Sephora Warm PRO Eyeshadow Palette ($68.00 for 1.12 oz.) is a new, limited edition palette that features 28 shades in a “warm color story.” The new PRO formula is supposed to have “high pigment” and “high performance” with a “smooth and “silky” texture and long-wear. I shared swatches of the Cool palette earlier this morning, and the Editorial palette will be next. This post, however, is all about the Warm palette, which I’ll be testing second and reviewing shortly thereafter!
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
21 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our
comment policy may be
removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to
participate respectfully.
Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an
off-topic question, or need technical support, please
contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above
for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't
answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but
will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when
a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set
expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up
being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Comments on this post are closed.
kjh
Well, at least you don’t see a couple of glitters with seemingly no base shade or binder, like in the cool…. it seems this is filing the void for people who cannot get the ND sunset. Seems overall more drab to me. And dupable. Many people are probably covered by various warm matte or ‘heat’ type palettes. But for smaller stashers, this could potentially expand existing shades exponentially and cover the current color preferences. Not lead footing to S any time soon.
kjh
Oh, $#!+, I guess there is. Filling, not filing.
Hlys
Surprise surprise! This looks better than the cool one ¬¬
These look… OK. I know if you break it down the value per shadow is good, but $68 is $68. I would rather buy something with a little less variety and better quality – and for that amount you could get almost any HE palette or even get into Luxury! I think there are some really nice items that come from Sephora’s house brand, but they are not the most consistent.
Katherine T.
Well, still a few duds, but this one looks much better than the Cool one. Might be ok investment if you don’t have these colors already, use primer, and can catch a sale
Brown Sugar and Peach look like a really bad joke! Oh my goodness, those and Chestnut are plain awful.
Thankfully, I’ve got got ABH Modern Ren, a ton of MAC pro singles in warm neutals and CP Yes, Please on its way. In fact, I think I need a warm neutals intervention. Actually, all neutals intervention!
Jessica
I have it and a wet brush is definitely necessary with Brown Sugar & Peach. They’re really pretty when used with a wet brush. The formula for those two colors are different then the rest of the palette. I like it more than my ABH Mod. Ren. b/c it includes a yellow and a black, plus this one has more options for my skin tone where transition colors are concerned. Overall, I think it’s a really good palette, but it’s definitely not necessary if you already have something like this that you love. Since I do like this more than the ABH Mod. Ren., I’m going to give theABH Mod. Ren. to my younger sister b/c I don’t need both.
Bea
Expensive and patchy looking. I will pass.
Miska
I cannot get past the ridiculous amount of money Sephora is charging…a firm NO here.
This is a palette of hit shimmers and lots of matte misses….far too big, and some duplication of shades. How hard is it to get a matte brown right Sephora?
Mandy
Doesnt look as bad as i thought it might. 68 is just really hard to stomach from the sephora brand. I hope these perform well!
Liz
This palette is amazing. I have nearly every warm palette and this is probably my now my favorite. The quality is excellent, very pigmented. It’s a good value for as many shadows as you get. I’m thrilled it’s a little more money if Sephora will keep producing palettes like this instead of from China. This is made in USA I believe per Sephora Pro account and then cruelty free. I’d rather pay a few bucks more and support makeup that. There are plenty of Inexpensive Chinese palettes around. This has great colors, lots of mattes, which is always tricky to get buttery and pigmented, and these are. This is a don’t miss palette. I don’t mind some kick-up of product here because of the trade off.
Liz
Auto-correct went very wrong here. I was saying this is now my favorite warm palette. And I’d rather pay a little more and support makeup that is made here and cruelty-free.
I totally agree with you Liz! Yes, it is cruelty-free and made it in the USA. So thumbs up to Sephora for that that. I think they did a fantastic job with the palette which I purchased and happy with. If you compare it with the UD Heat palette which is $54 the value is so much better and the color range is definitely better.
Liz
It is an amazing palette to the point I bought a back-up just in case it’s not ever made permanent. I did, though, just get the UD Heat palette and it is amazing as well. Love them both:)
I bought this and haven’t used it yet because I was waiting for swatches…I’m glad only one looks patchy (Brown Sugar). Oat looks a little transparent but since it’s light and I’m fair that will be a nice base for me. I think Peach will work with a wet brush to make it more opaque.
MoMerrell
I got the Heat Palette instead of this one and think I made the right choice. Every single color of HEAT will be used…can’t say the same for this one even though it looks nice.
Betty
I would have preferred a smaller, less expensive palette of hits without the misses.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get
behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback,
product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please
contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Well, at least you don’t see a couple of glitters with seemingly no base shade or binder, like in the cool…. it seems this is filing the void for people who cannot get the ND sunset. Seems overall more drab to me. And dupable. Many people are probably covered by various warm matte or ‘heat’ type palettes. But for smaller stashers, this could potentially expand existing shades exponentially and cover the current color preferences. Not lead footing to S any time soon.
Oh, $#!+, I guess there is. Filling, not filing.
Surprise surprise! This looks better than the cool one ¬¬
These look… OK. I know if you break it down the value per shadow is good, but $68 is $68. I would rather buy something with a little less variety and better quality – and for that amount you could get almost any HE palette or even get into Luxury! I think there are some really nice items that come from Sephora’s house brand, but they are not the most consistent.
Well, still a few duds, but this one looks much better than the Cool one. Might be ok investment if you don’t have these colors already, use primer, and can catch a sale
Brown Sugar and Peach look like a really bad joke! Oh my goodness, those and Chestnut are plain awful.
Thankfully, I’ve got got ABH Modern Ren, a ton of MAC pro singles in warm neutals and CP Yes, Please on its way. In fact, I think I need a warm neutals intervention. Actually, all neutals intervention!
I have it and a wet brush is definitely necessary with Brown Sugar & Peach. They’re really pretty when used with a wet brush. The formula for those two colors are different then the rest of the palette. I like it more than my ABH Mod. Ren. b/c it includes a yellow and a black, plus this one has more options for my skin tone where transition colors are concerned. Overall, I think it’s a really good palette, but it’s definitely not necessary if you already have something like this that you love. Since I do like this more than the ABH Mod. Ren., I’m going to give theABH Mod. Ren. to my younger sister b/c I don’t need both.
Expensive and patchy looking. I will pass.
I cannot get past the ridiculous amount of money Sephora is charging…a firm NO here.
It’s very odd that the formula varies so widely. Odd and frustrating. So, nope.
This is a palette of hit shimmers and lots of matte misses….far too big, and some duplication of shades. How hard is it to get a matte brown right Sephora?
Doesnt look as bad as i thought it might. 68 is just really hard to stomach from the sephora brand. I hope these perform well!
This palette is amazing. I have nearly every warm palette and this is probably my now my favorite. The quality is excellent, very pigmented. It’s a good value for as many shadows as you get. I’m thrilled it’s a little more money if Sephora will keep producing palettes like this instead of from China. This is made in USA I believe per Sephora Pro account and then cruelty free. I’d rather pay a few bucks more and support makeup that. There are plenty of Inexpensive Chinese palettes around. This has great colors, lots of mattes, which is always tricky to get buttery and pigmented, and these are. This is a don’t miss palette. I don’t mind some kick-up of product here because of the trade off.
Auto-correct went very wrong here. I was saying this is now my favorite warm palette. And I’d rather pay a little more and support makeup that is made here and cruelty-free.
I totally agree with you Liz! Yes, it is cruelty-free and made it in the USA. So thumbs up to Sephora for that that. I think they did a fantastic job with the palette which I purchased and happy with. If you compare it with the UD Heat palette which is $54 the value is so much better and the color range is definitely better.
It is an amazing palette to the point I bought a back-up just in case it’s not ever made permanent. I did, though, just get the UD Heat palette and it is amazing as well. Love them both:)
I swatched this and the KVD glimmer palette. I really liked the latter. I don’t know if I am going to get either. I am so indecisive!
I’m not very impressed, especially for a $68 palette.
I bought this and haven’t used it yet because I was waiting for swatches…I’m glad only one looks patchy (Brown Sugar). Oat looks a little transparent but since it’s light and I’m fair that will be a nice base for me. I think Peach will work with a wet brush to make it more opaque.
I got the Heat Palette instead of this one and think I made the right choice. Every single color of HEAT will be used…can’t say the same for this one even though it looks nice.
I would have preferred a smaller, less expensive palette of hits without the misses.