Archived Post

What brand dominates in your beauty stash?

What brand dominates in your beauty stash? Or are you totally equal opportunity?

MAC dominates my stash, more by the nature of their releases and having this blog – so many collections, gotta cover each and every one, which leads to lots and lots of MAC!

Thanks to Mary for today’s question! Got a question idea? Submit yours here.

208 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
dani@callitbeauty Avatar

i’ll have to go with MAC as well. purely because it’s the most affordable out of all the good quality cosmetic brands. also, i think the fact that, as you said, there are so many collections and such a wide range to choose from, there’s always something new to indulge in.

Andrea Avatar

Ha! MAC dominates for me as well.. I would like to try other brands, but MAC just comes out with so many collections that I barely earn any money before I’m spending it there 😛

Kristen Avatar

ELF. I know not a lot of people like it, but I’m just a beginner 🙂
I have glosses, eye shadows, brushes (all from the studio line) which I like a lot.

I am branching out though. I have a few things from Smashbox, and I’m really loving them

Nicole Avatar

U!rban Decay! I am in love with their shadows and liners. Sadly, I couldn’t get my hands on the BOS #3 or Naked palette and am stalking all websites that sell UD for both. Also love Mac and am currently growing that collection a lot more. Looking forward to Venomous Villains

Nicole Avatar

Urban Decay! I am in love with their shadows and liners. Sadly, I couldn’t get my hands on the BOS #3 or Naked palette and am stalking all websites that sell UD for both. Also love Mac and am currently growing that collection a lot more. Looking forward to Venomous Villains

BF Avatar

In this order
1. MAC (60%)
2. Smashbox (15%)
3. NARS (10%)
4. Stila (3%)
5. Bobbi Brown (2%)
6. The remaining 10 % belongs to every other brand in existence or discontinuation pretty much equally between them…:)

Paddychat Avatar

Oups !
Chanel and Estee Lauder for lips
Make Up For Ever (MUFE) et T. Leclerc for powders
Mac for foudation
MUFE for eyes pencils
Nars for blushes
Dior, Mac, MUFE…for eyeshadows

I’m not exclusive for make up !!!

Carrie Ann Avatar

Definitely MAC. I also have a lot of stuff from Urban Decay, Benefit and Clinique, and some Lancome, DuWop, Bare Escentuals (love their Buxom line), NARS and Too Faced.

El Avatar

I have been using MAC the longest but I love all my Arbonne stuff since I have such sensitive skin, it’s my go-to everyday brand. Those two are tied followed closely by Urban Decay and a sprinkling of many other brands

Erica Avatar

I guess it’s MAC…. almost 90% of my blushes are MAC, although I don’t own a lot of its eyeshadows or lipsticks, but ya, most of the compact-form makeup are from MAC, and mainly because it’s so affordable compared to many other brands.

Rosanna Avatar

65% is MAC, of course! (it’s my first makeup brand), But I am starting to lose interest because other brands are catching my eye – the more expensive ones unfortunately.

20% is NARS which comes in second, their blushes are my weakness (eyeshadow duos on occasion).

10% is MUFE which is third. 5% is other stuff (GOSH, etc)

Zoffe Avatar

Definitely MAC 😉
But that’s mostly because I work for them and because they come out with so many different products all the time.
I have quite a few colors from brands like Fyrinnae and GOSH too 🙂

Lisanne Avatar

Gosh make-up! I’m Gosh “ambassador” so I get some products but I already loved the brand and had a lot of it before I became ambassador.
I’d love to have an entire MC stash but that’s just too expensive for me 🙁

kali Avatar

It’s weird because I think I have a good “assortment” from every brand. Even though I love particular brands more than others, I always get products from every brand as all brands have their great “must have” products.

MAC definitely dominates my lipstick drawers though. It’s a shame that I use them about 5% of the time!

AnaG. Avatar

I was a huge fan of Bourjois, because it’s affordable and very good but, since I started using MAC (not so cheap), I’ve been spending my money there…at the moment I still have more stuff from Bourjois though.

Lipstick Luvvie Avatar

It has to be a tie between Chanel and Nars. Chanel’s face products & lipsticks are great and I love Nars eyeshadow duos and Velvet Matte Lip Pencils. I used to buy a lot of MAC when I was younger, but now not so much.

Nadine Avatar

I would say that 95% of my makeup is MAC.The rest are some Chanel products and stuff from drugstore brands.
There are so many brands that I would like to try and buy from(like YSL,Guerlain,Bobbi Brown,…),but my budget is kind of small,so it all goes to MAC,since they have collections coming out all the time.

caroline Avatar

I notice that most say MAC. I have the feeling I’m older than all of you. Maybe I have more $$ power…and so will you once you’re my age 😉 and you’ll still love MAC, but will indulge in those products that are heaven like: Dior, Clarins, Chanel……

Just a thought!

Mee Avatar

Well money is certainly not a problem when it comes to makeup, not everyone here is ‘young’. I personally think Clarins has the worst selection of colors. Chanel is nice but not the best. So I guess is what anyone favors and not a matter of money.

Kalex Avatar

Yup that’s me! 10 years ago my answer would have been drugstore brands and Clinique. Spending $30 on one mascara was completely out of the question. Now my stash is (by far) dominated by Dior and Chanel.

Lauren Avatar

I actually have a pretty healthy mix of all brands mostly because of this blog. Thanks for takin’ the hit Christine! Without your recommendations/reviews, I’d probably have no bedroom, just a make up alley.

daphne Avatar

MAC by a very long shot. Urban Decay is probably second for the number of their 24/7 liners I have as well as a couple palettes. Laura Mercier or maybe Chanel would be next but either would be a very, very distant third!

Principessa Grassa Avatar

You know, I’m pretty equal opportunity! I tend to have more indie/mineral-type stuff, simply because it’s cheaper so I can buy more of it! I have a little MAC, a little more Urban Decay, quite a bit of Aromaleigh, some Fyrinnae, some Wet ‘n’ Wild … I’m a democratic makeup harlot!

baby in a corner Avatar

It used to be pout – anyone remember them – about 5 years ago but since then I don’t get as excited about a particular brand. I like urban decay, especially their palettes which are really good value!

Ada Avatar

MAC for sure. It’s affordable and there are so many colours and finishes. I love that I can try stuff on and return it if it doesn’t work out. (I’ve only returned one e/s that made my eyes itch.)

With all the new LE stuff, there’s always something new to look at!

Taylor Avatar

Definitely Hi-Fi Cosmetics dominates my eyeshadows, Revoln is mainly what I use for my face and then MAC dominates in the lipstick area. I’ve very open to make up brands. Lol.

Alexis W. Avatar

As with many others it’s MAC. Urban Decay is at second, and I believe MUFE is at third. It’s actually interesting because my NYX collection is slowing building up.

Cathy Avatar

I honestly don’t have one,but of the stuff I rely on everyday,three of those are Benefit,but I use a little of many lines(such as Mayyl,Maybelline,Smashbox,Milani,Wet n Wild,etc).

leesie Avatar

Urban Decay’s first by a landslide, with Sugarpill in second. It’s not even that I have a lot of UD (okay, I do, but in comparison to other UD fans, it’s actually pretty meager), it’s more that the rest of my collection is a mish-mash of different drug store brands.

Amanda Avatar

Eyeshadows are all MAC and Lorac but I only buy neutrals nowadays so I’m leaning toward the latter. Aside from eyeshadows, most things I own are NARS or MUFE.

Laura Avatar

Like most on this post MAC is prominent in my makeup collection. I also have tons of Urban Decay. UD started my love affair with cosmetics so I’m partial to a lot of their products.

Jenny Avatar

Oh gees…well I pretty much have a little of everything, but am forced to admit that Mac is slowly taking over. It’s spreading like some sort of virus.

Valerie Avatar

Guerlain (65%) my first love and what started my addiction to quality brand makeup I pretty much have everything from that brand from Eyes Shadow, to Lipstick, lipgloss, primer, blush and powders,
Dior (20% Mostly Eyes shadow love their quints and lipstick) then goes Lacome, Chanel, NARS, smashbox and MAC I juste started to purchase those brands

BethM Avatar

Another vote for Urban Decay!!
I think about half of my stash is UD, and the rest is divided between MAC, Smashbox, and Stila, with a little bit of Tarte and Too Faced for good measure.
Clinique and Philosophy for skin care.

Liz Avatar

I love having a lot of different brands, and I do, but I have the most MAC. It’s because I go to the Toronto mac warehouse sales, so I pick up a lot of stuff there. I rarely buy m/u at full price.

shuz4ever Avatar

MAC too…ever since i got addicted to this brand 3 years ago (thanks to Christine/Temptalia’s awesome collection info, reviews n swatches) it now comprises 99% of my makeup stash.

Wendy Avatar

MAC definately dominates my collection because of all the eyeshadows I have – probably 125 – 150 singles and a couple Quads. But this will sound weird, they are not my favorite brand. They just have such a huge color choice that it dominates my collection. I’m really an Estee Lauder girl.

Anitacska Avatar

Hm, it’s hard to say. It’s probably Mac, Dior or Guerlain. I have loads and loads of Dior eyeshadows, also a lot of Mac and Urban Decay, but not quite as many Guerlain ones, whereas I have lots of Guerlain face products as well as Mac, but not that many Dior ones. Lip products I again have lots of Mac and Guerlain, but hardly any Dior or Urban Decay.

Riki Avatar

Can’t really say, every brand has it’s best products so I mostly use only them…still haven’t found a brand I use too many of their products, not even MAC.

Scarlett Avatar

Even though I have bought tons of MAC recently, Lancome and Estee Lauder dominates my collection…primarily because I have friends who sell both!

mylinda Avatar

Laura Mercier tops my list. I have a whole box dedicated to the brand. But Chanel is coming in a close second now, all thanks to a growing list of lip shades.

Nancy Avatar

I don’t own a single MAC product, but that’ll probably change after the VV collection next month.

Catrice and Lush dominate my stash as I don’t have that much money to spend on beauty products.

Lizzy Avatar

MAC. Good stuff, decent prices, lots of room for play built in. Too many brands give you no tools to get outside the box with. MAC keeps a foot outside that box at all times!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!