On my black lashes, it doesn’t usually look brown, just murky black. I like the concept, though, and I think it should work better for those with naturally lighter-colored lashes.
— Christine
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
I also have black lashes so it looks very dark unless I build it up a lot. I think it’s a good option for someone who wants a polished look that looks very natural.
I don’t have any good recommendations, but I hope someone else does! I’m in the market for a brown mascara that doesn’t pull too warm/reddish. My natural eyeshadow are almost white and black doesn’t work for natural/”no-makeup” looks on me.
My friend who has albinism used to use a light brown mascara from Burberry, but they discontinued it. We went to Sephora in Canada and they actually hooked her up with an eyebrow gel from Anastasia that she could use as a mascara.
Burberry actually makes a color called “Midnight Blonde” that looks pretty cool-toned.
My lashes are already black, so there’s no point in wearing brown mascara for me.
When I had a job with a more conservative dress code, I often wore brown mascara. I didn’t have black hair for most of the time I worked there, so brown was the best choice, especially on days I wore very light makeup (my daughter was very young, and I had to get her ready for/take her to different therapies, so time was very limited). It provided a more polished look, and since I worked in a bank, the more natural look was encouraged.
Now that I have more flexibility with my makeup, I prefer black. If mascara didn’t have to be replaced so often, I would keep a brown on-hand, at least until I go back to black hair. I’m not too picky with mascara, so if I find something from e.l.f., L.A. Colors, etc…, I may pick it up.
I don’t wear brown mascara. I have black lashes, so only the darkest browns show up on my lashes, and I really have to build up those. I prefer black, though. To me, brown just doesn’t stand out as much or set off the bright eyeshadows I like. I think it’s a good option for people who have really light hair and lashes; it’s not as harsh on them as black. It’s perfect for people who want a more natural look.
I have black lashes, but they are really short and skimpy, so I like black mascara to bring them out, especially if I’m using bolder, more colorful shadows. For a more natural look, I prefer a dark brownish black mascara, as black can look harsh against my fair skin.
Uh, definitely NOT on my lashes, not even black-brown will do, ONLY pitch, deepest, dark as night, black will do for me! With my having nearly black hair, olive skin, BUT having light eyes; my eyes need all the definition they can possibly get.
But, it might do for very quick brows? Idk?
Other than that, I could see it working for redheads or natural light blondes.
I use the chocolate brown color from Clinique Lash Power Mascara (a tubing formula) more often than I use the black color because it goes with the natural looks I usually do. I have dark brown lashes naturally and it is pretty similar to my natural color but it gives me more definition and length.
I don’t wear anything else. Black is too harsh. I use black-brown at night, but that’s it.
I have black lashes and brows and so brown looks unnatural on me. Whether it would be successful would depend on your natural coloring.
It’s a necessity for me! I am blond and i love bright lipstick, so I wear brown mascara every day. I hate the harsh look of black mascara on pale girls. Even when I’m wearing eyeshadow I tend to opt for a brown black color.
I hate that my favorite formula only comes in black!
I LOVE black brown or brown mascara. not black. I’m a fair to medium skinned woman with blonde hair and light eyelashes (and deep set eyes with dark circles). I HATE when mascara brands DON’T offer brown options. So I buy a lot of drugstore or clinique mascara….where both seem to realize not everyone wants deepest black eyelashes (regardless of what Bobbi Brown et. al. say)
Chanel Le Volume #80 came out with a new beautiful brown mascara that is great for a day time lash look. I have very thick eyelashes so if I use black during the day it’s just too much and looks over the top so for the gym and running errands I love the Chanel Le Volume. Definitely recommend this mascara!
Yes I love it too especially in black 🙂
Brown mascara looks good on those with fair eyelashes. Sometimes on us mature women (with fair lashes) it doesn’t look as harsh as black mascara. Usually I wear brown/black and that is fine.
Brown mascara is a casual choice for me. I always prefer black but I wear brown when I want to look casual but put together. I am trying to find a dark navy blue mascara.
Try Astor Seduction Codes for navy blue. I haven’t seen anything like this anywhere else.
Thanks Marta, I will try it 🙂
It’s just not a look I ever go for. My lashes are dark brown, so I could probably get a brown to show up on me, but I always want to go all-out with bold, black lashes. 😛
Rave: it isn’t black. I have sensitivities to black pigments so I cannot wear black mascara. I think brown is actually more flattering on a lot of people. Particularly on the bottom lashes.
Rant: where to start? Lol. It’s difficult to find a really good formula in just plain brown. Most drugstore brands only offer a black/brown shade, which is no good as most have too much black pigment, and it’s way too expensive to try all of them in hopes one will shade more brown than black. Estée Lauder makes the only waterproof brown mascara I’ve seen.
I have fair skin and dark auburn hair and have dark eyelashes, I wear black mascara when I go out, but for daytime it’s a little harsh. I prefer to wear dark brown mascara but this is hard to find, especially in a waterproof formula as I have oily lids and normal mascara just smudges off.
I have black lashes as well so it’s subtle, but I do think it works well if I’m going for a softer look. It’s hard to find ones that are pigmented enough to work with black lashes, but Clinique, Chanel and YSL do some good ones.
I haven’t worn brown mascara since high school. I thought it looked good then, but there were other questionable things I liked at the time. Maybe I should try it again.
I love brown mascara, I hate that I don’t use it as much as I like to! Also, it’s terribly hard to find at the drugstore.
I love how it looks with plum, green and blue eye looks.
My lashes have blonde roots and tips. The rest is brown. I used MAC Plush Lash in Brownette for a while, and I liked it, but it doesn’t take long to turn rancid.
I have fair lashes and love brown mascara. Sometimes black it just too harsh, especially if wearing a natural look.
I have black roots and white blonde lash tips so brown looks off on me. If it’s a dark black brown it looks fine for an ultra-natural result.
I’m blonde, and without mascara, my lashes aren’t much darker than my skin. Plain brown is absolutely critical for a no-makeup look on me. I don’t like black shadow, even when I go with very dark eye looks. It looks harsh on me, no matter what I do (the same reason I don’t use black liner), but it’s almost impossible anymore to find a highly-rated brown mascara (though some people have mentioned a few below). Right now I use Better Than Sex — which only comes in black — but I’m not going to rebuy because it flakes on me. So I’m on the hunt.
The only thing that really discourages me about mascara is that I do, on occasion, need to use waterproof, and it’s almost impossible anymore to find one in brown or brown-black. Maybe I’ll try Ulta.
it’s my preferred color for day/natural looks. I’m fair with mostly blonde lashes (nearly lashless without mascara), black mascara can look really harsh. Even when I do wear black mascara, I usually wear brown on my lower lashes (if any at all). It is hard to find in my semi-rural area though. Clinique’s Naturally Glossy was my go to for years.