Do you throw out your makeup when you should? Do you toss mascara after 2-3 months? Do you throw away old lipsticks and gloss? Or do you hang on to ’em? Store things in the fridge?
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
actually…….no haha
I usually throw make up out when it changes colour/ smells bad or changes consistency…
But if not..I keep it untill it’s all gone haha 😀
I can’t bear to throw out my favorite lipstick!
CiaoOo Marieke
i throw out mascara and old face product but i keep eyeshadow, lippies, and blush until it smells or runs out.
I second this!
Unless it smells or goes a bit funny then no! Usually with Mascara it goes dry within 3-month time limit, as I wear it nearly every day so I follow that one!
No, definitely not within the recommended timeframe, I have lipsticks as old as 6-7-8 yrs. But I have recently thrown out some old stuff, partly because they were smelly, partly because I hadn’t use them for a long time and I have so much new stuff anyway. My sister also benefited from my clear out (not the yucky things though). 🙂
Not if it’s eyeshadow or lip products. I actually have an eyeshadow palette that my mom gave me when I was like 8 years old (I’m 22 now) and all of the eyeshadows are still in good condition, it sorta confuses me.
If it’s old and smells bad, I’ll scoop out the product, and keep the plastic containers so I can back to mac it.
i dont throw them out like im supposed to. i guess i dont wear makeup often enough to use them in time so i hold onto stuff forever. if it doesnt look or smell bad, no need in wasting it.
Mascara goes every three months, because I use it up fairly regularly and by the end of three months (sometimes two, even) my mascara of the moment is almost gone anyway. Plus it’s the most bacteria-loving of cosmetics. Foundation, powder, and concealer don’t stick around enough to go bad, because I use them regularly. Things like gloss and lipstick only get tossed when they go really and truly bad, which could be years. And I have yet to have a powder blush or shadow go bad on me, but if it ever happens, I’ll throw them out (and replace!). Otherwise, it’s a waste of an investment.
Mascara is the only thing I toss within 3 months, because I have very sensitive eyes and often mascaras don’t work so well for me past three months anyway. Everything else I throw out only when it goes bad (changes smell, texture or colour).
I exchance my mascara every 3 month, meaning 1th of January, April, July and October.
Till now I have never thrown away an eye shadow or other powdery product, but I check my lip products and if there is a change in the smell or consistency I put it in my little basket and bac2mac it.
Sorry if this is a stupid question, but what is “Back 2 Mac”? I’ve seen it on my Mac e/s boxes, but don’t actually know what it means.
It’s a program where you can exchange empty MAC containers (the plastic packaging, not the paper boxes) for a free lipstick (or, at some stores, a lipglass or eyeshadow, depending on the MA/store policy). In the US it’s six empty packagings for one lipstick, it may be more than that elsewhere.
To be honest, aside from Mascara, I don’t actually throw anything out. Sometimes I don’t even throw out Mascaras after 3 months, but those are the colored ones which I rarely use. But if I notice stuff looking weird and whatnots I throw them out. But otherwise it’s kind of wasting them a little. haha.
I agree with the majority of folks in here…
Powders, shadows & lip products hang on until they just look wrong.
But I do replace my mascara, and liquid eyeliner every 3 months.
Anything that’s liquid and prone to bacteria accumulation very close to the eyes get the boot.
Only my mascara…I have very sensitive eyes. Those go in the trash 3 months later to the day. The only exception is if I have one that I only wear rarely, I give it an extra month or so. But my daily wear ones get TOSSED.
No, I certainly don’t throw out things within the “recommended” timeframe. I think the only people recommending this are the cosmetic companies themselves. Sort of like the built-in obsolescence of newer appliances.
No. I throw out makeup when it’s empty/close to empty, or I’ve used it a lot (getting old). For example, if a mascara is 3 months old, and I’ve only used it twice, I’m not going to throw it out.
I throw out mascara after 3-4 months (if it hasn’t already dried up) and chuck lipglosses & liquid liner away after about a year. I keep powder eyeshadow,blush and mineral foundation until it’s finished though! Although my foundation normally only lasts a year anyway :o)
I try to hold on to as much product as I can -they do cost a fortune anyway!- but that being said, I also do throw them away when they need to be thrown away. Mascara lasts up to 6 months MAX (they rarely ever do since I use them daily), but that’s about it. I go through powders and concealers fastest, so I don’t worry about their expiration dates. As for the rest, I smell and reconsider 😛 It sounds so unhygienic but it somewhat works for me 🙂
I definitely do not. I probably should but i haven’t gotten any fungi or anything yet LOL (knock on wood). I do throw out mascara after a while though, like a couple of years old just because it always seems to clump.
No, unless it’s smells funny, changes color, or I am definitely not using it, I don’t.
I only throw out mascara frequently. I use mineral makeup for my face and am careful with that but if do use any liquid/cream face products I throw them out whenever I feel like I’ve had them too long…haha, that was really specific wasn’t it? Lipstick, gloss etc. I keep until they change color, consistency or smell.
nope never! lol
i toss them out when the lipstick tastes bad( usu rancid ..ugh)
mascaras i toss when they get clumpy which is usu before 3 months.. i really cant find a good mascara that i totally love.. the closest is Maybelline lash discovery
no, like everybody else, only when it changes in smell, consistency, color. but i also hate seeing makeup go to waste because they’re not being used. i know some of my e/s will take me years to finish them or if i have a couple of cream blushes of similar color, i would make an inventory and give the ones i can really let go to my teenage nieces. i have three so i’m sure they will use them up and i don’t have to worry about anything going to waste.
Other than mascara, I don’t even know what the “expiry date” is for other things. Mascara gets tossed/Back to Mac when it starts getting clumpy.
I usually throw it away for one of the following reasons:
1. I don’t like it.
2. It breaks me out of I have another type of reaction to it.
3. It changes color or consistency.
4. It smells horrible.
5. I find a product that does the same thing only better!
I like to use a product up completely. The expiration date is probably way overdue.
No, no and no! LOL I don’t believe that stuff since I NEVER share my makeup stuff. I only swtached one colors and give them to my closed ones when I don’t like how they look on my skin. Second, I own a lot makeup, but I don’t put them on my face often; I’m lazy. (I mostly own eye shadows, lips)
And the mascara, they do clump after a while. But some of the mascaras I bought state that 9M or 12M after opening, so I got no problem. However, I really think that cosmetics comapny put new formulas into mascaras so that they clump after a while. C’mon, liquid shadow=reaching into the wand every time you use it, but they last much longer..?
Bottom line: I throw it away when it’s becoming bad or smells horrible.
No way… i luv my makeup too much! except when it is empty, but it still makes me sad to see them in the garbage. Anyway, last makeup that i threw away was from.. CLINIQUE and INGLOT. not because of the smell or anything, but because it started giving me pimples.
Nope. I get rid of mascara when it’s gone or it starts to change consistency/dry out. Usually not more than 6 months. I have an ice blue lipstick from middle school (circa ’98) that hasn’t dried out yet. I throw out icky colors or stuff I never use, unless I think I might use it for costume/stage makeup.
Masacara, definitely, but now that I have some of the Urban Decay Big Fatty Colored mascaras,I’m kinda hesitant because there’s no way I’ll use thme upin 3 months. I’ll play it by ear. For everything else, it gets tossed if I notice a funny smell or change in consistency.
can you back to mac mascaras? or is it only eyeshadows and lipsticks?
I believe you can B2M mascaras.
i totally jus bought my first mac eyeshadows today at the mall! im soo excited.. but idont have any to throw out yet.
Unless it’s mascara, no.