Friday, October 16th, 2009

Temptalia Asks You

Do you let others play with your makeup stash? Or do you say, “Hands off!”

Temptalia's Answer.

Personally, no, not really. I’ll show them where it’s at, but I prefer not to have people to touch it… and if I let anyone play, I have to be there to supervise!


Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

45 thoughts on “Temptalia Asks You – Do you let others play with your makeup stash?

  1. Christina

    No. I used to let my friends swatch my makeup, but I realized just how incredibly unsanitary that is.

  2. Dorie

    No, not normally. But I do like giving my friends makeovers, and so I do use some of my stuff on them. However, would I let them go all willy-nilly with things such as my foundation, eyeliner or mascara? Hell to the NO!

  3. I don’t let anyone else use my make up, but then again, I don’t think any of my friends are that interested, seeing how most of them are guys. :p But still, I wouldn’t let anyone use it, I’m very protective of my stash! ^^

  4. Alexis

    I only let people closest to me play – so only my sisters get to try out my stuff. They use their own brushes of course!

  5. Elle

    Nah. I’m a germaphobe when it comes to makeup. It’s all mine. :)

  6. Kristina

    No,I’m not 13 anymore. We play at Holt Renfrew now, my makeup aren’t testers.

  7. Becca

    I have one friend that I will let play but mostly b/c she’s just become addicted to MAC and is still trying everything and deciding what to purchase. I also let my mom & sister “play” in it but none of them are allowed to touch unless I’m there to assist. haha My husband says I’m a little psychotic about it but I seriously have a LOT invested into it….

  8. AYHM

    NO WAY! I do let friends and family admire my stash because I think it’s pretty nice and really cool and when they see something they like I encourage them to buy for thier personal enjoyment.

  9. Michelle

    I have sensitive skin and eyes…so I just can’t imagine having tons of fingers and/or brushes playing in my makeup. Just…yuck!!

  10. Nicole13

    Luckily none of my friends are into makeup like me….because I think I would be a “hands off” kinda person. Now I have done up my friend eyes before but that was one time.

  11. Akia

    Play with? No. But I do let my 3 close friends and my sister use some of my stuff if they wish… which is not very often. I’m the resident makeup person when we’re going out, which can be very annoying, so I’ve learned to only bring what I’m using for myself when I’m getting dressed somewhere other than home.

  12. Bunny

    No, germs! Also, before I was a germaphobe they would ask if they could have things and I would lose parts of my stash to their looting.

  13. Paige

    My sister uses my makeup but I make her leave out whatever she uses so I can sanitize it later.

  14. Yeah… my friends aren’t into makeup. :( So no one really cares to play with my collection. If they asked though, it’d probably be a no. lol

  15. A

    I am a big germaphobe! Occasionally I’ll do makeup for my friends, but I am very careful about not contaminating my stuff.

  16. Anitacska

    No, mostly because noone ever asks, but also, I don’t think it’s appropriate. When my daughters (who are 8 and 5) are older I might let them use my small collection on drugstore make up, but not my high end stuff! :)

  17. Rengirl

    I keep the makeup I tried and didn’t like (will never use again) stashed in an old caboodle container and let my little girls play with that (they usually get excited about makeup when they see me putting it on). Other than that (and the occasional pedicure sessions with my daughter), no one touches my stash but me.

  18. Marina



  19. Hinahon

    No… I’m kinda THE make up girl of the family
    I mean one day I went to MAC with my sister (she’s 9 and half years older than me) and she was there pointing at jars of pigments and being “What do you use them for?” So it was so funny explaining her about everything while the MAC MUA was watching us lol

  20. amy

    Yes, I don’t mind too much because it is all in good fun. I only have only really good friend who is as big of a beauty addict as me, so it is really only her I would like rummage through my stash and play and test out my stuff.

  21. Nicci

    They can look for the most part. I don’t care about lotion, they can test that but other items I prefer not.

  22. Definitely not. I’m a bit of a germaphobe and prefer not to have others use my goodies. I don’t mind using my stash on others when I’m using it on them. Then I can make sure that it hasn’t been mucked around with.

  23. nope…sure wouldn’t

  24. Susie

    I let my sisters grab whatever they need as long as they simply put it back where they found it. no need to cry over bottomless pit of pigments, can’t use it all up myself so might as well share the wealth =)

  25. Sass

    Nobody touches my makeup. Nobody.

  26. Cherie

    Oh, gaaaaawwwwwd NO! I show people but that’s it! :) Perhaps it’s my Virgo-only-child coming out. hehe

  27. xKiKix

    nope, i’m pretty much a “no-go” person when it comes to my makeup collection. i even have to supervise my friends when they go through my makeup bag, lol.

  28. Melissa

    No one is allowed to play with my makeup! Way too much cash invested haha but I do offer makeovers on ocassion and will offer advice or color suggestions based on what I have

  29. Ruth

    NOT A CHANCE IN H-E-L-L !!!!!!!!!!!!

  30. Bridgette

    Only my sister gets to touch the stash and thats it!

  31. AndreaMarie

    NOOOOOOOOOO!!! No one. Nadie. Nada.

  32. Tattoo Girl

    Oh no!! I have two carts. One is mine and one is for when I do a job. The only person I’ve even let open one of the drawers on the cart was my mom!! My personal makeup never gets touched except by me!! The other cart.. I might let someone look at it but not touch it!!

  33. Never ever. I have a make up bag when I´m working as a MUA but with my personal stuff? Not a chance! Occasionally, I give away things to my family and friends, but mostly samples and NIB products.

  34. Miss_M

    God no !!

    I’m pretty OCD when it comes to other people touching my stuff. I keep all my make-up, skincare and fragrances nice and tidy (and in their original packaging) in boxes and carts in my bedroom and no one is allowed in there besides me.

  35. Nobody plays with my makeup stash, but not because I won’t let anyone play with it, but because no one I know is interested in makeup. Most of my friends just use eyeliner and mascara.

  36. I don’t mind sharing my makeup but I have to be the one applying it, haha ;D I don’t like to have other people play with my makeup!
    Of course, it depends on who it is. Some of my friends are allowed to touch, but only because I’m sure they know how to use the products properly and in a sanitary way, haha 😉

  37. Cherokee

    My niece is an up and coming makeup artist so I allow her to use me as a model using my makeup. Other than that, NO. I am more into makeup than my friends. If they want makeup, I take them out shopping and swatching.

  38. Eyeris

    Just my little sister cus she loves make up like me and cant afford to buy it but other than that ….HELL no it irritates me….

  39. Jannie

    Yeah to be nice, but I rather not -_-

  40. Candoo

    No one else in my fam or my friends likes makeup as much as I do, so I never have to worry about anyone touching my stuff.

  41. Karli

    All my friends love playing with my makeup stash, but I hate when people touch my stuff. If I let people play, its one at a time and I’m right over their shoulder the entire time. My stash is far too precious too me to let anything walk away in someone’s pocket.

    I’m a bit obsessive.

  42. Rosie

    My sister was home this weekend and asked if I had purple e/s so I let her borrow the two newest UD deluxe shadows. Later I find that she’s taken my Book of Shadows Vol. II as well and a NYX shadow and that she took them out with her. I was pretty upset and tried to politely tell her that if she wants to be able to use my makeup in the future she must return it and never leave the house with it. But before this weekend, no I do not let people touch my stuff.

  43. Rarely! I’m afraid someone will break it or walk away with it :(