What do you look for in the perfect lipstick? Share your must-have qualities!
It should wear for four to six hours at a minimum, wear evenly and fade evenly, feel comfortable without being slick or bleeding, moisturizing, and deliver opaque color.
Got a question idea? Submit yours here.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
It has to be long wearing and a beautiful colour of course
1) Fades down evenly
2) Luxurious, moisturizing lip feel
3) Semi-opaque
Nothing worse than a bold lip that fades out to the edge and leaves you with a lipstick “ring” around the edges of the mouth. YUK!
1. Long wearing.
2. Nude, pink, nude pink, light coral.
3. Creamy, smooth, a bit of shine. Matte lipsticks look chalky on me.
4. No glitter.
5. Doesn’t dry and crack my lips.
Ditto for me! I also add pigmented for the longer wearing factor.
1. Beauty. An awful lipstick that looks amazing is very often excused.
2. Smearability. I prefer dark lips, so easy smeared products.. ooh no.
3. The perfect amount of “waxiness”
I’m searching for the perfect pink. Everything I try is either too light/bright/opaque/crazy looking. Plums love me, though. I can pick up any plum and rock it.
Creamy, non drying, semi opaque, no scent or taste, void of shimmer or glitter, affordable.
Long wearing and moisturizing with great color payoff. It should also fade evenly
Long wearing, pigmented and moisturizing.
Color and extreme pigmentation that lasts with a yummy scent!
Something that feels moisturizing but lasts and has SPF in it. I don’t really care for bold colors, so it would also have to be a pretty, fairly natural-looking shade.
u said it Christine…Id add plushy feeling.
my lips so try, i just want something super moisture
Long-wearing is my absolute #1 requirement. Even some of MAC’s lipsticks last maybe 45 minutes for me. Other than that, opaqueness, easy to apply, even, and not drying. Wow, I’m picky.
It is nice to find something that is not drying – that feels moisturizing on the lips – but that also doesn’t feel greasy and travel and bleed. Combine that with lasting colour and I’m happy. Oh, and I have to agree with “even fading” – I also hate that lipstick ring but if something fades evenly and maybe leaves just a hint of a stain all over the lips, I’m good with that.
It needs to fade evenly. Leaving a ring is a no no. Or it fades and becomes splotchy. It also doesn’t need to fade in an hour without eating or drinking. I also hate lipsticks that are EXTREMELY drying. Yuck! They create flakes and then you have dry lips, flakes and fading lipstick.
Even coverage, fades to a nice, uniform stain and doesn’t dry my lips. Mild to no scent and I especially try to avoid fruity scents.
Long wearing, applies smoothly, i dont hsve to layer on layers just to get that correct coverage. Doesnt dry out my lips. and a formula that doesnt stain. I love wearing red lipsticks but i hate the fact that alot of lipsticks stain on my lips. So im staying away from reds right now unless its a special occasion
* Good coverage
* Staying power
* A smooth and soft feeling on my lips
* Good pigmentation
* No glitter or too much glossiness
Very opaque color, but creamy to apply. Applies evenly and smoothly. The MUFE Rouge Artist Intense usually has my ideal choice for color payoff, but it isn’t as easy to apply as the YSL Rouge Volupte. The MAC satin finish lipsticks are usually the best of both worlds in those aspects, but I find some of them to be a bit drying. I usually prefer shine and gloss over glitter or frost as well. Even though some of the lipsticks I mentioned have their flaws, I still enjoy using them and I can work with what I don’t like 🙂
Great color of course, decent to long wear time, and my number one is moisture. I hate drying lipsticks.
long wearing, moisturizing, and compliments my skin tone
Opaque, moisturizing but long wearing. I also like if it has a slight scent and not smells like plastic packaging. I’m not fond of frosty, shimmery and sheer lipstick – otherwise I would just purchase a lipgloss. I also look for a nice packaging. There’s nothing like playing w/ a tube of luxuriously looking lipstick.
Opaque, creamy, and a quality product.
Great pigmentation, long lasting colour and when it does start to wear off, it needs to do so fairly evenly. Oh and a great selection of colours is a must for any lipstick collection!
it can’t have ANY shimmer in it. & it can’t be drying.
*Great pigmentation
*A harder/waxier feel
*Smooth application
*Non-setting, non-feathering
I adore the pigmentation of Illamasqua’s lipsticks and the texture of Clinique’s.
1. Preferably matte, but cream finishes are ok too.
2. Must be opaque.
3. Nothing that smells like play-doh or any other odd scent.
I share the exact feelings like these lovely ladies here. Also I would like to add, I love a lipstick that tastes luxurious too.. u know, the scent is nice and tres elegant . None of the placticky taste and scent that lingers on your lips.. ( cue Bobbie Brown Lippies)
I actually like lipsticks from both ends of the color payoff spectrum, both extremely pigmented and sheer (though not uneven) shades, depending on whether I want a statement lip or a softer every day lip look. The long-wearing aspect is a plus but not required for me (2-3 hours wear time is good enough). If the shade is gorgeous enough, I have no problem re-applying throughout the day. I can’t stand synthetic or waxy smelling lipsticks (like NYX rounds). My nose is just too sensitive! My favorite every day lipstick at the moment is a Revlon Color Burst in Soft Rose. It encompasses everything I love about lipsticks and is super flattering!
Moisturizing,long wearing and pigmented
Bright Colors (they look good with my summer tan), even fading, and comfortable feeling.
I like it if it has low risk of grabbing onto my front teeth.
dont have the lipstick feel, unscented, named brand, moisturizing, when used up…I can find a replacement…not discontinued, pretty color, doesnt go rancid on me if I dont use it for a awhile.
apply, wear and fade evenly
semi-opaque
creamy, but not to the point where I can only apply it with a brush
no shimmer. I usually DETEST shimmer on my lips, save for that rare occasion where I pull out a NYX diamond sparkle lipstick, but you know what I mean, that really shimmery, metallic effec lipstick that looks SOOOOO cheap and tacky. no go for me.
long wearing, a beautiful colour- usually nude, pink, coral etc.
no bleeding or feathering
NO WHITE LINE!!!!!!!!!!
not too glossy, but not 100% matte (unless I’m going for that look)
non drying- but doesn’t necessarely have to moisturize my lips
wow, that’s quite a list of things, but I’m quite picky when it comes to lipstick as I will feel it and have to look comfortable in it and be confident that in an hour I won’t look like a monster attacked my lips.
What brand(s) do you prefer?
Again, of course I want to like the way it looks. And then I want it to be long-wearing, non-drying, non-bleeding and comfortable to wear!
A good colour range, enough creme/satin finishes in the line (I hate frosts), a good price for what you get ($12 for a drugstore lipstick is ridiculous), not overly drying, but not overly creamy so that it melts off your lips halfway through the day.
Creamy, long wearing, moisturizing and there should no fragrance or flavor. Preferably affordable too!
Moisturizing and true to it’s color!
Color that stays true (does not turn on me)
Does not mush out ASAP in the bullet – hate to pay $ and instantly have a mess on my hands.
Natural as possible as I don’t want to ingest a bunch of chemicals
Cannot dry out my lips. I work hard to keep them moisturized
Having an natural (non chemical)spf in the lipstick is a HUGE bonus
non sticky, applies evenly even when your lips are chapped, basically a mac lustre without such a short longevity, and maybe a bit more opaque
Honestly, I am completely inspired by the show Pretty Little Liars when it comes to lipstick. They ALWAYS have the best pink hues without them being too overpowering or too “80’s neon.” So the pretty pinks are what I always search for. The best ones I have tried are Revlon’s Pink Pop Lip Gloss and then Cover Girl Lip Stick in Temptress.
Apply evenly
Not drying
Pigmented
Nice colour
Not too big size packaging so I can easily put in my pocket.