We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • Macy's50% off Benefit Boxes of Powder, ends 10/20.
  • TarteFree Shipping + 17% off almost everything with code HAPPY17, ends 10/20.

Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

Get Updates by Email

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

71 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. Please do not ask if/when a review will be posted. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us. Thank you!

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

When the colour payoff is TERRIBLE, no matter how much I like the colour if the payoff is bad I won’t buy it.

Also, the smell/taste, if a lipstick for example smells/tastes funny I don’t wanna put it on my face!

Bulk packaging, ugly packaging, when the product smells weird or when it gets back reviews.

Temptalia is my makeup kiss of life on the other hand. My makeup collection has been on the rise for the past year lol.

Anything with a strong fragrance is a huge turn off for me but I also agree with outrageous claims. I think sometimes the simple products work better than ones that have all these new special ingredients.

(sorry for some reason it didn’t let me send the email to you)
Hey Christine,
In a couple of days i’m going to having a photoshoot it’s just like a family portrait plus many photos of myself. I was wondering what would be some good eyeshadow for the photoshoot? smokey? neutral looking on the eyes and maybe some berry tone lips? please give me some tips!

also for foundation, i dont wear foundation on a daily basis only some concealer so i was wondering if i should buy the makeup forever HD foundation? or is it ok to use the laura mercier tinted moistourizer?

thanks!

The smell. Sometimes the smell is just distracting or annoying, as with some lipsticks or lipclosses, but with some products, especially expensive creams like Chanel or Clarins the smell was so bad that it caused me a headache and nausea.

Ooh yay! A question from someone I know! (well, kind of… hehe). I’m usually put off by really cheap, off brand products – The stuff you only see on-line. If I’m not sure what’s in it or in what conditions it’s made, I won’t usually buy it.

A big no no for me are ridiculously overpriced products, like Serge Lutens make-up. I doubt if the quality is any better than Bobbi Brown or MAC.

I also don’t like really flimsy, cheap looking packaging. I’m not a package snob, but I just prefer a package that looks classy, but simple at the same time.

Strangely enough, for me it’s the smell of a product. I always smell the tester before I buy it, because I know that I would not be able to use it if the smell puts me off! 🙂

Animal testing, will not support anyone who does it or has ingrediants that are animal related, so most drugstore items are off limits.

Revlon and Almay are listed on caringconsumer on the list on companies that does NOT test on animals:) GOSH cosmetics is cruelty free as well 🙂

Hmm nothing, maybe like Christine, products with ridiculous claims. And though I hate wasteful packaging, I keep buying UDPP.

when I don’t like the smell. there are some scents I like, but some I hate. Like rose-smelling stuff, and those maybelline lipsticks smell like caramel gone terribly wrong.

I had that happen to me with Urban Decay Lip Sticks – I love them and think they are pretty but the caramel taste / smell is soo bad I threw mine out

The frangance that some companies add to their products, like the one on the YSL’s lipsticks. Also, some packaging tend to add some smell to the product too, don’t know if it is the glue on it or the material, like too face cardboard packaging for shadows book.

Animal testing. This means that I’m never tempted to impulsively buy random cheap/drugstore cosmetics and such, since the majority of them are not cruelty-free. Consequently, I am rarely ever disappointed by products I buy and I probably end up spending less money, so I guess it’s a win-win situation!

When I pay for something I pay for quality (and hopefully a decent amount of product too!) That means I want it animal testing/cruelty free (There is no point in testing cosmetics, we know all the chemicals used in cosmetics for the most part or there are in vitro lab experiments that do the same thing!) as well as having good colour pay-off, good feel and good smell. And uber glitter tends to put me off as well.

For me it would have to be price and smell. The smell would probably take the prize on this one, I just get headaches pretty easily and smell is a huge factor for me. As far as price goes, I really try to be reasonable… If something I want is very expensive I always try looking for a cheaper alternative for it, but if it is something completely “undupable” and reviews are amazing, I will take the hit.

Parabens, but especially in lip products. I’m not quite as picky about them in eye products, but I do not want to be inadvertently getting toxic preservatives in my mouth.

A disgusting old-school cosmetics dusty, petroleum, chemical smell. If it reminds me of all the cosmetics on my grandmother’s dresser when I was a kid, I’m not buying it.

Expensive products like designer makeup, I probably wouldn’t go near that even if it was given to me. Packaging isn’t even an issue because all it does is contain the product, I’m not picky and anything is better than nothing for me and I can just appreciate owning it. Everything will have different qualities that people are going to like and dislike, you just have to know how to make them work.

Anything with a package that leaks of product if I have it in my purse. Eg. Hoola by benefit ( the box will open and destroy in my purse)

🙁

Wasteful packaging is a big kiss of death for me. This includes pump products which put out too much in a single pump. I love loose powders, but I hate when powder comes out through the holes, and can’t be pushed back. So hard to only pick up a little bit when the top is full of loose powder.

Hehe Yay! I’m having fun reading all of it! I’m glad I’m not the only one who refuses to buy things that smell too weird. I’m SOOOOOOOO sensitive to the “chemical” smell that that is a HUGE consideration for me right there. Oh, and bad tastes with lip stuff. It doesn’t have to be sweet, or flavored, just so long as it doesn’t remind me of washing my mouth out with soap.

I’m all but vegan, so I try to buy vegan where I can. I NEVER buy from brands I know use animal testing. Don’t buy cheap/flimsy packaging either, though I don’t usually notice that too much with my favorite brands.

That said ,i hate inconvenient packaging. i love the color of Urban Decays Gash lipstick, but I REFUSE to buy any of their colors, because the poky thing on the handle just bothers me.

Will save up for expensive things, won’t feel bad about buying cheap things…. really smell, and package design are what gets me.

Yes! Thank you for mentioning that crazy Urban Decay lipstick packaging. I think that Rush is probably my perfect MLBB color, I’ve swatched it about a million times in Sephora & Ulta, but I just can’t bring myself to buy it, because I know that stupid little dagger is going to poke a hole in my bag or pocket. Why would they do that? Why?

Whew! Glad I’m not the only one. Come to think of it, I just hate the vast majority of Urban Decays packaging. I mean, the eyeshadow ones are OK, but I depot anyways.

The palettes feel cardboard-y and cheap(PARTICULARLY the BoS’s), the lipstick has that poky thing, the primer is in the godawful lamp(I think one of my happier decisions in memory was to cut it open and put it in some other containers! I HAD been ready to buy a new one, since no product would go on the brush-after cutting it open i discovered I’d only gone through 1/3RD teh product! THAT infuriates me!!!!)

Love UD products, but their packaging REALLY makes it hard to me to like them as much as I otherwise would.

Poor pigmentation, poor finish, poor texture, gritty or chunky frostiness or glitter, non-user friendly packaging, smell, allergic reactions….there’s a lot of reasons not to buy a product 😉

Products with outrages disgusting scents! Mainly with Lipglosses and mascaras like UD’s Pocket Rocket and Lash Stiletto.

Also way high extreme pricey gonna make you bankrupt brands like La Mer or La Piere (How ever those brand names are spelled!) There is no way I am going to spend 1000 bucks on anti aging product or 100 bucks on foundation!

– if I have something vaguely similar
– if I know I’ll never get much use out of it (even if the packaging is super pretty!)

Animal testing is mine I’d guess. Also, any lipgloss, shampoo, conditioner, ect. with wheat germ oil or hydrolyzed wheat protein in it. I have a wheat allergy, so “kiss of death” is a great term! lol

Smell and Taste. I’ve completely tossed very good and expensive lippies because they tasted like poison or smelled terrible.

If I had to chose which was more important, I’d say Taste. Can’t do the nasty tasting stuff. No, no, no.

Taste of lip products, ie UD Pocket Rocket – yuck yuck! I also don’t buy cheap cosmetics anymore, unless I know they’re really really good, like the Sleek palettes (UK).

Super expensive products tend to be a no go, mainly because I’m a student and they tend to not be in my price range! (I tend to stick to mid-range, ie MAC, MUFE, UD, Benefit etc) Also if something has poor colour payoff I’ve learned the hard way to not avoid it.

I struggle with not buying things I know I don’t need or will ever use, especially LE stuff (I always have the “what if” thoughts and I worry about regretting NOT getting things!). Colours I know aren’t flattering on me get the kiss of death!

bad smell, packaging that will break, overpricing, animal cruelty. I’m pretty loyal to only a few brands because of these reasons.

I hate cheap makeup… I can´t Stand a 1 dll lipstick… sorry If I sound kinda picky but I have very special skin… so not all productos works on me

Awful or overpowering scents. Little to no pigment. Powdery/ dusty eye shadows. Cheap looking products; those MAC holiday palettes from about a year ago come to mind- they were in the red, cheap looking plastic palettes with jewels on them. The packaging was so horrible I didn’t even look inside.

Product availability is a big one. I live in Canada, so some brands aren’t sold here or they’re hard to get. In the past I would search ebay or get a CP, but now I’m much more selective.

Also, if a product is made by Revlon, 99.9% of the time I won’t buy it. I’ve never been happy with them.

I honestly don’t like the special packaging, like when Mac has a collection that has stickers or whatever on it, I honestly don’t like it too much, I prefer it all to look the same.

Poor quality product. I also like to know of the brands I use do animal testing, because while I can see why it’s a helpful thing I still don’t like the idea of animals spending their lives locked in a lab. It doesn’t seem fair.

Smell & taste – I prefer fragrance free. I’ve had some items I’ve used once and had to toss and take off because I couldn’t stand the scent.

Wasteful packaging is annoying but bearable. The thing I hate most is over expensive products. Like the Guerlain concealer that’s $50. $50 for a 0.05 oz. MAC Moisture Coverup is three times that. I mean NARS is expensive but $50 for such little product that doesn’t even work all that great is ridiculous.

When it smells bad or when it’s waaaaay too expensive. My pockets aren’t that big and and 88sgd for a palette is just a killer for me. And oh, also when the packaging is… Blah but I’m not half as picky about packaging as I asm about price and smell.

And yes, if the colour sucks on my skin? No way in he’ll. And if I know it’s going to make me breakout. Over my dead body.

If something claims to do miracles, I usually won’t even bother testing it to see what it *does* do. I figure if they’re willing to stretch the truth a little, they might really be stretching it a lot. I’ve noticed that it’s mostly skin products (foundation, concealers, moisturizers, creams, etc) that fall into this category.

Also, I’m not a big fan of bulky packaging. I just don’t have space for that.

I can’t stand glosses or lipsticks that leave a scratchy feeling in my throat. There is something in them that irritates me once I’ve licked my lips a few times. Anyone else have the same experience?

Extremely over priced products that don’t work any better than comparable products. (ex. Nars lipgloss vs Mac lipglass)

color payoff, easily dupable, price (ie the new mac mineralize foundations are too expensive for the amount of product you receive)

Lush and B&B works. Too much perfume and fruit extracts.
I don’t use fruit or mint extracts, so any product with those is a no-no.
I don’t use lip enhancing products as they generally use skin irritants to make the enhancing bit.
I don’t like lotions in jar containers too.

well, my #1 gripe is the sales person who hovers over me and pushes products on me!! if they borderline harrass me, i’ll just go to another store to pick up the product.

oh i hate that! sometimes i dont even bother to ask an opinion (I.E.: “would this color look good on me?”) because 99% they are going to say “OH YEAH! LOVE IT” even if i looks ugly just to get me to buy it, so they can get the sale.

smell…example the studio sculpt foundation by mac smells like butter scotch and i like butter scotch but not that much lol.
also i cant stand cheap/flimsy looking packaging even if i only paid a couple bucks for it.

Scent of the product is a biggie. Some scents make me queasy.

Over priced for very little product means I’ll pass. It’s arrogant of the companies to do that.

I stick to Eye shadow with good color payoff. It frustrates me when you have to pack it on. I read reviews or use testers before I buy.

DS items that have no testers. I don’t buy DS much but when I see something I want to try, I usually can’t find a tester so I don’t.

If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!