33 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Edea Avatar

They’re so fake, it’s not very interesting. Mostly it’s promotionnal space for the brands, and the tips are the worst : “two coats of black mascara”, helloooo, do you think we’re so dumb we do not see the fake lashes ?

Tanya Avatar

LOL OMG I soooo agree with both Edea and Kayc! Its like either they think we are dumb or its just one big ad for whatever line the celeb is being paid by. Its fake and an insult to our beauty smarts 😉 I pass on them!

blu3 Avatar

I like the ones that look like they are really listing what actually was used. But lots of times, as the first commenter said, they use false lashes but claim only mascara was used. Or, they’ll say X brand eye pencil was used, when the celebrity clearly has liquid / gel liner on. Often they’ll omit key products as well!

Once I spot something like that I don’t even bother reading the rest.

Macaddict Avatar

Totally agree!!! And, like super hot Hollywood stars &/or supermodels would really wear Maybelline, Cover Girl, AVON, or Rimmel makeup!! PPPUUULLLEEEAAASSEEEE!!!! LOL. I don’t even wear that s**t on my face! Yeah! With the $$$ they have, it’s most likely most of them have had plastic surgery &/or Botox injections, laser treatments, or some other non m/u work done!

Kayc Avatar

No not really. I don’t really care for celebrity looks since I’m sure they pack on 500 pounds of make up. I prefer reading about beauty tutorials from blogs, etc.. coz they’re actually done by people who understand that not every woman wants to pack on enormous amounts of makeup on a daily basis.

Whitney Avatar

i just look at the pictures, not how they did the makeup. It would probably be just as good if you just put the pictures without how they did the makeup and hair.

Cat Avatar

I love reading it….especially if the celebrity has similar skin tone as me…gives me different ideas. Some of the tips are spot on but others can be a lil exaggerated.

Myxa Avatar

I skip’em. I agree with Edea. I mean come on – sometimes, it comes across as if all they are wearing is mascara and lipgloss. But in most cases, there are way too many products that are way too high-end for me to try something similar. Now if there were more looks using MAC, that would be cool!

Lena Avatar

Yes, I do enjoy reading what products maybe used to create a look. What gets me is how the majority of the m/up artists are in over drive with that totally nude look at the gala events.

geri Avatar

I prefer reading books by professional Make-Up Artists. Have a few from Bobbi Brown, Linda Mason, Kevyn Aucoin etc…

Its more interesting and their style are all so different and fun to read and learn from!

carriespooner Avatar

Every minute of the day I read those. I disagree that they are just ‘advertisments’. People ask stars all the time what they are ‘wearing’. Why not makeup too?

Please don’t stop doing them.

missobtuse Avatar

i find post on celebrities looks to be quite annoying. Half of the time it is just an advertisement for one brand and the instructions are way off.
“Oh this look is just foundation, a sweep of blush, a dap of lip gloss, and two coats of mascara” YEAH RIGHT.

jess Avatar

I like them if I can actually believe what was on them. I agree with other girls–I hate when they use it as an ad for their sponsor–thats complete bs and fake. Be honest! Y go through the motions if your just gonna lie? Like I believe Amy Adams only used one coat of mascara–who ever does that? lol If it looks like a wide range of brands then I might believe it. But I agree, these girls only wear drugstore makeup if they are pimping it. Then its just another ad opportunity. I don’t believe they walk around using neutrogena skincare and covergirl makeup. NO WAY! The hair is less interesting. I still like to look at the makeup up close to see how it looks. A slideshow would be cool to so I don’t have to point and click through 20 posts.

jess Avatar

One more thing—I agree with Missobtuse–they think we are fools if we believe that its one swipe here and one swipe there! COME ON! These are actresses under harsh lights–they HAVE to use more makeup then us!–not less! We know not all actresses are stunningly beautiful without makeup–thanks to STAR mag. we know this! lol So quit pretending they wear no makeup!

Vivian Avatar

yeah, like everyone here, celebs don’t tell us EVERYTHING they used. You can’t blame them, we’re the ones that kept pestering them what they wear and of course they don’t give out many info-it’s most likely a makeup artists who TELL us, so don’t always shift blames to celebs.

To me, I just go “they so had false lashes” and that’s it. Yeah, some had plastic surgery, but not all do that. However, i’m seeing few outrageous NOMAD here talking gibberish. Who doesn’t like saving $, esp when we find a great price for a great look. mind you, I use low-end lip/gloss and they work better than high-ends I’ve tried. *rolls eyes*

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!