Wednesday, May 25th, 2011

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Bora Bora, Rock Candy, Electric, Sequins, Royal

Stila Sparkle Liquid Eyeliners

Stila Sparkle Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner ($22.00 for 0.05 oz.) is available in eight shades: Bora Bora (sparkling turquoise), Rock Candy (sparkling warm brown), Electric (sparkling bright green), Sequins (sparkling black), Royal (sparkling electric purple), Flash (sparkling olive khaki), Starry (sparkling gunmetal gray), and Curacao (sparkling violet blue). I do not have Curacao, so unfortunately, it is not included in this post.

  • Bora Bora is a bright, electric blue with soft silver sparkle. Make Up For Ever #5 Aqua Liner seems similar–possibly a little darker.
  • Rock Candy is a medium-dark brown with khaki, bronze, and gold shimmer.
  • Electric is a bluish teal with brighter blue shimmer. Make Up For Ever #4 Aqua Liner seems similar.
  • Sequins is a dark black with silver sparkle.
  • Royal is a medium-dark red-toned purple with violet and magenta sparkle. This was the least pigmented shade out of the seven I tried–it wasn’t as dense as the others, a little watery in the overall feel.
  • Flash is a olive green with gold and green sparkle.
  • Starry is a grayish mauve with multi-colored shimmer. I don’t get gunmetal gray at all here. It seems like it might be similar to Make Up For Ever #14 but it’s harder to call without a side-by-side swatch.

Stila’s Sparkle Eyeliners apply smoothly and evenly with excellent color payoff that requires no layering or build-up. I showed swatches of the very first stroke, then a second and third–never going back to get more product. The sponge applicator on these is thin and tapered to a dull point with enough give to easily maneuver around the curves of the lid but not so much that it is floppy. The formula is budge-, smudge-, and water-proof, as advertised, and removal went easily with both Lancome Bi-Facil and Make Up For Ever Sens’Eyes. As you remove, the product will flake off, akin to tube mascaras.

When I reviewed Make Up For Ever Aqua Liners, I touched on some of the recent releases of eyeliners in the same vein as those, which included Stila’s Sparkle Eyeliners, too. Stila’s are different from the others in terms of color and finish–these are richly shimmered and very pigmented, but the formula feels very much the same. In the next few days, I will be doing some swatch comparisons where applicable and posting the results.

The Glossover

stilaSparkle

Stila Sparkle Liquid Eyeliners Swatches, Photos, Reviews

A
For those who love sparkly eyeliner and are on the hunt for something in liquid form, Stila's Sparkle Eyeliners offer a great solution. The formula is fantastic, and the color range has good variety and a few never-before-seen shades in this kind of formula.

Product

10/10

Pigmentation

9/10

Texture

10/10

Longevity

10/10

Application

4/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Login or Register to be able to add this to your Vanity or Wishlist! Plus rate and review!

See more photos & swatches!

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Bora Bora, Rock Candy, Electric, Sequins, Royal

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Bora Bora, Rock Candy, Electric, Sequins, Royal

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Stila Bora Bora Sparkle Eyeliner

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Stila Rock Candy Sparkle Eyeliner

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Stila Electric Sparkle Eyeliner

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Stila Sequins Sparkle Eyeliner

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Stila Royal Sparkle Eyeliner

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Stila Starry Sparkle Eyeliner

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Stila Flash Sparkle Eyeliner

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Bora Bora, Rock Candy

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Electric, Sequins

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Sequins, Royal

Stila Sparkle Eyeliner
Flash, Starry

Product & Review FAQ

Where can I purchase Sparkle Eyeliner? How much is it?

<Sephora, $22.

Is it limited edition?

No.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

33 thoughts on “Stila Sparkle Liquid Eyeliners Swatches, Photos, Reviews

  1. Starry is beautiful and I love how green Flash is. Will definitely check these out next time I’m in Sephora.

  2. These look spectacular in your swatches. And your photography skills are impressive!

  3. Karyn

    Oh I LOVE the sparkle in these! It’s not super over the top it looks like so there’s less chance of my eyes looking like a Twilight vampire reject. Thanks Christine!

  4. Caitlin

    Are these limited edition?

  5. Julia

    Christine- if you had to choose one sparkly black liner, would you choose Stila Sequins or MUFE Aqua Liner #14?

  6. frida

    bora bora is so pretty !

  7. Hi Christine, do you like the MUFE or the Stila ones better? I can’t decide which ones to go for….

    • Formula-wise, they really wear about the same, and so it’s just about color for me. I do find the applicator on MUFE just a smidgen better, but really, they’re all close.

  8. they look so pretty!!! All of them!!!

  9. Tigress

    Bora Bora is gorgeous!

  10. Dana

    These look lovely! I am definitely an eyeliner addict and I need a new eyeliner like a hole in my head, might try in a few months when I use up some I already have.

  11. MJ

    IMHO I like these better then the MUF liners. The sparkle and shine is amazing. As usual though the MUF liners have much better color selection, but color for color I like the Stilla better.

  12. Cora

    I <3 BoraBora and Electric. Beautiful summery liners.

  13. mnm

    I was eyeing these at Ulta last week and *almost* bought Electric. So glad you have such a positive review, I may have to go pick it up!

  14. I want Starry & Sequins!!

  15. These look amaaaazing. Totally want.

  16. Emily

    Did you have any trouble taking these off? I tried out the electric color in Ulta when they came out and the green pigment would NOT wash off my hand, I mean that’s a good thing as far as longevity goes but I felt like it really stained my hand for a couple days! I would not want my lids stained green… lol

    • I used Lancome Bi-Facil and Make Up Sens’Eyes no problem. Greens/teals have a tendency to stain (no matter the product – just like reds for lip colors are more likely to stain than a nude).

  17. I want to order some Stila makeup (graduation present for myself!) I will add some of these to my list. :)

  18. Devi

    That Rock Candy. It looks like the liquid version of NYC’s Mink Eye Pencil… I wish I was willing to pay $22 for an eyeliner now.. ;_; So beautiful…

    Darnit makeup, why must you look so darn irresistible?

  19. katrina

    I have all these execpt Rock Candy and I love them all. I wore them on my hair for two days (included, a shower, bath, many hand washes) and they didnt budge.
    :)

  20. Shi

    Lancome’s Beach Gem liquid eyeliner is a nearly perfect dupe for Electric. :)

  21. Yvonne

    Gah! I don’t want to like them, they are $22!! But, sadly, they are gorgeous. ::sigh::

  22. These are gorgeus! I’d love to see Curacao (well, Cura├žao…) because that’s where my dad grew up. :D

  23. Bethy

    I must have all of them. That is all.

  24. I love bora bora & royal sparkle!! I think I have to check these & the MUFE liners out!

  25. Thalie

    If you do any comparison post, could you include the MAC Superslick Liquid Eyeliner ? Some colors look pretty comparable to me (Flash = on the hunt ; Flash = Desires & Devices…) !
    Thank you for all your wonderful work Christine !

    • I was just going to write the same thing. I’d love to see you compare these with MAC superslick liquid eyeliners. Which one would you rather use/purchase since some colors look similar?

  26. Ms. Jimmi

    Gorgeous!!!