65 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Amanda Avatar

AGREEED! (caps are also necessary here!)

Seriously – Amazing Concealer is the best. It covers what NO OTHER concealer I’ve tried will cover! Love love love!

Elizabeth Avatar

I just got Amazing because I’ve never found a good concealer, and the girl at Sephora recommended this. It’s a pretty good match for my skin and covers more than other stuff I’ve tried. But I think there’s something wrong with my technique, since it’s not perfect coverage. Any hints or tips?

Kate Avatar

Cle de Peau, hands down. It is worth every penny if you have really horrible hereditary circles like I do. Been using it for 5 years and still love it!

Claire Avatar

I would say Full Cover by Make Up For ever which hides my rednesses on my very pale skin
And as a makeup student I really like the 5 cream concealers palettes (I think it’s pro only) by Make Up Forever too
And the Touche Eclat in shade 2 is great on dark circles when you mix it with concealer

Priscilla Avatar

Under my eyes: Laura Mercier corrector, concealer, and setting powder. I’m calling them all concealer because they all go in the same area.

Cle de Peau concealer everywhere else. Acne prone skin and acne scars.

Fro Gord Avatar

Soap and Glory Kick Ass Concealer! It comes with one under eye shade and one redness/pimple shade, plus translucent setting power and a mirror, all in a handy little compact and for 10 pounds! I think the brand is coming to Sephora in the US in the future…

Alejandra Avatar

I second this.It’s the most pigmented concealer I have found.You have to work a little with the formula, but the results it yields are impressive.

k8r8r Avatar

Simply Ageless Concealer (Corrector) by Covergirl (!!!) totally neutralizes my bluish-purple under eye discoloration. It has good pigment, but is nearly undetectable. It’s light-weight and stays put!

Amanda Finlaw Avatar

I use the Cover FX cream foundation as a concealer and it gives wonderful coverage for dark circles, but it definitely creases. Their liquid concealer is good as well, but I wouldn’t consider it full coverage.

Jennifer Spears Avatar

I like dermablend….and I’ve tried a billion concealers for these allergic, hereditary dark circles. Smooth Indulgence Concealer SPF 20 in almond.

Teresa Avatar

GLO Camouflage! I’ve tried so so many concealers and color correctors to cover old pigmented acne scars and discolorations. I was very surprised that Glo Minerals offered as much coverage as it does. Their undereye concealer is great too!

Omta Avatar

MAC studiofinish definitely, it is creamy and just glides on and you don’t even need to use that much to get a great coverage. It doesn’t crease if you use a little bit and set it with a bit of powder.

Mariella Avatar

Another vote for It Cosmetics. When I first got it, I didn’t like it at all but I’ve learned to work with it and it is one of the best under-eye concealers I’ve got.

Kristabelle Avatar

Kat Von D Tattoo Concealer. I use it for both undereye and on blemishes/redness/dark spots. A tiny bit goes such a long way, it’s amazing.

QuinnFace Blog Avatar

I’m partial to a few, but the best I think I’ve found so far is Laura Mercier Secret Camouflage. It’s so light but has such good coverage, it’s kinda magical. And it comes with two colors so its super versatile.

Ana Avatar

Haven’t found my HG concealer yet. I have oily skin but my under eye area is particularly dry. Most of the concealers I’ve tried (High End and Drugstore) leave me with dry flaky skin which leads to the concealer to look very obvious and unflattering. For blemishes I use Vichy’s Dermablend. Is a miracle product if you find a color that matches your skin tone (I mix 025 Nude and 035 Sand to get my perfect color). For my under eye area I use Lancome’s Effarcernes which is the less drying on my skin but doesn’t hide the under eye circles that well.

Susan Nevling Avatar

I think you need a different product for under eye. Not a true concealer. Have someone help you at a makeup counter. You use a tiny amount and pat with your small finger to blend. YSL Touche Eclat makes a nice one but there are others that are not as expensive.

Andrea Avatar

I love MUFE HD for covering blemishes but I would have to say hands down, MAC Prolongwear concealer because I can use it under my eyes as well.

dtan0914 Avatar

Kevyn Aucoin The Sensual Skin Enhancer! Had a demo of it at the Kevyn Aucoin counter at Barneys NY in Beverly Hills and bought it right away. Don’t know how I lived without it before. Using it now I save money on my expensive foundations (like Hourglass or Giorgio Armani) because I don’t have to use as much. Worth every single penny!

Lily M Avatar

MUFE full coverage is the best , water resistant for my watery eyes . Little horas a long way , give me a coverage that last forever seriously ! 😀

Terri Avatar

I like Cle de Peau concealer although the price tag almost gave me a heart attack when I bought it and still makes me cringe when I think about it. But. My 46 year old face appreciates that it covers where it needs to, stays put and does NOT cling to wrinkles/loose skin. It’s texture has to be felt to understand!!!

MrsWASP Avatar

Amazing Cosmetics.

It covers everything completely, {including my tattoo} while still managing to be light and does not crease.

I’ve even mixed it with my moisturizer and made a breathable full coverage foundation out of it.

And that tube that’s the travel size? Lasts me a whole year.

Why would anyone ever buy another concealer after this?

It’s honestly the best one on the market.

Christine Avatar

Amazing concealer is long time holy grail but love cle de peak for versatility- use onlids to cover discolorations and as cream shadow highliter. Stays in makeup bag. Armani maestro concealer is pretty nice for coverage and light weight texture.

Brittany Avatar

When i worked at sephora the FULLEST coverage out of all the concealers was hands down MUFE full cover. I used it to cover tattoos or for clients who had particularly bad dark circles. Only problem is that it dries fairly quickly and is not good for super dry skin! I’ve recently found an inexpensive dupe though, Hard Candy Glamoflauge concealer! Its under $10!!

Trillium Avatar

My current favorite is Smashbox HD. It’s a liquid, and for me it covers and blends out the best without looking flaky or obvious on my skin. It also has a shade I can wear, as a very fair coolish toned person. TheBalm Timebalm is pretty good too. I’ve been on a concealer hunt lately though, still looking for the perfect one I feel like.

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!