Best Makeup Organizers | Editor's Most Recommended for 2020

Let’s get into my favorite part: now that you’ve figured out how to go about organizing your makeup collection, how do we go about compartmentalizing everything in an organized fashion?  The best and worst part… storage for your storage! ?

It’s important to have an idea of how many products you own (along with general sizes), and you’ll want to have a rough idea of the dimensions of any drawer or flat surface you’re using.

001

If you have drawers, you want to ensure that the drawer organizers you’ve purchased aren’t going to be too tall or too wide!  You may want to work out how you can fit together multiple organizers together so you can get sizes that work for your products but also the space.

On a budget or want to recycle? You can reuse boxes from online orders or gift sets (often more decorative and sturdier cardboard without being a literal, brown cardboard box).  You can also take the box of many cosmetic items and cut it in half to store it–you can even glue them together to create your own drawer organizer (like for lipstick).  You can use scrapbooking paper or stickers to decorate a lackluster box to better suit your aesthetic!

Best Drawer Organizers for Makeup

I like more freestyle organization systems, as this allows me to adjust the use of any organizer on the fly.  If I have more glosses, I can store them in the same container I might use for eyeliners.

If you’re someone who acquires or declutters infrequently, having a more defined storage system (like an acrylic lipstick organizer) may be perfect.  If you’re a bit unsure, freestyle systems give you more flexibility to learn as you go and figure out how best to organize in a way that’s useful to you.

The Container Store Linus Drawer Organizers ($3.99 to $9.99) are my personal go-to.  I use these everywhere in my home.  I use a combination of the Shallow Drawer Organizers and Deep Drawer Organizers.  My pro-tip: REALLY measure and figure out the sizes you need, and if you need a lot, wait for a coupon for 15% off one item and buy a box of the size you need.

003
My entire palette closet is a mixture of Linus Drawer Organizers (on the right side you can see tons of extra organizers!), plus Clear Storage Boxes (lower shelves).

Here’s a breakdown of the various sizes and what I use them for…

  • 3″ sq. (Shallow) — not recommended for makeup; works well for hair ties, rings, very small things
  • 4″ sq. (Deep) — lipglosss, eyeliners, eyeshadow pencils, cream eyeshadows, lipsticks
  • 3″ x 6″ (Shallow) — eyeliners, liquid eyeliners, lipglosses, lip balms, small compacts (think a MAC/Urban Decay eyeshadow)
  • 6″ sq. (Shallow) — virtually anything! often use these for cream eyeshadows, larger bronzer/blush compacts, lipsticks (stood up), lipglosses (stood up)
  • 6″ sq. (Deep) — same as the shallow version, just taller sides, and I use it similarly, though I often use this size for standing glosses or lipsticks up
  • 4″ x 8″ (Deep) — a taller, slightly wider medium rectangle that is excellent for holding larger compacts, like eyeshadow quads, blushes and bronzers, etc. (MAC MSFs, Chanel quads, Dior quads all fit perfectly in this width); also excellent for lipglosses if you want to stand them up (taller sides)
  • 3″ x 12″ (Shallow) — small compacts (most eyeshadow compacts fit, like Bobbi Brown, MAC, MUFE, UD), smaller blushes (MAC blushes fit, for example), lipsticks (stood up), lipglosses (stood up or lying down with two “sets” lying down with labels facing outward)
  • 4″ x 12″ (Deep) — a longer version of the 4″ x 8″, it just holds more of the same; this is one of the sizes I use most often
  • 6″ x 9″ (Shallow) — again, anything, as it’s a medium rectangle in size; I often use one of these for brands I don’t have a lot of products for, as I can fit an assortment of products together in it
  • 6″ x 12″ (Shallow) — a larger version of 6″ x 9″–just longer–so it fits a slew of things; I use them often for cream and powder eyeshadows
  • 6″ x 15″ (Shallow) — the largest rectangle-shaped drawer available; I don’t use this as it doesn’t fit my system (mine fits 12″ with about 3/4″ to spare)
  • 4″ x 16″ (Deep) — a longer version of the 4″ x 12″ — as it is too long for my system, I don’t have any of these but they would work similarly to the others! Great for larger compacts, blushes, quads, palettes, etc.

Other Favorites:

  • The Container Store Clear Storage Boxes ($1.89 to $21.99) are another personal-go to for all things organizing throughout my home.  I use these for larger items, like skincare and hair care.  I think these are less practical for someone who a few items; I use these for more bulk organizing for something like “100 liquid lipsticks I have to swatch someday” and less for products I want to use one-by-one (like in a vanity).
  • The Container Store Clear Stackable Drawers ($12.99) come in a few sizes, and you can also purchase dividers (the best part about the system).  I like these for how they store product BUT I am not personally enthused over the feel and quality (they just feel very thin and squeak when I pull drawers out).  For The Container Store, I was ho-hum on them, but they are very functional… they’re just far noisier and thinner than anticipated.
  • The Container Store Luxe Acrylic System ($7.99 to $29.99) is a modular system using acrylic pieces, including drawers, open units, and things like lipstick holders (see my review here).
  • byAlegory Makeup Organizers ($9.99 to $22.99) are for those who either have smaller collections where spending $20 on a holder for a dozen lipsticks is acceptable or for someone who has a big budget and wants to go all-in on acrylic organizers.  I find acrylic organizers just get to be very expensive and aren’t as space-efficient for my personal needs (since I have a metric ton) but are gorgeous for those who more edited stashes or aren’t looking to maximize every bit of storage space.  I reviewed their various organizers extensively here.
  • iDesign Onyx Organizers at Ulta ($9.99 to $39.99) — iDesign seems to be the same company that makes a lot of favorites, and if Ulta is more accessible, it might be a good option!

Best Makeup Organizers for Brushes & Eyeliners

First, you’ll want to determine whether you want to keep your brushes covered, protected, or on display.  Some are concerned about dust, while others fear a pet getting hold of a brush!  Others may prefer the convenience of having them reachable on top of a vanity.  What works well for brushes tends to work well for eyeliners, as they have similar length and diameter!

product
Sonia G Wooden Brush Holder

Covered Solutions

There are two major types here:  continuing to use drawer organizers, which allow you to keep your brushes tucked in a drawer (perhaps even a bin with a lid if you want to store on a shelf) or a brush roll, which is designed to hold a myriad of brush shapes and sizes.  The latter is really great for those who travel with their makeup, as it’s a compact, tidy solution and travel-friendly.

You can also try using pencil cases and soft, makeup bags to hold brushes, though I’ve found that this can sometimes result in larger, less-dense brushes getting misshapened.

  • Brush Rolls — pricing varies, and my favorite place to shop for this type of solution would be on Etsy! (If you sew, you could even make your own.)
  • Clochees and Bell Jars — these are domed, glass tops that can be used to protect more open-based solutions — perhaps you don’t mind leaving brushes open when in heavy use but want to keep them protected when on vacation.
  • Glass Canisters with Lids ($9.99 to $19.99) which are often used for food storage can work well to visually see your brushes with the protection offered by the lid–I prefer ones that lift off for ease of use (make sure to measure the length of your longest brush and add some extra to give space; you’ll likely want something wide enough to easily pull a brush out of it, too).
  • MyKitCo. My Brush Buddy ($48.00) has four sections to help divide tools for on-the-go use, and it’s easy to clean.
  • Sephora PRO Brush Caddy ($24.00) works well for at-home (by having it open, you’ll get two “cups” effectively) or travel and stands up well on its own.
  • Sephora PRO Easel ($32.00) has 32 slots for brushes and stands up like an easel. It’s kind of like the makeup lover’s brush binder.
  • Smith Cosmetics Smithfolio ($96.00) is a well-crafted, leather case with three brush plates and a mesh pocket; it’s pretty much the ultimate, more indulgent solution for storing makeup brushes and/or eyeliners on the go.  This is what I typically use for travel (if it’s a longer trip).
organizers030
byAlegory Organizer

Open Solutions

Anything that is cup-shaped effectively can work well as a brush or eyeliner holder/organizer.  This means pencil cups, glassware, barware, toothbrush holders, candle holders, empty candles, vases, mugs, utensil holders…

My recommendation is to find something that allows you to evenly divide brushes by function (e.g. eyes brushes in one holder, face brushes in another) or keep them all in one holder (so go for a wider holder).  It is ideal to have something that has enough height to support the weight and length of multiple brushes, too.

Pro tip:  If you want the fancy glass beads that are often found in brush holders, the only place I’ve found that’s really reliable has been here ($6.99 for 1lb. bag, and I find 1lb. bag works well for two glass tumblers).

Makeup Traincases

A traincase is a larger storage unit that holds everything, opens and expands in place, but then quickly folds back up for easy on-the-go traveling. They’re popular with makeup artists, but I found it essential when I lived in a college dorm and traveled home for the weekend or a holiday break.

Oh, and depending on your aesthetic, a tacklebox (for fishing!) may work just as easily, but with the accessibility of products via the internet, it’s a lot easier to find an array of traincases at lower price points these days.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
Explore Temptalia

We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!

Here are some useful resources for you:

Compare Any Two

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

14 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Leave a Reply

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

I reuse Birchboxes, magazine holders, pencil cups, and gift boxes. This fits the vintage/eclectic aesthetic of my house way better than generic (and expensive) acrylic thingies.

This is so great! Thanks, Christine! I know you do these posts every so often, and I always enjoy them because my collection is pretty large, too! I’m always looking for ways to better store my collection.

LOL! I’m actually thinking I need to reorganize some of my kitchen and bathroom drawers now, too! The Container Store ones are perfect!

I use the sonnycosmetics acrylic containers for my ikea Alex drawers. I’m still struggling to find a way to store foundation and concealers in it though, haven’t been able to find anything that would store mine without taking up a few drawers…for now I’m storing a lot of them on top but would like to organize them inside.

I use CHANEL’s fancy packaging boxes as drawer Organizers all over my house. You can use the base but also the lid.

I need better storage for my brushes and eye liners. I’ll check these out!

I’ve used recycled Sephora Play boxes to hold eye pencils, lip pencils and lip glosses in the past. The holders I’m currently using for my makeup brushes are faux mercury glass candle holders that I bought at Wal-Mart for $3 each a few Christmases ago. They still have them each year, in red or silver. They have a glitter snowflake on one side, but I love winter and Christmas too so it doesn’t bother me. I also have a really nice zip case for brushes from Sigma. I believe I paid about $25 for it, but I was traveling frequently for work and wanted to protect my investment.

For my small, just one of each, collection two drawer trails and two make-up brush jars (one for clean, one for dirty) are enough. I purchased them all from MUJI almost 4 years ago. I recommend the MUJI systems for smaller collections like mine, they have both soft and hard plastic items. Also, don’t overlook their stationary storage solution, some are better than the special make-up ones.

I really like these informative articles Christine. I congratulate you for also promoting cheap sustainable options, like reusing packaging or jars used previously for other things.

Having a clean/dirty holder for brushes is awesome! I have a flat tray for my dirty brushes, otherwise they’ll clutter up the whole vanity top, lol!

lol mine is so DIY. I have an antique flower arrangement holder (flower frog I think it’s called) that I keep my slim brushes in, a large margarita glass for lipsticks, some glasses and tea tins for pencils, a repurposed cute paper jewelry box, and a few Daiso plastic bins.

Thanks so much for this, Christine. Great content, as always! I’m still in the process of majorly reorganizing and decluttering my collection, so I bookmarked this page. I’m ready to move on to lip products and eyeliner pencils, so I may need some more or different organizers.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!