Star

Natasha Denona Star Mini Eyeshadow Palette ($25.00 for 0.14 oz.) is a new, limited edition palette featuring shades from the Star palette. While the mini eyeshadow palette didn't perform poorly, it wasn't consistent with the shades in the original Star palette, which is permanent, so I'm not sure why there was any inconsistency or why the ingredient lists aren't the same between the two. Most notably, Orion was much, much creamier and deeper in color, while Atik changed in depth and undertone. The other three shades were more similar in color, but Cosmo was a bit lighter depending on how it reflected the light.

If you liked Natasha Denona's shimmer formula in the past because of how cream-like they were, you'll likely be disappointed with this palette as the formula has changed to be denser/firmer with less creaminess (though I do find they wear better than the creamier formula but that's without primer; with primer they're comparable).