Archived Post

MAC Tartan Tale: Comparison Swatches

Florida vs. Her Blooming Cheek vs. Full Fuchsia

MAC Tartan Tale: Comparison Swatches

Here are some comparison swatches for obvious and/or most requested dupes.

  • Her Blooming Cheek: The best dupe would be Azalea, which I don’t own so I’m not able to swatch it. Full Fuchsia is noticeably different in undertone, while Florida is similar but is a touch more purple.
  • My Highland Honey: Utterly Game is a touch darker, Peaches a touch darker as well — but they’re both similar, especially when worn. Melba is too dark.
  • Deepest Wish: A little browner than Media, but very similar to Kittenish.
  • Cut-a-Caper: It’s quite similar to discontinued Funshine, and it’s a little less orange and sheerer than Jazzed.
  • Courting Lilac: Similar to Aristocat, but the latter has more berry to it, while the former is definitely lilac.
  • The Faerie Glen: It’s a sheerer, slightly lighter version of Cherish; not like Freckletone at all.
  • Radiant Jewels: It looks exactly like Creme Allure.

See more swatches!

Utterly Game vs. My Highland Honey vs. Melba vs. Peaches

Media vs. Deepest Wish vs. Kittenish

Funshine vs. Cut-a-Caper vs. Jazzed

Courting Lilac vs. Bubblegum vs. Aristocat

Freckletone vs. The Faerie Glen vs. Cherish

Radiant Jewels vs. Creme Allure


Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Ani_BEE Avatar

I take it back, Full Fuchsia swatched is the shade of the Temptalia Flower. ^_^

Utterly Game didn’t sell out when it was released so I wonder if My Highland Honey will?

Glo Avatar

Hi Christine! I know you mentioned in a separate post that My Highland Honey was a shade lighter than Illamasqua’s Lover. I’m such a visual person so i compared the individual swatches from your blogs and Lover appears pinker and My Highland Honey is more orange/peachy? I don’t know, its probably my laptop resolution. But anyhow, my question to you is, if one has My Highland Honey, do they still need to get Lover or can they skip out? Are they different enough to own both? Thanks so much =)

Holly Avatar

Wow, some of those look identical.
Especially Funshine vs. Cut-a-Caper vs. Jazzed.

That’s embarrasing for MAC AND for all us makeup junkies who rush out to buy these ‘new’ shades.

Thanks Christine.

Erica Avatar

I agree. It’s embarassing to see how similar these colors are. These comparisons are very helpful, and saved me from wasting money on products that are already similar to what I own.

Jenna Avatar

Thanks! This helped a lot! I really wanted to want Highland Honey, but its so similar to Peaches, and I already have that!!

Thank you for doing this post – it was a great idea!

M. Avatar

Thanks for this. Sorry for asking, but do you have plans to do comparisons for the eye shadows too? I really love Semi-precious, Glamora Castle and Enviably Fun but I don’t think I’ll be able to get them soon, and since they are limited I’m afraid that I won’t be able to get them at all..(wow that sounds so much more dramatic than it should)

califabulous Avatar

I am NW43 in MAC and I just bought melba as a better version of my highland honey for my skintone (per the MUA). Melba only showed immediately after application. after 2 hours it was no longer visible on my cheeks! I wish I would have waited for this comparison b/c I would have seen that it wasn’t going to work. I am still in search of a perfect peachy/coral blush for me…any suggestions Christine? if not this post was still very helpful 🙂 I’ll have to stick with pinch me by mac for now…!

Lucie Avatar

I picked up My Highland Honey and Her Blooming cheek the other day…all the lipsticks were out of stock. 🙁

I am LOVING Her Blooming Cheek. To be honest I only got it because it was LE, and was simply going to sell it at a later date should demand pick up. But that crazy fuschia colour was too enticing, and I cracked open the pan. I am not a blush person. I have one pan of Nars Orgasm that I’ve been using for the past three years, and would never try anything that wasn’t on the peachy side of the spectrum.
But Her Blooming Cheek is soooo pretty as long as you use a VERY light touch. This stuff will last forever!
I just dyed my hair neon orange and it offsets the orange nicely, with a touch of Impassioned lipstick. 😀 Great purchase.
Highland Honey is great, looks very natural on fair-but-warm skintones, but I would call it a must. Her Blooming Cheek would probably look better on a variety of skintones than HH.

Sharon M Avatar

Thanks for this, Christine. 🙂 I’d been wondering about Courting Lilac/Aristo-Cat and also Her Blooming Cheek, still intend to pick up the blush but am really on the fence about the lipstick since Aristo-Cat didn’t look as good on me as I’d hoped it would.

ellie Avatar

Thanks Christine for doing these comparison swatches. It’ll definitely help us save some money by not buying same stuff again. I hope you could also do a comparison swatches of full fuchsia lipstick vs. girl about town or impassioned. I own GAT, Show Orchid and Impassioned already do you think i still need full fuchsia? Thanks.

Angel Avatar

Hey Christine!
I missed the Faerie Glen lipstick because it surprisingly sold out at our tiny mall -_-. I’ve heard that Blankety is very close? Is it similar in your opinion?

aradhana Avatar

i can’t believe how similar so many of these swatches are….
though i think if people have different skin tones, some of the shades might have a totally different effect. for example highland honey and peaches look very distinctly different on me!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!