What do you do with products you don’t like? Toss? Return? Give away?
I return if I’m not outside the return period or else pass it along to a friend/family member.
Thanks to Kristina for today’s question! Got a question idea? Submit yours here.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
If I can’t return it, then I try to swap it on Makeup Alley or else just give it away.
Have you had good luck with swapping on Makeup Alley? I’ve thought about it but have never heard any feedback from anyone on it.
Hey! I know you didn’t ask me specifically lol, but I’ve been on makeup alley for a while now and have done several swaps and its really fun and easy. You just have to make sure you swap with members who have positive tokens, it really feeds my makeup addiction and instead of going out to buy the makeup I can swap a makeup product I don’t use as much with another person and get the product I want! =)
How many members will happily swap with a newbie? Like Kalex, I have never swapped on MUA before, but have always thought about trying it out. However, the number one thing I hear is to swap with members who have positive tokens – but I don’t have ANY tokens so who is going to want to swap with me!!
I sell, swap, or give away. I don’t think I’ve ever returned anything!
I shouldn’t feel bad but I usually feel bad returning an opened makeup item…so I usually just bring it back for an exchange..as there is always something else I could use! 😛
Give it to a family member. If they don’t want it, then I toss it.
Give it to my sister or cousin
or Swap it on Makeupalley =)
Swap them away! It just might be someone’s HG item!
I’ve had to exchange a couple times but I feel bad about it. I tried swapping on MUA but got swaplifted so now I just hang onto the products hoping I’ll use them in the future.
That’s what I’m afraid of. Is there no recourse when that happens?
I usually give them to my friends, if they want to have it 🙂 If they don’t, I’ll try to swap it, because I want to find somebody, who loves the product, although I don’t 😉 In Germany you usually can’t return a product, that has been opened 🙂
I rarely don’t like products and make up ! But when I have choose a wrong one for me I give it to my mum or one of my friends.
Have a nice day (sorry for mistakes !)
I feel iffy about returning used products, so I usually just pass it along to a family member.
I have never returned a product I don’t like because I didn’t know that I could do it so I always find a way to use it. For example I bought MAC “myth” lipstick because I only swatched it on my hands when I saw that it appears almost white on my nc43/nc45 skintone I start mixing it to use it.
I found that when I mix it with red lipstick I have a nice coral shade. lol
i usually pass whatever it is to my little sister or just toss it 😀
I try to exchange it for something else
My sister always gets them, i think it kind of curbs her from ‘borrowing’ things from me ! lol
Depends. If I REALLY don’t like it, I try to return it. Otherwise, I try to find new uses for it. maybe that eyeshadow color is poorly pigmented on its own—-but maybe it works to soften the crease of a VERY bright lid.
I give away Dupes(like when you buy another darn UD palette with half baked and midnight cowboy!)
I haven’t yet figured out the whole swapping thing, but there’s a lot of products I’d feel a bit bad doing that with, since I’m a FIEND for depotting everything. I doubt anyone wants to trade for NARS orgasm, depotted from the case, or whatnot. I just HATE opening 20 different containers to see the colors I’m debating using.
i usually keep the failed purchase for awhile trying to find other ways to use it by messing around with application and stuff… if it still isn’t working out i either give it to a friend or family member or just toss it!
If it was under $10 and a BIG mistake, it gets tossed. If it was a quality product, I’d try to return. If I couldn’t return, I’d give it to family or friends.
Return if I can. If I can’t then swap if it was an ok product but did not work for me, toss if it was a crap product.
Since you can’t return cosmetics in the UK, I give my unwanted bits and bobs to my sister, swap on MUA or sell on eBay. Unless it’s too old or broken or something, then just bin it.
I usually return it. If I can’t I just keep it in an old drawer and eventually throw it out…it’s usually crappy drugstore makeup anyway which I no longer buy, thank goodness!
I try to use everything even if I dont like it. If its a lipstick, Ill just use it with a gloss that will change up the color. Ill only toss something if it was really cheap and I dont normally give away products if they have been used.
Same here. If I don’t like it, I keep it around and in a few weeks I’ll pull it back out and see if time has changed my mind. I’ve never returned makeup and I feel bad giving a friend something I didn’t like. To me that’s like tasting something and saying it’s disgusting and then asking someone else to try it. Why would you do that to them??
If I can’t return them I usually give them away to someone I know.
I give it to my mom or a friend, sell it or toss it out.
I have just discovered that returning is an option! I will return, or it ends up at the back of my makeup drawer. Haven’t really swapped anything.
I’ve done loads of good swaps on beaut.ie. Its only for people within Ireland (or maybe the UK at a stretch) but I’ve swapped things that didn’t work for me for a MAC 190, Chanel Particulaire, BNIB Lancome Hynose Drama, MAC Fix +, and MAC electra eyeshadow. Very happy with all my swaps and I love waiting for the postman!
I return them. There have been very few items I’ve disliked enough to return, though.
If a product is good, but I get the wrong color, I give it to my mother or a friend.
I offer them to my daughter, sister or my friends.
i always give them to my relatives, friends , my employees, or sometimes i just throw them away
I fit cost a lot I will return it. Otherwise, I try to swap it.
I don’t think it’s right to return something just because I’ve decided I don’t like it. If that’s the case, I toss it or give it away if it’s something like an eye pencil that can be easily sterilized. In the case of a faulty product or an adverse reaction, I have no problem taking it back.
Unless it’s a foundation in the wrong shade (which I return), I just use it anyway. All the store is going to do is throw it out, and I’d rather waste my money than have it end up in a landfill.
My sister and I swap products every few months, so I’ll usually just exchange it with her. Otherwise, I’ll keep it (I can’t throw away) and keep trying to use it.
If I can’t return it, I stash it away. Periodically, I revisit old products and end up liking some of it later or I figure out great ways to use it.
I give all of it to my 15 year old sister
If I can return (which is very rare in Canada) I try to on makeup tools (brushes that don’t work really don’t work). Otherwise I’ve taken up with MUA (Makeup Alley) to swap for my barley touched products. Most product I only test once to know if A. don’t like the tesxture B. the colour won’t work or C. or something else unexpected about the product dosen’t work.
MMU samples I swap or giveaway to friends.
The Sephora stores in Canada always take returns. As do MAC stores as long as the return is within 30 days.
Here in my country we can not return open procucts. So I give them away to someone who likes them.
1) I try it again another way first.
2) I return it.
3) I give it to my mom or sisters.
If returning isn’t an option and it’s something I think someone else may want, I’d either swap it, throw it away, or if it’s small, include it as a freebie in a swap or sale.
I always return it! If that’s not possible then I sell it on Livejournal.
i either return it if it is within the return period or swap it away
Post them up for swaps on MUA. I throw them in a drawer until someone is interested.
I’ll keep them…for a while, and then try to use them again just to see if it’s any better than I first experienced 🙂
Try to make it work or just toss. I recently ordered Jones eyeshadow from Sephora and I sucked so I returned it.
If it’s a product I don’t like and the company is a good one, I’ll give it away to a friend or sell it.
If it’s a product I don’t like and the company is a bad one, I’ll throw it away.
If return and/or exchanges aren’t allowed I eventually throw it away.
Experiment with them; I always find ways to blow things up or mix them so that something whacky happens.
Depends on how much I’ve spend on it…’
If it’s expensive, I’ll try to find a way to make it work for me by mixing it with other products or changing the application.
Stuff that didn’t cost a lot and I don’t use goes to my best friend. Sometimes I give her my expensive stuff too… What good is it laying around in my drawer while she’s happy with it? I never make her pay for it; it’s my bad I bought a product I didn’t like so thats just good luck for her ;-).
Depends on the product. If it is a situation where I feel like the product failed (ie: made me break out, major flaking or smudging, any irritation, etc) then I will return it without hesitation.
The only other products I have returned are foundations/concealers if they were the wrong colour or if I bought a duplicte item by accident.
Otherwise, I give them away.
I’ve always wanted to try swapping, but it seems difficult for newbies to get into the game so have never bothered.
I usually swap it away for something else I want to try.
I had no idea you COULD return a used makeup item, unless it was broken or something…