Pat McGrath Beautiful Creature vs. Hourglass I Can't Live Without Comparison

Editor's Comparison

Pat McGrath Beautiful Creature is a warm plum with a cream finish that is discontinued and retails for $40.00. In comparison, Hourglass I Can't Live Without is a warm plum with a cream finish that is permanent and retails for $34.00.

Hourglass I Can't Live Without is 95% similar — it is darker.

Community Comparison

Your Vote — 95%

• I Can't Live Without is Brighter (2)
• I Can't Live Without is Glossier (2)
• I Can't Live Without is Darker (1)
• I Can't Live Without is Cooler (1)
• I Can't Live Without is Less pigmented (1)
• I Can't Live Without is Warmer (1)