Archived Post

Is there anything you collect when it comes to beauty/makeup products?


Is there anything you collect when it comes to beauty/makeup products? Something you have to have? A product you always buy each shade of?

More recently, I did do my best to own all of the shades of Giorgio Armani’s Eyes to Kill Intense line-up, and I’m certain I’ll continue to purchase any additional shades they release.

Thanks to Jenny for today’s question!

Got a question idea? Submit yours here.

86 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Mary Beth Avatar

Red lipstick!!!! If a new shade is released, I cannot rest until I own it. For example, both Lancome & Estee Lauder are coming out with new red lipsticks for fall, and I definitely plan on buying them, even though I already own close to 20 red lipsticks already (from Makeup Forever to Revlon to Sephora to Mac, etc.) 🙂

beth maiorana Avatar

@Mary Beth, I am RIGHT with you on the Red Lipstick “problem”: I must own all of them … Used to collect nail polishes- but now my full attention is red lipsticks …

Shannon Avatar

I collect yellow eyeshadows,starting to collect everything UD eyeshadow,and any shadows with a fairy/magical/mystical theme or name!

Shannon Avatar

I know what you mean! My mom too. It can be the ugliest color,but let it be named the right thing,I cant quit thinking about it!

Jill Avatar

I am the biggest eyeshadow and lipgloss junkie! I own mostly UD eyeshadow including 7 Palettes, 12 token pots of shades not in the palettes I already own, loose shadow and cream shadow. I also have several MAC e/s, and palettes from Stila, Too Faced, Benefit, and Tarte. Lipgloss I own anything from MAC Lipglass, UD Lip Junkie, Victoria’s Secret and several drugstore brands. And it keeps growing!

meme Avatar

Oh yeah…I forgot – I do get a lot of lip balms – always looking for a better one, a better deal on them $ wise vs. the fav high end $ ones.

Gillian (AKA Munchy) Avatar

i like to collect the cardboard packaging that limited edition MAC collections that come out. I am a graphic design student so I like to keep the packages for some inspiration and research

Catherine Avatar

Darker pink blushes – everytime I see a new one I have to buy it. I still have a couple at home that I haven’t used more than once, because I just have so many.

Laura Avatar

NARS eyeshadows (especially the duos) and blushes. I won’t buy a shade I know I would never wear, but if I could even possibly wear it once in the future, I’ll buy it even if I have dupes. I just love NARS, it’s my favorite brand!

ybell Avatar

I completly agree with you. I love all things coral! The color just looks good regardless of whether im tan or not at the moment. I especially love this color because it is harder to find so when I find something in coral I must get it!

Stefani Avatar

I wouldn’t say I really collect anything… but I am on the lookout for somthing to collect. Im thinking I will start collecting MAC msf’s… but Im kind of past MAC. The only thing I might consider a collection is perfume. I must own a vanilla perfume from every brand (=

Aly Avatar

I really really love ALL of the Venomous Villains collection from Mac.. I would’ve bought the whole thing if I was into Mac then): So now I find myself paying a lot more for them on eBay lol..

Ashley Avatar

Light pink and nude lipsticks from MAC, and NYX pearlmania eyeshadows…for some reason 🙂 They’re cute and little and not expensive, and very pretty.

Mel Avatar

Eyeshadow. I have not even put a dent in my stash but I continue to buy more. If I see a pretty palette by UD or KVD or something movie or TV themed that I like,, or sadly enough if I just like the name of it, I’ll buy it.

Maureen Avatar

I’m currently trying to ‘collect’ the Tokidoki eyeliners. All the Brillante liners are on sale, and the Perfetto ones are basically going on sale one at a time.

Anitacska Avatar

Ugh, too many things. As you know I love everything mineralize/baked, Guerlain Meteorites, I also collect pretty powders (not collect on purpose, just can’t resist buying them, lol). I love Urban Decay palettes, although I don’t have all of them, and also Guerlain lipsticks, Rouge Gs, Kiss Kiss lipsticks and the new Automatiques range. Like I said, too many things, lol.

Mariella Avatar

Nope! I just buy what I like. I have never bought an entire collection or line of anything – I pick and choose what appeals to me. I suppose if MAC or Tarte or any company launched a collection based on something I really liked – the Avengers (Diana Rigg version) or Spooks/MI5 – I might consider buying the whole thing but even then, I doubt I would. I do still have ALL my Beatle bubblegum cards from when I was in grade 5 or 6, but that’s about the last thing I collected obsessively.

Krista Avatar

Whenever I find a couple of products from a brand that I like, I try to collect a whole makeup routine’s worth of products–foundation down to lipstick. It’s really annoying since whenever I try to collect the rest of the products, there’ll be one or two that I’m not much a fan of but would still be forced to buy. Last time I did it was with ELF because I enjoyed their mascara, blush, and one of their lipstains. Now I have the whole line plus all the brushes. 🙁

Renske Avatar

I don’t really collect make-up. I am really into eyeshadow though. I have a ton of different brands, shades and finishes. Sometimes I just cannot resist. And I am getting into nailpolish as well. Love all the pretty colours brands like China Glaze and Color Club come out with.

J12003 Avatar

This isn’t really makeup but I consider it beauty… I collect the Harajuku Lovers Perfumes. I absolutely LOVE the bottles. The perfume itself could smell like pickle juice and I would still buy the collections. As far as makeup goes I am a complete and total sucker for purple eyeshadow. I own over 50 different purple eyeshadows… and I continue to purchase purple eyeshadow to add to my collection!

Rachael Avatar

I’ve started collecting Guerlain. The packaging is splendid and of course the products are as well. I haven’t invested in meteorites or foundation yet. Yet being the key word. 🙂

L Avatar

Definitely nail polish. If I see a shade I sort of want and end up not buying it, I feel sick and empty until I do. It’s like a disease.

MAChostage Avatar

Sadly, I understand this, haha! I do limit myself, however, and try not to buy what I consider to be *expensive* polishes ($10+). I have only purchased one like that twice in my life and I seriously questioned the purchase after the fact each time. Bought 6 bottles of China Glaze on clearance for $1 each just today and it felt like Christmas to me!

Jet Avatar

I have the hugest freaking collection of red eyeshadows and I keep buying more, especially when they’re true red. A lot of them are very similar but it doesn’t stop me, haha.

Jasmine Avatar

I used to love collecting lip products! From lip balms, chapstick, lip gloss, lip stains, and lipsticks! I have a whole small Sterilite drawer of them! But recently, I’ve done a 180 turn, and now I hate lip products! I decided that I will pare down my collection. I guess you could say I’m doing a project pan. I just feel like I have too much 🙁

monique Avatar

deborah lippman polishes! as well as special packaged lipglasses from mac, i just need to have one color from a collection, i love seeing all the different variations of the classic lipglass tube.

Amy Avatar

I own quite a bit of perfume, I always buy ones I like but then I tend to only wear 3 of the 20 scents I own… so i should really stop buying perfume haha.
But my major obsession for collecting is Nail Polish!! Especially OPI Nail Polish! I love all the colors!! Every time a new collection comes out I practically buy every shade! I’m at about 130 shades now.

Líria Avatar

mm, probaby blushes with cute designs. mac msfs too… but I don’t have the ones I dont think are worth it. And mac eyeshadows too – except the lustre ones, those crappy things drive me crazy with their fallout!

Joslyn Avatar

For me it’s lipsticks and blue eyeshadows. Blue is my favorite color and I tend to gravitate towards deep or electric blue shades.

Jessica Avatar

I used to collect the Victoria’s secret body spray line. I had every one of them at one point, and then I had so many, there was no place to put them all when I moved, so I put them all out at a yard sale and gave away the extras. now I try to be more careful when I start getting into a brand. I try to keep it to where I won’t buy new things until what I have is nearing the bottom of the bottle lol… it’s sad how much money I wasted on things I never even got to use… lol

Lily Avatar

i have a ridiculous amount of bath and body works products….. like over 40 perfumes and 25 lotions…oh and some shower gel…and candles….and 24 tubes of their lipgloss….this is pathetic xD

Aud Max, R.N. Avatar

Yes, everytime a new collection of Givenchy, Armani and Mac comes out with new blushes, shadows, shimmer and highlighters I have to buy them. I am a real junkie when it comes to cosmetics. All my friends come or call me including my daughters when they need makeup. Can’t wait
till all the new fall collections are out. I love it.

MakeupbyThess Avatar

I don’t really. I rarely find a line of a product were I like every singe colour. If I like a product I’ll propably by a few of them but only if I know I will actully get use out of them. I’ve learned over the years hehe =)

Katie Avatar

I am fighting (a losing?) battle against collecting blushes. I love the colors and how they look on and they are so easy to wear. My current wants are the latest Chanel, a soft pink one that I can’t spell the name of, a YSL , actually make that 2, and a couple from clarins latest line – I think the battle is lost 🙂

Deb Avatar

Yes, lip gloss and lip balm! I collect a number of brands and series, but the one I’ve been collecting for the longest and most anal about are Bonne Bell Lip Smackers. Close to 400 and counting 😀

meme Avatar

I also am not a horder – I like to keep my stuff so I can find what is stuff I want to use vs. have stuff lost…so I thin my stuff out all the time. But I do have a huge stash of nail polishes. Now that I see what some (if they were unused) go for on the 2nd market – makes me never want to part with any unless they are shades I won’t ever wear or dupes.

Kathrina Avatar

I’m a huge lipstick collector. My favs are MAC lipsticks, Guerlain Rouge G and, thanks to Temptalia, I’ve discovered the wonderfull Bobbi Brown Rich Lipcolor series. I never had a single Bobbi Brown product before.

I also have quite a big bunch of MAC fluidlines.

Meg Avatar

Lately I’m obsessed with collecting all the permamanent shadows from MAC and also like to collect powder blushes (especially corals and bright pinks)

Ayzee Avatar

I’m crazy about Urban Decay palettes. I really don’t mind the repeat shades. Right now I have 10 UD palettes.. and I’m just waiting for the 15th Anniversary palette to arrive. Haha! 😀

Natalie Avatar

I seem to collect all of MAC’s blushes and MSFs, and to a lesser extent their eyeshadows. I’m not sure when it happened, I just know it did somewhere along the line! The MSFs have their own drawer in my vanity, and almost every blush I own is in a palette.

Jocelyn Avatar

I collect pinky/nude/beige lipsticks and lipglosses. I am constantly on the search for the perfect “better than my lips pink nude beige” color. I tend to go more towards the neutral to cool pinky nudes. If it gets too warm or coral it doesn’t look good on my fair pink skin. I love NARS lip gloss in Chihuahua and Belize. MAC’s lipstick in Hue, Angel, Hug Me, Kinda Sexy and Faux. MAC’s Plush Glass in Ample Pink and Big Baby. NYX’s Mega Shine Lip Gloss in Sweetheart!

Chelsea Avatar

Last fall I tried to collect mascaras, but I had to stop because my mom forbade me to buy anymore mascaras until I used up my others. I can’t wait until they expire. So all of them I’ve had for almost a year.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!