ColourPop Just My Luck Eyeshadow Palette ($12.00) is a new, permanent all-green palette that joins the brand’s line-up of 9-pan palettes. There are four shimmers and five mattes within the palette, and I’d say three are very warm-toned, three are more neutral-to-warm, and three are cooler-toned. Here are swatches!
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
31 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our
comment policy may be
removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to
participate respectfully.
Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an
off-topic question, or need technical support, please
contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above
for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't
answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but
will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when
a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set
expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up
being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Next day from CP? That’s amazing! Took them more than a week just to get mine shipped. Abysmal.
kjh
Boy, would I like to jump on this right away! But, thankfully itās perm. Have the feeling that since I just adore green, itāll probably wind up pretty duped. Go, CP, and thanks!
Mel
I’m impressed! I might get this palette solely because of its mattes.
Oh wow! This is an amazing St. Patrickās Day palette! I especially love Olive U and Charmed, but I donāt think Iād get much use out of the other shades and I probably have dupes for the two shades I love. So I am going to have to give this lovely green palette a pass.
I have Melt Smoke Sessions but I may still pick this up. I think they look different enough to justify having both and love the small size for traveling. Ah heck I have Huda’s Emerald palette so I may pass too.
Shawne
So excited ColourPop released this! Canāt wait to see your review and Iām glad itās permanent so I can pick it up whenever.
I’m in to charmed really hard and hope it’s a single at some point.
Sandy
Bought it as soon as it came out…if it’s as good as the purple one, I’ll be happy! I don’t have many greens at all except for Absinthe, which is beautiful but not a ton of green.
@Christina I swear I live for eyeshadow but I’m not good at choosing the best shades to combine (might be due to my massive collection ?) so I’m always on the hunt for pictorials or video tutorials of eyeshadow looks. I love the amazing looks you come up with! Have you ever thought of including a step by step pictorial or video tutorials for the looks you create such as above?
Sorry, I don’t have the time to do tutorials (I’m already woefully behind just trying to stay afloat, though mostly drowning, with the blog)! I list where each shade is placed for each look because my technique doesn’t change much from look to look, and I have detailed photos + instructions of that process here: https://www.temptalia.com/how-to-apply-eyeshadow-eye-makeup-tutorial/
I think this is Colour Pop’s answer to the Melt Smoke palette. And it looks pretty good too. As to whether I will get this one, depends on the review. It certainly is inexpensive.
Katherine T.
I got this as soon as it launched! YAY, brands are FINALLY hearing our pleas for green palettes -this one looks great and you can’t beat the $12 price!! Christine, hope it performs well, I know your’re a fiend for green shadows, so let’s hope other brands follow suit š
Very cute with St. Patrick’s Day approaching but for the most part, the only greens I wear are sludge-y greens or gold greens, so Olive-U and 50-50 appeal to me but I never do a completely green look so I’ll look for dupes in my stash for those 2 shades. But this palette will be a real boon for those who love very full on green e/s looks.
Over the years I acquired several green singles from LancĆ“me, Nyx, and Kryolan so I donāt think I need this. I had bought Emily Wants for the greens but discovered that the green shades there were too murky for me.
Kermit the frog skin… perhaps slight exaggeration ? Greens are so challenging for me. I bought the huda palette because I literally hade no green eyeshadows and I rarely wear it. This looks like a very affordable palette with a balanced mix of temperature, but not for me.
Cute. Kiss My Hass, Act Natural, and Big Banks are too close in color to each other (and I know that the latter is a shimmer, but it could still stand to vary a bit more). I think they could have nailed this by giving Big Banks a blue duochrome, and by making either KMH or AC more of a murky, warm, greyed sage color. Still … pigmentation looks excellent.
I wonder how some of these greens translate for blue eyes. It’s a nice selection and you can’t! beat! the! price! But the greens do seem very blue-leaning and I’m not sure I know how I would use all of them.
These are SERIOUSLY the best looking matte green eyeshadows I’ve ever seen. Like; my jaw needs to be picked up off the floor! I do have Huda Emerald and am buying CR Safari Raine, so those 2 likely cover me in the green family…. I think? Oh heck! Y’all know I’ll probably grab this one up at some point, too. ?
I didn’t think I would like a green themed palette but it is very pretty. I saw a tutorial on youtube and it looks really nice and easy to work with. I also like the look you did too. I loved their it’s my pleasure palette, I love purple it’s my favorite color.
I ordered my palette on 03/08/19. As of this afternoon, the order is still processing. It will be shipped eventually. I’m sure with any of shipments for new products there is some delay.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get
behind and appreciate your patience! š If you have general feedback,
product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please
contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
I ordered this yesterday and got the shipping notification today! Nice to see the swatches look good.
Next day from CP? That’s amazing! Took them more than a week just to get mine shipped. Abysmal.
Boy, would I like to jump on this right away! But, thankfully itās perm. Have the feeling that since I just adore green, itāll probably wind up pretty duped. Go, CP, and thanks!
I’m impressed! I might get this palette solely because of its mattes.
Oh wow! This is an amazing St. Patrickās Day palette! I especially love Olive U and Charmed, but I donāt think Iād get much use out of the other shades and I probably have dupes for the two shades I love. So I am going to have to give this lovely green palette a pass.
Very pretty bu since I have Melt Smoke Sessions Iām passing.
And see, since I missed out on Smoke Sessions I purchased! Very happy for the less expensive alternative!
I have Melt Smoke Sessions but I may still pick this up. I think they look different enough to justify having both and love the small size for traveling. Ah heck I have Huda’s Emerald palette so I may pass too.
So excited ColourPop released this! Canāt wait to see your review and Iām glad itās permanent so I can pick it up whenever.
Is that a dupe from Huda?
So excited for this one!
I’m in to charmed really hard and hope it’s a single at some point.
Bought it as soon as it came out…if it’s as good as the purple one, I’ll be happy! I don’t have many greens at all except for Absinthe, which is beautiful but not a ton of green.
@Christina I swear I live for eyeshadow but I’m not good at choosing the best shades to combine (might be due to my massive collection ?) so I’m always on the hunt for pictorials or video tutorials of eyeshadow looks. I love the amazing looks you come up with! Have you ever thought of including a step by step pictorial or video tutorials for the looks you create such as above?
Sorry, I don’t have the time to do tutorials (I’m already woefully behind just trying to stay afloat, though mostly drowning, with the blog)! I list where each shade is placed for each look because my technique doesn’t change much from look to look, and I have detailed photos + instructions of that process here: https://www.temptalia.com/how-to-apply-eyeshadow-eye-makeup-tutorial/
I think this is Colour Pop’s answer to the Melt Smoke palette. And it looks pretty good too. As to whether I will get this one, depends on the review. It certainly is inexpensive.
I got this as soon as it launched! YAY, brands are FINALLY hearing our pleas for green palettes -this one looks great and you can’t beat the $12 price!! Christine, hope it performs well, I know your’re a fiend for green shadows, so let’s hope other brands follow suit š
Thank you for reinstating the buttons for Previous and Next posts!
Looks like a dupe for Melt Cosmetics Smoke Sessions palette.
This is perfect for St. Patrick’s Day on the 17th š
Very cute with St. Patrick’s Day approaching but for the most part, the only greens I wear are sludge-y greens or gold greens, so Olive-U and 50-50 appeal to me but I never do a completely green look so I’ll look for dupes in my stash for those 2 shades. But this palette will be a real boon for those who love very full on green e/s looks.
Over the years I acquired several green singles from LancĆ“me, Nyx, and Kryolan so I donāt think I need this. I had bought Emily Wants for the greens but discovered that the green shades there were too murky for me.
Kermit the frog skin… perhaps slight exaggeration ? Greens are so challenging for me. I bought the huda palette because I literally hade no green eyeshadows and I rarely wear it. This looks like a very affordable palette with a balanced mix of temperature, but not for me.
Cute. Kiss My Hass, Act Natural, and Big Banks are too close in color to each other (and I know that the latter is a shimmer, but it could still stand to vary a bit more). I think they could have nailed this by giving Big Banks a blue duochrome, and by making either KMH or AC more of a murky, warm, greyed sage color. Still … pigmentation looks excellent.
I wonder how some of these greens translate for blue eyes. It’s a nice selection and you can’t! beat! the! price! But the greens do seem very blue-leaning and I’m not sure I know how I would use all of them.
These are SERIOUSLY the best looking matte green eyeshadows I’ve ever seen. Like; my jaw needs to be picked up off the floor! I do have Huda Emerald and am buying CR Safari Raine, so those 2 likely cover me in the green family…. I think? Oh heck! Y’all know I’ll probably grab this one up at some point, too. ?
Your eye look is everything! That and the swatches made me order this. It’s so, so great to see a stunning all-green palette.
I didn’t think I would like a green themed palette but it is very pretty. I saw a tutorial on youtube and it looks really nice and easy to work with. I also like the look you did too. I loved their it’s my pleasure palette, I love purple it’s my favorite color.
How beautiful is this?? I am going to have to pick this up sometime.
I ordered this as soon as I saw iton Trendmood! Iām so glad it seems to swatch beautifully!
I ordered my palette on 03/08/19. As of this afternoon, the order is still processing. It will be shipped eventually. I’m sure with any of shipments for new products there is some delay.