I’ve been loving MAC’s new 24-hour primer lately but my go-to has been NARS Smudge Proof in the past!
— Christine
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
NARS
Yes, I have to agree with you Christine, MAC 24 Hour Extended Eye Base is my daily go to as well. I have only been using it for about 3 months but I really don’t think I’ll go back to my previous eye primers after trying this one. It’s a keeper!
Without a doubt the Wet’n’Wild Fergie primer.
My nephew works for Urban Decay, and I like their regular primer. The anti-aging primer was roo oily for me. I haven’t really tried other primers, but I hear good things about Too Faced. I love everything Nars, but I haven’t tried their primer.
How lucky for you!
Urban Decay’s Original Primer Potion!
Mac paint pots or Milani. I have oily skin and I switch between both primers and my eyeshadow stays all day
For me it has to be the NARS Pro Prime. Nothing I’ve used in the past compares to it! It makes my eye makeup wear like iron even though I have oily lids. I don’t see myself straying from this primer anytime soon. ?
Hard Candy eyes the limit primer. it is super cheap and i love it even more than the Urban Decay. It is an absolute must have
NARS for me! But ooooh, I wanna try the new MAC one now 🙂
Me too. Have to try the new mac.
Same here! Good to know Mac has a good one. 🙂
Too Faced Shadow Insurance works best for me.
I used Urban Decay for years (and I really like the Anti-Aging version) but the Wet n Wild primer was an emergency purchase that’s proven surprisingly solid.
I have discolouration on my lids from eye meds and use Clinique Touch Base in Canvas. Makes a nice even base and seems to hold shadows too. My lids are not oily or very crepey.
Too Faced Shadow Insurance. Urban Decay Primer Potion is a close second.
This would be my exact answer, as well!
Right now I am using Tarte 360 degree Creaseless Primer because it has a slight peachy color which covers slight discoloration on my lids but overall I use it because it doesn’t enhance the crepey skin on my lids as so many primers do. Does it help my eye shadow last longer….hmm, I don’t really think so. If I could find something that worked better for my sagging eye skin I would definitely switch.
All the ones I’ve tried – TFSI, Lorac, Bare Minerals and UDPP have all been super and have done the job but when I really need to know my eyeshadow will last in the hot commercial kitchens at school when the outside temps are in the high 20’s (Celsius) and inside is way worse, I rely on UDPP (I have the original, Sin and Eden). I’m almost finished my Too Face and while I like it a great deal, when I go to replace, I think I really have to try NARS.
Wet ‘n’ Wild Fergie Primer is my favorite primer. Keeps my makeup in tact 12+ hours! And I’ve tried sooo many!
Eyeshadow primer is new to me so I stuck with an affordable one from Milani Cosmetics. I like it better than this E.L.F. primer I’ve been wearing all week, it doesn’t seem to last all day.
TFSI or UDPP. Dk why Nars was not great for me. Tell me, guys, is the standard WNW primer like the Fergie or not?
I just tried the new WnW primer for the first time yesterday, and it’s definitely not the same product though I do still like it. The texture is of the new primer feels thicker and a little stickier than I remember the Fergie primer being. It does just as good of a job giving my eye looks enough longevity to last the day, but it’s not quite as good at making my eye shadows look their most vibrant.
I have two favourite primers: MAC Painterly & The Balm Put a Lid on It
Good choices! Those are my favorites too 🙂
Yay! 😀
I’ve used all the Urban Decay ones (got the samples when I bought the Naked palette), but now I’m using the NARS one. It’s great as a primer and my eye makeup lasts pretty much all day long, provided my watery eye doesn’t act up. For whichever random reason my right eye tends to get very watery* and when that happens the makeup on the inner corner of my eyelid basically melts away. The rest of my eye makeup looks flawless, except for that tiny spot. I’m beginning to suspect my tears are corrosive. Maybe I need to invest in a more powerful eyeshadow primer and/or go to the doctor.
*I’m talking tears running down my face like I’ve opened the water tap and forgot to close it. It will go on and on for hours. It’s very annoying, no least of all because random people – sales assistants, people who’ve stopped me to ask for directions, bus drivers, etc – will always bring it up: ‘Did you know your eye is watery?’ ‘Why are you crying?’ and so on. I’ve got literal tears running down my face, people. I’d have to be dead not to notice.
This is why I don’t wear mascara, by the way. I don’t want to risk a random watery eye attack and end up looking like a racoon. I’m not sure how waterproof mascaras really are, and if they could withstand the power of my tears.
I have a similar issue with my right eye, but outside corner. Google histamine intolerance. Mine also worsens in spring/fall and correlates with allergy seasons.
As strange as this might sound, you might actually have dry eyes, or possibly an allergy of some kind, or even a reaction to heavy pollen in your area. Those things can crop up at any time in life. You need to go see an eye doctor – an opthalmologist, not an optician. I have this same thing in my left eye sometimes even though I use Restasis twice a day, and have since it came out. Both my eyes ran so much before I got on it, that the salt was making my undereye area raw. In the meantime, get some good eye drops like Systane, and Systane Balance when it’s really bad. These are both gentle enough for problem eyes. Won’t entirely fix it, but it’s good moisture. I have Keratoconus in my eyes as well, and these were recommended to me by both my othalmologist and my special contact lens fitter doctor – a womsn who also loves make-up? Hope you get some answers and relief soon.
I use the NYX HD Eyeshadow Base with the doefoot applicator. It works virtually as well as the NARS one for me, but doesn’t sting my eyes like NARS sometimes does.
MAC’s 24-hour primer is the only one I have been using for well over a year now. I used to use NYX’s HD eye primer and it worked really well for me but won’t replace my MAC.
Tarte 360 degree Creaseless Primer. Hands down works the best on me.
My all-time favorite was WnW Fergie Take On The Day eyeshadow primer. Now I’m going to try their new non-Fergie one and hope for the best.
Annnd, I forgot to add “why”!
Because it held up even under 120° of heat, monsoon downpours and thunderstorms, high humidity. Plus, it made almost ANYTHING stick and not migrate much, if ever! Even glitterbomb eyeshadows!
I only have the Urban Decay Primer Potion, and MAC’s Paintpot in Painterly, but I really want to get the NARS one and possibly the TooFaced one asap!
Hi Christine,
I love NARS Smudge-Proof Primer as well and I would love to know your favorite way of applying it and how much you apply.
Love your work! 🙂
I just apply a tiny amount with my fingertip!
I have tried so many of them and they seem to make my lids look wrinkley.Right now I am using Dior. Its OK? Not loving it though. I read that Tom Ford makes an excellent one, so I will keep you all updated after I put it to the test.
I love NARS but hate the doe-foot. I’m curious about MAC’s new primer now! Will you review it?
Still new to eye primers in general, I used to just use cream shadows; however, I really like the Tom Ford one.
Hands down, Wet N Wild Fergie Eye primer. I’ve tried the top 15-20 primers out on the market, and that’s the only one that doesn’t crease on my oily lids.
Thinking I need to try this!
Sadly, the Fergie one got DC’d earlier this year, when the contract with Fergie ended, but WNW re-issued without the Fergie name. I heard the ingredients are supposed to be the same, but there’s various opinions as to whether it works as well as the original. But for like $3-$4, I think it’s worth a try. Hope it works for you
Milani eyeshadow primer or Wet n Wild eyeshadow primer. I need something new to keep glitter shadows in place. I’ve tried Too Faced Glitter Glue, but am still looking. I know Nyx makes a Glitter Glue too
UD primer in the basic normal colour and these Benefit Stay something.
My favorite combo is thebalm put a lid on it with Mac Painterly on top to cover a freckle and give me an even canvas. Sometimes I use my UD anti aging PP. Between palettes, value sets, goodie bags and gwp’s I have so many unopened primers if they stayed good forever I’d never need to buy another one! I wonder how long they stay good unopened? Anyone have an idea?
It’s not really a primer but Duraline by inglot you can’t beat it .
I recently bought the MAC 24-hr Extended eye base and I do like it, but I find it takes trial and error for me to figure out how much to use to avoid creasing (since using TOO much will cause creasing on me). I LOVE the NARS Smudge-Proof and I like the doe-foot applicator because it applies a perfect amount to each lid/brow area, so it’s pretty foolproof.
On my drier lids, UD (except for Eden) and Too Faced work the best. NARS and Tarte come in second. Pixie Epoxy is the only loose pigment/glitter adhesive I’ll use on my lids.
Smashbox 24-hour Eye Primer…it’s the only one that works on my oily lids. The Nars one just didn’t work well.
I do things a bit differently. Or should I say, HEAVILY. I lay down either HD Micro Primer from Kryolan or Perfect Matt (also Kryolan). After this is done, I base the entire eye in stark white cream concealer (Kryolan Dermacolor in 0070 — if you want this to not be so intense, use a cream in your skintone), and set it with M.A.C. Studio Fix Pastels in Shivering White. The end result is very…. white, but also VERY ready for whatever color you plan to layer over it! When I do my makeup like this my eyes are the last thing to come off my face.
TheBalm’s Put A Lid On It works great on my oily lids! I don’t know how I managed without it, I always ended up with my eyeshadow collecting into the creases of my eyelids and just disappearing over a few hours! NYX’s Milk also works well but is a bit more messy to work with.
Hi Christine! Is this the one? http://www.maccosmetics.ch/product/153/33821/Products/Augen/Primer/Prep-Prime-24-Hour-Extend-Eye-Base/index.tmpl
Yes! (http://www.maccosmetics.com/product/13780/33821/Prep-Prime/Eyes/Prep-Prime-24-Hour-Extend-Eye-Base)
Thanks!
Sigma Beauty (all of them) I’m talking supreme awesomeness!!