mind at the moment

Your skin tone/coloring: Porcelain
Last product you resisted? MAC Charlotte Olympia Overdressed pigment. I LOVE the little jar with the spiderweb, but the color isn’t something I’d wear often enough to justify the $23 price tag.
Last product you caved on? MAC Night Crawler pencil and I’m glad I did.
Last product you wished you had purchased? maybe MAC Lavender Jade? but now it’s going to be permanent so yay!

(this is a lot of MAC considering I’m not a big MAC fan and don’t own many of their products haha πŸ™‚ )

I’m considering getting a backup since it’s so hard to find a good purple liner that isn’t super red-leaning, and I just saw they marked the price down to $12.25.

NC15
Resisted – 1993 Revolution lipstick. I keep convincing myself that my MAC Spice is close enough.
Caved – Colour Pop Stole the Show, mostly because I got Birthday Boy with it.
Wish I Purchased – I keep wondering if I should have picked up UDs Alice lipstick. The duochrome makes me want it, but when I swatched in store I didn’t think it would look good on me. But now I still want it.

Your skin tone/coloring: medium, warm/neutral undertones, dark eyes
Last product you resisted? ABH Glow Kit in Sun Dipped- now I just have to keep resisting until it sells out!
Last product you caved on? Nars Orgasm- I bought the LE XL from Sephora
Last product you wished you had purchased? I actually can’t think of one that I missed out on that’s no longer available.

Coloring: light, neutral-ish, brown hair, brown eyes.

Resisted: Too Faced Peanut Butter…but that’s not likely to last very long.

Caved: I didn’t end up buying it myself (my fiance ended up buying it as a Mother’s Day gift), but the UD Alice Through the Looking Glass palette. Before that, probably the Too Faced Sweet Peach palette, which I was definitely not going to get until I saw it in person. Not that I regret it.

Wish I’d purchased: KVD Monarch. Still kicking myself over that one.

Idk that monarch was gone. That was my first nude and brown love. Surprised me; Truly great. Would not be surprised to see it reappear with a l/s, like they did before.

Skin tone: medium warm, MAC NC 40 (with my tanning lotion)

I am currently trying to resist the Anastasia summer collection but just until July (I’ve already spent June’s beauty budget)

I caved on Chanel’s Empriente Du Desert Quad

I missed out on an Anastasia single highlight powder in 2015, don’t remember which one it was.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool
Last product you resisted? Becca blushes (though that might just change tonight)
Last product you caved on?/strong> UD Aura highlighter (I really did NOT need another highlighter but….well…)
Last product you wished you had purchased? There are 2 – MAC Subtle Breeze Mineralize Blush from quite a few years back, and Anastasia Self-Made Palette (I would have got both Pink Champagne – which I’ve since bought as a single – and Witchy, which I crave like a mad thing)

Your skin tone/coloring: light and warm
Last product you resisted? A UD Vice Lipstick – I will get some in the near future but I was tempted to grab one on vacation.
Last product you caved on? Kiehl’s Avocado eye cream. I already have a bunch of eye creams but after reading all the positive reviews, I hope it will help with the dehydration that causes fine lines.
Last product you wished you had purchased? Becca x Jaclyn Hill face palette. I know it’s supposed to hit stores tomorrow but I’m not sure I’ll have a chance to go.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair-Light w/ Neutral Undertones
Last product you resisted? Tarte & Graveyard Girl collaboration palette
Last product you caved on? Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette
Last product you wished you had purchased? Jeffree Starr highlighters

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair with neutral undertones; magenta hair; hazel/green eyes.

Last product you resisted? Tarte x Graveyard Girl palette

Last product you caved on? Jeffree Star Beauty Killer Palette (I ordered it this morning).

Last product you wished you had purchased? The Sugar Pill Edward Scissorhands Palette. I know they recently released the colors as singles, but I would have loved to have had the packaging.

Skin Tone – light medium, East Asian
Resisted Product – KVD Thunderstruck
Caved on Product – Mac Fix+ full size (usually I go for travel sized but this stuff is gold)
Wished I purchased – KVD Thunderstruck (one day it will be mine mwahaha)

No kidding on the Fix+. I just bought it on a whim without ever have trying it before this past weekend – it’s a total face changer!

ITA! I was really really surprised with it, as I thought it’d be based mostly on hype just because it was Mac. But it’s not like other misting sprays I’ve tried. It doesn’t just moisten skin, but elevates any foundation or concealer to HG status.

Your skin tone/coloring: NW20

Last product you resisted? Tarte Exposed. I have a few blushes I want to make a bigger dent in before I buy such an expensive one.

Last product you caved on? ColourPop’s Vanity Fair (a dark taupe) eye shadow. My friend was doing a big order so I picked up that shade because I wasn’t paying for shipping.

Last product you wished you had purchased? IT Cosmetics Superhero mascara. It looked soooooo good when I tested it, but the cheaper travel size wasn’t at my Ulta yet. I think I’ll pick it up next time Ulta does a prestige 20% coupon.

*Last product resisted – Still resisting Viseart Boheme Ribbons. I’d love to do some bright pops of color, but can’t justify the $80, and it has too many pinks for me, wish they had included a purple or some bright mattes
*Last product caved – Chanel Empreinte quad, and so glad I did! One of Chanel’s best quads in years, you will fall in love at first swatch
*Last product you wished you had purchased -hmmm, wish I got a back up of Bite Beauty Shiraz, but afraid it would go bad. I had no idea they were DC’ing it, thought it would be re-issued under the new Amuse Bouche formula, but nope!

It’s those pinks in the Viseart palette that I want most! If Viseart ever sells trios, and one contains pinks like in the Ribbons Boheme palette, I’ll buy it in a second!

Your skin tone/coloring:
Last product you resisted? I resisted buying lipsticks from MAC during their 15% off sale!
Last product you caved on? Dior Fluid Stick in 373
Last product you wished you had purchased? Chanel CamΓ©lia de Plumes

Your skintone/coloring: Medium w/ olive undertones MAC NC37-40, deep brunette, teal-green eyes w/ gold flecks.

Last product you resisted: Dr. Dennis Gross Retinol & Ferulic Acid Eye Serum.

Last product you caved on: <strong, Tom Ford Lips & Boys Derek! I only went into Nordstrom for the Chanel Empriente du Desert quad, but then I stopped at the TF counter, just *had to* try on Derek….walked over to Sephora to buy the eye serum, and had an impulse to just get a sample, and run back over to Nordie's for Derek! ?

Last product you wish you had purchased: As much as I love my little tube of TF Derek ( umm, a lot?), I know that I really ought to have bought that Dr. Dennis G. Eye Serum, cuz that stuff is truly amazeballs!

~NW 25.
Resisted: virtually everything these days. T helps me resist and write off. Of the not written off/available: modern renaissance, a big Zoeva haul, Bite summer/non-summer shades, and a growing list of KB, mostly Mizon.
Caved: Chris Chang lavender lip and CCB.
Wished/had: No real regrets, second to TMS (too much stash.)

Your skin tone/coloring: light to medium with yellow undertones, dark brown eyes, black hair
Last product you resisted? Becca x Jaclyn Hill Champagne Collection face palette
Last product you caved on? MAC Brun eyeshadow
Last product you wished you had purchased? Easy one! Tarte Glitzy Lipsurgence when it was $12 on Sephora’s site. Now they’re long gone, along with all my hopes and dreams. Sad face πŸ™ lol

Skin Tone: Very Fair with cool undertones/peach
Last Product Resisted: The entire Becca Jaclyn Hill collab line.
Last Product Caved: I can’t really say I caved and bought it because I hunted for it for months and finally got it about a month ago and that is the KVD Thunderstruck metallic eye shadow. I don’t regret it a bit.
Product I Regret Not Buying: Even though it is permanent I haven’t been able to find it anywhere and lust after it every time I see it mentioned and that is the Tom Ford Honeymoon eye palette. I have signed up for email notification on what seems like 100’s of sites so that if it ever gets restocked I will be notified but I am not holding my breath.

Your skin tone/coloring: between fair and light; cool undertones with warm features
Last product you resisted? I have at least been stretching out my Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche lipstick purchases, but I couldn’t resist Lavender Jam and Taro. I held off on Squid Ink, Thistle, Rhubarb and Spritzer.
Last product you caved on? Sephora Collection Pro Press Full Coverage Complexion and Precision brushes (#66 and #67) — extremely glad I got them, they worked beautifully for applying RCMA cream foundation on my fellow esthetician students’ faces, when I’d had difficulty using other foundation brushes for the task and was reduced to using disposable sponges.
Last product you wished you had purchased? The Fresh Sugar holiday set of mini tinted lip balms. Darn it!

Your skin tone/coloring: NW10, porcelain, green eyes, strawberry blonde currently
Last product you resisted? UD Alice in Wonderland palette
Last product you caved on?/strong> Anastasia Modern Renaissance palette
Last product you wished you had purchased? Too Faced Sweet Peach palette

Your skin tone/coloring: NW13.
Last product you resisted? ABH’s Modern Renaissance palette… Not sure if I’ll be able to keep resisting it haha.
Last product you caved on? ABH’s summer lipgloss set.
Last product you wished you had purchased? I wish I would’ve been able to get some MUG eyeshadows during the BeautyBay sale! By the time I was ready to order most were sold out lol.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, light-neutral
Last product you resisted? NARS Summer 2016 Lip Cover in Do Not Disturb. I did some research here in the swatch gallery and found that my NARS Audacious Lipstick in Annabella was a dupe.
Last product you caved on? Urban Decay Revolution Lipstick. Even though there had been good reviews on the new Vice lipstick formula, I’m a sucker and scooped up three when they went on clearance.
Last product you wished you had purchased? Dermalogica Special Cleansing Gel. I wish I had splurged on my favorite cleanser instead of trying to save money by purchasing an Olay cleanser.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC15 with some redness

Last product you resisted? Don’t remember specifics, but I think it was some impulse-buy stuff at the MAC store. I tend to research stuff to death so I don’t feel like I’m resisting as it either falls into the “definite no” or “definite yes” category. I think the exceptions are pricey things (Guerlain Perles Des Neiges! So pretty but waaaay out of my price range! Still miss that I don’t have it.)

Last product you caved on? NARS Dolce Vita lipgloss. So worth it!

Last product you wished you had purchased? Jo Malone Herb Garden Collection Cologne in Sorrel & Lemon Thyme.

Skin tone: NC45
Last product you resisted?
Becca’s Champagne Pop highlighter! I almost bought it last night but somehow I just closed my laptop and fell asleep. The next morning when I woke up, I saw that the new ABH glow kit was released and I bought it straight away from Beauty Bay! I think I’ll buy champagne pop another time.. ?
Last product you caved on?
Anastasia Beverly Hills’ new glow kit in Sun Dipped, MAC Amorous lipstick and Luxie Beauty’s 5piece kabuki brush set. I’m actually about to order the last two as well; Amorous has been haunting me for weeks since I swatched it in the store ? And I instantly fell in love with the Luxie brushes the second I saw them online (they remind me of Zoeva’s rose gold set but not as expensive) so I want both.
Last product you wished you had purchased?
I wish I had purchased Laura Geller’s Gilded Honey highlighter. It’s still available, but I recently bought something else for the same price and than ended up not liking it!

Skintone?
Fair with neutral undertones

Last product you resisted?
Marc Jacobs lipstick in Slow Burn– I’ve been buying too many lipsticks lately.

Last product you caved on?
Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Ravenswood and Snitch. I’ve been buying too many lipsticks lately! Oh, and I just caved and made my first Colourpop purchase– highlighter in Lunch Money.

Last product you wish you had purchased?
Anastasia Self Made palette. Hoping to find one on Glambot.

Skin Tone: Fair, porcelain
Last Product Resisted: Lorac Pro Metal palette – I love it, but I have dupes for the colours.
Last Product You Caved on: Bareminerals The Scenic Route – I have been eyeing this one off for years and when it was on sale, I knew I just had to have it because of that glorious olive colour.
Last Product You Wished You Had Purchased: Well, I am still waiting for the bareMinerals Soft and Smoky palette to come onto an international shipping retailer so I can purchase it.

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/neutral

Last product you resisted? Kevyn Aucoin Neo Bronzers in Siena and Capri. Kept telling myself that I have quite enough coral and pink blushes and bronzers and highlighters, but damn, I love that gradient! I just got the Bliss gradient blush in Peach Bellini, so hopefully that’ll do me for awhile!

Last product you caved on? NARS lipstick in Jane and Multiple in Hot Sand

Last product you wished you had purchased? Wet n Wild Megaglo highlighters. I’ve heard so many good things about them, but they’re sold out everywhere I’ve checked!

Your skin tone/coloring: fair, warm
Last product you resisted? Viseart Minx palette (so far, I am able to resist.)
Last product you caved on? Guerlain Kiss Kiss in Air Kiss
Last product you wished you had purchased? Mostly I wish I’d stocked up on several favorites before they were discontinued.

Your skin tone/coloring: Light leaning yellow undertone

Last product you resisted? Hourglass Ambient Lighting palette, my oily skin just cannot justify the purchase.

Last product you caved on? Nothing much really, but I did get a whole whole lot of lipsticks (especially Korean ones, they are the master in creating irresistible formulas and packaging) in multiple tones only for the pleasure of having options πŸ™‚

Last product you wished you had purchased? Rosebud Salve in Mocha Rose instead on the original scent. Since my body cannot digest coffee anymore (no idea why!), at least I have the option of having both the scent and the benefit of ultra soft moisturized lips, ha!

Skin tone: fair/cool (NW20ish):

Last product I resisted: I built a super pretty six eyeshadow palette on MAC during their 15% off sale, but then I resisted buying it. Although I really liked the colors, they all seemed unnecessary considering the rest of my collection. How many bronzey peachy browns do I really need?

Last product I caved on: I totally bought an Anastasia 4 eyeshadow palette. There goes my stance against materialism! In my defense I did that BEFORE the MAC sale and some of the new eyeshadows are why I didn’t need the MAC palette. I think I’ll get a lot of use out of these.

Last product I wish I’d purchased: Hard to think of anything, which is probably why I don’t need any more bronzey peachy browns!

Skin tone/ coloring : Light, golden undertones, blonde, hazel eyes
Last product you resisted: Urban Decay Gwen Stefani collection when it went on sale
Last product you caved on Urban Decay Alice Through The Looking Glass palette
Last product you wish you purchased: Kat Von D Monarch and Chrysalis palettes

Your skin tone/coloring: NC15
Last product you resisted? A couple of MAC lipsticks while they were having 15% off..I’ve been buying a few of the new UD Vice lipsticks so I just couldn’t justify it
Last product you caved on? UD Vice lipstick in Wildfire and Crisis..they look so pretty lol. And Marc Jacobs mascara
Last product you wished you had purchased? I honestly can’t really think of anything right off. If I really want something I kind of evaluate whether I’d use it or not and either buy it or don’t. If I chose not to buy it then it was for a reason so I don’t so much regret it.

Your skin tone/coloring: very fair/ yellow undertone

Last product you resisted? The Anastasia Modern Renaissance Palette, but it’s only a matter of time until I give in πŸ˜€

Last product you caved on? The Benefit Cheekathon Palette – I’m glad I did

Last product you wished you had purchased? Mac Dazzleshadows come to mind, but since they soon are going to be permanent I’m guessing I’m off the hook πŸ™‚

Your skin tone/coloring: light (NC/NW15)

Last product you resisted? The “Modern Renaissance” palette by ABH.

Last product you caved on? An order from Kiko. It was buy 3 get 3 free, and I just couldn’t resist buying lip oils and eyeshadow sticks..

Last product you wished you had purchased? The Peanutbutter and Jelly palette from Too Faced. I’m bummed out that I missed that one πŸ™

Skin tone?
Medium

Last product you resisted?
A haul of MUG shadows. Really, aren’t the ones I have close enough? πŸ™‚

Last product you caved on?
IT Celebration Foundation. Still may cave on above. πŸ™‚

Last product you wish you had purchased?
Atelier Cologne Collection Azur – Mandarine Glaciale

UGHHHH THOSE ATELIER COLOGNES ARE TO DIE FOR. THE ONE I WANT IS SOLD OUT BUT GOD HELP MY SOUL AND MY WALLET WHEN THEY ARE BACK IN STOCK.

Your skin tone/coloring: light – NW20
Last product you resisted? Becca x Jaclyn Hill face palette. I don’t need it. I don’t need it. It’s going to be too sparkly. I have plenty of highlighters. I don’t usually like sparkly blushes. Except when I do. Gah.
Last product you caved on? Anastasia Modern Renaissance palette. It’s due to arrive on Sat!
Last product you wished you had purchased? one I’m eyeballing: Drunk Elephant Lala Retro Whipped Cream. It’s quite the struggle to figure out what skin care routine really works and which components work well not only alone but together.

Skin tone: fair, cool
Resisted: Lorac Pro 3, not different enough, but I totally want to complete my set. πŸ™
Last product caved on: tarte tartist lash paint. I’m strictly a drugstore mascara gal, because I never see enough difference for me to justify the price tag, but I sampled this and loved it. I never use a full-size tube completely up, so the guilt is real.
Last product I wish I purchased: So hard. I can think of dozens, but I also have poor self control with makeup so most of what I love I buy. I’m going to go with Nars Matte lip pencil in Walkyrie. I just can’t pull the trigger on it for some reason.

Resisted: Urban Decay blush, the purple one
Caved: Kiko Cosmetics lip marker and their loose mineral shadows (they were on sale).
Wished: Anything from Colourpop, or the limited edition Black Honey eyeshadow palette from Clinique

Your skin tone/coloring: NC42 (medium/dark w/golden undertones)
Last product you resisted? NARS Orgasm LE XL
Last product you caved on? ABH Summer collection (everything except the eyeliner)
Last product you wished you had purchased? KVD Vida Loca Palette. I purchased it last year while it was readily available but changed my mind and returned it. I now regret that I did so.

Your skin tone/coloring:
Pale olive with dark hair and eyes

Last product you resisted?
By Terry sun design palette. I realized I was only drawn to two shades, indifferent to three, and could do without one on both palettes.

Last product you caved on?/strong>
Maybelline Color Jolt lip paint in berry naughty. Surprised to find that the texture was comfy, the smell was faint and tolerable, and my lips don’t react negatively to the formula like it does to 90% of lip products out there but it is not long lasting.

Last product you wished you had purchased?
Nars audacious lipstick in fanny during the beauty.com sale. Would have been a wonderful way to try out the line.

Your skin tone/coloring: dark deep with red undertones
Last product you resisted? anastasia beverly hills sun kissed glow kit ( it think it’s too ashy)
Last product you caved on?/strong> i think it’s couloured raine liquid lipstick ( soul and truffle raine)
Last product you wished you had purchased? modern renaissance palette by abh and i think it will be my next big purchase

If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!