I was so excited to see these in the flesh when they first came out at Macy's. I swatched so many and the colors were all gorgeous. I decided to start with milkshake. However, when I applied it to my actual lips, it was really goopy, didn't apply evenly and definitely accentuated my chapped lips by nesting in every single crease. Im still optimistic though, so 3.5 stars for now.