29 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Dominique Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring: medium/fair

■Best beauty gift you’ve received? “Diorissimo” from my mother a very long time ago

■Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? So many, it’s so hard to answer this !

■Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Maybe Serge Lutens ” Iris Silver Mist ” perfume but actually none because I have so many beauty products !

Raquel Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring – yellow/ light-medium
Best beauty gift you’ve received? my all time favorite perfume, for her by narciso rodriguez
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? i dont tend to give beauty gifts..
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? a clarisonic mia (a lavender one, if possible!)

Arden Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light
Best beauty gift you’ve received? My Clarisonic Mia!
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? Can’t really think of one, but I love introducing people to new beauty products.
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Hmm something I couldn’t justify buying myself, like the naked palette.

Marian Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/Warm ■Best beauty gift you’ve received? Chanel Illusion d’Ombre in Mirifique and Fantasme
■Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? The MAC Barbie collection to my daughter
■Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? a Clarins collection

Cat G Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fairly light with yellow undertones
Best beauty gift you’ve received? I can’t choose! I ALWAYS ask for makeup!
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? Probably Clinique 3-step!
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Guerlain Meteorites!!! Or Guerlain Turandot!

Bernadette Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: very fair
Best beauty gift you’ve received? Chanel No. 5
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? brown crocodile train case from Marshall Field’s (it was that long ago!)
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? An enormous Sephora gift card, probably

Lauren Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light-Medium (around NC30)
Best beauty gift you’ve received? Not sure.
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? The Sephora Deluxe Fragrance Sampler set. It has 10 adorable mini-sized bottles of fragrance and a certificate to redeem for a full size perfume. I gave it to my Mom and it was fantastic.
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? An incredibly generous Sephora gift card. 😉

Joyce Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: light to medium with yellow undertones, black hair, dark brown eyes
Best beauty gift you’ve received? Chanel Dragon Rouge Allure Laque!
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? Hmm maybe Stila Backstage Palette. A Christmas gift for my mother-in-law. She has repeatedly told me how much she loves it because it’s colors she uses and lasts all day! She carries it around everywhere also!
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Hmm something I’d use but would never buy for myself. Maybe a Le Métier de Beaute kaleidoscope?

Sabriel Avatar

Coloring: Black/brown eyes, chestnut hair, roughly NW20.
Best beauty gift, received: A book about hair braiding, from my boyfriend who noticed me looking for tutorials online.
Favorite beauty gift, given: A set of eco-tools brushes to somebody used to using the applicators that come in drugstore compacts.
Beauty gift, wished for: Hmm. Hard to think of things so soon after Christmas. I still feel quite thankful for what I recently received.

Georgie Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC/NW20
Best beauty gift you’ve received? Illamasqua Bronzer (I don’t get many beauty gifts – bad times)
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? I’ve given lots of beauty gifts!
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? LMDB quad or Guerlain Liu palette

Mirian Avatar

Skin tone: vampire pale with neutral/cool undertones

best beauty gift received: probably guerlain turandot palette

favorite beauty gift given: hmm bare minerals the rare find for my mom

beauty gift i wish someone would give me: this is hard because i received everything i wanted! I guess I would say the tom ford lip color gift set from neiman marcus because it’s super indulgent. that or Maison Francis Kurkdjian Oud or Serge Lutens Bois de Violette EDP

Tennyoceres Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring:
MAC NC25 (aka pale Asian)

Best beauty gift you’ve received?
My sister-in-law got me a Clarisonic PLUS set this Christmas. I used it as soon as I could. How did my beauty routine go without this for so long?!

Favorite beauty gift you’ve given?
I gave my sister-in-law the Sephora Pantone eyeshadow set as a graduation gift. Now she has every interview and work friendly shade possible for her career in nursing.

Beauty gift you wish someone would give you?
Clarins 230 (aka Unicorn Pee aka HOW MUCH for a bottle of nail polish)

Mariella Avatar

Skintone/colouring: Fair, cool-toned
Best beauty gift I’ve received: probably Chanel Illusoire Illusion d’Ombre shadow (last year)
Best beauty gift I’ve given: Clarins facial oil to a friend I knew would love it and use it
Beauty gift I wish someone would give me: Bare Minerals The Finer Things palette (even before it sold out, it wasn’t available here!) or the Lorac Pro Palette (I got Star Treatment instead and I’m thrilled with it but still hankering after the Lorac palette!)

Jennie Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: very fair
Best beauty gift you’ve received? My fave perfume (MAC MV2 – discontinued)
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? A MAC lipstick palette
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? A gift card for Sephora

Liza Avatar

■Your skin tone/coloring: fair/light
■Best beauty gift you’ve received? a gift set my husband got me, makeup bag filled with a ton of brushes & makeup. It was the best because he didnt just get me a gift certificate, he was thoughtful and did research and picked something out for me.
■Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? I gave my cousin a pro bag when she decided she wanted to become a MUA & a lip tar set
■Beauty gift you wish someone would give you?
Honestly, I have been very fortunate. People have been very generous with me, and I am amazed how many wonderful beauty gifts I get. Especially this year, I got a ton of great stuff for my bday & xmas.

Michelle Teixeira Avatar

I have olive tan dry skin. My fave beauty gift I received was Mally Evercolor Poreless defender from my hubby. My fave beauty gift given would be a complete set of Juicy Couture fragrance to my Mum. I wish someone would get me Pumpkin and Poppy cosmetics a full collection line called One Ring.

Cheyanne Avatar

Skin tone/coloring: Olive-y
Best Beauty Gift I’ve Received: Naked Palette
Best Beauty Gift I’ve Given: MAC Lipgloss
Beauty Gift I Wish Someone Would Give Me: Anything, honestly! lol

Nikki Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC50

Best beauty gift you’ve received? GHD Flat Iron (given by my favorite uncle three yrs ago for Christmas)

Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? La Femme blushes; I fell in love with them as soon as I tried them, so I bought some for my sister soon after so she could experience their excellence too!

Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? UD Naked 2 Palette; I don’t wear eyeshadow often so I hate to buy it with my own money, but I’m infatuated with all the beautiful neutrals in the set. If I received it as a gift, I think I’d be more motivated to make time for eye makeup in my routine.

clara Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20
Best beauty gift you’ve received? I hardly ever get beauty products from other people :/ But once my friend gave me MAC melon pigment and I love it! My aunt once gave a Benefit they’re real mascara which I love too.
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? A Lancome lipgloss to my sister who a while ago was obssessed with lipglosses!
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Currently Nars Albatross highlighter or Mac’s lady danger lipstick!

AudreyS Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, MUFE 115, Chanel B12

Best beauty gift you’ve received? *This* Christmas: Korres Lip Butter set of 3 (Jasmine, Pomegranate, Rose). *Ever*: NARS Danmari Blush Palette or my 6 blush MAC Palette

Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? N/A. All of my friends/families are tree huggers who are against makeup on principal… 😛 They wouldn’t appreciate a beauty gift. So I’d have to say an organic soap set.

Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? I wish someone would buy me a perfume. I dont’ own one, and I think it’d be really great and personal. Or a lipstick or a Dior eyeshadow palette. Mostly, I’d like to be suprised 🙂

CeeBee Avatar

Skintone/colouring – light medium with yellow undertones

Best beauty gift received? Errr, I don’t think I’ve been given one… (probably because of my already ludicrously huge collection)

Best beauty gift given? Dior Petal Shine quint to my best friend (she ADORED the hell of it it) and Prada Infusion D’Iris bath salts for my mother.

Beauty gift I wish someone would give me? My BFF is in the USA at the moment and she has a shopping list – I’m really hoping the Sephora + PANTONE metallic eyeshadow palette is on it!

Jade Avatar

I’m fair to light with warm undertones. The best beauty gift I’ve ever received was a bag of MAC makeup and mini nail polishes from a friend for my 21st birthday. It had a Dazzleglass, Mineralize eyeshadow and a Liquidlast liner, and 4 mini Orly polishes. I was blown away that she went and cherry picked the shades, that she would spend so much, and it was just so awesome to open up that bag and squeal in delight! She attached balloons and streamers to it as well!

The best gift I can think of would be the Balm Jovi palette I gave to my sister-in-law for Christmas. I knew it would go down well because it’s funny too haha.

I would love love love to recieve Guerlain Meteorites as a gift.

BooBooNinja Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20/25
Best beauty gift you’ve received? Chanel Notorious
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? Chanel Notorious
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Hmm… I don’t think I need anything right now!

Mel Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NW15/20.
Best beauty gift you’ve received? When I first got into MAC around 5 years ago the Starflash eyeshadow collection was out. I bought a few of them and drooled over the rest. My boyfriend and my friends teamed up and completed my collection for my birthday. It was awesome!
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? My sister wanted a Chanel red lipstick. I had fun swatching a bunch and picking out the perfect one for her. I gave it to her for her birthday and she loved it!
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? I would love a Clairisonic!

Kimmie T Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC 40/43, MUFE 170
Best beauty gift you’ve received? Not to sound terrible but I hardly get beauty gifts that I love! My husband did buy me a few things off my wish list from MAC.
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? I give amazing gifts, I have given Sephora perfume sets, Sephora Mascara set, Urban Decay basics, Real Techniques brushes. I honestly just know what my friends like and gift them what they need.
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Hmm… I don’t think I need anything right now! But I am always keeping an eye out on what I can buy though!

Veronica Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool-toned.
Best beauty gift you’ve received? Oddly enough, it wasn’t an actual cosmetic – last year my coworker included a little snap-lock lipstick holder with my Christmas gift a year ago, and it is quite possibly the most pragmatically useful gift I’ve ever been given. It’s saved me from so many potential castastrophes carrying different shades back and forth from work. 🙂
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? I gave my roommate and best friend Urban Decay’s deluxe eyeshadow palette awhile back. She’s told me on multiple occasions that it’s one of her most favorite posessions. 😀
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? Oh man, this is going to sound terrible, but I actually hate it when people buy me cosmetic gifts unless they specifically ask me what I want. I’m very picky with what I’ll buy and use, and I hate watching people waste money on bad cosmetics. Just give me a gift card and let me loose in the cosmetic wilds. 😛

Kelly Amanda Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring:
MAC NC30
Best beauty gift you’ve received?
MAC Guilty Passions Cocktail Corals and Miss Dior Le Parfum
Favorite beauty gift you’ve given?
Lush products
Beauty gift you wish someone would give you?
Something I wouldn’t expect

Amber Avatar

OOOH I love reading everyone’s responses!Here is mine:

My skin tone- N/C-N/W 5-10.
Best beauty gift I have received: Chanel Chance perfume for Christmas – I was pleasantly surprised to get this amazing perfume from my friends! The fact that it was from them gives it so much meaning.
Fave beauty gift I have given – I gifted a basket of beauty gifts to a good friend of mine – I gave her a makeup travel bag, a full brush set, eyeshadow, lipgloss, bath products and hair products for her birthday. It was so much fun to put together and I did her makeup as well!
Beauty gift I wish someone would give me: Recently fullfilled – a $50.00 GC to Sephora!

Jackie Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair with pink, almost neutral undertones.

Best beauty gift you’ve received? Urban Decay Smoked Palette – I really wanted it but didn’t expect to get it, so when I did I was in shock.

Favorite beauty gift you’ve given? I got my mom Urban Decay’s Naked Palette for her birthday, it was her first real splurge-ish item to receive as a gift. And she still uses it daily almost a year later!

Beauty gift you wish someone would give you? The Sephora Fragrance Sampler – it’s a cute idea, and it gives me a chance to get any full size perfume of my choice. 🙂

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!