Archived Post
Temptalia Asks You - What are you getting from MAC Style Black?
What are you getting from MAC Style Black? Everything, nothing?
.
You already saw my haul – everything, LOL.
.
Explore Temptalia
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Compare Any Two
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
54 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Comments on this post are closed.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Nothing. I dont buy at each collection and hadnt planned to get anything from this collection when it get announced last summer. Sometimes Im just not tempted at all and even get bored by the constant racing MAC impose. I might adore black and wear the color on my eyes for a decade already, I wont get anything from Style Black. I think that my black paint pot, my carbon e/s, my khôls, and the various pigments I use to bring vibrancy to black are better than everything they proposed that time. As for lips, Im not someone who usually enhance my lips a lot so I will also skip the black lipsticks. Concerning nail polishes, they really are the only things that tempt me, but 13€ ($19) for one single bottle of polish is too expensive for me.
Well, Im waiting for it to be online here in France. As for now its not out so…
It will depend on my budget. I almost have what I needed for my must have and if I get a bit more money ill get more.
So my Must have that ill get for sure:
Black knight
Night Violet
Blackfire
Blackware
Baby goth girl
Young Punk
Gilt by Association
Blue Flame
Volcanic Ash Exfoliator
If I can have a bit more, ill chose between those products what ill add to my haul:
Midnight Media
Cinderfella
Grease paint stick black
VA thermal mask
This is the first (and probably the only) time Ill spend so much in make up. But being kinda goth/punk, I just couldnt miss that one
Blackfire dzglass
VAE (4) 🙂
Seriously Hip polish
Wow. Actually, that was really smart of you. I only got one of each, went through Buyers Remorse an now feel like I should have gotten more. Ug!
I understand you completely, if i could i would by EVERYTHING!!!! so i really dont know what ill be able to skip on this one, everything looks amazing, since i LOVE black!!!! guess i have to check it in person before i make any decisions!
I need to see the stuff in person (not released yet in Europe) but I am thinking: a lot. The 4 eyeshadows for sure, and the grease paints.
I already have Illamasquas black intense lipgloss so Ill pass on the lipstick.
I want everything hehe.
Ill be grabbing:
The 3 MES
Baby Goth Girl n/p
Seriously Hip n/p
Blackware
Blackfire
Grease Paint Stick
Midnight Media
Black Knight
Night Violet
Maybe:
Bling Black
Ill probably have to pick up a dark lip liner for the lipstick.
I placed my online order already for 2 Volcanic Exfoliators! Nothing else interests me.
Im thinking Bling Black and Black Knight.
Not much…Volcanic Ash Exfoliator and Volcanic Ash Thermal Mask…maybe the Black Greasepaint Stick.
nothing for me
I ordered the volcanic exfoliating cleanser, and the volcanic warming mask. Glad I ordered yesterday since one of the mask has already sold out.
with D-squared on the horizon…maybe only a few things but Ill be waiting until Monday now!
Ill definitely get all 4 of the mineralize shadows, probably the VAE, and maybe the Night Violet lippie, but need to see that in person first. The collection isnt out in the UK yet, so itll be at least another week before I can check it out.
Hi Christine,
I saved some money for this collection. Here is my list:
– All 4 eye shadows
– Grease Paint Stick (2x)
– All 3 Glimmerglasses
– Volcanic Ash Exfoliator (2x)
– Midnight Media lipstick (thanks to you!:))
– Seriously Hip and Baby Goth Girl nail polish
The last black lipglass that MAC has launched was years ago. I still have Tux-De-Lux and love it. Thanks for all the swatches and reviews. You are the best. 🙂
Not worth my money..
Nothing. I’m not nearly as impressed with the eyeshadows as I’d hoped (having to use something wet is just way too fussy) and I don’t think anything else looks very nice. I love black, but this just isn’t for me.
Most likely Night Violet and some of the e/s as well. I’m tempted to go for the Volcanic Ash products, but am deathly afraid of breaking out!
I already ordered the volcanic ash exfoliator and mask, the greasepaint stick and the nail laquer with the pink glitter. I’m glad I ordered too, because the mask is sold out online!
I’m probably only getting:
Bling Black glimmerglass
Blackfire glimmerglass
& Volcanic Ash Exfoliator
I’m more excited for the d/g cremes!
I probably will get Bat Black CCB and Young Punk eyeshadow. The Grease Paintstick, Gilt by Association, Bling Black, and Blackfire are maybes.
VAE, VATM, the 3 glimmerglasses, Black Knight, Seriously Hip, Baby Goth Girl, 3 greasepaint sticks, Black CCB and all 4 eyeshadows. Part of it I bought online while the rest I’m getting today. I am just thankful that I got a gift card to use towards the CCB, VAE, VATM and 2 of the greasepaint sticks. Then I’m B2M for Black Knight. At the same time I’m picking up 3 dazzleglass creams, which I get to B2M for as well.
Seriously Hip Nail Polish
Volcano Ash Exfoliator
If I have any extra money I will get Baby Goth Girl nail polish and Volcano Warming mask. I also want to get some dazzlecremes but I need to see some swatches and save up some money also for the Dsquared2 collection next week!
Nothing, because it’s too dark.
Picking up after work:
Blue Flame
VAE
Bat Black CCB
Black Grease paint
I’ll have to play around with it to see what stays and what gets cut
hopefully I won’t be adding on…but my regular MAC girls know how to add-on sell to me =(
I just ordered the Volcanic Ash Exfoliator and the Mask online. Can’t wait! 😛
I ordered online on tuesdays adn didn’t really get that much but i am excited for it to get here;
I ordered 2 x Volcanic Ash Exfoliator and 1 Mask. I have bever tried them but I though what the heck. That’s really all i ordered.
I am going to a mac pro next week to check out the eyeshadows. if I like them I might back2mac for 1 or 2. The greasestick is also on my mind but i am gonna wait to see what people think and then maybe order it when the DSquared coll. comes out
Nailpolish not so much. I have seen similar colours before;0)
Duh! Volcanic Ash Exfoliator and Thermal Mask! Theyre in the mail right now, yippee!
getting the two polishes, baby goth girl and seriously hip 😀
Black Knight l/s
Blackware g/g
Young Punk and Blue Flmae m/e
Volcanic Ash Exf. and Mask (2 sets)
Thats it. I just mostly want that l/s.
I got:
Young Punk
Cinderfella
Blue Flame
Smolder (mine was almost gone)
and the mask and exfoliator
I had already gotten the grease stick last week!!
Maybe:
Young Punk
Greasepaint Stick
🙂
Nothing. Maybe VAE online..
Just Volcanic Ash Exfoliator – ordered it online yesterday! YAY! I’ve heard so much about it, how could I not? 😉
two volcanic ash exfoliators are on their way to my house 🙂
i want to check out the rest at the store and may pick up one of the dazzleglasses.
My Style Black haul:
Volcanic Ash Thermal Mask
Seriously Hip Nail Lacquer
& a big maybe on
Blue Flame MES
& I may break down and get trendy with
Black Knight L/S & Blackware G/G
However in the new MAC video, the artist
used 6 or 7 products to get that super rich black lip. Amazing!
At the same time there are also some new D/G coming out
and I am in love with Amorous 🙂
That be it! Peace!
EVERYTHING! Plus all the Dazzleglass Cremes l/gs + the new mascara!!!
Going with a friend after work today… Cant wait!!! 😀
Of course, I put everything on hold for me and her 3 weeks ago!
Black Knight L/S
Black wear d/g
Volcanic Ash mask
I got this today at lunch since these were what i knew i wanted but I didnt have time to play with everything. so this is all…. for now 😉
Young Punk, Blue Flame and Cinderfella MES, Midnight Media mattene, Black Knight l/s, greasepaint stick, 3x VAE, 3x VA Thermal Mask. Eek!
I ordered the Volcanic Ash Exfoliator and Thermal mask on the website. My hubby will be taking me to Macys tomorrow so I have my eye on Seriously Hip and Baby Goth Girl polishes, Blackfire gloss, black grease stick and Night Violet lipstick.
I will only be getting Baby Goth Girl. That is the only thing I see that intriques me from this collection.
This is only a wishlist, which I hopefully will get later on because I literally dont have any moolah =/ *crosses fingers*
*All the mineralized eyeshadows
*Both polishes
** Would love to get VAE and TM because I hear everyone raving about it and want to try it for myself
I got
-Night Violet l/s
-Baby Goth Girl — except Im returning it because when I got home I realized I had a color exactly like it. haha.
-Volcanic Ash Exfoliator Thermal Mask
-Greasepaint Stick
Hmmm honestly not much… This is actually a good thing considering at the mo i own way tooo much mac and way more than what i actually use tehe… but doesnt everyone 😛 And I also dont want to buy much cause I brought quite a lot from the make up art cosmetics collection!
What i definitely want is Volcanic Ash Exfolatior… after reading the review on here a while ago I got so excited so yay cause I can finally buy it (hopefully!)… I would prob buy the mask aswelll.
What also is of interset to me is the grease paint stick. I might just have to take a visit to my local mac counter and find out more 🙂
For sure list:
Young Punk E/S
Blackfire glimmerglass
Night Violet lipstick
Baby goth girl nail polish
Maybe list:
Cinderfella, Blue Flame, Gilt by association E/S
Thermal mask
I wanted the Volcanic Ash Mask but it is already sold out on the site and I am no where near a mac store, counter, etc….
Darn it girl. It acutally launched yesterday on line. I added two in my shopping cart but ran to Macys after work today. Maybe you have a friend or relative that lives close to a MAC store or counter that could pick it up for you. You could always order on line at Nordstrom or Macys. So get to it.
atfirst i wanted EVERYTHING…but i have other stuff i need to get from mac aswell and decided i dont NEED everything.
but i plan on getting Black Knight L/S, Blackware G/G, smolder, and possible the grease paint stick. EVENTUALY i will get bat black CCB but thats i nthe regular line anyway, and also im thinking about the 2 mattenes, mostly midnight media.
I purchased 2 Volanic Ash Exfoliator and Volanic Ash Thermal Mask. I really don’t want to spend lots of money on products I am not going to get good use of. I don’t collect makeup for the sake of collecting. It is a waste of money.
I was absofreakinglutely enthused about this collection and then ehhhh I don’t know… maybe I had heard about it for too long, and the passion died. Realistically I wouldn’t wear a black lipstick. If I wanted black lips I could do lipliner and gloss on top for the same effect if it came down to it. Anyway, what I got:
VAE x3
VATM x2
Young Punk – B2M
Cinderfella – B2M
Greasepaint Stick
oh man, here it is:
greasepaint stick
blue flame
young punk
night violet
blackfire
VAE x2
VA thermal mask
i actually bought the volcanic ash exfoliator and the thermal mask. I got the grease paint stick, bling black, blackfire, and black knight.
But this is subject to additions, as I have to go back Monday for DSquared and to take a good look at the dazzleglass cremes.
I don’t know if I’m getting anything from Style Black since I’m not really blown away by this ‘goth’ collection. Maybe I’m getting a nailpolish and the thermal mask and/or exfoliator, but that’s it.