Do you line your waterline? If so, how/with what?
More inadvertently than intentionally! I don’t find many liners last *that* long on the waterline, so I tend to focus on the lower lash line, but inevitably, some liner gets on my water line at times.
Thanks to Sovann for today’s question! Got a question idea? Submit yours here.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
i feel like you’ve asked this question a few times already
Almost everytime i put on make up!
Yes! With a black kohl pencil. I agree that it doesn’t last long, but I love the look. It’s also the first thing my mum taught me about make up. 😛
I do, but I wish it would stay. I’ve tried almost everything. Does anyone have any suggestions?
Oh and does it matter what ethnicity and kind of eyes you have? I go with suggestions people at MAC or Sephora give me and it works for them and not me, it’s weird.
Have you tried Mac’s fluidline? It’s the only thing that really stays for me, but I have to dry off my waterline with a q-tip first. You could also pat on a matte black eyeshadow (carbon) on top of the fluidline to give it extra staying power.
How do you pat eyeshadow on your waterline? Doesn’t that irritate it?
Not if it’s over a base, (the gel liner) that means it wouldn’t directly be touching the waterline. It would just be setting the gel
MAC fluidline. It stays on my waterline ALL DAY.
i highly doubt it, it just depends on your eyes. My eyes are really watery (in my opinion), and things that have worked for my friends has not worked for me.
Have you tried the new Maybelline gel eyeliner that comes in pots?
I bought it recently and used it on my waterline, and it stayed forever. Also, a lot of people will dip a black eyeliner pencil into a gel like this, and then line the waterlines, b/c the gel helps it stay.
Personally, I’m only going to use the gel on my waterlines occasionally, I’m not sure it’s supposed to me used that way.
Hope this helps! 🙂
how does the waterline differ by ethnicity? i can understand the lids but waterlines look all the same to me :-/
Before I say anything, it’s not recommended for the waterline, BUT I’ve found that MAC’s fluidlines stick VERY well. I’ve never had issues or irritation but again, it’s not recommended.
yes it does, i think some asian eyes look REALLY stuffy with their bottom waterlines lined.
I agree, I’m Asian and I don’t like lining my lower waterline but a MUA on youtube, gossmakeup, suggested lining the upper waterline and it looks really good. It makes my upper lashes look really thick.
smashbox works for me. I line my waterline every single day.
Hey, Chanel. The ones that work for me are MAC’s Technakohl eyeliners (I prefer either Graphblack or Photogravure). They just don’t get enough love: they’re twist-up, smooth, stay put, and are great for tightlining and waterlining. I’m Asian with small eyes and wear contacts, and I’ve got no problems. You just have to experiment with or w/o waterlined eyes. I love the Urban Decay’s 24/7s and Milani’s Liquif’eye, but they’re too creamy for the waterline.
Milani liquif’eye. Christine reviewed it and gave it an A+. It would stay for days if I never washed my face! Lol. Try that.
Sometimes…but never in black. Silver or gold!LOVE!
I don’t do it on my own and only had it done once or twice while getting my make up done at the counter…I wasn’t too crazy about how it looked on me.
Yup! I use Benefits Eye Bright!!
Never successfully. I can never seem to get any liner to apply to the waterline! Though I can’t ever get it on my eyelids well either, so I think there is so human error involved. : )
i try not to, because i actually had a major eye issue. this hasn’t stopped my passion for makeup though! i do everything but the waterline and tightline. 🙂
only if i’m doing a smoky eye. otherwise, i think it looks too harsh on me for everyday. plus, i often wear a winged liner on my upper lashline, and i find it looks better without liner anywhere on my under eye area.
funny… i remember my first experience with makeup was in the 7th grade, and that was me wearing just black eyeliner in my waterline everyday and nothing else. ::shudders:: oh, the naivety of youth! haha
OMG I thought I was the only one!!! XD
never, my eyes always get irritated 🙁
No because it means tugging on my lower lash when it comes to taking it off..that is def not someplace I want to start sagging in my 20s.
I do line my waterline on days that I want a more dramatic, dark eye. I found a technique that works fairly well for making the liner stay longer. I gently wipe my waterline with a qtip before applying gel liner with an angled brush, then I set the liner with black eyeshadow. It’s not perfect but I found it works the best, because gel liner seems to be more waterproof than any kohl liners I’ve tried.
Hope I helped 🙂
Sure do! Mine always lasts throughout the day and I often get things in my eye so they water a lot. I like to use Lise Watier’s eyeshine liners. Dior also has some waterproof liners with really good staying power. I try to only use black during the night but I like to use brown during the day. If I’m doing a light colour I tend to go for Benefit high brow. It gives you that white water line look but without being too harsh.
Yeah..
I do line my waterline. Guess it helps in making my eyes look bright and kinda opens up 🙂
Yes! My eyes are small, dark brown, and almond shaped, so I usually line on my actual lower lashline with colored pencils (the faves being marines,jades, greens, plumps)to create a subtle cateye. However, I am a huge fan of lining my wetline with lighter shades of white, gold, or clair kohl liners to really open up and brighten the whites of my eyes. It makes such a huge difference, especially in pictures.
I would like to, but my eyeliners don’t last on my waterline. I use gels, but are there better alternatives?
yes! all the time.
I never do it because I only line my upper eye line… if I do both I look gross!
Nope. It smudges all the time – literally within a minute of applying! I don’t think it’s worth it though. I only line my upper and lower lash lines, as it makes my eyes appear a bit bigger. Plus, flecks of eyeliner will smudge onto my eyeball if I line my waterline. Tightlining is very difficult because the skin on my upper lid is very thin, so there’s not much to really line. I used to really want to line my waterline, but now it seems inefficient and unnecessary in any of my looks.
Not usually – it closes up my eyes and makes them look very small. Once in awhile if I experiment with a smokey look, I might inadvertently do it, but I normally leave it as is. It’s healthier for the eyes too.
Never. It makes my eyes look tiny and beady — not a cute look. As a contacts wearer, it also doesn’t work very well. Plus, I don’t think it’s particularly good for my eyes, and I try to take care of them.
nope! tends to make my eyes look smaller and it doesn’t last more and a couple hours anyway, what’s the point?
Sometimes I do 🙂
I waterline with a white pencil liner for everyday.
I only waterline with dark gel liners (Bobbi Brown Black and Sepia gel liner has never failed me!) for occasions where I want to wear a more dramatic look.
Only for going out, not for day.
never! though it accentuates my naturals “cat-shaped” eyes it also makes them look smaller and I prefer my eyes to look big.
Yes, I do from time to time. For example I like to put Urban Decay’s Electric Glide-on Pencil as a colorpop. 🙂
Yes, whenever I do my eyes, I line the water line (more than the lower lashline). If not, I feel the makeup is unfinished…
Exactly how I feel too!….about my makeup being “unfinished” that is 🙂
I line my (bottom) waterline with MAC Technakohl in Photograuve, and it stays on relatively well. The key is to not line it too darkly, that way it stays put. I also find that it helps if you apply a bit of loose powder around the bottom of the eye to “set” it and prevent it from being too watery.
Often, either with black or brown Kohl.
You should try the Astor Eye Artist Kajal!! Its absolutely phenomenal! I have long harboured dislike for the brand, but recently they’ve been turning it around & keep on discovering sensational products.
I don’t because it doesn’t stay!
almost never…with my contacts and dry eyes it’s sadly a bit of a nightmare…it gets all over my lenses! actually, that happens enough with it simply on the lash line, so why exacerbate the situation?
I don’t, since I’m wearing glasses all the time, which make my eyes look ~15% smaller – so when I’m lining my waterline, it makes them look even smaller, and really, I don’t want my eyes to disappear under my glasses! 😀 Also I’m looking quite emo…
Not very often. I don’t like that it shrinks my eyes so I usually just do the lashline instead
ALWAYS! With something light for day make up, otherwise dark.
Yes !! Any liner works for my waterline .I use UD’s 24/7 but I used sephora’s and max factor’s in the past and they all worked great.
always
If I’m going out, I do…otherwise, I think it looks too harsh on me. I don’t use black when I do it, either; I try to stick to khaki, bronze or brown, using any kind of “liquid pencil” type liner. Surprisingly, Prestige (a drugstore brand) Total Intensity pencils stick around for quite awhile and are super-easy to apply.
Yes! All the time! I used either dipdown or blacktrack fluidline and set it with a bit of black or brown eyeshadow and it stays all day
Yes indeedy! I use a fine line smashbox bent tip eyeliner brush and any gel eyeliner ( favorite is Bobbi Brown) , but I also pack 24/7 pencils for travel. I use Black, dark brown, dark blue and recently picked up a Pixi for Target pencil in a dreamy Teal.
I do on occasion, it irritates my eyes so I try not to.
I don’t line my waterline, though I used to in high school. I have small eyes so it’s just not a flattering look on me, as it makes them look even smaller. Instead, I line the outer third of my lower lash line.
On rare occasions I’ll line my water line with white but it never stays on longer than an hr. So I mostly just line the lids. I wear a winged liner everyday(well everyday that I do make up) tho.
Always, I think it helps make me look more awake. I use MACS fluidline and dap a tad of shadow. This usually lasts all day, I am also a contact wearer and it does not bother them.
I never do. I have small eyes and I think lining the waterline makes eyes look smaller. I usually just line my top to make my eye look more open.
I try, and sometimes I feel like it gets in my eyes and I wear contacts, so my eyes feel blurry?
The only liner that hasn’t done that so far was Tarte emphasEYES, and I can never get any liner to last long on my water line!!! But it looks so cool. 🙁
only for going out at night and only with Mac’s kohl eyeliner that’s waterline-safe cuz i won’t use anything that’s not approved for waterlines or else it’ll sting my eyes (and i wear contacts). it’s hard to get the color to stick, though, and fades soon after. maybe my waterline is too watery? i wonder how some people manage intense black lines on theirs without fading???
Stila Kajal liner in Onyx is amazing on the waterline. It does smudge, but not unless you touch it. I put it on last, and the boldness never gets watery or rinses off with tears. It is my fave, if they stop making it, I will cry!!!
Yes, I line the inner rim every single day. I have large, round eyes and it gives the illusion of a more almond shape eye. My routine pretty much lasts all day except for the outer corner area where no liner will ever stay. I use a Mally waterproof pencil first and I usually go over the area with the pencil twice and then I use a Stila smudgepot on top of that.
No, i have small eyes and that would make them tiny!
Never. Not even with smokey eyes. Just doesn’t look good on me.
I always use MakeupForever Aqua liner in black.. I dry off my waterline with a qtip and then set with mac carbon. its literally lasted me an entire night out at the bars, and then still looked perfect the next morning.. unbelieveable.
That’s the only place I put eyeliner. I find that Urban Decay 24/7 Zero works best and actually stays on the waterline.
No 70%
Yes 30% : remove moist with q-tip then use gel liner or pencil.
i dont usually use eyeliner but more often than not i’ll line my water line and lower lashline and forgo the upper line just cuz its a pain! i know it’s a major nono according to bobbi brown but i could really care less haha. it does tend to smudge on me sometimes though so i don’t do it a lot.
No. It irritates my eyes.
in my teenage years, i don’t anymore now
of course.
Sometimes I do
I love to, really makes my brown eyes pop nicely, but it doesn’t always stay. Smashbox gel liner used to work like a charm but the pot dried up :(. Tarte, BB, Zero, MAC kohl- all smudge. It’s a neverending quest for me.
I like the look of a lines waterline, but I rarely do it because any makeup that gets in my eyes makes my contacts very uncomfortable. Mostly, I use my UD247 pencil, but I may try MAC fluidline next.
Yes sometimes, depends on the look… But I don’t wear black! I feel is too much for my eye… I use MAC Coffee Pencil!
I actually prefer lining my waterline than my lash line, it’s more subtle that way and it makes my eyes look bigger. I find a khol liner pencil or khol powder stays put no matter what, especially the khol liners of Guerlain.
Only with white. As I got older I noticed my eyes got smaller. My lashes got skimpier. This OPENS my up and makes my upper lashes stand out more instead of competing with them. 🙂
I never line my waterline unless I am doing a smokey eye. I have relatively large eyes (not like Christina Ricci large), but lining my waterline seems to close them off — and not in a good way. I do line my upper waterline to make my lashes look thicker, though!
Sometimes I’ll line it halfway, but most often I don’t because it makes my eyes look smaller. I already have big eyes, but I love for them to look even bigger!
I do, but only with white eyeliner, so I guess that doesn’t count. White liner, paired with darker liner on my lower lashline, makes my eyes definitely larger and brighter. Dark liner on my waterline just makes me look tired/mean with small eyes. Even with smokey eyes, I avoid the waterline!
All the time, but not with black, with gold/brown/burgundy tones. It makes a big difference but is not harsh looking. I like MAC’s Kohl Power pencils and Loreal HIP loose kohl (I wanna try Guerlain but can’t afford it yet!).
I never put liner on my waterline- it makes my eyes looks smaller, and I wear contacts. It’s one of those things that looks good on some people but not others, in my opinion.
Yes, I do, but I have the same problem with it not lasting. I just assume I still look okay without my waterline done 😀
I do everytime I do a night look, i use fluidline and my smashbox bent liner brush and it stays on very well.
sometimes i do. i do when i don’t feel like lining my eyes and just wanna wear mascara. i i love mufe’s aqua eyes!
Yup yup yup. Not supposed to now because of contacts but oh well haha.
I line my upper waterline and the outer 1/3 of my lower waterline. I have small-ish eyes and wear glasses, and my eyes COMPLETELY disappear without it!!
Plus, I’m a huge fan of doing my makeup in seconds (I’m a high-school student) so usually my eyes just get eyeliner, mascara, and a quick hilight.
I always do, with my pencil liner. I have deep-set eyes & if I put it on the lash line it looks far too low on my face.
I usually don’t line my waterline, but if I make a smokey eye i love to do it. so it depends of the occasion.
NO
hello from rainy Greece!i line my waterline everyday but it doesn’t last more than an hour(sometimes half an hour)..in your opinion,is there any brand that lasts more(without smudging)?? p.s. on july 30,i asked you if you could recommend me quality blue-based red lipsticks(under 40$) that suit to my fair/pale skin(+brown eyes+blond hair)..and i just found out you answered me..sorry!in Greece i have access to:l’oreal,max factor,Bourjois,dior,chanel,clinique,lancome,estee lauder,revlon,korres(!),pupa,clarins,make up forever,maybelline,sephora,shiseido,Yves Saint Laurent and mac(not very easily)..
No, I do not line the waterline. I believe it makes my eyes look smaller.
Yes to lower waterline, no to upper. It’s too hard to do upper waterline!
I agree, sometimes it’s too ticklish for me. gotta make sure your mascara is dry before you do it too
No, it makes my eyes look smaller.
Sometimes only if I want a dramatic effect.
Nope, makes eyes appear smaller and makes my round-ish eyes rounder, a big no-no for me.
Nope. Makes eyes look smaller and who wants that?
I would say that I line my waterline 9 times out of 10. I prefer the look of dark liner on the waterline (even if it doesn’t last all day) and a medium toned shadow on the lower lash line. I get raccoon eyes if I line my lower lash line with a dark pencil liner.
I use a pencil liner. I like Avon gel eyeliner pencil in steel. which is silvery/grey color.
I really don’t like to look of black on the waterline… It makes eyes look creepily defined and gerbil-ish, in my opinion. I like the look of big bright eyes, so I use white on the waterline.
There’s a word for the lower inner lash line? I learn something new every day!
I like the look, but only with certain shadows. And I agree, it doesn’t last long – it slides down onto the lower lash line and good luck trying to make it behave after that. I will definitely have to try this Fluidline you ladies are talking about – it would be my first MAC purchase! I’ll have to brave the icky MAC counter for once.
NARS black eyeliner works well but isn’t perfect; same result with Urban Decay’s 24/7 liner. I hardly ever try anymore, because I feel like pulling and prodding my eyelids will only do serious damage (aging, lines, tissue damage etc) down the road. Plus black eyeliner generally makes your eyes look smaller – not larger, as I think people who use it intend.
I only use it to define my eyes a little when using shadows that could otherwise make you look tired – Urban Decay shadow in Baked comes to mind.
This has always been my #1 most-pondered beauty issue. Thank you for posting it!! I will be reading all the above comments for advice 🙂
everytime i make up
I’ve just begun to do this more and more. I normally waterline when I’m wearing black liner, but sometimes I’ll do another color. I always use UD 24/7 pencils, because they just work for me. I *gently* blot my waterline with a piece of paper towel (no shredding or leaving behind pieces of anything) and then I immediately waterline that eye. The 24/7 pencils stay on my waterline until I remove it.