Written Reviews

This is a gorgeous bright light silver. It does eventually dry out a bit.

This is a lovely color on. It looks like it might be a contour color in the pan, but in actual practice, the color is gentle and kind of like NARS Sin, just a bit warmer and darker. It had pretty much disappeared when I checked it out 11 hours later, but I had only used a tiny bit, so that might be why. The included brush is usable.

This is a matte cobalt blue that is very stiff in the pan. Next to nothing comes off on fingers but it does scrape off with anything abrasive like fabric. It's part of the Pandamonium Quad.

This is a pale yellow/cream colored frost that is very nicely pigmented. It's part of the Pandamonium Quad.

I have this in the non-Rihanna packaging and it seems to be considerably darker, cooler and less sparkly (though the second color does still seem to be prone to fallout). The middle color is the biggest difference where mine is a dark blue gray instead of a grey taupe like this one.

This is a beautiful bright matte orange! One of my first MUFE purchases and still one of my favorite.

I'm not sure what I think of this product long term, but I thought I would at least leave a description of the color which is a light pinky peach with a slight golden sheen!

For some reason, my version of this is a completely different color, more mauve with almost no coral. The finish is lovely, but I have no data yet on how long it lasts.

I really like the color, but I want to add a warning that this is in no way light-fast. (Apparently it's a recurring problem with light purple as the Sephora Over the Moon blush was discontinued for exactly this reason.) . I wasn't keeping it in direct sunlight or anything, just in a z-palette with a clear cover on the bathroom counter (indirect sunlight by day and occasional artificial light). Fortunately, the faded bit didn't go all the way through and I was able to get the color back by brushing off a few layers.

This is my first time seeing one of these in person (I ordered online) and my first impression is that I'm pretty disappointed. Honestly, it just looks like someone combined two different L'Oreal Infallible colors (maybe Garnet and Black). It's pretty and it's still possible that I'll fall in love with it, but it makes me want to just play around with multiple Infallibles instead. The packaging is definitely a bit nicer (glass instead of plastic), but the one I bought had been discontinued so had started to dry out anyway, so I doubt the packaging matters much in the long run.

This color must vary a lot by imprint because my version (not from Selena collection) is a straight up warm brown that is by far the ugliest thing in my blush palette!

I theoretically love this blush, but for whatever reason, mine is super un-pigmented. My color is definitely more dusty rose than it appears here (and I like that difference), it just takes 2-3 layers to see anything. My highlighter is fine, and I ordered it directly from Belk online, but all I can think of is that it was quite cold out when it was sent and that effected the powder? It's quite sad because I love the color, I just wish it showed.

This is a very pigmented shimmery warm tan color.

The reason this was discontinued is that it fades very quickly and very badly, even in artificial light. I tracked down one of them, and there is barely any color left. There is only a bit of lavender in the middle of the pan where the word SEPHORA on the top of the package cast a vague shadow.

This is a lovely color, and I'm sure it was very good at one point, but just as a warning, the version of this on allcosmeticswholesale as of Jun 2017 isn't very good. I'm sure it's authentic, just old. It's stiff in the pan and lacking pigment.

Just as a warning, the amount of pink/cream/brown in the product is pretty variable. Both the one I was sent and the one pictured on Colour Pop's website have considerably more brown then the one pictured, making mine swatch more of a straight up bronze than the lovely pink of Christine's.