Natasha Denona Star Palette
Natasha Denona Star Palette ($169.00 for 1.44 oz.) includes 18 full-size eyeshadows in a variety of finishes and hues. Here are swatches…
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Those metallics and duochromes look divine, but no way I’m dropping this amount of cash on a single palette… especially when brand reviews are so mixed! At least it’s at Sephora now for the VIB sale.
Anxiously awaiting your review of this palette. I do not own in products in this brand and am curious if this is worth its price tag. It may contain many shadows, but how versatile and usable are they? In my experience, 1 shadow out of each quad I own does not see pan ever so I don’t know how I would do with a palette of 18. (I am guessing 6)
Woah, those shimmery shades look amazing! Some of the mattes look pretty bad though, oops…
These swatches are beautiful.I can’t wait to get mine!!
will be disappointed I am. I have cheaper palettes that are much better for example the Anastasia palettes (the last two were much better than this) Modern R and Master Palette by M are way better and they were cheaper in price. Wait until you get yours. I don’t trust finger swatches anymore they may show one thing but when you use the brush it’s another story!
I love my mr palette but after two months I’ve hit pan on a major color and I’m bummed at how expensive but little product
Some of these shadows look amazing but at $215 here in The Great White North, I’ll be hoping that I have multiple dupes for the shades I like best. Electra looks dreadful AND it’s a shade I don’t wear (and there are a few others in that category of “not flattering on me” colours) so I’ll be keeping my fingers crossed for dupes (and saving my loonies and twonies for the Estee Edit palette(s)!)
I cant wait for your review of it! Im thinking of buying it, but i need your review first.
WOW – save for Electra and Phoenix, the swatches are stunning!
Love the colours, but the pricepoint is eyewateringly painful …
This swatches much better than past ND palettes. There’s a few weak ones here, but everything else looks decent to great, but I’m not paying $170 for a palette, so will be looking for dupes for Spectrum and Cosmo.
YIKES. For such a pricy palette, there should absolutely be zero misses as horrific as whatever is happening with Electra. Earth is also pretty bad and Phoenix underperforms, but Electra alone is enough to turn me off this palette forever.
Oh man, these are mostly stunners! I see one that if sold as a single, I will buy: Spectrum. What a mind blowing shade of almost duochrome khaki-bronze! But, her reds fall VERY short of ABH Mod Ren. If fact, I’d say that if one has MR, they do NOT need this. Ahh, Spectrum and Cosmo, though.
While I am not opposed to dropping some cash for high end makeup I have zero desire to purchase anything from this line. I like the color story here but $170 for a palette? Not when Anastasia has colors and quality at over half the price. I think I will pass.
Spectrum is the only one calling my name here. Looking forward to your dupes!
Thank you so much for swatching this before the sephora sale! I so so so appreciate it. Definitely not worth the money for me, it’s all much too warm for my tastes. Gonna stick with a viseart palette and another of her cool toned 5-pans. You are a life saver, Christine.
Orion looks pretty!
Spectrum is such a gorgeous color. I would consider getting that one in a single, but I remember that her shimmer shades crease a lot? I have a lot of issues with creasing. Aside from that, there are a lot of pretty colors here, but I have no desire to pay that much money for an eyeshadow palette.
I’ve heard this brand has fantastic matte eyeshadows and I was impressed with the swatches until I got to Electra – yikes! A few of the others have a little too much chunky glitter action going on for my taste. Thankfully I’m not longing to own one of these palettes. I definitely couldn’t afford it.
Considering the size of the pan, the price per gram of product is not so bad. But do I want such big pan though? No. I enjoy discovering new formulas and colours and I don’t like being pushed into buying my eyeshadows in bulk when they come in a palette.
At this price tag you really got to love all the colours and be sure to not let the palette rot in a drawer!
The palette would hold twice as less product and be at 80 dollars… I could eventually consider buying it if it reviewed good.
hmm not a fan of these colours, or that price tag haha. gonna look at the review just to find a dupe for Diadem. also this Natasha lady is just a bit shady (and rude) according to The Fancy Face on YouTube.
I’ve already ordered it. I absolutely adore the other two large ND palettes that I have, and I am really excited that this one has more mattes.
Some of the duochromes & one or two of the metallics look really nice but the rest did not impress me at all. So far the YouTube review I saw did not give it a high score at all for the money it was a total disappointment.
Wow !!! Love this palette , too bad I can probably find close dupes for all the shades at half the price this palette costs ! Most of which I’m sure I already have in my collection
I think this palette could have been smaller, 12 pans at the most, and more selective.
Is it really necessary to include 2 reds in a palette? And a few other colors look similar
or in the same color family as well (at first glance). That way it would be a more affordable price for most and more useful for all.
That’s a great point – there are a few shades that look a bit too similar to each other.
Very pretty, but not really my shades and I wouldn’t spend this money on it. All the shimmers seem good, but a couple of the mattes are a tad patchy. Time will tell.
Yawnnnnnnnnn… So boring
What a stunning palette! Only the price itself is a little bit out of range for something this size!
I like it, but agree that for so much money they all should be perfect. I have a 5 pan purple Natasha Denona palette that I love. Super pigmented and last all day. I’m gonna get something from this brand during Sephora VIB. Might get the 28 pan greeneye shadow palette.
Rhea is screaming my name!!! Thank goddess for Beautylish w/their Flex-Pay thing! This baby is a comin’ tomorrow & I can’t wait!! $56.33 a month for 2 more months isn’t bad. Plus I love her metallics and heard that her new matte formula is amazing. Not too thrilled about the crystal formula, but it’s all good. The pans are huge and I LOVE the way she does these big palettes…although I don’t believe these are removable like in the Green-Brown & Purple-Blue….
Wow, this looks beautiful, but no water will I spend that much for a single palette.
I see some under-performers. Which at this, astronomical, price level is unacceptable.
I saw a review where there was much fallout with the glittery shades, and praise for an improved formula. It feels as though this brand is still in the growing stages where eyeshadow is concerned. I don’t feel drawn to the brand at this time.
I like this one a lot! Very steep though for shadow. But I’ve wanted a ND for a long time. I’m considering this one as a little gift to myself for Christmas? Is she still only on Beautylish?
Some items are on Sephora now!
I love those shiny ones, but at $167 there’s no chance I’m going to be buying this
I bit the bullet and bought this palette… $169 is a lot for a palette, but that is why I love Beautylish! 🙂
Pretty, but too spendy for what it is, IMHO.