We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

42 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

I’m NC15or20, blue eyes, dark hair
Favorite Liquid Lipstick: NYX Matte Lip Cream
Favorite Highlighter Formula: I prefer powders because for some reason creams and liquids do weird things to my dry skin. The highlight shade in the hourglass ambient palette is my go to because I don’t like a lot of glam highlight
Favorite Eyeliner Formula: I love my liquid smashbox pen but am going to try the kat von d eyeliner next

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair (NC15)
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Still searching…want to try the TooFaced Melted lipsticks!
Favorite highlighter formula? Laura Mercier Matte Radiance Baked Powder in Highlight 01. So not matte, though. 🙂
Favorite eyeliner formula? NARS Larger Than Life

my skin tone is medium
I like hydrating formulas which stays longer 🙂
I do not use highlighter 🙁
Eyeliner which stays longer ,smudge proof and smooth like gel formula

Your skin tone/coloring: Deep/Dark/MAC NW 47
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? I don’t own any
Favorite highlighter formula? The Balm Highlighters in Betty-Loumanizer, Mary-Loumanizer, and Cindy-Loumanizer
Favorite eyeliner formula? Rimmel Gel liner or Wet N Wild Gel Liner.

Your skin tone/coloring: MAC NC 40

Favorite liquid lipstick formula? I haven’t yet indulged in this formula, but from what I have heard Sephora and Bourjois do a great one!

Favorite highlighter formula? ill go with liquid/cream.. easiest! I really like MAC’s Hush cream color base and Benefit’s Sun Beam

Favorite eyeliner formula? Pencil all the way! My favorite is MAC’s pearlglide formula and also kohl’s in Teddy and power surge

Your skin tone/coloring: NW45
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? None
Favorite highlighter formula? Liquid
Favorite eyeliner formula? Liquid and Pencil are tied with Gel following closely

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium, Warmish!
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Guerlain Rouge G L’Extrait and Shiseido Lip Lacquers
Favorite highlighter formula? Not technically a highlighter but Hourglass Ambient Lighting Powder (Incandescent & Luminous Light) + Guerlain Météorites
Favorite eyeliner formula? For liquid: K-Palette Liquid Liner; for gel: 3CE and Sasa; for Pencil: MAC Eye Kohls. 🙂

Skin tone-Light/medium with pink undertones
Favorite liquid lipstick formula-Too faced Melted lipsticks
Favorite highlighter formula-Benefit High Beam
Favorite eyeliner formula-Stila Stay all day liquid

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? not exactly sure…not entirely sure I have “liquid lipsticks” – I do have TooFaced Melted Ruby, OCC Lip Tar – are those “liquid”? I do like OCC NSFW but it’s the colour rather than the formula that I like
Favorite highlighter formula? Powder – just works best for me (I’m not removing my foundation/BB cream trying to blend in a cream product(
Favorite eyeliner formula? No question – pencil! I did recently purchase some Nars Eye Paints and I’m quite liking though, too.

Your skin tone/coloring: NW10/15
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Not a big liquid lipstick fan, but I love the richness and texture of Armani’s Maestro formula.
Favorite highlighter formula? NARS liquid luminators can’t be beat!
Favorite eyeliner formula? For liquid, Urban Decay; pencil, Estee Lauder; gel liner, MAC. I personally prefer liquid liner out of the three of time, but Maybelline’s new kohl is helping me rediscover my love of the softer pencil look.

Your skin tone/coloring: NC 43.5 in MAC
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Loving the Bourjois Rouge Edition Velvet lipsticks. They go on matte and last forever!
Favorite highlighter formula? Powder
Favorite eyeliner formula? Pencil..Love the Sephora Jumbo Liner formula

Skin tone/coloring: Porcelain with cool undertones

Favorite Liquid Lipstick: I’m not a huge fan of liquid lipsticks, but Shiseido Lacquer Gloss is my favorite “hybrid” type formula. It’s the only one that I find hydrating and totally comfortable.

Favorite Highlighter: Benefit Watt’s Up as it is incredibly easy to use (cream-to-powder formula) and subtle.

Favorite Eyeliner: If I’m in a hurry, a gel pencil type (Chantecaille, Clinique Intense, and Laura Mercier are all good). If I have plenty of time, a cake liner with an angled brush is my pick (Chanel is my favorite here, but Clinique is very good as well). If I need something to last forever, Buxom Hold the Line cannot be beat. It outlasts even UD’s 24/7 pencils.

.Skin tone/coloring: Palest porcelain with neutral undertones and a cool lean in eye and hair color.
.Fav Liquid Lipstick: This is tough for me! I’d probably say Lip Tar but I sort of categorize it as its own unique sort of lip pigment product. Maybe KVD’s formula, but I only have three shades all in bolder colors (Outlaw, L.U.V, and Vampira) so I can’t speak to the lighter ones. I’m trying Pretty Zombie Cosmetics liquid lippie in 3 Witches soon and I’m excited for that. The only liquid lippy I dislike that others seem to love are the Stila ones. They don’t dry down on me so they’re just transfer happy and supper slippery on me. Love my liquid lippies.
.Favorite Highlighter Formula: AH! Also, tough! I like different highlighters on different days. If I had to pick, I suppose I’d pick liquid because it’s easy to incorporate into your foundation/primer/tinted moisturizer/etc. But I love me my cream sticks and powders as well. I like NARS Albatross for when I’m feeling super vixen-y and want some sparkle. Otherwise, Kevin Aucoin/Benefit/and a few others make highlighting products I like.
.Toughest questions ever, Christine! Favorite eyeliner formula is impossible. I love gels, liquids, pencils, and powders. They’re all so great for different things! I suppose my favorite liquids are Stila, TheBalm, and Eyeko. My favorite cake powder is Clinique. My favorite gels are NARS and Bobbi Brown. But any eyeshadow is a potential liner for me 🙂 For pencils I tend to favor Stila.

Ditto on the Stila pencil eyeliners… The product is great. If only the packaging didn’t SUCK! They break so easily, not the pencil itself, but the thing that twists the product up (can’t use it if you can’t get the product to come up) and/or the cap (if it breaks, the product dries out in less than a day and it’s game over!)

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20ish

Favorite liquid lipstick formula? I don’t have one, yet. I’m on the hunt, though.

Favorite highlighter formula? Liquids or powders. I love creams, too, but they can sometimes stick to my dry skin in a weird way. Liquids can be really versatile and often times more subtle, but powders are convenient and sit nicely on my skin. My favorite liquid formula is BECCA’s, but
I also love Josie Maran’s. Don’t have a fav powder formula. I prefer the ones that are more refined in texture.

Favorite eyeliner formula? I’m a gel liner kind of woman. MAC Fluidline has been my go to for many years. For some reason, this is the only one that doesn’t smudge onto my lids at all. I’m interested in trying the YSL one now that WWENDY mentioned in another post, though. Never thought to try a YSL liner.

■Your skin tone/coloring: NC20
■Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Stila Liquid Lip Color. So matte. They’re drying, big whoop. NYX Matte Lip Creams feel nice but they’re just not as opaque as I’d like. Giorgio Armani is just not matte enough. I do wanna try the Too Faced Melteds though! I need to visit my local Macy’s.
■Favorite highlighter formula? Well, I finally learned to love my Hourglass Ambient Lighting Powder palette! They’re nice and sheeny, not in your face disco ball. It’s nearly impossible to be heavy handed with them. HG higlighters right there!
■Favorite eyeliner formula? I loved gel but my eyeliner wings faded quite fast thanks to watery eyes/oily lids. So I’ll take liquid, Physicians Formula 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner in Ultra Black, thank you. Holy freaking Grail liquid liner. I’ll never get over it.

Your skin tone/coloring: I’m a NW13 in mac, but at this time of the year I might be a NW15 right 🙂
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Too Faced melted in Melted ruby is pretty great.
Favorite highlighter formula? oh my god, Becca shimmering skin perfector in pearl. YES.
Favorite eyeliner formula? Anything LORAC is just amazing 🙂 or my Irisdescent pink 115 by Shu Uemura

Your skin tone/coloring: Light/medium, warm yellow tones

Favorite liquid lipstick formula? OCC Lip Tars

Favorite highlighter formula? A soft cream that blends beautifully into skin – Edward Bess Afterglow is my HG

Favorite eyeliner formula? Soft, long lasting pencil (that sharpens well), like MAC Pearlglide, Milani Liquid Like and Jordana 12 Hour Made to Last in Black Point (the other colours aren’t so great, but the black is fabulous)

Your skin tone/coloring: NW10 ish (although even that is a bit dark for me)
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? NYX matte cream and the new Revlon Colorstay moisture stains
Favorite highlighter formula? Powders definitely. I’ve never found a cream or liquid highlighter that doesn’t remain tacky.
Favorite eyeliner formula? Gel for winged liner (love the essence one) and pencil for smudgy smoky liner (Rimmel scandaleyes)

Your skin tone/coloring: NC 15/20 sometimes 25 in summer
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? none
Favorite highlighter formula? powder, I use TheBalm MaryLou-Manizer
Favorite eyeliner formula? pencil or retractable love Urban Decay

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium/NW30
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Shiseido Lacquer Rouge, Too Faced Melted Liquid Lipsticks (although I wish they had more colors that are suitable on me!)
Favorite highlighter formula? Mally Beauty Effortless Airbrush Highlighter/theBalm Mary-Lou Manizer/MAC Cosmetics Extra Dimension Skinfinish in Whisper of Gilt
Favorite eyeliner formula? Pencil: NYX Slide On Pencils Liquid: MSH Love Liner Gel: Eyemazing Cosmeline Gel Liner

Your skin tone/coloring: NC 30-40 in MAC depending on time of year
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Shiseido Lacquer Rouge
Favorite highlighter formula? Pupa Milano Luminys Touch
Favorite eyeliner formula? Pupa Milano ,Lancome and Urban Decay

Skin tone- NC 20
Favorite liquid lipstick- Kat Von D Underage is the only liquid one I have, but I really like it.
Favorite highlighter formula- probably powder
Favorite eyeliner formula- gel all the way!

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium Light/Neutral
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Still searching! Looking forward to reading the answers.
Favorite highlighter formula? Also still searching, but I like powder highlighters!
Favorite eyeliner formula? UD 24/7 Pencils and Loreal Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Liner

Your skin tone/coloring: NW45-47
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? I like the MAC Kissable Lip Colors and NYX Soft Matte Lip Cremes
Favorite highlighter formula? Becca Shimmering Skin Perfecter Pressed in Rose Gold
Favorite eyeliner formula? I like gel/cream eye liners

NC 50
Liquid lipstick: OCC lip tars.

Highlighter formula: I like powders and liquid. Sidebar: the Revlon highlighters are actually very good!

Favorite eyeliner formula: old school baby – cake liners and gel liners only. Pencils do absolutely nothing for my oily lids and smudge/fade by mid morning. Including the infamous UD Perversion.

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium with yellow undertones/MAC NC30
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Kat Von D. Everlasting Liquids Lipsticks followed by Stila Stay All Day Liquis Lipsticks
Favorite highlighter formula? Powder one or hybrids like MAC Extradimension formula, actually my favorite!
Favorite eyeliner formula? Also by Stila – Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner

Your skin tone/coloring: Really Pale/MAC NC 15
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? I’ve never tried liquid lipstick!
Favorite highlighter formula? Cream – MAC Cream Colour Base in Pearl
Favorite eyeliner formula? Pencil eyeliner

Your skin tone/coloring: Tan with neutral undertones
Favorite liquid lipstick formula: Revlon Superlustrous
Favorite highlighter formula: TheBalm Mary-Lou Manizer
Favorite eyeliner formula: Stila Stay All Day Felt Tip

Your skin tone/coloring: Porcelain
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Matte. Pretty Zombie Cosmetics and LimeCrime velvetines are my favorites.
Favorite highlighter formula? Pressed powder. Too Faced Candlelight and the one in UD Anarchy face case are my most used.
Favorite eyeliner formula? kohl pencil (MUFE) and cream pencil (UD 24/7)

Also MUFE and Tarina Tarantino cream pencil eye liners.

The new Sephora formula liners are starting to grow on me too!

Coloring: probably tanned up to a NW 30; you can’t help it, when you live at the beach + walk dogs.
Liquid Lipstick: think I’m too old. bought one of the grand KVD reds + my lips wound up 1/2 their normal size + felt like they were shrink wrapped. If OCC matte tars count, they are fine.
Highlighter: powder. HG Incandescent or Nars Albatross.
Eyeliner: straight up pencil. UD or Stila (thanks once again, just starting to fill in the rainbow with those beauties.) because IT’S ALL ABOUT COLOR for me. The black liners are always the longest in the jars. Followed by the browns….

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/cool
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? OCC lip tar (I am partial to Black Dahlia)
Favorite highlighter formula? Nars illuminator
Favorite eyeliner formula? MAC fluidline

Your skin tone/coloring: light med/yellow undertone
Favorite liquid lipstick formula?: matte or creamy just not too shine
Favorite highlighter formula?: liquid and powder I used them both
Favorite eyeliner formula?: pen liquid and pencil

Your skin tone/coloring: cool-neutral vampire

Favorite liquid lipstick formula? I’v never really been much for liquid lipsticks! I couldn’t tell you!

Favorite highlighter formula? Hm, well, I only own one dedicated highlighter, which is Benefit’s High Beam (sample size). However, I do think I would prefer powders somehow…

Favourite eyeliner formula? Urban Decay’s 24/7 liner pencils <3

Your skin tone/coloring: NW15

Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Pretty Zombie liquid lipsticks, but I’ve been dying to try KVD Everlasting

Favorite highlighter formula? I don’t actually own a highlighter, but love to use “Lunar Nights” from the KVD Chrysalis Palette

Favorite eyeliner formula? For liquid, I love Physicians Formula 2-in-1. For pencil, I love UD Perversion.

Skin tone: I am incredibly pale- I need to mix white foundation with the lightest shade of what I use, usually.

Favorite Liquid Lipstick: Does OCC count? I don’t have many high end products, the only pricier products I own in the lip department are OCC lip tar in Rollergirl and Kat Von D’s Everlasting Love Liquid Lipstick in Armageddon. Both are neck in neck, though.

Favorite Highlighter: I haven’t highlighted much, I plan on experimenting with it though!

Favorite Eyeliner Formula: I LOVE NYX’s gel liner. For me, it’s more black than Maybelline’s Eye Studio. Love it!

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair with slight yellow undertone

Favorite liquid lipstick formula? I’ve got some OCC lip tars but I find them tricky to use as they’re a lot less forgiving that a solid lipstick, you have to be so precise with the application.

Favorite highlighter formula? I use a realtively matte MUFE powder for everyday but I like the mineralized MAC highlighters for evening.

Favorite eyeliner formula? Still love MAC fluidlines, I get a neater, more precise line with a slanted brush than I coudl ever manage with a liquid liner and they last all day on me. I do wanna try the new Benefit liner pen tho’.

Your skin tone/coloring: Deep with golden undertones. NC45, UD 9.0, Nars Macao
Favorite liquid lipstick formula? Bourjois Rouge Edition Velvets. They feel moisturizing on the lips, but they’re matte. It’s crazy!
Favorite highlighter formula? Definitely powder; I find creams and liquids hard to blend out before they get splotchy. I like theBalm Betty-Lou Manizer.
Favorite eyeliner formula? A very creamy pencil for convenience, but in terms of look, I prefer gel. Mac Blacktrack is worth the hype.

Your skin tone/colouring: Tan/Asian, MAC NW30-35 for reference
Favourite liquid lipstick: Topshop Lip Paint
Favourite highlighter: Etude House Secret Beam
Favourite eyeliner: L’oreal Perfect Slim Super Liner

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!