54 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Amelia Avatar

Skin Tone: Sexy Off-white lol no I’m tan with neutral undertones
Fave Fall Lippie: I love any deep burgundy color but if I had to narrow it down, it would be Btwn Mac Viva Glam I or Covergirl Tempt from the Queen Collection
Fave Fall Blush: Milani Mai Tai Blush
Fave Fall Eyeshadow: Korres shadow in Golden Bronze…it has soooo much shimmer but I love it with some black eyeliner 🙂

Rigor_Mortis Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Pale as hell with neutral undertones
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Rouge Dior in Fantastic Plum
What’s your favorite fall blush? Clarins Blush Prodige in Lovely Rose
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? MUFE’s black tango palette

Angie Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair with yellow undertones
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? I love wearing deep reds paired with a soft bronzer on the cheeks
What’s your favorite fall blush? I use my Chanel bronze universal as a blush if I wear a red lipstick, if not I’ll wear something like Nars Sin or Dolce Vita.
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? soft brown if I pair it with the deep red lips. if I’m doing more of a nude lip I like to wear something coppery/ bronzy.

Dominique Avatar

Skintone : medium/fair
Favourite fall lipstick : many ! Maybe M.A.C Musky Amethyst or Chanel Destinée or any pretty red lipstick from Nars, Chanel, M.A.C, Guerlain.
Favourite fall blush : many ! Maybe Cargo Lyon or any JC blush from Chanel
Favourite fall eyeshadow : Maybe 4 that is M.A.C Lady Grey quad

Chris25 Avatar

Skin tone: Tanned with yellow tones/NC42

Favorite fall l/s?: I like to rotate my deep reds (and these change because I am always testing out new shades). Revlon Raisin Rage is an old fave, and I also like NARS Success.

Favorite fall blush?: NARS Luster and MAC Sweet as Cocoa.

Favorite fall eyeshadow?: NARS Cordura duo, and MAC Carbonized.

Kate Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Really pale
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Too Faced La Creme in Spice Spice Baby
What’s your favorite fall blush? MAC Peaches
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? Stila in the Know Palette

Ana Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30-35
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Red
What’s your favorite fall blush? Plum/Neutral
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? MAC Cranberry

Kiss & Make-up Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: medium warm
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? I don’t stay true to seasons.
What’s your favorite fall blush? And it’s still summer anyway!
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? I’m such a rebel!

😉

Andrea Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? I don’t go on seasons, so I keep the same colors it only change in day and night look. ( wine colors and berry
What’s your favorite fall blush? bronze or coral
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? always neutral as sheer a possible

Stephanie t-p Avatar

Skin: MUFE 115, NARS mont blanc
Fall lipstick: ysl luscious pink
Fall blush: NARS g-spot or mata hari
Eyeshadow: usually more neutral but I do switch up for more dramatic looks.

sunny Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Warm olive skin (NC40)
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? MAC musky amethyst, MAC craving, Estee Lauder black cassis
What’s your favorite fall blush? MAC Early Morning, MAC gingerly
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? UD smog, UD darkhorse, UD smokey palette, Estee Lauder violet underground.
Lots of smokey eyes

Ashley Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Fresh Sugar Plum Lip Treatment
What’s your favorite fall blush? Nars Sin
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? Mac Satin Taupe

Alexa Avatar

Your skintone/coloring: MUFE 118 or Light
Favorite fall lipstick: MAC Plumful (Lustre)
Favorite fall blush: NYX Cream Blush in Rose Petal
Favorite fall eyeshadow: NARS Eyeshadow Duo in Cheyenne

Audrey Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair. B-12 for Chanel Vitalumiere Aqua
What’s your favorite fall lipstick?: Revlon Lip Butter in “Brown Sugar”
What’s your favorite fall blush?: NARS’s “Sin”
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow?: UD’s “Smog” or MAC’s “All That Glitters”

Mariella Avatar

Skintone: fair, cool
Favourite fall lipstick: either Guerlain Habit Rouge or MAC Dubonnet
Favourite fall blush: not sure I have one; perhaps MAC Frankly Scarlet or Conjure Up (LE from years ago)
Favourite fall eyeshadow: Stila La Douce

JEN Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Tan skin (more medium dark in fall/winter) with yellow undertones (MAC MATCHMASTER SHADE 5.0)

What’s your favorite fall lipstick? MAC So Scarlet

What’s your favorite fall blush? MAC Plum Foolery

What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? MAC Satin Taupe

amelia Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NW10
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? So far, Nars Dolce Vita lipgloss & Revlon Berry Haute lipstick
What’s your favorite fall blush? Illamasqua Naked Rose
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? I bounce around but recently I’ve been trying more subtly smoky looks. The palette I’ve been playing with the most is Sonia Kashuk Eye on Dazzling Color.

Holly Avatar

Skintone: Medium Warm
Favorite Fall Lipstick: MAC Plumful
Favorite Fall Blush: Burberry Light Glow Blush in Cameo
Favorite Fall Eyeshadow: MAC Satin Taupe, Nars Eyeshadow Duo in Kalahari

army_wife_in_alaska Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC 25
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? MAC UP THE AMP!
What’s your favorite fall blush? right now it’s MAC Worldly Wealth!
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? MAC Marche Aux Puces eyeshadow duo from Styleseeker Collection and MAC Brown Script!

Kimi Avatar

Skintone: Medium with warm/yellow undertones
Favorite Fall Lipstick: favorite neutral is Bite Beauty in Zin, favorite bold is Laura Mercier in Currant
Favorite Fall Blush: Laura Mercier creme cheek color in Blaze or Tarte Blushing Bride
Favorite Fall Eyeshadow: NARS Grand Palais duo

Katie Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Neutral Beige
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Hm..I love Chanel Dragon as well as Dior Plum Decadence
What’s your favorite fall blush? NARS Crazed (discontinued)
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? Anything dark, smudgy brown. I love NARS Galapagos for fall.

Catherine Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: light-medium with warm undertones
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Not a lipstick but Burt’s Bees Pomegranate lip balm – adds a hint of color and is very moisturizing. Also, Nyx lip cream sao paulo, laura mercier discretion
What’s your favorite fall blush? Sleek Suede
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? I’d say it used to be Mac Burnt Orange but now that they’ve changed their animal testing policy, La Femme Golden Rod which is very very similar (just has a tiny amount glitter particles thrown in, usually they’re not visible on the eyes though)

Maureen Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: very fair with neutral-warm undertones, copper red hair, and blue eyes

What’s your favorite fall lipstick? N/A

What’s your favorite fall blush? Nars Dolce Vita

What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? Nars Isolde (with Nars Cordura) or Nars Tzarine

rachel Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light olive/Fair with yellow/green undertones
What’s your favorite fall lipstick?: MAC Perpetual Flame
What’s your favorite fall blush?: Nars superorgasm
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow?: Mac Moth Brown

kdrake31 Avatar

skin tone/coloring: NW43
favorite fall lipstick: CoverGirl Queen Mocha Locha
favorite fall blush: Sleek Pink Sprint
favorite fall eyeshadow: Mac Superwatt

Lyn Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Very very fair and very pink
What’s your favorite fall lipstick?: Either Clarins Rouge Prodige in Fig or my old stand by MAC Dubonet
What’s your favorite fall blush?: Lately it has been MAC MSF in Light Years but normally in the fall I wear things like NARS Torrid
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow?: NARS Kuala Lumpour duo. It looks like autumn leaves when I wear it.

Anne Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium Olive

I don’t really have favorites for fall, but my faves for this fall are:

What’s your favorite fall lipstick?: Shiseido Drama Lacquer Rouge or Guerlain Luxure Rouge G L’Extrait
What’s your favorite fall blush?: Nars Outlaw
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow?: Guerlain les fauves

Miss J Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light to Light-Medium with golden/olive undertones.

What’s your favorite fall lipstick?: I have WAY too many. MAC Party Line, MAC Hang-up, NARS Fire Down Below, NARS Mascate, and I could probably go on for an hour.

What’s your favorite fall blush?: NARS Sin, but I also love NARS’ Dolce Vita, Outlaw, and Luster during fall.

What’s your favorite fall eye shadow?: Not an eye shadow, but I love MAC’s Cocomotion Pigment, and I wear it a ton during this season.

Alicia Avatar

My natural skin tone is most closely matched to NARS Siberia, and I have very strong yellow undertones.
My favorite fall lipstick is MAC Media used as a stain,
My favorite fall blushes are NARS Liberté, MAC Fresh Honey (applied very sparingly), and Benefit Dollface,
My favorite fall eyeshadows are MAC Patina, MAC Bronze and Urban Decay YDK.

Danielle Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, NW 20
What’s your favorite fall lipstick?: Mac Cosmo, Mac Dubonnet
What’s your favorite fall blush?: NARS Sin, Mac Mocha
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow?: Mac Romp or Bronze.

Alexandra Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: MAC NC15
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? MAC Fresh Brew
What’s your favorite fall blush? Haven’t found one yet!
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? Maybelline Color Tattoo Bold Gold, NARS Coconut Grove, or MAC Indianwood with UD Toasted

Nat Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NW 10
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Chanel Rouge Noir, MAC Dubonnet
What’s your favorite fall blush? NARS Douceur, Sin
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? NARS Cordura Duo, MAC Sumptuous Olive

cassandra Avatar

nw20
fall lipstick: nars amsterdam or l’oreal infallible persisting plum
fall blush: no answer
fall eyeshadow: maybelline eye tattoo in gold shimmer, mac morning frost paint pot from glitter and ice collection.

jess Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: fair with a golden undertone
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? MAC so scarlet or MAC red she said
What’s your favorite fall blush? MAC Darkly my Dear
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? I’m loving Maybelline Olive Martini

xamyx Avatar

Skin tone/coloring: Fairly light; neutral; dark hair & eyes.

I wear pretty much the same types of shades year-round, and they fall into the “Fall” & “Winter” makeup shades. That said, one of my favorite eyeshadow combos is NARS Night Fever & Ondine. I usually wear lip balm, and I contour & highlight using NARS Zen & Nico. On the rare occasion I wear blush, it’s almost always L’Oreal Mauvelous.

Elle Jaye Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring:
NC50 (MAC) or NARS New Orleans
■What’s your favorite fall lipstick?
MAC Darkside/NARS Volga both with MAC Nightmoth liner
■What’s your favorite fall blush?
MAC Raisin or La Femme Sienna
■What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow?
I have been loving my Wet N Wild Comfort Zone Palette and Coastal Scents Fall Festival Palette

Winni Avatar

My coloring: Mac nc35, Kat Von D Medium 54
Fav fall lipstick: Tarte Lipsurgence in Moody or Mac Rebel
Fav fall blush: Estée Lauder Pure Color Blush in Naughty, or Tarte Amazon Clay in Blushing Bride, or Nars Outlaw, I cant decide!!!
Fav fall eyeshadow: most golds, darker greens, deep purples, wine, browns and taupes. Think UD Naked 1, Mac satin taupe and moth brown, etc.

Irene Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Very very fair, yellow-neutral undertones
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Chanel Rouge Allure Laquer in Dragon or MAC Russian Red
What’s your favorite fall blush? MAC Desert Rose matte blush
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? MAC Golden Lemon pigment

Lauren Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium – NC35
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Estee Lauder Pure Color in Tiger Eye (it’s a medium warm orange brown with sparkle)
What’s your favorite fall blush? Tarte Blushing Bride
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? Too Faced duo in Poodle Puff

Nikki Avatar

Coloring: NC50

Lipstick: Currently, I don’t own one! I prefer brights, which are usually reserved for spring and summer. However, I’ve had my eye on MAC Rebel for a while so I may invest in that one soon. It’s so gorgeous!!!

Blush: I’ve been loving La Femme Bordeaux lately. Lovely shade of wine!

Eyeshadow: I generally prefer a neutral eye so my looks are pretty much the same all the time. Most times, I use my Wet n Wild Comfort Zone palette.

rubygarnet Avatar

colouring: MAC nc20

Fave Fall lipsticks: MAC Queen’s Sin, MAC London Life, MAC Brick-O-La, MAC Sophisto, Rimmel Kate Moss 05, (& lipglosses: MAC Red Romp,MAC Jampacked, MAC Red Reflection)

Fave Fall blush: haven’t found one yet that works on me

Fave Fall eyeshadows: All MAC – Brilliantly Lit, Moth Brown, 100 Strokes, Flip, Shale, Bronze

Jackie Avatar

Skin tone/coloring: MAC NW10/15
Favourite fall lipstick: L’Oreal Colour Infallible in Mahogany
Favourite fall blush: NARS Sin
Favourite fall eyeshadow: MAC Satin Taupe, or Urban Decay Half Baked. (Mainly when I do a dark lip, I go for Half Baked, and light lips I use Satin Taupe)

Tulie Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring: NW20-25, red hair, blue-gray-green eyes
■What’s your favorite fall lipstick? UD Naked Lip Junkie, Chanel Bois des Iles Rouge Coco
■What’s your favorite fall blush? NARS Sin
■What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? MAC Coppering, Fig 1, Burberry Rosewood

t_zwiggy Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light-medium (NW20-25)
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? I’m not a lipstick person
What’s your favorite fall blush? MAC Breath of Plum, MAC Peachtwist, NARS Luster
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? I love olive greens, like MAC Mink & Sable and dark smokey browns.

Michelle Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Deep dark, NW 45/ Nars New Orleans
What’s your favorite fall lipstick? Tom ford Black Orchid
What’s your favorite fall blush? Lancome Plum Noir
What’s your favorite fall eyeshadow? Mac constructivist paint pot

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!