Makeup Geek First Love vs. MAC Pink Buttercream Comparison

Editor's Comparison

Makeup Geek First Love is a cool pink with a satin finish that is discontinued and retails for $9.99. In comparison, MAC Pink Buttercream is a cool pink with a frost finish that is limited edition and retails for $34.00.

MAC Pink Buttercream is 90% similar — it is more shimmery.

Community Comparison

Your Vote — 80%

• Pink Buttercream is Less pigmented (1)
• Pink Buttercream is More shimmery (1)
• Pink Buttercream is More muted (1)