I prefer them over compacts, since they take up less space and are usually less expensive! I’m definitely the type of person who would rather pay less and get less packaging as a result (as long as it remained functional).
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Don’t like it! I’m not into the do-it-yourself palettes, so I never buy the pan-only eyeshadows (except once by accident from Colourpop). For me, the packaging is part of the whole wonderful ritual of doing my makeup, so even though it costs more, I still prefer to have the nice palette or compact.
I have a couple Z-palettes, so i don‘t mind the singles and would generally prefer the savings from less packaging. But before I bought the palettes, I didn‘t like receiving pan-only products in subscription boxes like Ipsy. I like keeping a couple shades as singles in normal packsging – a crease and browbone shade in case a palette I‘m using doesn‘t have them, and a shade for a one-shade look.
I prefer it because it goes from the store right into my own palette.
No compact > compact if it means lower price (and also easier to put into a single palette), but I still rarely reach for single shades whether they’re in a compact or not.
Prefer sleeve to compacts, and order them that way, whether e/s or b. Started depotting due to TMS/Nars rubberized deteriorating in my house. Course, now I have too many Zs…. For palettes, keep intact when I like the pkg. but some (UD BOS 4) are so bulky, foolish, and wasteful that they have to go. Love that CP has the option for most products. If I butcher extracting a product (MAC comes to mind), tend not to want to revisit that experience, and leave them alone. For minimalist, like Viseart, or if there is no room saved, leave it alone. Am ordering the Ofra stand-up magnetic palette. You can put all the day’s powder products from differing brands in it, and not have to drag out 3 Zs plus a matte palette! Ironically, tend to keep 1-2 of the empty compacts, JIC.
I really like them for if I want just one or two shades from a palette, but can already dupe the other shades. Then I can have the satisfaction of not spending even more money and accumulating more clutter.
I highly prefer that. I keep all of my singles together because it’s a waste of space otherwise. When I travel, I bring a matte palette and cream shadows, or just a regular palette. Pan only saves money, too!
I started to think and buy them very recently, after buying 13 pallets, I noticed I have a pretty large selection and some very close colors and also noticed that what attracts me in new releases is the (pop) color…
Finding dupes (you help alot, thanks!) And buying them is cheaper and keeps me happy.
I vastly prefer purchasing them in pans. I’ve depotted all the singles I had that were in their own compacts. I wish all the eyeshadows I wanted were sold in Makeup Geek/Colour Pop size round pans. I keep mine in Adept palettes.
Love them! I have a large MUFE pan that they live in, and a couple of smaller z palettes that I sometimes use to make my own versions of popular palettes that I like. (I made one inspired by one of the NARSxErdem palettes the other day, very fun.)
Also they’re cheaper, and at this point I like being able to pick and choose the exact colors I want – I need more browbone and matte dark brown shades like I need a hole in the head.
I did that with the Christian Siriano palette from Target. Realized I could completely dupe it with singles I already own. Yes, it’s nice to buy a palette bc it’s a certain collaboration or has special packaging but a lot of times you are buying to buy or buying out of boredom. It’s completely wasteful to buy a palette you know is going to sit there bc you have those shades a million times over. Sometimes seeing if you can dupe it with pans singles you have in your collections saves you from buying what you don’t need (though you are tempted by). I want those Erdem palettes though:)
I’m all for them!
Love them! It allows me to be more conscientious of my purchase when adding colors to my vast (for me) collection. Though I do love compacts and some companies are learning to combine the best of both worlds: viseart theory palettes and colourpop quads are awesome in that I can easily remove the individual pans if desired.
In spite of how many premade palettes I own, I actually prefer singles w/o packaging. Plop them into an empty palette. Getting to pick out exactly which shades I want; ones that *because* I picked them, I will continue using them. Less wasteful. Less overwhelming.
I much prefer the “pro pan” shadows sold without bulky single compact. They take up so much less room and offer better value since I’m not paying for packaging that I don’t want and is inconvenient. I like it even better when the company throws in a “free” quad pan or palette with the purchase X number of shadows, as ABH and, I think, MUFE do.
It’s pretty much the only way I buy eyeshadow and even most of my blush and some other powder products. It’s fun and I feel free to find my own combos daily instead of feeling compelled to work within the pallet. Also takes up less space and I don’t have to be irritated by to many boring colors ,most pallets have too many “easy shades” I don’t need more matte black of varing quality . Rant over
I love them bc you can personalize to your taste. Really before the ABH Modern Renaissance, I didn’t really own any premade palettes. Just had several eyeshadow pans. Now I have a few palettes but I still like buying pans so I can just target holes in my collection rather than buy an expensive palette that has a bunch of shades I won’t ever use to get those few unique shades!
I really like individual pans and have a couple, (well like 5 and two of them hold 96 shadows) of magnetic trays for them. I also have a four pan magnetic tray that I can use to travel with and take individual pans. Having said that, there are certainly beautiful palettes that I have and would be disappointed not to have the pretty packaging.
I much prefer single pans I can organize in my own way to pre-made palettes. I love my old-formula MUFE singles, and also have MAC and Pur Anada pans in their own palettes. I *do* own several pre-made palettes, too, but really should stick to buying singles!
I prefer compacts rather than pans alone because it easier for me to store and, as I don’t own a z palette, it is also easier for me to use. I generally don’t buy singles either.
I have a love/hate thing going on with singles. I buy a lot of palettes because I like them, but if I’ve got a look in mind and none of the shades I own is *exactly* right in my mind I will start buying singles to ‘fix’ it. I am exceptionally- and that is not a strong enough word – fussy with shades and while I love all of the colors I have as singles or I’d not have bought them, it can get out of hand very quickly when I’m looking for a certain shade of say, pink, and I buy single shadows left and right until I find one that is *exactly* what I had in mind. I only return things if they perform poorly or irritate my skin, but I do purge my eye shadow collection about once a year, throwing out creams and liquids and putting the powders and pans and other ‘dry’ items in a box for my younger cousins, friends and assorted local homeless ladies to look through. This starts the single shadow buying cycle again, of course. It’s insane.
I know I can’t possibly be the only person with that “this is the WRONG SHADE for this!” fussiness issue. I really wish more companies made those tiny little sample pans and put them up for sale to minimize waste for people like me. I have a couple of Urban Decay shadow singles in the sample sized pans and that was enough for me to feel like I had the *exact* shade I was looking for every time I used them.
I prefer them. I hate looking around for a bunch of little singles. I much rather put pans in my own magnetic palettes and keep them organized the way I want. They are usually cheaper, as well.
Like ’em. I have a couple Book of Shadows palettes, and I like to rearrange the shadows in them every now and then for inspiration; can’t do that with shadows in packaging — palettes or otherwise.
I love the concept of it. I want to be able to one day make my own customized palette. I always find in palletes there’s shadows I don’t like or use. Maybe because I’ve never shopped color pop buying singles seems more expensive- like ABH singles are 16$ in Canada where’s I can buy Soft Glam and get 12 shadows for 50$! But one day I want to get a z palette and start my own.
I don’t really care either way. The shades I like tend to be found in palettes, but if I found the perfect shade as a single or pan, I’d be fine with it.
I prefer having the case already as long as it is not too bulky i dont care much for including a mirror and not trying to find small loose ones. I have a few from Colourpop and keep them at the front even in the small envelope otherwise would be a challenge to find and I don’t want to hassle owning a pan to transfer then. Easy dies it for me.
I prefer them!!! I just wish Makeup Forever hadn’t discontinued their perfect empty magnetic palettes. I’m discouraged from ever buying more pan singles because I don’t know where I’d put them and I don’t feel like hunting for an empty palette that’s as sleek as the MUFE ones were… 🙁