Friday, March 5th, 2010

Maybelline Legendary Lilac Eyeshadow Quad

Spring Pastels with Maybelline are a Little Too Light

Maybelline Eye Studio Legendary Lilac Eyeshadow Quad ($9.99) includes an icy silver with very faint, icy lilac shimmer; a lilac-lavender with gold shimmer; a blue-based blue-purple with subtle gold shimmer; and an eggplant purple with red undertones. This is probably my least favorite Eye Studio Eyesahdow Quad I’ve tested–it’s very faint overall. The pigmentation just isn’t there in three of the four shades (all but the eggplant-y one). I like the concept of four different purple shades, but I must say the blue-based purple might have been nicer with another, stronger medium purple with red undertones.

The eyeshadows themselves are soft and smooth, they just lack pigmentation. I’ve been happier with some of the other variations in this product type, like Good with Gold. This is definitely a skip variation to me — if the colors had more pay off, it could be a nice a way to try out purple eyeshadow, but since they’re already so soft, it’s hard to build up the intensity with these.

More Maybelline Eye Studio Eyeshadow Quad Reviews…

If you want to know more about how products are evaluated, read out Rating System FAQ! :)

  • Product: 22/30
  • Value: 9/10
  • Ease of Use: 4/5
  • Packaging: 3/5

Recommendation: Skip this one — it’s just too faint — unless you love really soft, subtle color!

Availability: Target

See swatches!

Maybelline Legendary Lilac Eyeshadow Quad

Maybelline Legendary Lilac Eyeshadow Quad

Maybelline Legendary Lilac Eyeshadow Quad

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

17 thoughts on “Maybelline Eye Studio Legendary Lilac Eyeshadow Quad Review, Photos, Swatches

  1. margot

    Funny enough, the other quads looked much better, the colors more appealing too … This one is definitely not calling me ! The colors look nearly chalky, which is not a look I’d go for !

  2. Ashley

    The purple is nice, but again, I have seen these colours done from so many other brands.

  3. Elysia

    I think it’s pretty, but the two lighter shades do look a little chalky

  4. Elysia

    Uh do I have a twin walking around? Referring to the previous poster

  5. Amanda

    How would they look over a black base? Like Blackground?

    • It could be pretty! I think that they’re still quite sheer, so you’ll definitely get more of a shimmery overlay over the black of Blackground than a real color change.

  6. Anitacska

    This is one of the very few shades available in the UK and the reason why I never bothered purchasing any of these. Just too blah! 😐

  7. Luisafer

    funny!!! this colors on your arm doesn’t seems like the ones on the palette…

  8. Helena

    That third one kills me. I NEED it!

  9. Adriana

    these e/s are like mac pigments from mac s.forecast??

  10. Leila

    I’m not much of an dark eyeshadow gal so this might be a pretty good eyeshadow quad for me. They look pretty rich in the container, thank goodness you did this swatch or I might have passed them on! :)

  11. Margaret

    HA! Okay so this was the first (and only) quad I bought from this line, and I hated it! And I was kinda shocked because your other reviews seemed to generally have positive things to say about the Eye Studio Quads. For the most part, I tend to agree with you. So its interesting to read that this was your least favorite… Maybe I won’t completely rule these quads out.

    • Like a lot of makeup, your mileage may vary :) The best one I’ve tried was the gold one, but I find that drugstore brands are often better at more neutral shades — so I definitely wanted to try some of the bolder, more color-heavy quads too. I haven’t found any to be as good as the gold one I tried, but there are some that are better than others. (This one being the worst I’ve tried.)

  12. queenfrostine

    I own this quad and agree that it’s a little sheer dry, but I’ve had good luck using this quad (and other eye studio quads) wet. I love the blue lilac shade. I don’t own anything like it and my collection is huge.

  13. Bridget

    A lot of people are saying it looks chalky, it actually isn’t! It’s smooth and the colours are so pretty! You have to look at in the store, the pics online don’t do it justice!