What do you do with makeup you don't like or no longer use?

What do you do with makeup you don’t like or no longer use? Share!

My answer as a regular consumer would be to pass along to friends or donate (it is harder to find a place that will take tested or used products). As a blogger, I do keep products I don’t like personally or don’t expect to wear often (if at all), but some things (MAC products, for example), I keep for future reference/dupes and the like. I usually donate products twice a year (especially hair care, skin care, foundations) and pass on some things (like a used lipstick) to friends/family.

Thanks to reader Johnna for today’s question idea Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Anything I get from a subscription box that I won’t use I sell on ebay.

Anything I use that I don’t like/stop using gets put up for sale/trade in some of the various facebook & LJ trade groups, or sometimes given to a friend I hardly ever return anything if I can help it.

I’d either make it work, repurpose, or pass it on to friends whom I know don’t mind my used make-up (after sanitizing it and everything, of course).

I will return some things, then donate or throw away the rest. None of my friends or family wear much makeup, so I will donate it to Goodwill. I don’t think they can sell used makeup/skincare, but I think their employees will just keep it, so hopefully, it gets re-used, as there is some good brands in there.

makeup I don’t like goes to my little cousin to play with it, for the makeup no longer use I set it on fire with my old stuff as simple as that. I always do a cleanup for the whole vanity & closet at christmas & things that I don’t want I burn immediately to make room for my stockpile & new clothes & makeup. I never threw any old bottle of fragrance ever though.

Generally I either give it away, but if it’s expensive I tough it out. If I just spent $56 on a tube of mascara I am using that up to the last drop!

Mostly hang onto it in the hope I might use it. If it’s something old and yuk I’d throw it away, if it was a more expensive purchase with a decent amount of use left I’d try swapping it on makeupalley.

I either pass along to a friend or just toss. I would never donate a makeup product, especially not something that I have used on my eyes or lips.

That’s a great question! I have a basket full of stuff that I don’t like/use and never can quite figure out what to do with it. Unfortunately most is tested or used a couple times so donating it really isn’t an option. It usually goes to my sister.

If it’s new and I swatched or wore once and don’t like it then I either return it or sell/swap through some groups I’m in on Facebook. If I just don’t wear it anymore and it’s a shadow palette or blush or something that’s easy to sanitize, I’ll do that and swap or sell. If it’s older, I can’t sanitize it, etc I just toss it. I always give someone else a chance to snag it up if possible though.

I usually just return the higher end product but I’m trying to stop doing so as it’s wasteful. I’d rather someone else use it than for it to get tossed out. As far as cheaper stuff, I give it away to my family and friends

I have a friend who is in medical school and a cousin studying to be an engineer. Neither of them work, so whenever I have something higher end that I don’t use much or that doesn’t suit me, I try to give it to either one of them. My bff just recently went through my entire collection and took home a ton of stuff! haha

Powder stuff, brushes, and unused samples I pass along to friends. I’m a packrat so by the time I decide to get rid of a lipstick or cream anything it’s probably past its prime anyway, so I toss it.

If it’s been used a lot, I throw it out. I also throw out mascaras and liquid eyeliners. If isomething is only slightly used, I give it my mom or a friend who doesn’t mind my cooties. Unused, I’ll offer first dibs to family/friends who may want it. Things appropriate for teen girls, I save for last-minute gifts for my sons’ friends (many a lip balm with a handmade cozy backpack clip have saved the day). Right now, I have a bunch of those huge palettes that e.l.f. and Coastal Scents give free with some promotions. I don’t need or use them, so I offered them to my younger son’s drama department. If they can’t take it, I’ll probably donate to a woman’s shelter.

I keep my receipts so I return stuff I don’t like back. Older items I will sanitize and sell on makeup selling websites. Stuff that is harder to sell I’ll just give away to friends.

I usually return everything I don’t like. Right now the only think in my stash I’m not crazy about is the Naked Skin Foundation. I just can’t get over the smell and tingly feeling when I apply it on my skin. I don’t know what to do with it! The box is long gone, so… yeah lol

Depending on the item, how it’s packaged and how much it’s been used, I’ve either passed them on to friends and family or sold them on Facebook. I just took a blush and a powder to the post office — I do love downsizing but unfortunately I love shopping and trying things out even more 🙂

I keep a drawer of all the stuff I don’t use…usually I just throw it away but sometimes my sister will go in there and find stuff she wants so I just give it to her. My little sister who is like 16 is just starting to get into make-up so maybe she’ll take some off my hands soon too.

With lipsticks, I’ll wait until I have a batch of ‘why on earth did I buy that’, then melt them down in the microwave and I then end up with a spot-on colour! Foundations I try to colour up or down to make them colour match my skin, by mixing. A few things I’ll offer for sale for the price of postage on FB beauty sales groups, the rest I put into the charity bags that come through the door and then get picked up from your doorstep. They ask for any makeup. Some things just get put to the back of the drawer until the colours come into fashion again!

I usually throw away products that I didn’t care for or know I will never use again. Occasionally I will keep high end products. I have never shared my used cosmetics with anyone thinking no one would want them?

I rarely have stuff I don’t like or don’t use. If I do I throw it out unless it’s something I know somoene I know can use and is cleanable.

If I’ve used it — even once — I throw it away. If it’s a freebie with an order, or a gift that I’m not interested in, I take it to work and leave it on the break room table with a note “free to good home.”

I used to sell stuff to members of a group I was part of. Now I either return if I can, throw stuff away if it’s cheap and crappy (bad drugstore products), or hoard. I don’t really know anyone who wears much makeup, and I wouldn’t feel comfortable giving a friend a product that I think sucks. If I like a product but don’t use it much, I usually keep it. That’s why I have storage problems…

I do return somethings. But, I try to pass things on to friends or relatives. Some things that haven’t been used I give to a local shelter. Tossing out is the very last resort.

I have two younger sisters who aren’t as picky as me when it comes to make up 😀
So I never feel like I’m wasting money. (Can’t return products from where I’m from).

Things I buy that are higher end I return. Drugstore things I will sometimes return and just keep and pass it on to someone. Stuff from my subscription boxes I don’t like I either trade (or try to trade!) Or sell on ebay.

I’m intrigued and baffled! Where do you live that you can return make-up? In the UK, you can only return make-up within 28 days of purchase AND only if it’s completely sealed and unused.

I hoard it mostly if it’s high end and dump if it’s drug store. Lately I’ve been giving some to my eleven year old to play with. Obviously turning her into a makeup monster like myself lol.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!