Make Up For Ever ME828 Garnet Black vs. Tarte Scarlet Comparison

Editor's Comparison

Make Up For Ever ME828 Garnet Black is a warm plum with a pearl finish that is discontinued and retails for $17.00. In comparison, Tarte Scarlet is a warm plum with a frost finish that is limited edition and retails for $14.00.

Tarte Scarlet is 85% similar — it is lighter, brighter, warmer.

Community Comparison

• Scarlet is Less shimmery (1)
• Scarlet is Darker (1)
• Scarlet is More muted (1)
• Scarlet is Cooler (1)