Can you have too much makeup? Or is it never enough?
.
It really just depends on what you’re going for. Practically, of course! But if you’re collecting or it’s a hobby… not so much.
.
.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
If you’re not a makeup artist and only use the makeup on yourself, YES.
Nobody needs a hugeeeee amount of makeup if they are just using it on themselves. Cosmetics products DO go bad, so if you have a large collection and use it JUST on YOURSELF, then the things that DON’T get used 24/7 will go bad and you’ll just have to throw them out.. Really cream products. But powder products go bad too over a period of time.
I personally disagree, but that’s just me. I’ve had products for 10+ years that have not “gone bad” at all. I don’t get sick or any kind of bad reaction to them either. Again, just my personal experience though.
My great aunt still has makeup she bought 16 years ago. She still wears it It’s all super high end stuff. My little cousins play dress up and use it. I’ve looked at all of it. The containers are so beautiful. There doesn’t seem to be anything wrong with it except the colors are ugly. My great aunt likes bright colors.
At the moment I’m sort of limiting myself by my bathroom drawer which I keep all my makeup in by necessity. Though, I don’t think I ever want to get to the point that I can’t keep all my makeup in it… I guess I just can’t really see the point in keeping stuff I don’t use. And clutter drives me insane, lol…
I think the logical answer to this question is YES, one can have too much makeup.
But when new makeup collections keep launching every other week, and all sense of logic and self-restraint fly out of your mind, and soon you find that your drawers or vanity table is overflowing with lots of makeup. 🙂
I completely agree!
I must admit, I have seen some people’s collections which are insane but I figure if it makes ya happy, why not?
I rationalise my spending by using my friends as a frame of reference. They’ll go out drinking each weekend and spend £30-ish each night. I don’t do that because I think its a waste of money. I’d rather spend the money on make up because its something I can keep and use more than once – even if eventually things go off.
If you’re not a makeup artist Yes, if you are then No.
I pretty much second that 🙂
I agree with christine that if it’s your hobby, why not collect as much as you want? It’s no different than spending money on collecting beseball cards, or model airplanes (dorky examples, i know :).
I disagree. It is not like collecting model airplanes or baseball cards. They appreciate and gain value over time; whereas, makeup depreciates as soon as you open it.
You can have too much, in my opinion.
it’s my obsession (plus hobby) so i can never have too much, especially blushes and palettes! <3
but i do realize practically they are too much i would probably don’t need to buy in a life time!
i think yes and i think i am having too much at the moment and trying hard to size it down. i don’t like keeping too much despite that i try a lot of products. i am thinking about a giveaway for my readers but not sure where to go about as i never enter any contest myself. perhaps, i should just randomly pick out a person and send her some goodies.
so yes, it can be too much even if you are a collecter. i now feeling the pinch when i opened up my MUFE Star Powder Collection. i don’t even want them all now even though i use and collect them. it bugs me to see so much makeup…
oh, well…
Oh jojoba, I would love to help you and take some (I don’t want to be greedy 🙂 of stuff from your great collection. I drooled over your MUFE Star powders and you should feel good having them all! 😀
Yes, I have makeup that will last me two lifetimes probably but I keep going. It is a total obsession. I do realize that I’m more of a collector than anything and it doesn’t keep like say, baseball cards. So am I throwing money away? Probably to an extent. It does make me happy and I’m now making a greater effort to cycle through and use everything I have through Project 10 pan.
I am struggling with this right now. A few weeks ago I threw away a ton of make-up that was probably 3 years or more old. It hurt but at the same time, I had not been using it. Right now, the only thing that I don’t have an insane amount of is lipstick. So I am building a lipstick collection. Plus thanks to your must have lipstick series, it has helped narrow down some colors that I am going to try. 😉 But as far as eyeshadows, I have an insane amount of eyeshadows and blush.
yeah..i have too much makeup…obviously considering the fact that i use soo less, not even frequently….i know its waste of money…but then i kinda gift them way before they expire….just to avoid guilt of my makeup being unused…
I’m trying to limit myself on how much I will spend on makeup and using the ones that I’ve bought.
I think makeup is something that’s meant to be used, so I’d say everything you don’t use is probably too much, especially since cosmetics go bad after a while (that’s in my eyes the one major problem in ‘collecting’ cosmetics)
Yes you can especially since it goes bad. I just have enough for one person not a store’s worth.
Too much makeup? Sacrilege!
Too much makeup and I am proud of it! 😀 Sure, things might go bad, but then I still keep them, because they look great in my collection. People collect stamps, I collect makeups!
I agree!!!
Can you have too much? Maybe.. I don’t know the answer to that.
Can I ? Nope. Not possible. 🙂
I AGREE! tehe. :o)
Never…I always want more
Never enough for me LOL
never!! seriously my friends are like you have a ridiculous amount of makeup but i love it, it makes me happy and i love having a ton of options!!
It’s really varies by person. Some people think having more than two pairs of shoes is an extravagence. If your babies are going hungry ’cause you’re spending it all on MAC, then, yeah, you have too much make-up. But if it’s how you choose to spend your discretionary money and it’s a hobby you enjoy, then who cares? I spend a lot less on make-up than a lot of guys spend on video games or electronic or computer equipments or mountain biking or a number of other expensive hobbies.
Yes, I definitely think there’s such thing as having *too much* makeup. I think if you’re an average person that uses an average amount of makeup (even on a daily basis) there’s a finite amount of makeup you’re going to go through. Personally I love to spend my money on collecting *tools* and new types of product, rather than hoarding eyeshadows and lipsticks that I will never use.
But I know myself well enough to know that I’m not the type of person who *collects* things just to have them, because I always get to a point where I feel the need to purge unused/unwanted items. So I usually restrain myself to things that I feel I’ll use on a regular basis. When I want to try new things, I usually wait for sales that include things I know I’ll use plus things I can try a few times to see if I like it.
Yes. Unless you’re a makeup artist there’s a point where you just own too much! After a while you really are just getting doupes of colours. Plus, we all have our go-to shades and it may not be worth it to get into depth for the other colours. As some above have mentioned, products DO go bad. Some products, like eyeshadows, seem to last a really long time! Others, like mascara, are bad in a few months (MA’s recommend replacement every 3 months but I usually get 6 months of wear out of a product before I need to trade it in for a new one!)
That said, if it’s your hobby then there are lot unhealither things you can spend your money on. Makeup is fun, so if you enjoy it then it’s your thing and that’s fine! But that’s just a question of needing something versus wanting something. Some people collect stamps; others lipsticks. To each their own!
Oh yes! I am in the midst of purging my obnoxious stash. It is sick!
haha you can physically have too much makeup but since makeup is my obsession I can never have enough!!!
Never!!!!
Well…maybe…
My credit card tends to be pretty critical of dupes. I will not purchase a pure dupe, but I do have a bad habit of buying shades that are similar but different bases (i.e. I have to shimmery “sand” colors where one is pink based and one is beige based). This lets me mix and match.
I used to think not.. but I often feel overwhelmed for choice by my collection. I don’t really buy glosses or lip products anymore because I know they will turn before I finish them completely, but I still buy powder products. Now on my spreadsheet I write the date next to a product when I’ve used it just so I can give some love to my less used items 🙂
i used to think you ould never have too much until i filled a whole drawer and went to put away a new haul and there was no room. i found a lot of products still in the wrappers at the bottom.
There is no such thing as too much makeup. Tammy Faye Baker is my idol. I have a huge collection and I’m going to wear it all at the same time every single day. ;-D
No I personally can never have enough makeup. I’m always tempted to buy more even though I have not used all of the ones I already have. I seriously have an addiction lol.