50 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Tia Avatar

I’ll wash off my makeup wth Neutrogena One Step Gentle Cleanser. Then I’ll use Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover on my eyes to take off any mascara or eyeliner that’s left behind. Then I’ll use Cetaphil Daily Facial Cleanser For Normal to Oily Skin all over my face and rinse off. After I dry my face, the very last step is to spray MAC Fix+

twitter.com/TiaNgo 😉

Anitacska Avatar

I use Estee Lauder’s make up remover (blue bottle) and sometimes if I’m wearing something long lasting (mascara, lipstick) then I will either use Clinique’s Take the day off or Avon’s make up remover. I also wash my face with Clinique facial wash to get the rest of the make up blush, powder, foundation) off.

Lo Avatar

I use Lush Babyface cleanser for taking off my eye makeup, it’s the only eye makeup remover I’ve ever used that doesn’t sting my eyes or make them watery at all, or make them feel raw at the outer corners. For the rest of my face I just wash with Lush Coalface facial soap, then tone with Lush Eau-Roma Water Toner.

Milan Avatar

I remove my make up with some olive oil on a cotton ball, then I cleanse my face with castile soap and use acv diluted with a lot of water as a toner.

SarahT Avatar

I use coconut oil to remove my eye makeup – doesn’t sting at all! It’s super oily so it works in a couple swipes. After that, I use Olay Daily Facials wipe all over my face (also helps remove the oil around my eyes). Then I wash my whole face with Spectro extra sensitive skin cleanser.

Nora Avatar

Coconut oil is rather interesting – it’s actually a solid at room temperature. But once you touch it for a second, your hand’s heat will turn it into the common oil texture. I bought a giant jar at a healthfood store, so try Whole Foods or Wild Oats, etc.

Amy Avatar

Lancome Bi-facil is an AMAZING make up remover. Although I generally remove eye makeup with it it can be used for the lips too, like the last time I wore mac’s pro longwear lip colour, it was the only make up remover which could get it all off in a swipe!

Jenna Avatar

If found that a single MAC Wipe does the job! I’m impressed! With a little more diligence I can get rid of all my waterproof mascara after everything else!

When my acne was much worse, the MAC Wipe would sting my face like crazy, but all the alternatives at the drugstore stung worse.

MC Avatar

I use dermatologist prescribed face wash and cleanser but I have Lancome’s Bi-Facial for eye makeup remover. Really good stuff! Too bad it’s a little pricey. I use L’Oreal too.

Mara Avatar

I use MAC Gently Off makeup remover for my lips and eyes. Olay Daily Facials and/or Neutrogena Blackhead Eliminating Daily Scrub and finish with OC Bigelow’s witch hazel formula skin tonic. Then I moisturize! 😀

tremorviolet Avatar

For eye makeup, I use Sonia Kushak make-up remover from Target with a cotton square. I usually just wash with Cetaphil for the rest of my face.

Ms Trendy Avatar

In the morning I wash with Cetaphil because my skin is bare. At night if I am not wearing any eye makeup I wash my face with Philosophy Purity Made Simple – gets everything off and doesn’t dry the skin. Sometimes I use MAC’s cold cream cleanse… its somewhat soothing and calming to the skin but does leave a residue so I wash it off with cetaphil. For eyemakeup i use MAC Gentle Off (pink one) then wash my face. If I am on the go, i keep a travel size of unscented baby wipes and these get everything off then rinse with water.

Nathalie Avatar

Rose water on my face every morning.

On the evening, Maybelline Cils Demasq waterproof for the eyes (if I’ve worn make up), then I wash my face with a 70% olive oil Marseille soap (no matter I’ve worn make up or not), then I finish with cornflower water on my eyes to apease them.

Miss_M Avatar

I use The Body Shop Camomile gentle eye make-up remover and Garnier Clean Detox facewash to remove my make-up. I use mineral make-up and not a lot of eye make-up so I don’t need heavy duty removers to clean my face.

Mistli Avatar

I Love dermalogica!! I use their soothing eye makeup remover and then ultra calming cleanser for my face, gets everything off and never irritates my eyes.

ice Avatar

If I have waterproof makeup like mascara or eyeliner, I use a mixture of olive oil & castor oil(80-20) to wipe them off with a cotton wool. Then I wash my face with Shiseido Skincare Gentle Cleansing Foam. Otherwise, I just use the cleanser to wash my face when I don’t have stubborn makeup. I certainly recommend this cleanser. It’s really good:)

Annette Avatar

Since I always use waterproof mascara I have to use special make up removers, I use the cleansing oil from MAC, it works well but I see blurry then for the next five minutes, I am using the wac wipes they are great and I love the smell, but they are kind of expensive, here in germany a 100 pack costs €30.00 I use 1 a day for my personal use and more when I have makeup gigs (do makeup on other people) so theorethically a package should last about 3 months which would be then about €10.00 per month.

Diane Avatar

First, I wipe everything off with a Neutrogena makeup remover wipe.
Then I wet my face and wash it with whatever cleanser I have at the time… right now, it is an Estee Lauder foaming cleanser that comes in a pink tube (can’t remember the exact name.) Then I use either Paula’s Choice 2% BHA liquid or Dr. Denese Advanced somethin’-or-other (little round glycolic acid wipes that come in a jar) and tone with that.

LadyT Avatar

if i’m not wearing waterproof mascara, i wash my face with Neutrogena’s cleansing bar for normal/combination skin. any eye stuff that didnt come off (lower lid eyeliner) i remove with a q-tip.

waterproof stuff gets swiped with baby oil. i’ve got eye makeup remover but i find that baby oil works faster. then i wash with the cleansing bar….

after whatever makeup remover method i use old school sea breeze to make sure everythings off…then moisturize.

DanielleO Avatar

For eye makeup, Lancome Bi-Facil with a cotton square (sometimes a q-tip as well for close-to-the-lash eyeliner).

Then Cetaphil like a cold cream – rub it all over my face, wipe off with Kleenex.

Then depending on time and how my face feels, either a facial wipe (currently Pond’s Cucumber ones), and/or facial cleansing wash (still looking for a good one)

Then start seruming, moisturizing, eye-creaming, etc.

Brenda Avatar

baby oil or lavender oil for stubborn eye makeup, and I get blurry eyes too 🙂 Then either Skyn Iceland Glacial Facewash or just rice flower soap if i’ve worn makeup. I hate wipes as they usually hurt my skin.

On a bare face day or in the morning I use DermaE Clear Skin 1 cleanser with tea tree oil. Its refreshing and not drying at all but it doesn’t really remove makeup.

I always use some kind of Thayer’s witch hazel toner. I’m using the Rose Toner right now.

Lisa Avatar

Christine whats the difference between shu’s cleaning oil and mac’s? I currently use shu’s its great at taking off my make up but im not keen on the smell!!

Rita Avatar

I use L’Oreal Eye & Lip Make-Up Remover Waterproof for eyes (takes off every mascara), Vichy Purete Thermale Calming Cleansing Solution and Vichy Hydra Soothing Toner Dry Skin. I avoid cleansing with (a product &) water, since my sensitive and dry skin does not like it.

Christy Avatar

MAC wipes, MAC Cleansing Oil and Dove Soap. Usually the wipes work just fine, but for waterproof eyeliner, I have to use some cleansing oil. Dove Soap works just perfect, not too harsh and oh so gentle on my skin.

Cindy S Avatar

i use mac cleanse off oil just for the eye makeup to dissolve the liner and mascara etc, then i take a baby wipe and wipe off my entire face, whatever reisdue i can get off from the foundation, blush, eye makeup residue, but make sure never to go too close to my eyes because apparently baby wipes are not eye-safe and then i wash my face with dove foaming facial cleanser for sensitive skin

inuchan Avatar

cheap cleanser lotion sold in drugstore. Does the job as good as the expensive ones, without harming my skin, or my wallet. I also use baby wipes, then i wash my face with a cleansing bar (no soap formula). Then I systematically apply nightcream as moisturizer, and voilà

Vanessa Avatar

Neutrogena Make Up Remover Wipes/MAC Wipes, then wash my face with Dove bar, either exfoliate with St.Ives or cleanse with Clean & Clear Continuous Control Acne Cleanser, and finally moisturize with Olay! : ]

angelica Avatar

i just use philosophy purity made simple( it really takesoff all my heavy makeup!!!)..then everyother day i use clinique acne solution toner. then i either use clinique acne solution clearing solution or philosphy hope in jar for moisturzer!!

Vivien Avatar

I use face makeup remover from Sephora on a square cotton pad. It’s non-oily and gets everything off nice and clean. Then i wash my face with Neutrogena Soothing night cleanser then moisturize with Olay Regenerist!

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!