Pat McGrath Guinevere vs. NARS Shirley Comparison

Editor's Comparison

Pat McGrath Guinevere is a warm red with a satin finish that is permanent and retails for $38.00. In comparison, NARS Shirley is a warm red with a cream finish that is permanent and retails for $34.00.

NARS Shirley is 90% similar — it is lighter, cooler.

Community Comparison

• Shirley is Lighter (1)
• Shirley is Brighter (1)
• Shirley is Warmer (1)
• Shirley is Glossier (1)